The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – March 2025
Dive deep into the world of true crime with this blog, where we explore captivating cases that have captivated the nation. From the tragic murder of Helen Betty Osborne to the unsolved mystery of Midtown Jane Doe, each episode unravels a complex web of events, revealing shocking twists and turns. Join us as we delve into the investigations, examine the evidence, and uncover the stories behind these chilling crimes. Get ready to be captivated by the stories of victims, suspects, and the relentless pursuit of justice. Listen now and discover the truth behind these compelling cases.
The 10 Best True Crime episodes
MURDERED: Helen Betty Osborne
This podcast explores the brutal murder of Helen Betty Osborne in 1971, highlighting the systemic racism and lack of justice that plagued the investigation and trial, ultimately leading to a plea deal and a conviction for one of the perpetrators.
This podcast delves into the tragic murder of Helen Betty Osborne, a young Indigenous woman, in 1971. The episode highlights the systemic racism and lack of resources that hindered the initial investigation, leading to the case going cold for over a decade. An anonymous letter provided crucial information about potential suspects, leading to the discovery of blood stains and hair in a suspect's car, further implicating them in the crime. A new investigator, Robert Urbanowski, reopened the case in 1983, utilizing new forensic techniques and interviewing witnesses, reigniting hope for a solution. Several witnesses came forward with information about the suspects, including a sheriff who recounted a conversation with Lee Colgan, where he admitted to his involvement in the murder. Based on the new evidence and witness testimonies, Lee Colgan and Dwayne Johnston were arrested. Lee eventually agreed to a plea deal, providing crucial information about the crime in exchange for immunity. Lee Colgan detailed the events leading up to the murder, revealing how the group targeted Helen Betty Osborne, forced her into their car, and assaulted her. He described the brutal attack and the subsequent cover-up. Dwayne Johnston and Jim Houghton stood trial for the murder of Helen Betty Osborne. Dwayne was found guilty of second-degree murder, while Jim was acquitted. The episode discusses the systemic racism and lack of justice that contributed to the outcome. The episode concludes by reflecting on the impact of the case and the lasting legacy of Helen Betty Osborne. It highlights the importance of truth and reconciliation in addressing the systemic issues that led to her murder.
MURDERED: Dana Ireland
The podcast explores the unsolved murder of Dana Ireland in Hawaii on Christmas Eve 1991, examining the evidence, witness accounts, and the evolving narrative of the case.
This podcast delves into the unsolved murder of Dana Ireland, a young woman found injured and barely clothed near a vacant house in Kapoho, Hawaii on Christmas Eve 1991. The investigation revealed a complex web of events and witness accounts, including the discovery of a broken bike, tire tracks, and other evidence suggesting a sexual assault. Authorities pieced together a timeline based on witness accounts, placing Dana at various locations throughout the day. One witness reported seeing a turquoise green pickup truck at the intersection where Dana was hit, suggesting a possible vehicle involved in her abduction. The podcast explores the challenges of piecing together the truth, highlighting the shifting narrative of the case and its impact on those involved.
INFAMOUS: Indiana Dunes Disappearances
This episode of Crime Junkie explores the unsolved disappearance of three young women from Indiana Dunes State Park in 1966, examining various theories including a boating accident, a planned disappearance, and involvement with a horse syndicate.
This episode of Crime Junkie delves into the mysterious disappearance of three young women, Patricia, Ann, and Renee, from Indiana Dunes State Park on July 4th, 1966. The episode begins with the discovery of their belongings on the beach, suggesting they boarded a boat but never returned. The investigation, involving the Indiana State Police, the US Coast Guard, and a large search party, yielded no trace of the women. The episode explores various theories surrounding their disappearance, including a boating accident, a planned disappearance, and involvement with a horse syndicate. The boat wreckage theory is initially considered but dismissed due to the lack of reports of a missing boat or injured boaters. The "walked off on their own" theory gains traction, fueled by supposed sightings of the women in different locations, but these sightings are never confirmed. A letter found in Renee's purse reveals marital issues, leading investigators to believe she may have run away, but this doesn't explain the disappearance of the other two women. Sergeant Burke suggests the women had "personal problems," including Patricia's affair with a married man and Ann's potential pregnancy. The episode also explores the connection to the Chicago massacre, a brutal crime involving the murder of eight student nurses, which occurred just two weeks after the women's disappearance. Authorities investigated a possible connection but found no evidence. Dick Wiley, a former reporter who covered the case, believes the women died aboard an "abortion boat" on Lake Michigan, claiming they were both pregnant and sought illegal abortions. However, this theory lacks evidence and is considered less plausible. A more plausible theory emerges, linking the women's disappearance to the "horse syndicate," a group involved in the Chicago equestrian scene. Patricia had been involved with the syndicate and had a bruised face, suggesting she was in trouble. The theory suggests the women may have known something about a car bombing attempt on George Jane, a member of the horse syndicate, and were silenced as a result. The episode concludes with the unresolved case and a call for information. Authorities are now considering the possibility that the boat wreckage was related to the women's disappearance. The families are still seeking answers.
