The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – February 2026
Dive into the captivating world of true crime with our latest podcast series! This blog brings you compelling narratives of unsolved mysteries, tragic events, and intricate investigations. From the suspicious house fire claiming a family's lives to the complex case of a detective entangled in a mistaken identity murder, we explore the darkest corners of human nature. Join us as we unravel the stories of the Hansen twins, the mysterious death of Michelle O'Keefe, and the chilling murder-for-hire plot targeting the Latham family. We also delve into the disappearance of Jay Lee, the heartwarming yet haunting tale of Helen Goley and Olga Rudderschmidt, and the unsolved murder of Rachel Hansen. Plus, get updates on ongoing trials and safety tips. Tune in to uncover the truth and find closure in these gripping true crime sagas.
The 10 Best True Crime episodes
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: The Day-Stewart Family
A house fire killing a mother and children is investigated, revealing potential abuse, conflicting evidence, and questions about the initial investigation's impartiality.
This podcast investigates a tragic house fire that claimed the lives of Summer Day and her three children. Initially ruled an accident, the investigation uncovers troubling details, including allegations of domestic abuse by the father, Sean Stewart, who is a firefighter. Evidence such as removed smoke detector batteries, an arson expert's analysis, and Summer's plans to leave Sean raise doubts about the fire's accidental nature. The podcast highlights a potential conflict of interest in the investigation due to Sean's profession and calls for a new, independent inquiry into the case.
MURDERED: Bobby Moore
This podcast details the unsolved murders of Bobby Moore and his wife Barbara in Indiana, involving mistaken identity, domestic disputes, and revenge.
This podcast chronicles the complex and tragic case of Bobby Moore, a detective who became entangled in a mistaken identity murder in D.C. He later married the victim's wife, Barbara Sissler, and moved to Fremont, Indiana, where he became town marshal. Their lives took a dark turn when Barbara was murdered, with Bobby claiming self-defense. Despite conflicting evidence and public outcry, the charges against him were dismissed. Tragically, Bobby Moore was himself murdered five months later, a crime that remains unsolved, with his wife's son considered a person of interest due to a suspected revenge motive. The case highlights themes of mistaken identity, domestic violence, forensic challenges, and the enduring quest for justice in cold cases.
MURDERED: Jill & Julie Hansen
The Hansen twins case involves a house fire, a shooting, and a trial where the son, Donnie, was acquitted due to reasonable doubt, leaving lingering questions.
This episode details the tragic case of the Hansen twins, Jill and Julie, who were victims of a house fire and shooting. The investigation revealed the fire was arson, and shotgun shells were found. Suspicion fell on Donnie, the twins' brother, due to a palm print on the shotgun and matching ballistics. Despite Julie's inconsistent testimony and Donnie's suspicious behavior, he was arrested. Julie later died from a medical accident, and Donnie's trial began. The defense argued for reasonable doubt, highlighting investigative flaws, and Donnie was acquitted. Years later, Donnie died in a car accident, and the family continues to seek answers.
The Girl in the Blue Mustang – Ep. 1: Michelle's Last Day
This podcast explores the tragic murder of Michelle O'Keefe, detailing the investigation, her background, and the lingering questions surrounding her death.
This podcast delves into the unsolved murder of Michelle O'Keefe, an 18-year-old found deceased in her blue Mustang at a Palmdale park and ride in February 2000. It introduces Dateline's \"The Girl in the Blue Mustang\" podcast, recounting Michelle's life, aspirations, and her final day leading up to the discovery of her body. The narrative follows homicide detective Richard Longshore as he tackles the perplexing case, highlighting the challenges of a crime scene with limited leads and the emotional toll on investigators and Michelle's grieving parents. The podcast also touches upon witness accounts, forensic evidence, Michelle's own premonitions of her death, and the eventual scrutiny of the security guard present at the scene, leaving many questions unanswered as the investigation continues.
The Thing About Helen & Olga – Ep. 1: Nothing to Lose. Everything to Gain
Two women, Helen and Olga, help homeless individuals but their benevolence turns sinister as suspicious deaths and insurance fraud emerge.
This Dateline podcast episode, hosted by Keith Morrison, explores the story of Helen Goley and Olga Rudderschmidt, two women who dedicated themselves to helping the homeless. They offered support and shelter to individuals like Paul Vados and Kenneth McDavid. However, the narrative takes a dark turn as both Vados and McDavid are found dead in alleys, initially ruled as hit-and-runs. Further investigation by private investigator Ed Webster reveals suspicious circumstances, including inconsistencies in the accident reports and significant life insurance policies taken out on the victims with Helen and Olga as beneficiaries, suggesting a more sinister motive behind their charitable acts.
