Discover
The Spear
The Spear
Author: Modern War Institute at West Point
Subscribed: 1,057Played: 96,341Subscribe
Share
© 2019
Description
The Spear is a podcast from the Modern War Institute at West Point. It sets out to explore the combat experience, with each episode featuring a guest who tells a detailed and personal story, describing the events and exploring topics like decision-making under stress and what it feels like to be in combat.
227 Episodes
Reverse
In this episode, Colonel Richard J. Ikena Jr., director of the Command and General Staff School at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, reflects on nearly three decades of Army service, including five combat deployments and leadership assignments across four infantry divisions. Drawing on his experiences as a field artillery officer in Iraq and Afghanistan, he discusses the importance of rehearsals, clear commander’s intent, and disciplined initiative in combat, as well as the challenges of employing fires while minimizing collateral damage. Colonel Ikena also examines the enduring lessons of counterinsurgency operations and their applicability to large-scale combat operations, emphasizing the importance of mastering fundamental warfighting skills before integrating new technologies. Recalling his experiences commanding the Mission Command Training Program, he explains how effective staffs support commanders' decision-making and why understanding the preferences and processes of higher headquarters is essential. He also discusses how the Command and General Staff School prepares field grade officers for the uncertainty and complexity of future warfare through professional military education, critical thinking, and practical application of doctrine. Throughout the conversation, Colonel Ikena emphasizes the importance of repetition, shared understanding, effective communication, and the distinction between training for certainty and educating for uncertainty.
Chapters
(00:00:02) - Introduction and Origin Story(00:01:30) - Combat Deployments and Lessons Learned(00:03:25) - Mission Command Principles and Clear Intent(00:04:35) - Employment of Fires in Counterinsurgency(00:09:48) - Lessons for Large Scale Combat Operations(00:12:20) - Experiences Across Multiple Divisions(00:16:14) - Returning to Korea: Then and Now(00:18:36) - Mission Command Training Program Insights(00:21:19) - Operations vs Targeting Process Commanders(00:25:40) - Developing Leaders at Command and General Staff College(00:31:05) - Balancing Planning Speed and Preparation(00:33:49) - Training for Certainty, Educating for Uncertainty(00:35:44) - Mastering the Basics as a Leader(00:36:39) - Closing Thoughts on Communication and Leadership(00:39:24) - Closing and Podcast Credits
Editor's Note: In conjuction with the pending publication of the latest edition of the Modern War Journal, Relections on Security Force Assistance and the Afghan War, we are re-releasing this episode, which was first published on September 14, 2022.
In 2001, Scott Neil was already an experienced Green Beret assigned to 5th Special Forces Group and preparing to deploy again to the Middle East. The events of 9/11 changed the nature of that deployment and directly impacted Scott. Within weeks, he became part of the legendary Horse Soldiers who led some of the opening operations in America’s war in Afghanistan. While theirs is a well-known story, Scott’s career did not stop there. The following years saw him deploy multiple times in support of the Global War on Terrorism.
In this episode of The Spear, he reflects on twenty-five years of service, the battles that shaped him, and his evolving role as a leader, mentor, and soldier. From occupying a foxhole in Panama as a young private to being wounded for a third time in Iraq to serving as the senior enlisted advisor to an interagency task for with US Special Operations Command, Scott’s career was consistently one of transition and growth.