INFAMOUS: Lovers' Lane Murders
This episode of "Dark Down East" investigates the unsolved murders of Andy Atkinson and Cheryl Henry in Houston, Texas, exploring the evidence, suspects, and the lasting impact on their families.
The episode of "Dark Down East" delves into the unsolved murders of Andy Atkinson and Cheryl Henry in Houston, Texas in 1990. The story begins with Cheryl's sister Shane discovering her missing and the subsequent search that leads to the discovery of their car with signs of a struggle. Cheryl's body is found in a wooded area near the car, revealing signs of a brutal attack, including being bound and her throat slashed. Andy is eventually found tied to a tree with a similar fatal wound. The episode explores possible scenarios of the crime, suggesting a blitz attack in the car followed by the victims being taken to the wooded area. The investigation focuses on DNA evidence, leading to the exclusion of several suspects, including Lance and Aaron. A strange letter demanding $100,000 for information about the murders is received by HPD, but it leads to no further leads. The case goes cold for many years, with Detective Belk, who had been working on the case since the beginning, retiring without a resolution. A DNA hit connects the case to a brutal sexual assault case that occurred two months prior to the murders. The victim, who had worked for Andy's father, provides a description of her attacker, leading to a composite sketch. The victim's description of her attacker, including his possible connection to the club scene, raises suspicions about Andy's involvement. The media frenzy surrounding the potential connection to the club scene fails to yield any concrete leads. The episode explores the possibility of a connection between the Andy and Cheryl case and the Lake Waco murders, but no concrete evidence is found. The case remains unsolved, with Cheryl's family expressing frustration over the lack of communication from HPD regarding the use of genetic genealogy. The episode highlights the devastating impact of the murders on the families, particularly Andy's father Garland, who passed away recently with the case still unsolved. The episode concludes with a plea for information from the public, hoping to bring closure to the families.
The Haunted House Confession
This podcast investigates the murder of Shantay Blanconship, a young woman from a small Texas community, ultimately leading to the arrest and confession of Ryan Riggs, who was motivated by a desire to harm an easy target.
This podcast delves into the investigation of the murder of Shantay Blanconship, a young woman from a small Texas community. The episode begins with Shantay's disappearance on Friday the 13th and the discovery of her body in an abandoned farmhouse nicknamed "the haunted house." The investigation focuses on potential suspects, including Shantay's boyfriend and a local man named Colin Smith. The episode details the discovery of Shantay's body in the cellar of the abandoned farmhouse, revealing signs of a violent assault. The investigation intensifies, focusing on Charlie Raidle and his girlfriend Jackie Neal, the searchers who found Shantay. The investigation expands to include everyone in Shantay's circle, starting with her boyfriend John Adams. The pressure to find Shantay's killer mounts, and authorities prepare for a manhunt. Colin Smith, a local man who knew Shantay, is questioned and subjected to a polygraph test. The investigation focuses on Colin Smith, who is considered a highly suspicious suspect. The community is gripped by fear as the investigation continues with no leads. Investigator Bird decides to use a new DNA technique called phenotyping, which predicts a person's physical appearance based on their DNA. The DNA is submitted to a lab, and five months later, Investigator Bird receives