Bringing Jay Home
Dateline's "Bringing Jay Home" chronicles the disappearance and murder of Ole Miss student Jay Lee, the investigation leading to Tim Harrington's arrest, and the eventual discovery of his remains.
This Dateline episode, "Bringing Jay Home," details the perplexing disappearance and subsequent murder investigation of Jay Lee, a popular Ole Miss student. The narrative follows the initial alarm raised by his mother when his location tracking was turned off, the discovery of his abandoned car, and the deepening mystery surrounding his whereabouts. Key developments include the review of security footage showing Jay leaving his apartment and his car being found towed off-campus. The investigation gained traction with testimony from Jay's friend, Khalid Fears, who revealed Jay was on the phone discussing an argument with someone identified as "Red Eye 24." This led to the identification of Tim Harrington, a fellow Ole Miss graduate, as "Red Eye 24." Despite initial denials, Harrington eventually admitted to a sexual relationship with Jay and was arrested. The case faced challenges due to the lack of Jay's body, leading to a mistrial. However, the discovery of Jay's remains, coupled with crucial forensic evidence—duct tape matching Harrington's apartment—led to a plea deal. Harrington confessed to strangling Jay and dumping his body, pleading guilty to second-degree murder and tampering with a body, receiving a 40-year sentence. Jay's family continues to advocate for the "Jay Lee Information Act" to aid future missing persons cases.
Talking Dateline: The Girl in the Blue Mustang
This Dateline podcast delves into the complex \"Girl in the Blue Mustang\" true crime case, exploring Raymond Jennings' wrongful conviction and exoneration, and the enduring pain of Michelle O'Keefe's family.
This Dateline podcast, \"The Girl in the Blue Mustang,\" investigates the murder of Michelle O'Keefe and the subsequent conviction and exoneration of Raymond Jennings. The narrative highlights the complexities of the investigation, including accusations of tunnel vision, lengthy jury deliberations, and cultural differences impacting trials. It introduces Clint Ehrlich, an autodidact whose investigation, spurred by a Dateline episode, played a crucial role in uncovering new perspectives on the case. The podcast also touches upon other Dateline productions and emphasizes the profound and lasting grief of Michelle O'Keefe's family, while acknowledging Raymond Jennings' resilience and lack of bitterness despite his years of imprisonment. The case's unresolved aspects and Dateline's commitment to long-term storytelling are also discussed.
Murder & Magnolias – Ep. 1: Marked for Death
A murder-for-hire plot targeting the Latham family unravels through Aaron Wilkinson's confession, revealing marital strife and criminal connections.
This podcast delves into the complexities of a murder-for-hire plot targeting the Latham family, a prominent Charleston couple whose marital issues and impending divorce became a backdrop for criminal conspiracy. The narrative follows Aaron Wilkinson, a convicted felon and drug addict, who, under pressure from his cellmate Sam Yenowine, becomes entangled in the plot. Wilkinson's arrest during a traffic stop in Charleston leads to his confession, revealing that Yenowine was hired to kill a member of the Latham family. The investigation uncovers details of the plot's origin in Louisville, the payment received, and the chilling "hit packet" containing photos of the target family. The podcast also touches upon other Dateline offerings, including "The Road to Milan" and "The Drink with Kate Snow," and revisits the Martha Moxley murder case.
MURDERED: Rachel Hansen
This podcast investigates the unsolved murder of Rachel Hansen, exploring theories and police oversights.
This podcast delves into the unsolved murder of Rachel Hansen, a 19-year-old shot in her apartment. The investigation highlights police shortcomings, including redacted files and overlooked evidence like a jar of pickles. Theories explored include a mistaken identity involving a subletter, conflicts at her equine therapy job, and suspicious behavior from Jomett's father, Gary Bailey, who made threats against Rachel. The podcast calls for public assistance to solve the case and keep Rachel's memory alive through her mother's rescue efforts. A listener notes the improved investigative quality, attributing it to reporter Nina, and dubs it the "Nina Effect."
Michigan husband on bodycam. Trial of former college football player. Plus, stadium safety tips.
This podcast covers true crime cases, stadium safety tips, and promotions for other Dateline and Today Show podcasts.
This podcast episode features updates on several true crime cases, including the Michigan farmer trial for the murder of Dee Warner, the trial of Rashawn Jones for the murder of his college football teammate, and the sentencing of an au pair involved in a double murder. It also includes a segment on stadium safety tips from NBC News correspondent Vicky Nguyen and promotions for Dateline and The Road to Milan podcasts.
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – December 2025
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – January 2026
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – June 2025