Chapters
(00:00:00) - Intro and Combat Montage(00:01:16) - Meet Scott Neal and Early Army Career(00:02:45) - Panama Invasion Experience(00:05:01) - Post-Panama: Germany, Fort Carson, Gulf War(00:05:52) - Trying Out for Special Forces(00:06:34) - Special Forces Qualification Course(00:07:28) - Robin Sage and Language School(00:09:31) - First ODA Assignment at Fort Campbell(00:11:16) - Kuwait Rotations and Iris Gold Exercises(00:13:14) - Missions in Kenya and Pakistan(00:15:23) - September 11th and Deployment Alert(00:17:57) - Planning the Afghanistan Invasion(00:19:10) - Return Home and Iraq Invasion Prep(00:20:33) - Fall of Baghdad and Post-Invasion Chaos(00:21:35) - Mapping Foreign Fighter Networks in Africa(00:24:21) - Return to Iraq Amid Civil War(00:25:27) - Role as Troop Sergeant Major on Raids(00:29:26) - Managing Battlefield Chaos and Communications(00:32:00) - When Missions Go Wrong(00:35:28) - Post-Mission Recovery and Operational Rhythm(00:37:02) - Family, Isolation, and Coping with War(00:38:18) - Early PTSD Awareness and Hidden Injuries(00:41:09) - Third IED Hit and Deciding to Step Back(00:42:02) - Transition to SOCOM Headquarters(00:44:26) - The Decision to Step Down from Combat Role(00:47:28) - Leadership Role in Interagency Task Force(00:49:10) - Retirement and Life After the Army(00:51:34) - Reflecting on Legacy and Mentorship(00:53:10) - Closing and Outro
In this episode, Dr. Charlie Faint sits down with retired Lieutenant Colonel Andre Rivier, a former infantry officer and foreign area officer, to discuss a military career that took him from combat operations in Iraq to diplomatic assignments across Southeast Asia and the Pacific. An immigrant who enlisted in the US Army at seventeen before attending West Point, Andre reflects on his early experiences leading soldiers in Kosovo during the September 11 attacks, commanding an infantry company in Iraq, and discovering the importance of understanding the cultural, political, and social dynamics of military operations. He then describes his transition into the Army's FAO community, sharing insights from his assignments as a military attaché and security cooperation officer in Fiji, Laos, and other Pacific nations. Drawing on lessons from his military service, Andre argues that successful leaders must be comfortable operating in ambiguity, willing to challenge their assumptions, and capable of understanding the world through perspectives other than their own.
Chapters
(00:00:02) - Introduction and Origin Story(00:00:32) - Joining the Army and Path to West Point(00:01:42) - Family Reaction and Early Career(00:03:31) - First Deployment to Kosovo and Handpicked Platoon(00:04:33) - Selecting Soldiers and Leadership Qualities(00:06:21) - Pre-9/11 Balkans Mission and Combat Status(00:08:18) - Experiencing 9/11 Overseas(00:12:06) - Global Reaction to 9/11 and Local Goodwill(00:13:31) - Language, Culture, and Communication Abroad(00:16:54) - Language Learning and DLPT Experiences(00:18:46) - Path to Becoming a Foreign Area Officer(00:19:49) - Understanding Iraq's Social Dynamics(00:23:00) - Command Experience and Deployment Cycles(00:23:51) - Deciding to Become a FAO(00:26:10) - Explaining Branches vs Functional Areas(00:27:40) - Language Training in Iraq with Soldiers(00:30:32) - FAO Application Process(00:33:00) - DLI Training and Learning Thai(00:34:42) - Foreign Staff College in Thailand(00:37:03) - Family Life and Immersion Overseas(00:37:53) - Graduate School at Yale(00:40:20) - Yale Classmates and Cross-Cultural Bonds(00:42:05) - Karaoke and Cultural Icebreakers(00:44:01) - Recommending Yale and Other Programs(00:44:56) - JMAS and Attache Training(00:46:40) - Favorite Grad School Courses(00:48:47) - Learning Indonesian and Field Experience(00:50:34) - Best Job: Southwest Pacific Attache(00:53:28) - Assignment to Laos(00:56:20) - Final Assignment and Afghanistan Deployment(00:56:40) - Career Reflections and Key FAO Skills(00:58:38) - Advice for Aspiring FAOs(01:02:33) - Visiting West Point with His Daughter(01:03:24) - Closing Thoughts on Cultural Awareness(01:04:49) - Life After the Army: Defense Consulting(01:06:54) - Family, Moves, and Closing Remarks
In this episode, Colonel Mike Rosol joins MWI's Charlie Faint to reflect on a career spanning armored warfare, multiple deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan, teaching and scholarship at West Point, interagency work, and his recent service leading the commander’s action group for Security Assistance Group–Ukraine (SAG-U). Mike describes SAG-U’s role in coordinating US and allied support to Ukraine and examines lessons emerging from the Russia-Ukraine war, including Ukraine’s rapid expansion of its military, the transformative role of uncrewed systems, the increasingly compressed relationship between reconnaissance and strike, and the extraordinary speed of technological adaptation on the battlefield. Mike also highlights Ukraine’s willingness to innovate and openly debate how it fights—and warns against the temptation to dismiss the ongoing war's lessons simply because the participants or circumstances differ from those the US military expects to face.