an email with a sketch of the potential killer. Shantay's half-brother sees the DNA sketch and recognizes the person depicted as Ryan Riggs, a local man who knew Shantay. Ryan Riggs is identified as the prime suspect in Shantay's murder. Investigators learn more about Ryan Riggs, discovering that he was a suspect in an illegal dumping case. After the DNA sketch is released to the public, Ryan Riggs goes on the run. Ryan Riggs unexpectedly shows up at Shantay's church with his parents. He confesses to the congregation that he is the murderer. Russell LeMonde, the assistant pastor who knew Ryan Riggs, confronts him after his confession. Ryan Riggs is taken to the sheriff's office by his parents. Ryan Riggs confesses to the authorities, detailing the events leading up to Shantay's murder. He describes how he strangled her, raped her, and then disposed of her body in the abandoned farmhouse. Ryan Riggs explains that he killed Shantay because he felt she was an easy target. He also reveals that he had previously had thoughts of harming animals. Ryan Riggs is charged with capital murder. The state offers him a plea deal, a life sentence without the possibility of parole. He accepts the deal and is sentenced in February 2019. Shantay's family is relieved that her killer is finally in custody, but they are still grappling with the loss of their daughter. Shantay's mother Michelle decides not to forgive Ryan Riggs, believing that he does not deserve forgiveness. This segment focuses on remembering Shantai, a young woman who was tragically killed. The speaker emphasizes the importance of remembering her for her vibrant personality and positive contributions to the community, rather than solely as a victim. This segment introduces "After the Verdict," a bonus series that follows the stories of individuals impacted by true crime cases after the verdict is reached. It highlights the ongoing struggles and resilience of those left behind, emphasizing their strength and courage in navigating extraordinary circumstances.
Deadly Entanglement
This podcast explores the complex relationships and events surrounding the murder of Desiree Sunford, revealing a web of deceit, obsession, and ultimately, a tragic loss.
This podcast delves into the murder of Desiree Sunford, a young art teacher found dead in her home. The investigation quickly focuses on her husband, Scott, whose suspicious behavior raises red flags. However, the case takes a dramatic turn when a friend of both Scott and Desiree, Paige Blades, reveals a three-way affair and names Marty Guizmer, a co-worker, as the killer. Marty, driven by an obsessive desire for Paige, confesses to the murder, claiming he wanted to remove Desiree from the picture. The podcast explores the complex dynamics of the relationships involved, highlighting the emotional turmoil and manipulation that led to the tragedy. Paige's role in the events remains ambiguous, with investigators suspecting her involvement but lacking concrete evidence. The podcast also delves into Marty's troubled past and his strained relationship with his wife, Beth, who was often overshadowed by his obsession with Paige. The investigation reveals a series of twists and turns, including Marty's attempt to hire a hitman to silence Paige and the challenges faced by prosecutors due to the circumstantial nature of the evidence. Ultimately, Marty accepts a plea deal, reducing his charge to second-degree murder and receiving a 15-year sentence. The podcast concludes with reflections on the aftermath of the case, highlighting the lingering pain and unanswered questions for Desiree's loved ones.
Lori Vallow Daybell: The Jailhouse Interview
This podcast delves into the disturbing case of Laurie Vallow Daybell, exploring the events leading to the deaths of her children and the subsequent investigation and trial.
