Discover
Derech HaShem with Rabbi Aryeh Shulman
131 Episodes
Reverse
Rabbi Shulman concludes the Ramchal’s discussion of individual providence by distinguishing between events that establish a person’s intended circumstances and events that serve as steps toward something else. Apparent setbacks may produce unexpected benefits, prevent greater harm, or affect another person’s life. He then explains how providence operates alongside free will and why “for the best” means the best opportunity for spiritual growth—not necessarily the most comfortable circumstances.
Outline: https://ateres-ami.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dh-biyun-2-3-12-20261118-211949-outline-20261118-212106.pdf
Rabbi Shulman explores the Ramchal’s distinction between the shared humanity of Israel and the nations and their different capacities for spiritual connection. Drawing on the Maharal, he explains why Jewish identity cannot be reduced to national characteristics or intellectual accomplishments, while emphasizing the dignity of every human being. The discussion then turns to Adam’s original purpose, proposing that his descendants could have inherited his spiritual perfection as extensions of one unified humanity.
Outline: https://ateres-ami.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dh-biyun-2-4-1-20261118-211313-outline-20261118-211457.pdf
Rabbi Shulman explains Ramchal’s presentation of reincarnation as an expression of divine mercy: an opportunity to repair earlier failures, without erasing responsibility for them. He distinguishes between the circumstances assigned to a person and the ultimate judgment of that person’s choices, which accounts precisely for effort and freedom of choice. The discussion concludes by explaining how divine wisdom selects among the many possible causes of life’s circumstances, rather than allowing conflicting purposes simply to cancel one another out.
Outline: https://ateres-ami.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dh-biyun-2-3-10-20261110-040540-outline-20261110-040722.pdf
Rabbi Shulman examines how suffering accepted with love can benefit not only an individual but an entire generation—and, at the highest levels, humanity across history. He distinguishes punishment understood as satisfying justice from suffering understood as actually cleansing the world and restoring the revelation of Hashem’s presence. The discussion then introduces reincarnation as another avenue of divine mercy, while emphasizing that it is a last resort, not an escape from responsibility for one’s previous life.
Outline: https://ateres-ami.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dh-biyun-2-3-9-20261103-131054-outline-20261103-131242.pdf
Rabbi Shulman explains how the Jewish people’s spiritual interconnectedness allows individuals to benefit from the merits of others—and enables exceptionally righteous people to suffer for the benefit of their generation. Building on Ramchal’s discussion of mutual responsibility, he distinguishes between suffering that atones for a contemporary community and a higher form that repairs longstanding deficiencies in the world. Central to both is the righteous person’s identification with others and imitation of God’s goodness through selfless giving.
Outline: https://ateres-ami.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dh-biyun-2-3-8-20261027-030537-outline-20261027-030729.pdf