Chapters
(00:00:02) - Introduction and Guest Welcome(00:00:24) - Choosing West Point and the Army(00:02:45) - West Point Academics and Branch Selection(00:04:36) - First Assignment and 9/11(00:07:01) - OIF2 Deployment: Green Zone Checkpoints(00:09:47) - Pre-Deployment Training and Innovative Leadership(00:13:09) - Learning from Company Commanders and NCOs(00:18:44) - Lessons on Leadership, Competence, and Character(00:20:12) - Joining the 82nd Airborne and Culture Shift(00:24:14) - Standing Up a New Cavalry Unit(00:25:48) - Second and Third Iraq Deployments: Route Security(00:30:34) - Returning to West Point to Teach(00:34:35) - Origins of 'SOSH' and Value of Military Education(00:35:00) - Commander's Action Group in Afghanistan(00:37:44) - The Lincoln Brigade and Legacy of Social Sciences(00:41:07) - Joint Task Force North and Interagency Lessons(00:45:53) - Returning to West Point Faculty(00:46:28) - Security Assistance Group Ukraine Overview(00:48:39) - CAG Role Supporting General Buzzard(00:51:52) - Capturing Lessons Learned from the War(00:54:15) - Institutional and Technological Lessons from Ukraine(00:59:41) - Drone Point System and Data Sharing Strategy(01:03:52) - Recon-Strike Complex and Future Warfare Challenges(01:08:08) - Casualties and the War's Uncertain Future(01:10:46) - Ukrainian Military Culture and Adaptability(01:13:17) - Advice for Young Leaders: Intellectual Curiosity(01:15:56) - Intellectual Courage and Historic Army Debates(01:20:14) - Closing Thoughts and Farewell
In this episode with host Dr. Charlie Faint, retired Colonel Pat Howell reflects on a career that took him from the 82nd Airborne Division and conventional engineer units to the 75th Ranger Regiment, strategic planning in Afghanistan, Joint Special Operations Command, and ultimately leadership of the Modern War Institute at West Point. Pat describes how strong noncommissioned officers and demanding organizations shaped his approach to leadership, particularly the need to balance leading by personal example with stepping back to supervise the larger mission. He discusses his intellectual development at West Point and beyond before recounting his experience as a lead planner for the International Security Assistance Force under General Stanley McChrystal and reflectiong on his later service with Joint Special Operations Command and as director of MWI. Throughout the conversation, he returns to several enduring lessons for military professionals: accomplish the mission while taking care of soldiers, remain intellectually curious, learn to evaluate facts and assumptions rigorously, and develop critical-thinking skills that remain useful regardless of how warfare changes.
Chapters
(00:00:02) - Introduction and Guest Welcome(00:00:44) - Family Background and Choosing West Point(00:02:27) - Cadet Life, Academics, and Athletics(00:03:42) - Commissioning and Early Assignment Setbacks(00:04:30) - Serving with the 82nd Airborne Division(00:05:35) - Move to Germany and Mechanized Unit Culture(00:06:43) - Leadership Lessons: Leading by Example vs Supervising(00:09:14) - Adapting to Heavy Unit Culture and the Cot Story(00:11:24) - AMFL Mission and Multinational Training in Germany(00:13:56) - Teaching at West Point's Department of Social Sciences(00:15:11) - Becoming Course Director for International Relations(00:18:38) - CGSC and Learning from Iraq War Veterans(00:21:03) - Joining the 75th Ranger Regiment as Engineer(00:23:58) - Deployments and Lessons on Mission Importance(00:25:08) - School of Advanced Military Studies (SAMS)(00:27:59) - Understanding Campaign Planning vs Tactics(00:30:31) - Deploying to ISAF Under General McChrystal(00:32:21) - The 40,000 Troop Request Planning Effort(00:36:22) - Other Major ISAF Planning Projects(00:39:09) - Congressional Testimony and Rapid Staff Work(00:41:05) - Marines Under McChrystal: Command Relations Explained(00:45:16) - Reflections on General McChrystal's Leadership(00:46:27) - Battalion Command at Fort Leonard Wood(00:48:53) - Second Tour: JSOC Engineer Role(00:50:43) - The ASP3 Fellowship and PhD Pursuit(00:52:24) - Strategic Planning Roles After ASP3(00:55:21) - Becoming Director of the Modern War Institute(00:58:05) - Returning to West Point: Reflections on Change(00:59:28) - Career Takeaways and the PhD Story(01:03:16) - Advice for Aspiring Military Professionals(01:05:56) - Closing Remarks and Podcast Outro



