The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – February 2025
Dive deep into the world of true crime with this blog, where we explore captivating cases, uncover hidden truths, and examine the lasting impact of crime on individuals and communities. From the unsolved disappearance of Marcus Rutledge to the trial of Nima Momeni for the murder of tech executive Bob Lee, each episode delves into a compelling story, offering insights into the complexities of criminal investigations, the motivations behind crimes, and the search for justice. Join us as we unravel these mysteries and shed light on the human stories behind the headlines. Don’t miss out on this gripping journey into the dark side of human nature – subscribe today and listen to the latest episodes!
The 10 Best True Crime episodes
MURDERED: Marcus Rutledge
This podcast investigates the disappearance and subsequent murder of Marcus Rutledge, uncovering secrets about his life and exploring the connection to the murder of his best friend, Ethan Gibbs Jr.
The episode begins with an update on the case of Nathaniel Jones and the five teenage boys convicted of his murder. The focus then shifts to the disappearance of Marcus Rutledge in 1998. His girlfriend, Tawani, reports him missing after finding his dog locked in the bathroom and no signs of a struggle. The investigation reveals that Marcus had been selling weed and had dropped out of college, keeping these secrets from his family. As the investigation progresses, more secrets about Marcus’s life emerge, including the existence of two children and his involvement in drug dealing. His family is shocked to learn about these hidden aspects of his life. Investigators discover that Marcus had been involved in altercations related to his drug dealing and had rented a car for 10 days, raising questions about his activities during that time. The investigation takes a turn when Marcus’s car is found abandoned at an apartment complex. The car contains a gun and two fingerprints, but neither can be definitively linked to Marcus. The lack of evidence suggests that Marcus may have been alive after his disappearance. The episode then shifts to the murder of Ethan Gibbs Jr., Marcus’s best friend. Investigators suspect his roommate, Charles, who had a history of violence and had been involved in a home invasion the day after Marcus went missing. While investigators believe that Charles is responsible for Ethan’s murder, they are unsure if there is a connection between Ethan’s death and Marcus’s disappearance. The Rutledge family is devastated by Ethan’s death, but they hope that Charles’s arrest will lead to answers about Marcus’s disappearance. However, the charges against Charles are eventually dismissed due to lack of evidence. The episode discusses the lack of investigation into Cowan and his associates in connection with Marcus’s disappearance. The timing of the home invasion and the red car raise questions about a possible connection. The Rutledge family learns that Marcus had a daughter, a secret that was kept from them by both Marcus and Tawani. Detective Filter, who is in the Nashville PD’s cold case unit, takes over the investigation into Marcus’s disappearance. He updates the DNA profiles in the system to ensure a match if any remains are found. A major breakthrough occurs when Marcus’s remains are found. A skull found by a hunter in 2010 is confirmed to be Marcus’s through DNA testing. The discovery of Marcus’s skull confirms that he was killed, but it doesn’t provide any clues about how he died. Detective Filter plans to search the area where the skull was found for more evidence. Despite the discovery of Marcus’s remains, police still have no solid leads. Detective Filter believes that the case will only be solved if someone who knows the truth comes forward. The episode ends with a call for anyone with information about Marcus’s death or Ethan’s murder to contact the Metro Nashville Police Department.
The Devil Wore White
This podcast explores the life and crimes of Sante Kimes, a notorious con artist and murderer, and the impact of her actions on her sons, Kent and Kenny, including their involvement in her schemes and their struggles to find normalcy after her death.
This podcast delves into the complex and disturbing story of Sante Kimes, a woman convicted of murder and other crimes, and her sons, Kent and Kenny. The episode begins with the news of Sante’s death in prison, prompting a reflection on her life and crimes, including the murder of Irene Silverman. The episode explores the intricate relationship between Sante and her sons, highlighting her manipulative nature and how she used them to further her own criminal activities. The podcast details the investigation into Irene Silverman’s disappearance, leading to the arrest of Sante and Kenny. It also examines the murder of David Kasden, a businessman who was found dead in a dumpster in Los Angeles, and the evidence that linked Sante and Kenny to his death. The episode covers the trial of Sante and Kenny for the murder of Irene Silverman, discussing the evidence presented against them and the sentences they received. The podcast concludes with a first interview with Kenny Kimes after 25 years, where he expresses regret for his past crimes and proposes a plan to raise a million dollars for education while in prison. The interview also explores Kenny’s relationship with his mother, his struggles with grief, and his desire to find normalcy after a life of crime.
