Discover
Tomlin’s Harmonica Podcast
61 Episodes
Reverse
Confused by all the talk of positions on harmonica? In this episode I explain what second position actually means and why we play a C harmonica in the key of G.
Ken joins me on "Ask Tomlin" to untangle one of the most confusing topics in harmonica: positions, and what it means to play a C harmonica in the key of G.
I start by taking a step back to keys, because position is a harmonica word rather than a music theory one. We look at what a key is, what first position means and how second position makes the 2 draw your home note. I also explain why that opens up the bends and bluesy sounds, and why a full major scale is better kept for first position.
Ken asks where the name "second position" comes from, so we look at the circle of fifths, and we cover how many positions there are in theory and which ones players actually use. We also answer a question on tied notes and eighth notes in written music, and I finish on why positions make far more sense once you're playing real music.
If you're new to the idea of keys or you're a bit lost on positions, this one is for you.
⏱ Audio Chapters
0:00 – Why are harmonica positions so confusing?
1:34 – Is "position" a music theory term?
2:16 – What is a key in music?
4:55 – What is first position?
6:14 – What is second position and why play a C harmonica in G?
9:17 – How many positions are there?
10:16 – Where does the name "second position" come from?
12:33 – How do tied notes and eighth notes work?
16:21 – Do I need to learn positions before playing music?
This video is brought to you by the ever-growing Tomlin Harmonica School - where you get a proper step-by-step curriculum, real feedback from real teachers on your own playing, and a genuinely warm community of fellow Harmonicats. Try it free for 7 days at tomlinharmonicaschool.com.
👉 Get the free harmonica questionnaire: https://hxajyaf5p9.zite.so
How much should you practise, and when is it time to move on? In this episode of "Ask Tomlin" I help Nick work out how to spend a month on one lesson.
Nick is in month two of Advanced Beginner and wants to know whether he should spend the full month on each lesson, even when parts of it feel easy. We talk about how to tell when something is properly learned. Can you play your scale up and down five times in a row without a mistake? If the fourth run falls apart, it still needs work.
I share how I practise a scale in short rounds with a five second micro break, and what to do once you're locked in: add a challenge by raising the tempo, swapping the metronome for a backing track or trying another key. We also look at the bored, challenged or frustrated test, why it's fine to stop a challenge that's too hard, and why I wouldn't skip ahead to another month before you've done the meat of one.
Then we get into whether you can work on breathing while you play scales, how to make your practice sound like music and whether to play along to a 12 bar blues straight after practising. This one is for any adult learner wondering if they're practising enough or in the right way.
⏱ Audio Chapters
0:00 – How much should you practise?
0:25 – Should I spend the whole month on one lesson?
2:45 – How do I know when something is properly learned?
4:31 – What do I do once I've got it?
6:02 – Am I bored, challenged or frustrated?
7:03 – What if a challenge is too hard?
9:50 – Why not skip ahead to the next month?
12:02 – Can I work on breathing while I play scales?
13:17 – How do I make my practice sound like music?
16:23 – Should I play music straight after practising?
This video is brought to you by the ever-growing Tomlin Harmonica School - where you get a proper step-by-step curriculum, real feedback from real teachers on your own playing, and a genuinely warm community of fellow Harmonicats. Try it free for 7 days at tomlinharmonicaschool.com.
Can you play the 2 draw whole step bend on its own, but lose it the moment it shows up in a piece of music? You're not alone, and it's fixable.
In this episode of "Ask Tomlin", Nick joins me with a problem plenty of you will recognise. He can get the 2 draw whole step bend in isolation, but when it turns up in a piece from the curriculum, he can see it coming a few bars away and it trips him up every time.
We talk about why this is one of the hardest notes on the instrument and why it takes thousands of reps, and I share the story of a student who nailed the 3 draw whole step bend by playing Silent Night in front of an audience. We look at slurring versus articulating the bend, and why I practise the 2 draw, 2 draw whole step bend, 1 draw as a single unit rather than thinking about each note.
Then we get into how I practise a tune differently: hardest part first, building a lick back a few notes at a time, and knowing when to park a technique and move on. It's for any player who has a note they dread seeing in a tune, whatever your level.
