DiscoverCanada's Court: Oral Arguments from the SCC
Canada's Court: Oral Arguments from the SCC
Claim Ownership

Canada's Court: Oral Arguments from the SCC

Author: Criminal Lawyers' Association

Subscribed: 74Played: 1,473
Share

Description

Canada’s Court is the first podcast to highlight select oral hearings from The Supreme Court of Canada. Presented by the Criminal Lawyers’ Association and available on all major podcast platforms. Visit podcast.criminallawyers.ca for more information.


A full webcast version of the oral arguments featured in each episode can be viewed from The Supreme Court of Canada website at scc-csc.ca or obtained from the court directly.


The Supreme Court of Canada is not affiliated with this podcast and did not produce or participate in it’s creation.

101 Episodes
Reverse
B.F., a surgical nurse, had a child, E. In 2019, an interim family court ruling granted E.’s father supervised access, which B.F. resisted. At the time, B.F. was residing with her mother, I.F.On June 12, 2019, a neighbour found B.F., I.F., and E., then 19 months old, in B.F.’s home. All three were unconscious in B.F.’s bedroom. First responders found five empty insulin pens at the scene, each of which originally contained many times the normal adult dose. There were nine visible injection marks on E.’s body and evidence that E. had resisted the injections; no injection marks were visible on B.F. or I.F. The first responders also located a handwritten letter at the scene that they characterized as a suicide note. Due to the quantity of insulin injected into her system, E. suffered serious and permanent brain and organ damage. She was diagnosed with cerebral palsy and spasticity and requires constant medical care. B.F. was arrested and charged with two counts of attempted murder by administering a noxious substance and two counts of aggravated assault.The Crown’s theory at trial was that B.F. intended to kill E. in response to her estranged spouse obtaining access to the child. A jury convicted B.F. of the attempted murder of E. and I.F., and of the aggravated assault of E. The jury acquitted B.F. of the aggravated assault of I.F.B.F. appealed her conviction and sentence to the Court of Appeal for Ontario. The conviction and sentence appeal in relation to the attempted murder of E. was dismissed.The conviction appeal in relation to the attempted murder of I.F. was allowed and a new trial ordered.The Crown sought and was granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”). The Crown argues that the Court of Appeal’s findings were premised on a flawed understanding of causation for homicide, and that the Court’s reasoning led it to adopt a novel interpretation of the relationship between the offences of assisting suicide and homicide, which the SCC should reject.
Sharon Fox is a criminal defence lawyer whose client was the subject of a wiretap authorization. This authorization did not permit live monitoring of phone calls with a lawyer. During the surveillance operation, a call between Ms. Fox and her client was automatically recorded. A civilian employee also listened to a portion of the call before disconnecting.A reviewing judge concluded that an initial portion of the telephone call was not subject to solicitor-client privilege and it was released to the Crown. The recording revealed Ms. Fox had informed her client that a third party had been arrested and that the police would likely be obtaining search warrants for places where the third party had been. Ms. Fox was charged with wilfully attempting to obstruct, pervert or defeat the course of justice by interfering in an ongoing police investigation, contrary to s. 139(2) of the Criminal Code.The trial judge concluded that there was no section 8 Charter breach with respect to the civilian employee listening to her phone conversation. However, she found that ss. 7 and 11(d) of the Charter had been breached due to her inability to access the second, privileged portion of the recording. The entire recording was excluded under s. 24(1) of the Charter, and Ms. Fox was acquitted.A majority of the Court of Appeal of Saskatchewan affirmed the acquittal and the trial judge’s decision with respect to the ss. 7 and 11(d) breaches. However, the majority also found a s. 8 breachand therefore would have excluded the evidence of the telephone call under s. 24(2) rather than s. 24(1). The dissenting judge concluded that ss. 7 and 11(d) had not been breached but agreed with the majority that there had been a s. 8 breach. The dissenting judge would not have excluded the evidence under s. 24(2) and would have ordered a new trial.The Crown appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada as of right.
Dayton Kelly was driving at night on Highway 86 in October 2021 when his car struck a horse-drawn buggy entering the highway from a sideroad. He was travelling well above the 80 km/hr limit. Both occupants of the buggy died. Blood samples later showed that the amount of THC in his blood was above the legal limit, and he was convicted of the basic offence of driving with an illegal amount of THC. The trial judge acquitted Kelly of the two counts of causing death while driving with THC because the parties agreed there was no evidence that the amount of THC in his blood itself caused the collision. The Court of Appeal for Ontario held that this was a legal error. It ruled that the Criminal Code does not require the Crown to prove a separate causal link between the amount of THC in the driver’s blood and the deaths. The Crown need only prove the underlying offence and ordinary legal causation, meaning that Kelly’s driving was a significant contributing cause of death. A new trial was ordered.
Jordan Bilinski was acquitted by a jury of sexual assault in Alberta. The complainant, his ex-girlfriend, had invited him over for sex on the express condition that he wear a condom. The evidence was that they had three sexual encounters that evening: oral sex without a condom, vaginal intercourse with a condom followed by ejaculation on her back, and then a final act of intercourse after she again insisted on condom use and put on a new condom. The allegation was that, during that final act, Bilinski removed the condom and ejaculated in her vagina. In his police interview, he admitted she had required condom use, admitted removing it, and said he did so because “it feels better.”At trial, Bilinski did not advance honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent. The case therefore turned on the complainant’s credibility and reliability, whether she subjectively consented to sex without a condom, and what the Crown had to prove on mens rea. The trial judge told the jury the Crown had to prove, among other things, that Bilinski knew she did not consent, through actual knowledge, recklessness, or wilful blindness. The jury acquitted.The Alberta Court of Appeal unanimously found errors in the jury charge. The majority held the judge failed to distinguish properly between subjective consent for actus reus purposes and communicated consent for mens rea purposes, and failed to tell the jury that, if it found non-consent, it should have little difficulty finding mens rea. It ordered a new trial. Justice Feehan dissented on the result, concluding the errors were not shown to have materially affected the acquittal. The appeal went to the Supreme Court of Canada as of right.
R.B.-C. was convicted of sexual assault. He is an Iranian citizen living in Canada on a post-graduation work permit. But his sentence was not imposed until more than 14 months after his conviction. When it finally was imposed, he received a conditional sentence of two years less a day, followed by probation.Because of the delay in sentencing, R.B.-C. sought a stay of proceedings under section 11(b) of the Charter. The application judge relied on the leading Ontario case on post-verdict delay, R. v. Charley, which sets a presumptive ceiling of five months. The judge concluded that the net delay fell below that ceiling and dismissed the application.The Court of Appeal disagreed. It held that the post-conviction delay exceeded the five-month ceiling. Rather than ordering a stay, though, it reduced the sentence to 20 months.The Supreme Court of Canada granted the Crown leave to appeal. The Court will consider both the proper framework for post-verdict delay and the appropriate remedy where that delay is found to be unreasonable.
loading
Comments