WANTED: Justice for Rhys Pocan & MMIW Part 1
This episode of Counter-Clock investigates the unsolved murder of Reese Pocan, exploring potential suspects, inconsistencies in witness accounts, and a possible connection to other unsolved dismemberment cases in Wisconsin.
The episode begins with an update on the case of Nathaniel Jones, followed by a deep dive into the unsolved murder of Reese Pocan, a single mother who disappeared in 1989. The episode details the timeline of her disappearance, including her last known sightings and encounters. The investigation focuses on two primary suspects: her boyfriend Chris and her ex-boyfriend Larry. Inconsistencies in Chris’s story and Larry’s history of abuse towards Reese raise suspicions. A strange twist emerges when the anonymous caller who discovered Reese’s body comes forward with new information, leading to a renewed investigation and additional potential suspects. In 2017, Detective Nathan Hatch takes over the case, re-examining evidence, conducting new interviews, and utilizing modern technology to uncover new leads. The episode reveals a potential connection between Reese’s case and other unsolved dismemberment cases in Wisconsin, suggesting a possible serial killer at work. The episode promises to explore these connections in future episodes.
Under the Bay Bridge
This podcast investigates the mysterious death of tech executive Bob Lee, exploring the investigation, the potential motives, and the eventual trial of Nima Momeni, who was found guilty of second-degree murder.
This podcast, “Where Everybody Knows Your Name,” hosted by Ted Danson and Woody Harrelson, delves into the investigation and trial of Nima Momeni, who was accused of murdering tech executive Bob Lee. The podcast begins by introducing Bob Lee, highlighting his significant contributions to the tech world, including his work on Android for Google, his founding of Cash App, and his leadership roles at Square and MobileCoin. The investigation into Bob’s death initially focused on a potential random mugging, but quickly shifted to Nima Momeni as a suspect after a white BMW connected to the crime scene was discovered. The investigation also revealed a mysterious text message received by Bob’s ex-wife, Crystal, suggesting a possible connection to the Millennium Tower. The podcast explores the relationship between Bob and Nima’s sister, Kazar, who was revealed to have known Bob and had been with him just hours before his death. Their social circles and connection to the Battery, an exclusive social club in San Francisco, provided investigators with valuable information. The podcast also reveals that Bob was known to use drugs and had been at a party with Kazar and a friend, Jeremy Boyvin, who was also his drug dealer. The podcast details the arrest of Nima Momeni, nine days after Bob’s murder, and the subsequent search warrants executed at Kazar and Dino’s apartments. The episode reveals that Nima had retained a criminal defense attorney and was seen on video speaking with a private investigator, seemingly reenacting the crime. The podcast focuses on the trial of Nima Momeni for the murder of Bob Lee, highlighting the prosecution’s case, which relied heavily on security video footage and DNA evidence. The episode also reveals the testimony of Kazar Momeni, who claims to have been sexually assaulted by Jeremy Boyvin and that her brother was angry with Bob for his involvement. The podcast details the defense’s strategy in the trial, which challenged the prosecution’s motive and Kazar’s credibility. The defense argued that Bob was the one with a knife and that Nima acted in self-defense. The episode also reveals the defense’s attempt to play a digital animation of the alleged attack, which the judge ultimately denies. The podcast reveals the defense’s shocking twist in the trial, where they shift the blame from Nima to Bob Lee. The defense argues that Bob was under the influence of drugs and alcohol and could have become violent. They also suggest that Bob may have had the knife and that Nima acted in self-defense. The podcast focuses on Nima Momeni’s testimony, where he admits to being responsible for Bob’s death but claims it was self-defense. He describes a confrontation with Bob after Bob spilled beer on him and claims that Bob lunged at him with a knife. The episode also reveals the defense’s attempt to play a digital animation of the alleged attack, which the judge denies. The podcast concludes with the verdict in the trial of Nima Momeni. Momeni was found not guilty of first-degree murder but guilty of second-degree murder. The episode explores the reactions of both families and the implications of the verdict.
UPDATE: Beaumont Children
This podcast revisits the Beaumont children disappearance case, exploring recent developments, a new suspect, “The Satin Man,” and the upcoming dig at his former factory.