⏱ Audio Chapters
0:00 – Why does the 2 draw whole step bend fall apart in a tune?
2:08 – How do I get confident with a scary note?
4:25 – Should I slur into the bend or articulate it?
5:45 – Why practise the 2 draw, 2 draw bend, 1 draw as one unit?
6:53 – Playing the four-note unit
8:23 – Why practise the hardest part of the tune first?
9:31 – How do I build the lick back a few notes at a time?
11:04 – Why lean into the discomfort?
12:15 – When should I park a technique and move on?
This video is brought to you by the ever-growing Tomlin Harmonica School - where you get a proper step-by-step curriculum, real feedback from real teachers on your own playing, and a genuinely warm community of fellow Harmonicats. Try it free for 7 days at tomlinharmonicaschool.com.
👉 Get the free harmonica questionnaire: https://hxajyaf5p9.zite.so
Running out of breath on long runs of draw notes? It's a really common problem - and in this episode Scott and I work through it.
Scott went back to the Hoochie Coochie Blues and hit a passage with around 30 draw notes in it. He could manage it on his own, but once the backing track went on, his body went into panic mode and the air ran out. We start with the fundamentals - diaphragm breathing, standing up when you can and staying relaxed - and then look at why playing too hard wastes air.
From there I show him how to play at 80 per cent rather than 100, keep the airflow steady and slow a passage right down to find the gaps for breathing out. We also work on an exercise for breathing out quickly - holding a 2 draw for seven beats and emptying everything on the eighth - and I share a trick with a mic and an amp for stopping yourself playing too hard.
Most of the juicy notes in blues are draw notes, so breath management matters whatever your level. If you run out of air in long passages, this one is for you.
⏱ Audio Chapters
0:00 – Why do I run out of breath on draw notes?
1:29 – What are the breathing fundamentals?
3:12 – Am I using more air than I need?
6:11 – Should I start a new breath on every note?
7:07 – How do I find the gaps to breathe out?
8:07 – Why do I tense up with a backing track?
9:18 – How do I get comfortable breathing out quickly?
10:40 – Can the out breath sound musical?
12:01 – How do I trick myself into playing gently?
This video is brought to you by the ever-growing Tomlin Harmonica School - where you get a proper step-by-step curriculum, real feedback from real teachers on your own playing, and a genuinely warm community of fellow Harmonicats. Try it free for 7 days at tomlinharmonicaschool.com.
Finished the curriculum and not sure what to work on next? Peter hit exactly that wall six months ago, so in this episode we build him a plan for directing his own learning.
This one matters whether or not you're anywhere near advanced intermediate, because what I want for every student is that they end up able to keep learning with or without a teacher. The big habit is transcribing - sitting down with music you love and working it out by ear. I'm wary of calling a song "within reach", because at a certain point you can have a go at almost anything, you just accept that some bits will need revisiting later.
We talk about the difference between vertical progress, where you stack skill on skill through a curriculum, and horizontal progress, where you widen the foundation by learning repertoire and actually using what you've got. Then it becomes pick your own adventure - acoustic or amplified, lip pursing or tongue blocking, whatever you genuinely enjoy. Peter picks vibrato, acoustic playing and tongue blocking, so I suggest two tunes to start with, and we talk about why progress feels slower once you're sharpening tools rather than building them.
If you're at the point where you want to choose your own next step, this one is for you.
⏱ Audio Chapters
0:00 – Peter's question: what do I work on after the curriculum?
2:12 – Why I want students to teach themselves
3:40 – The big one: transcribing by ear
5:21 – A good first song to work out by ear
6:01 – Vertical progress vs horizontal progress
7:06 – Pick your own adventure: what do you enjoy playing?
10:07 – A tune for vibrato, acoustic and tongue blocking
11:07 – Why progress slows down, and that's fine
12:26 – Using the school once you've finished the curriculum
14:15 – Transcribe a little every day
This episode is brought to you by the ever-growing Tomlin Harmonica School - where you get a proper step-by-step curriculum, real feedback from real teachers on your own playing, and a genuinely warm community of fellow Harmonicats. Try it free for 7 days at https://bit.ly/4iYk0Cc