This podcast episode delves into the disturbing case of Laurie Vallow Daybell, a woman known as the "most hated mom in America" due to the deaths of her children and other individuals in her life. The episode features a jailhouse interview with Laurie, where she denies any involvement in the deaths of her children and claims to be misunderstood. The episode recounts the disappearance of her children, JJ and Tyley, from their home in Idaho, and the suspicious deaths of her husband Charles Vallow and Chad Daybell's wife Tammy. The episode details the attempted murder of Tammy Daybell by Laurie's brother Alex Cox, the subsequent death of Tammy, and the exhumation of her body, which revealed evidence of asphyxiation. The episode focuses on Laurie's wedding to Chad Daybell, which took place just 17 days after Tammy's murder, and examines the timeline of events leading up to the wedding and the evidence surrounding the purchase of wedding rings. The episode describes how the investigation into the disappearance of JJ and Tyley intensifies, with police surveillance on Laurie's apartment complex in Rexburg, Idaho, and the discovery of the missing Jeep registered to Charles Vallow. The episode reveals how Laurie lied to police about the whereabouts of her son JJ and discusses the strange encounter between detectives and Alex and Chad in the alley, which leads to the execution of a search warrant on Laurie's apartment. The episode recounts the chase for Laurie and Chad after they flee their apartment in Rexburg, and discusses the role of Laurie's son Colby in the investigation and the public appeal for information about the missing children. The episode describes the discovery of JJ and Tyley's remains on Chad's property in Idaho, the arrest of Chad and Laurie, and the subsequent trials. The episode concludes with a jailhouse interview between Laurie and her son Colby, where Colby confronts Laurie about the deaths of his siblings and expresses his disbelief in her story. The episode ends with Laurie's continued insistence on her innocence and her belief that her mission will be revealed. Laurie continues to deny her involvement in the deaths of her children, despite the evidence presented at her trial. She claims that the narrative of her children being labeled "dark" and then dying is false, and that she was falsely accused and convicted. She also claims that she will be exonerated in the future. Laurie will be representing herself in her upcoming trial for the murder of her husband, Charles, and the conspiracy to murder her nephew, Brandon. She claims that she will be exonerated and that she and Chad will go free. Colby, Laurie's surviving son, is trying to build a good life despite the tragedy. He feels guilty for being the only one who survived and struggles with the loneliness of the situation.
Poison Twist
This Dateline episode investigates the death of a chiropractor, Mary Yoder, uncovering a complex web of suspicion, two trials, and a shocking twist that leads to the release of the accused after seven years in prison.
This episode of Dateline delves into the mysterious death of Mary Yoder, a chiropractor who died suddenly and unexpectedly. The investigation spans nearly a decade, involving multiple suspects, two trials, and a shocking twist. After Mary's death, her family suspects foul play, and the medical examiner determines the cause of death to be Colchocene poisoning. Mary's sister, Sharon, contacts the police, leading to a homicide investigation. An anonymous letter accuses Mary's son, Adam, of poisoning her, providing specific details about the poison and its location, leading investigators to Adam's Jeep. However, they discover Adam was out of state when Mary died, casting doubt on his involvement. Investigators then turn their attention to Katie, Adam's ex-girlfriend and Mary's office manager. Katie admits to writing the anonymous letter but denies any involvement in Mary's death. However, investigators uncover evidence linking Katie to the purchase of the poison and ultimately arrest her. Katie is charged with second-degree murder, but her motive remains unclear. Investigators delve into her relationship with Adam and Mary, seeking answers. Katie's first trial begins, with the prosecution presenting evidence that she poisoned Mary. Katie's defense argues that she was framed by Bill, Mary's husband. The defense then shifts its focus to Adam, suggesting he was the real killer. The defense presents evidence of Adam's alleged abuse of Katie and his potential motive. Katie's second trial begins, with the defense again pointing the finger at Adam. Adam takes the stand to deny the accusations and presents his own theory that Katie poisoned him. The jury finds Katie not guilty of second-degree murder but guilty of manslaughter. Katie is sentenced to 23 years in prison. Katie appeals her conviction, arguing that her lawyers failed to challenge the search warrant for her phone. The appellate court grants her a new trial and dismisses the indictment against her. After seven years in prison, Katie is released. The district attorney is reviewing the case and could refile charges. The family grapples with the aftermath of the case and the loss of Mary.
IDENTIFIED: Midtown Jane Doe
The podcast chronicles the decades-long investigation into the identity and murder of Midtown Jane Doe, a young woman found encased in concrete in a New York City basement, ultimately revealing her as Patricia McLone and highlighting the complexities of her troubled past and the mystery surrounding her husband, Donald Grant.
