Discover
Broken Benefits
Broken Benefits
Author: Lee Lewis
Subscribed: 8Played: 85Subscribe
Share
© Copyright 2026 Lee Lewis
Description
Whether you are the benefits manager or CEO of your organization, one of the biggest drivers of organizational performance, that most get totally wrong, is the health and benefits strategy. We spend billions on benefits, yet healthcare is unaffordable and complicated. More than half of Americans don't even take their paid vacation, yet people are burning out faster than ever and remote work is scrambling company cultures.
It doesn't have to be this way! Great benefits can attract and retain top talent, communicate your values, rejuvenate your productivity, move your stock price, and even save lives.
Lee knows this because he advised and learned from many Fortune 100 employers on how to create wildly profitable and popular benefits programs that enhance all areas of the business. Lee created this podcast in the hopes that together we can save lives, save dollars, and save our talent.
Join us, each episode, on YouTube or your favorite podcasting platform for some great conversation with some of the world's leading experts in this space.
It doesn't have to be this way! Great benefits can attract and retain top talent, communicate your values, rejuvenate your productivity, move your stock price, and even save lives.
Lee knows this because he advised and learned from many Fortune 100 employers on how to create wildly profitable and popular benefits programs that enhance all areas of the business. Lee created this podcast in the hopes that together we can save lives, save dollars, and save our talent.
Join us, each episode, on YouTube or your favorite podcasting platform for some great conversation with some of the world's leading experts in this space.
42 Episodes
Reverse
What happens when someone with no traditional benefits background takes responsibility for managing hundreds of millions of dollars in employer healthcare spending?For Jackie Adams, it started with a lot of questions.Coming from a background in HR technology, analytics, and Lean process improvement, Jackie approached healthcare differently. Rather than accepting the industry's established processes, vendor relationships, and financial assumptions, she began looking at healthcare as a supply chain, examining where value was being created, where waste existed, and why so many seemingly simple questions were difficult to answer.In this episode of Broken Benefits, Lee Lewis sits down with Jackie to explore how her unconventional perspective helped transform her approach to employer-sponsored healthcare.Jackie shares how she began questioning the information provided by consultants and vendors, why she insisted on accessing raw claims data, and how her team learned to distinguish impressive-looking vendor ROI reports from meaningful improvements in overall plan performance.The conversation also explores the importance of building a clear benefits strategy, educating organizational stakeholders about the true drivers of healthcare costs, and establishing vendor relationships built around transparency, accountability, and shared responsibility for results.Jackie explains how her organization has achieved nearly flat healthcare cost trend in recent years without simply shifting more costs onto employees. She also discusses the role of secondary health plans in expanding access to care and reducing costs, along with her team's decision to transition toward an independent third-party administrator in 2027.Throughout the conversation, Jackie offers a compelling reminder that meaningful healthcare innovation doesn't always begin with specialized industry knowledge.Sometimes it begins with curiosity, an analytical mindset, and the confidence to challenge an answer that doesn't make sense.Because when you're responsible for protecting both a health plan and the people who depend on it, asking why isn't a distraction from the job. It's part of the job.Chapters:00:00 Why Jackie Started Asking Questions00:55 Welcome to Broken Benefits01:09 Meet Jackie Adams: An Unconventional Benefits Leader03:00 Applying Lean Thinking to Healthcare04:12 When Vendor ROI Doesn't Match the Results07:10 Challenging Traditional Carrier Contracts09:00 Where Benefits Leaders Should Start Asking Questions12:00 Following the Money Through Healthcare14:12 Building a Strategy and Getting Stakeholder Buy-In17:35 Exposing Healthcare Pricing Differences21:28 Why Benchmarking Medical Trend Isn't Enough23:00 Taking Ownership of Your Healthcare Claims Data25:00 Finding Advisors Who Challenge the Status Quo29:00 Rethinking the Role of Benefits Consultants33:34 Vendor Accountability, Contracts and Performance37:18 Building a Culture of Innovation40:18 Secondary Health Plans and Nearly Flat Cost Trend43:00 Why Jackie Is Changing Her Administrative Model46:24 Final Advice for Benefits Leaders48:00 Closing Thoughts