This episode of the podcast focuses on the Beaumont children disappearance case, a cold case that has captivated Australia for decades. The hosts, Ashley Flowers and Britt, introduce a new format for the podcast, focusing on case updates. They begin by revisiting the 1966 disappearance of Jane, Arna, and Grant Beaumont from Glenelg Beach in Adelaide, Australia. The episode delves into the initial investigation, the search efforts, and the various theories surrounding the case. The podcast then introduces a new suspect, Harry Vipps, also known as “The Satin Man.” The authors of the book “The Satin Man” present evidence linking Harry to the Beaumont children’s disappearance, including his satin fetish, violent tendencies, and a potential connection to the Adelaide Oval disappearances. The episode discusses the similarities between the two cases, both involving young children being taken from public locations in broad daylight. The podcast concludes by discussing recent developments in the Beaumont children case, including the death of Jim Beaumont and the upcoming dig at the site of Harry Vipps’ former factory. The dig is being conducted by a private firm with police supervision, and it aims to provide closure for the family after decades of uncertainty. The episode highlights the significance of the dig, as it represents a last opportunity to search the area thoroughly before development plans make future searches impossible.
A murder suspect’s brother under scrutiny. Breakthrough in parents’ quest for answers. And should jurors question witnesses?
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly explores the Ellen Greenberg cold case, updates on ongoing trials, and the benefits and drawbacks of juror questioning in trials.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly delves into the enduring nature of true crime stories and the ongoing journeys of those affected by them. The episode focuses on the Ellen Greenberg case, a 14-year quest for answers in a Philadelphia teacher’s death. The episode explores the initial investigation, the family’s relentless pursuit of the truth, and the recent developments that led to a settlement and a potential reopening of the case. The episode also provides updates on several ongoing cases, including the retrial of Eric Thompson, accused of murdering his wife’s ex-lover, the third murder trial of Dana Chandler, and the latest developments in the Donna Adelson case. The episode features an interview with Judge Boy Patterson, who discusses the practice of allowing jurors to ask questions during trials. He explains the benefits and drawbacks of this practice, as well as the legal framework surrounding it. The episode concludes with a preview of upcoming episodes, including a new podcast series “Murder in the Moonlight” hosted by Keith Morrison and a Dateline episode featuring an interview with Susan Smith’s ex-husband.
The 911 call in the Hollywood hairdresser murder. And investigators explore links between six violent deaths and a group called the Zizians.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly explores several ongoing criminal cases, including the trial of Monica Cementelli, the investigation into “The Zizians,” and updates on high-profile cases like the JonBenét Ramsey murder.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly delves into a variety of ongoing criminal cases, starting with the trial of Monica Cementelli, accused of conspiring to murder her husband. The episode then shifts its focus to “The Zizians,” a group linked to multiple deaths across different states, including the murder of a border patrol agent in Vermont. The investigation centers on Teresa Youngblood, a member of the group, and her connection to Jack Lasota, also known as “Ziz,” who is a person of interest in multiple murders. The episode also provides updates on several high-profile criminal cases, including the sentencing of Natalie Cochran, convicted of murdering her husband, the sex trafficking case against Sean Combs, and the ongoing investigation into the murder of Jimmy Jay Lee. Finally, the episode revisits the unsolved murder of JonBenét Ramsey, a case that has garnered renewed interest due to a Netflix docu-series and John Ramsey’s push for authorities to utilize advanced DNA technology to solve the case.
An alleged “murder dentist” in Colorado. Hawaii husband takes the stand at his second murder trial. And Keith talks about his latest podcast series.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly covers multiple murder trials, including the case of James Craig in Colorado, Eric Thompson in Hawaii, and updates on the Karen Reed and Brian Kohberger cases, concluding with a preview of Keith Morrison’s new podcast, “Murder in the Moonlight.”
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly delves into several high-profile crime cases. The episode begins with a discussion of the enduring impact of true crime stories, especially for those affected by them. It then focuses on the trial of James Craig, a Colorado dentist accused of murdering his wife, Angela. The episode explores the original murder charges, the new charges of solicitation to commit murder and perjury, and the evidence presented in court, including Craig’s alleged attempts to fabricate evidence from jail. The episode then shifts to Hawaii, where Eric Thompson is on trial for the second time for the murder of John Tokuhara, his wife’s ex-lover. The episode covers Thompson’s testimony, the evidence presented, and the focus on the white bucket hat found at the scene. The episode features a Dateline Roundup segment, providing updates on several high-profile crime cases. This includes the Karen Reed case in Massachusetts, where the judge suspended a hearing due to concerns about the defense’s expert witnesses, the Brian Kohberger case in Idaho, where the judge ruled on motions to suppress evidence, and the arrest of the leader of a group called the Zizians in Western Maryland. The episode concludes with an interview with Keith Morrison about his new podcast series, “Murder in the Moonlight.” Morrison discusses the case, which involves the murders of a couple in a small Nebraska town, the initial focus on a suspect, and the discovery of a gold ring that becomes a crucial piece of evidence.