The episode delves into the chilling case of Midtown Jane Doe, a young woman discovered encased in concrete in a New York City basement. The discovery sparked a decades-long investigation to uncover her identity and bring her killer to justice. Construction workers unearthed the concrete slab concealing a skeleton, revealing a homicide with the victim hogtied and wrapped in a carpet. Clues like long fingernails, a tan bra, and a signet ring with initials PMCG suggested a young female victim. The victim's dental work and bone structure provided further insights into her age and background. The basement, with its history of illicit activities, including a speak easy and a rock club, was known for drug use and sex work, attracting vulnerable teens and predators. Investigators struggled to build a profile of the killer, considering the possibility of a local resident familiar with the building and concrete work. Joel Rifkin, a notorious serial killer, was briefly considered but ruled out. The building's transient residents and multiple access points made it difficult to find witnesses. Investigators attempted to identify the victim using the boulevard watch and the signet ring, but the watch's serial number proved unhelpful. The initials PMCG led to a nationwide search for missing persons. Soil samples from the crime scene revealed a torn clothing label, narrowing down the estimated time of death to the late 1980s or early 1990s. A facial reconstruction of the victim was featured on America's Most Wanted, but no one recognized her. DNA analysis proved difficult due to the degradation of the bones. A woman named Maureen believed the sketch resembled her missing sister, Judy O'Donnell, but DNA analysis ultimately ruled her out. Detective Glass, assigned to the case in 2022, challenged previous assumptions about the victim's background and time of death. A genealogy grade DNA profile was obtained, leading to two crucial matches. The DNA matches led to Patricia McLone, a 16-year-old girl who disappeared from Brooklyn. Patricia's family history and background revealed a complex and troubled family dynamic. Her father, Bernard McLone Sr., had a complicated past with multiple wives and children. Patricia's mother, Pat, was involved in a relationship with another married man. Patricia's attendance at school was sporadic, and she dropped out after getting married. Patricia's school records indicated a medical discharge, suggesting she was pregnant. The episode explored the "baby scoop era" and the exploitation of vulnerable young women facing unplanned pregnancies. Patricia married a man named Donald Grant a day before dropping out of school. Donald's address on the marriage license was the same building where Patricia's body was found. Investigators focused on Steve Paul's The Scene, a legendary rock club that operated in the basement where Patricia was found. The club's history was intertwined with mob activity, including Tony Cereko, known as Polly Walnuts from The Sopranos. Donald Grant, Patricia's husband, was identified as a key suspect. However, investigators discovered that Donald's identity was fabricated, and he appears to have stolen a dead baby's identity. The only documentation mentioning Patricia's disappearance came from a fraud case involving her half-brother, Junior. Pat claims Patricia abandoned her 11-month-old baby and moved away. A petition filed by Pat to release money from Patricia's inheritance revealed a forged signature. Pat's actions raised suspicions about her involvement in Patricia's disappearance. After extensive investigation, investigators are 99.5% certain that Patricia McLone is Midtown Jane Doe. Mitochondrial DNA analysis confirmed the match, finally providing a definitive answer. The case remains unsolved, with Donald Grant as the main suspect. Investigators are searching for information about Donald and the fate of Patricia's baby. They are also seeking anyone who knew Patricia or her family.
Emotional testimony from a killer. A murder defendant's unusual defense. And travel scam safety tips.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly covers several high-profile criminal cases, including the trial of Monica Sementilli, the third trial of Dana Chandler, and the investigation into the death of Gene Hackman.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly covers several high-profile criminal cases. The episode begins with an update on the trial of Monica Sementilli, who is accused of plotting with her lover to murder her husband. The episode then moves on to the third trial of Dana Chandler, who is representing herself in her defense against double murder charges. Chandler's main argument is that there is no physical evidence tying her to the murders. She has also called the lead detective who put her behind bars as a defense witness to highlight the lack of evidence. The episode also discusses the investigation into the mysterious death of Hollywood legend Gene Hackman and his wife Betsy. The investigation has ruled out carbon monoxide poisoning, but toxicology results are still pending. The episode then provides an update on the case of Diane Warner, a Michigan grandmother whose body was found stuffed in a fertilizer tank. Her stepson, Jaren Dale Warner, has been arrested on charges of tampering with evidence and accessory after the fact. The episode also covers the latest developments in the Karen Reed case, where she is accused of drunkenly backing her SUV into her police officer boyfriend, John O'Keefe, and leaving him to die in the snow. The defense has presented a motion to dismiss the case entirely, alleging that the prosecution suppressed video surveillance footage that would prove Reed's innocence. The episode concludes with a segment featuring NBC News Chief Consumer Investigative Correspondent Vicki Wynn, who shares tips on how to avoid travel scams. She warns about a new scam involving fake travel agents who use "corporate cards" to offer discounted vacations but never actually book them.
The 9 Best Pokemon Podcasts To Help You Catch Em All
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – February 2025