What if one of the biggest obstacles to better employee benefits isn't the cost of healthcare, but the questions employers aren't asking?For years, Lori Giuliano approached benefits management much like countless other leaders. Healthcare costs increased, medical trend dictated the budget, and the available options seemed limited to shifting more costs onto employees or reducing benefits.But what happens when you begin questioning the assumptions behind that approach?In this episode of Broken Benefits, Lee Lewis sits down with Lori Giuliano, a benefits leader at a major pharmaceutical manufacturer, to explore her transformation from following the traditional healthcare playbook to actively challenging the system and pursuing a different strategy.Lori shares how learning from other employers, examining vendor relationships and understanding the financial incentives embedded in healthcare helped reshape her perspective on what was possible.The conversation explores the importance of questioning consultant compensation, evaluating traditional versus transparent PBM models, understanding fiduciary responsibility and taking a more active role in managing healthcare spending.Lori also discusses several initiatives she's championing, including advanced primary care, improved access to menopause care, and a secondary health plan designed to create value for employees and employers alike.Throughout the conversation, one idea stands out: better benefits and lower healthcare costs don't have to be competing objectives.From building confidence to challenge established partners to gaining leadership support for new approaches, Lori offers a relatable perspective for benefits professionals who suspect there may be a better way but aren't sure where to begin.Because sometimes meaningful change doesn't start with a new vendor, a new benefit or a bigger budget.It starts with asking a better question.Chapters:00:00 The Cost of Accepting Healthcare Trend00:36 Welcome to Broken Benefits01:00 Meet Lori Giuliano: Rethinking Traditional Benefits03:00 From Passenger to Driver of Healthcare Strategy05:00 Why Benefits Leadership Is Personal09:00 Better Benefits and Lower Costs: Why Not Both?11:00 Discovering the Hidden Side of Healthcare14:00 Learning From Employers Who Challenge the System17:00 Building Support for a Different Approach18:00 Traditional vs. Transparent PBM Models21:00 Questioning the Role of Benefits Consultants24:00 Hidden Compensation and Fiduciary Responsibility28:00 How Lori Accelerated Her Healthcare Education33:00 The Business Case for Advanced Primary Care36:00 Making Better Healthcare More Accessible41:00 Addressing the Gaps in Menopause Care45:00 Secondary Health Plans: A Win-Win Strategy50:00 Why Independent TPAs May Be the Future52:00 Final Advice and Closing Thoughts
Healthcare costs keep rising. Employers know they need to do something different.But doing something different comes with risk.That tension sits at the center of Lee Lewis' conversation with Eric Foster, a benefits leader and consultant who has spent more than two decades in the industry and previously led benefits at Lowe's and Albertsons. In those roles, Eric helped manage health plans covering roughly 150,000 to 200,000 lives and hundreds of millions of dollars in healthcare spending.In this episode of Broken Benefits, Eric explains why healthcare is ultimately an opportunity-cost problem for employers. Every additional dollar consumed by healthcare is a dollar that can't be invested somewhere else in the business.Yet simply repeating the same strategy isn't an option either.Eric and Lee explore what it takes to create a culture where benefits teams can experiment, test new ideas and learn without allowing the fear of failure to become an excuse for standing still. Eric shares lessons from running multiple pilots, testing competing solutions and using real-world experience to make better decisions about what deserves to scale.The conversation also goes beyond healthcare cost.Eric makes the case that benefits teams should borrow capabilities from their own marketing organizations, listen more carefully to employees, turn successful programs into stories people actually understand and even equip recruiters to use benefits as a competitive advantage in the fight for talent.They also discuss the value of building a strong network of other benefits leaders, learning from failed experiments, holding vendors to higher standards and recognizing that communication and engagement may represent far more of a benefits leader's job than most organizations realize.Because innovation carries risk.But when the existing trajectory isn't sustainable, standing still may be the greater risk.Chapters:00:00 Healthcare Is an Opportunity-Cost Problem00:58 Welcome to Broken Benefits02:11 Eric Foster's Benefits Leadership Journey03:33 Managing Healthcare at Massive Scale07:57 Where Should Benefits Leaders Focus?11:20 Benefits as a Workforce Strategy14:00 Innovating Inside Organizational Constraints18:00 The Benefits Innovation Paradox19:35 "More Pilots Than American Airlines"21:00 Testing, Learning and Scaling What Works23:00 Why Benefits Teams Need Marketing27:00 Turning Benefits Into a Recruiting Advantage33:00 The Rising Expectations and Cost of Healthcare39:00 What Benefits Leaders Can Learn From Recruiters45:00 Learning From Other Employers' Experiments51:00 Holding Vendors Accountable54:00 Why Communication Is 70% of the Job60:00 Over-Communicate, Learn and Know When to Move On