Talking Dateline: Return to the Lake
Dateline NBC’s “Return to the Lake” revisits the Susan Smith case, exploring the impact on her ex-husband, the investigation’s challenges, and the ongoing struggle for closure.
This episode of Dateline NBC, “Return to the Lake,” delves into the 1994 Susan Smith case, focusing on the lasting impact of the crime on her ex-husband, David Smith. The episode begins with an introduction by hosts Josh Manquitz and Craig Melvin, who discuss the episode’s content, including an interview with David Smith and a clip from Chief of SLED Mark Keel. Craig Melvin shares his personal recollections of the case, recalling the widespread media coverage and the initial public sympathy for Susan Smith. The episode then explores the police investigation, including the polygraph test administered to Susan Smith and the role of renowned polygraph expert Pete Logan in extracting her confession. The hosts discuss previously unreleased audio recordings of conversations with Susan Smith, revealing inconsistencies in her story. They also discuss Carol Gable’s 20-year correspondence with Susan Smith, providing unique insights into her thoughts and feelings. The episode features a clip from the interview with Chief of SLED Mark Keel, who shares his emotional recollections of the case, particularly the discovery of the boys’ bodies. The hosts discuss David Smith’s decision to participate in the episode, his desire to ensure that Susan Smith’s actions are not viewed through a sympathetic lens, and the lasting impact of the crime on his life. They explore the ripple effect of murder, highlighting the ongoing trauma experienced by victims’ families and the challenges of moving on. The episode also discusses David Smith’s struggles with trauma, including his suicide attempts and the difficulty of remembering his sons. The hosts discuss Susan Smith’s upcoming parole hearing and the lack of closure for David Smith and his family. They highlight the ongoing threat of her potential release and the challenges of navigating the parole system. The episode features an interview with David Brock, Susan Smith’s lawyer, who argues for her rehabilitation and maintains that she poses no threat to society. The hosts explore the complexities of assessing rehabilitation in such cases and the challenges of balancing justice with the possibility of redemption. The episode concludes with an interview with Carol Gable, a Dateline producer who has been involved with the Susan Smith case since 1994. They discuss her motivation for writing to Susan Smith and her observations regarding her remorse. They also address the criticism of giving Susan Smith a platform and explain their intention to provide context and understanding. The hosts answer questions from social media viewers regarding the case, including the location of the 911 call and the marital status of Susan Smith’s parents. They provide clarification on the details of the case and address common misconceptions. The hosts conclude the episode by encouraging viewers to reach out with questions or case suggestions. They also promote Keith Morrison’s new podcast, “Murder in the Moonlight,” and remind listeners to subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening.
Talking Dateline: Under the Bay Bridge
This Dateline episode explores the stabbing death of tech executive Bob Lee in San Francisco, examining the trial, key witnesses, the defense attorney’s strategy, and the final verdict.
This Dateline episode delves into the stabbing death of tech executive Bob Lee in San Francisco, focusing on the trial and the key players involved. Blaine Alexander and Josh Mechowicz discuss the challenges of covering a national story like this, particularly with the public already having access to a lot of information. They analyze the complexities of the case, including the suspected killer, his sister, and Bob Lee’s brother. The episode then dives into the testimony of Kazama Mini, a key witness who had a relationship with both Bob Lee and the accused killer. Blaine and Josh discuss how her testimony impacted the case and the reaction of Bob Lee’s brother, Oliver. Next, they examine the defense attorney, Josh Broe, who came from Miami to represent the accused killer. They discuss his tactics, personality, and performance in the trial, as well as the deliberation process and the final verdict. Finally, Blaine and Josh answer listener questions about the episode, including questions about the object Bob Lee used to do cocaine, the defense attorney’s use of the word “bro,” and the judge’s decision to blur Neema’s mouth in a video.
Top 10 True Crime Podcasts
