Discover
The Litigation Psychology Podcast
The Litigation Psychology Podcast
Author: Courtroom Sciences
Subscribed: 54Played: 1,117Subscribe
Share
© Copyright 2026 All rights reserved.
Description
The Litigation Psychology Podcast presented by Courtroom Sciences, Inc. (CSI) is a podcast for in-house and outside defense counsel and insurance claims personnel about the intersection of science and litigation. We explore topics of interest to the defense bar, with a particular emphasis on subjects that don‘t get enough attention. Our hosts are experts in Clinical Psychology, Social Psychology, and scientifically-based jury research with a wealth of knowledge about psychology, science, jury research, human behavior, and decision making, which they apply in the context of civil litigation.
336 Episodes
Reverse
Bill Kanasky, Jr., Ph.D. talks about the concept of internal and external cognitive load for witnesses. Often the topic of cognitive load is focused on jurors, but witness cognitive load is an important challenge that doesn't get enough attention. External cognitive load for witnesses include things like the length of the deposition, the number of documents being reviewed, the environment in the conference room or the mental and physical fatigue of a lengthy Zoom deposition, etc. Internal cognitive load can include emotional issues, stress from issues not related to the litigation such as financial struggles, health challenges, family problems, etc., plus those directly related to the litigation such as anger, frustration, confusion, fear, worry, etc. External cognitive load issues are difficult to change, though some can be managed with breaks and proper preparation. Internal cognitive load issues need to be assessed well before witness prep begins and should be addressed throughout the prep to ensure the witness has the mental capacity and stability to inculcate the prep and be fully prepared for testimony. Watch the video of this episode: https://youtu.be/hlalgSzb8aA
Steve Ellis, Vice President Liability Practice at Sedgwick and Taylor Smith, Founder and President of Suite 200 Solutions join Bill Kanasky, Jr., Ph.D. to talk about AI in claims and litigation. Steve and Taylor share the background on their article titled "Are We Measuring the Value of Claims AI or Simply Measuring Its Activity?" which they wrote for Carrier Management. Steve describes the difference between how the plaintiff's side is using AI, which is to maximize outcomes, vs. how the defense side is using it, which is primarily for efficiency, and the impacts those different use cases are having on litigation. Taylor makes the point that the defense side is slowed and challenged by not having agreement between carriers and defense counsel on how to use AI and who should cover the costs for the tools. The group discuss the challenge of how to get new people, in both claims and insurance defense, the experience they need to be successful in their roles, the pros and cons of AI in their training, and how to attract new people to the profession. They conclude by sharing advice they would give claims leaders today. Watch the video of this episode: https://youtu.be/iEg5yFmdIYU
Sarah Burton, Ph.D. joins Steve Wood, Ph.D. to talk about how the integration of early jury research with witness training is beneficial in developing your cases. Sarah describes the strategic advantages for deposition testimony by identifying issues in the early jury research that jurors find important. Jurors will share things they want to hear, learn, or know that witnesses will be asked about at deposition and preparing and training witnesses to provide effective responses to these critical topics is key to strong testimony. Sarah gives the example of learning in early jury research that mock jurors had concerns about the credibility of the company, which led to a higher focus on the directness and credibility of the witness during their deposition testimony. Steve and Sarah talk about how important it is to spend time in the prep to help the witness stay focused when they get frustrated or are struggling to apply the training. They share different scientifically-supported techniques they teach witnesses to help them relax and calm themselves when feeling emotional or stressed. Lastly, they talk about the use of jury research in preparation for trial and how jury research can help with developing a compelling case narrative. Watch the video of this episode here: https://youtu.be/7C23JMxYvFY
Bill Kanasky, Jr., Ph.D. talks about using AI for jury research. There are several limitations in the reliability and validity associated with using big data and AI jury research. The AI analysis is only as good as the data fed into it. The AI jury research offerings that are being promoted today lack reliability and validity due to the data that it is collecting, most of which is not venue specific. In order to achieve statistical significance, the amount of data required from each individual venue is much larger than what is available today. Additionally, any AI jury research or big data studies on specific cases cannot identify juror comprehension issues, juror emotional reactions, and juror confusion nor can it replicate the juror interactions that take place in deliberations. These missing elements have a direct impact on the validity of the data collected. A larger sample is not necessarily better - sample size is not useful with artificial stimuli. Serial focus groups are a much more useful data collection tool as they address all the limitations around venue, juror comprehension, juror interaction, juror confusion and allow for a much richer, deeper discussion with jurors to understand both the what and the why behind their feedback. Watch the video of this episode: https://youtu.be/bdtiG8YGqWM
Bill Kanasky, Jr., Ph.D. shares a couple of stories of recent attorney inquiries for litigation consulting services at the very last minute because approval was not received from the client until days before trial. When authority for litigation consulting services comes late, it limits, and sometimes even completely prevents, the services from being scheduled due to other obligations. Waiting until the eve of trial is a poor and risky strategy. Discussing litigation consulting options early and preparing well in advance of mediation and trial is critical to increasing the odds of better litigation outcomes. Watch the video of this episode: https://youtu.be/P7ChblG403c