Adam Stavisky spent years running benefits for the largest private workforce in the country, overseeing the largest private health plan in the world along with a massive 401(k) and leave of absence program. In this episode, Lee sits down with Adam to unpack how a culture built on innovation and razor thin margins forced his team to find creative ways to cut costs without shifting the burden onto employees.Adam walks through the leadership lessons that shaped his approach: how consulting taught him to distill complex problems into a single page, why he insisted his team push back on his own ideas, and the moment a signature program he championed had to be pulled back in front of Walmart's CEO. He shares the exact language leadership used that turned a failure into one of his most defining career moments.From there, the conversation moves into practical strategy. Adam breaks down why provider quality, not plan design, is the biggest lever employers have for improving outcomes and controlling costs, using a striking statistic about C-section rates to make the case. He also flags the fiduciary risks most employers are sitting on right now, including voluntary benefits litigation, payment integrity gaps, and the importance of simply documenting the work you're already doing.If you manage benefits at any size organization, or if you're trying to understand why healthcare costs keep climbing despite everyone agreeing the system is broken, this episode is packed with tactical guidance you can apply immediately.Chapters:0:00 Cold Open: "You Had to Take Cost Out of the System"0:50 Welcome to Broken Benefits1:05 Meet Adam Stavisky: From Top Consultant to Walmart's Head of Benefits1:42 From Consulting Decks to "Kitchen English"2:56 The Real Shock of Moving In-House: Relationship Building5:06 How Adam Protected His Calendar to Protect His Team5:54 Sponsor Break: Catalyze Health6:42 Empowering a Benefits Team to Push Back and Take Bold Action8:39 The Most Underrated Leadership Skill: Prioritization10:54 Inside Walmart's Culture of Innovation and Cost Discipline14:20 When Leadership Says "Find $100 Million," Where Do You Start?16:22 What Most C-Suites Get Wrong About Managing Healthcare22:15 The Signature Program That Failed: A Lesson in "Limiting Blast Radius"24:28 Why Every Executive Recommendation Should Include the Best Counterargument26:36 "Don't Delegate Up": Building a Team That Owns Decisions28:48 Ownership Mentality and the Hardest Job of a Leader31:44 Opportunity #1: Provider Quality Is the Biggest Lever in Healthcare Costs36:03 Why Provider Directories Are a Hidden Cost-Control Tool39:33 Risk #1: Fiduciary Due Diligence Employers Can't Ignore40:26 Voluntary Benefits, Commission Structures, and the Schlichter Bogard Lawsuits41:57 Payment Integrity: Detection Isn't Enough, You Need Resolution44:37 Sponsor Break: Catalyze Health47:12 Engaging a Workforce as Diverse as a Small Country51:39 What Gives Adam Optimism About the Future of Benefits52:48 Where to Find Adam Stavisky53:09 Outro: Subscribe and Share
What happens when a benefits leader stops accepting rising healthcare costs as inevitable?For Paul Dumas, the answer was simple: start taking control.A longtime CHRO, Paul had spent decades approaching benefits much like many other employers do. Watch the trend. Build the budget. Work with the broker. Try to come in below the projected increase.That changed when his organization saw a 19.5% healthcare trend and was suddenly $15 million over budget after a single month, driven in large part by the rapid growth of GLP-1 utilization.That moment forced Paul to look much deeper into the healthcare ecosystem and question assumptions that had gone largely unchallenged.In this episode of Broken Benefits, Paul walks Lee Lewis through what he discovered, including misaligned incentives among brokers, PBMs and carriers, the difference between a discount and a genuinely good price, the problem with treating healthcare as a fixed expense, and why employers need greater independence and transparency throughout their benefits ecosystem.The conversation also explores Paul's approach to rebuilding the strategy from the ground up, including transparent broker compensation, a transparent PBM, an independent TPA, reference-based pricing, care navigation and a stronger emphasis on primary care.And the results were significant.Paul shares how his organization identified $8.5 million in hard savings in year one and approximately $24 million in year two, allowing the organization to reinvest those savings into total rewards, mental health and other areas that directly benefit employees.This isn't a conversation about simply cutting benefits.It's about asking a more important question:What if employers could spend less on healthcare while actually making the benefits experience better?That's the conversation.Chapters:0:00 Introduction: Why Healthcare Can't Stay a Fixed Cost 1:37 Paul's Journey Into Healthcare Strategy 4:09 The $15 Million Healthcare Wake-Up Call 6:18 Misaligned Incentives: Brokers, PBMs & Rebates 10:33 Why Employers Need to Take Back Control 16:25 The Problem With "Discounted" Healthcare 20:55 Rebuilding the Healthcare Ecosystem 25:20 What Happens When You Eliminate Rebates? 26:36 Primary Care, Navigation & Better Outcomes 28:48 $8.5 Million in Year-One Savings 29:09 $24 Million in Year-Two Savings 30:49 Reinvesting Healthcare Savings Into Employees 36:28 How Benefits Leaders Can Drive Change 42:47 The Playbook: Where Employers Should Start 48:11 Reference-Based Pricing & Regaining Control 54:08 Final Thoughts With Paul Dumas




