Claim OwnershipThe Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
Subscribed: 571Played: 80,463
Subscribe
© 2026 Audacy, Inc.
Description
The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle Monday to Friday 2pm-7pm on WFAN.
4777 Episodes
Reverse
David Stearns did what he needed to do to win the off season. Wait did they? Some think they did, others like C-Mac think the Mets did a lot just to get back to where they were when the season ended. Stephen Ross forgot who he hired at his introductory press conference and Pat Leonard sits in and discusses the changes taking place since John Harbaugh has taken over the New York Giants. Joe Schoen's daughter makes a joke on social media; David Stearns needs Freddy Peralta to sign in order to make the trade worth it. Plus, if you didn't know the Yankees have great pitching. And you don't want to miss out on the proposal gone wrong. In what could possibly be the craziest storm of all time, you should make sure to snuggle up to your loved ones a go watch the movie RIP, just so you can tell Carton whether or not Jon Hamm is in the movie. Plus, C-Mac brings his best Yankee hot stove on a Thursday night.
David Stearns did what he needed to do to win the off season. Wait did they? Some think they did, others like C-Mac think the Mets did a lot just to get back to where they were when the season ended.
Stephen Ross forgot who he hired at his introductory press conference and Pat Leonard sits in and discusses the changes taking place since John Harbaugh has taken over the New York Giants.
Joe Schoen's daughter makes a joke on social media; David Stearns needs Freddy Peralta to sign in order to make the trade worth it. Plus, if you didn't know the Yankees have great pitching. And you don't want to miss out on the proposal gone wrong.
In what could possibly be the craziest storm of all time, you should make sure to snuggle up to your loved ones a go watch the movie RIP, just so you can tell Carton whether or not Jon Hamm is in the movie. Plus, C-Mac brings his best Yankee hot stove on a Thursday night.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle hit everything from Joe Schoen’s daughter clapping back at Giants fans, to Mets fans panicking over pitching and the Dodgers being treated like MLB’s boogeyman — and then things go completely off the rails with an unbelievable Olympic “Penis Gate” story. Classic Carton Show chaos you have to hear to believe
Craig Carton and Big Mac break down David Stearns’ controversial Mets rebuild after moving on from Pete Alonso, Jeff McNeil, and Brandon Nimmo — and ask the uncomfortable question: are the Mets actually better now? The guys debate power replacement, pitching upgrades, defensive changes, and whether fans are overreacting. Then the show goes completely off the rails with a viral NFL conspiracy theory about the 49ers’ injury problems, Carton’s take on cancel culture vs prison, a John Wick argument
Craig Carton reacts to Joe Schoen’s daughter clapping back at angry Giants fans on social media, opening a real conversation about family, criticism, and life in the public eye. Then the show veers into a heated Mets debate: should the Mets extend Freddy Peralta now, are fans irrationally terrified of the Dodgers, and why Carton says New York needs to stop acting insecure. Just when you think it’s all sports… Carton introduces the wildest story yet: Olympic Thing involving the Norwegian ski team.
Craig Carton and Big Mac dive into Vegas World Series odds after the Mets land Freddy Peralta — and the results shock Mets fans. Are the Mets really contenders or just fooling themselves? The guys debate whether this offseason is a “masterpiece” or just a reset, break down the controversial Brandon Nimmo exit and locker-room drama, argue lineup upgrades vs downgrades, and rip into Dolphins owner Steve Ross for an all-time awkward press conference. Classic Carton Show chaos with real baseball truth.
Pat Leonard joins Craig Carton and Big Mac to break down the real impact of John Harbaugh taking over the New York Giants. From cleaning up leaks inside the building to reshaping the front office, Harbaugh is already wielding serious power. The guys dive into whether Joe Schoen is officially on borrowed time, what scared ownership into making massive changes, and how broken the Giants organization truly was behind the scenes. Plus: Jaxson Dart’s future, staff shakeups, and why this finally feels different for Giants fans.
Craig Carton and Big Mac go head-to-head on WFAN after the Mets trade two top prospects for Freddy Peralta. Is this a bold World Series move… or a massive overpay for a one-year rental? From Steve Cohen’s spending, David Stearns pressure, Pete Alonso fallout, and Mets fans being “happy being miserable,” this segment gets HEATED fast. If the Mets don’t win big, Carton says there are NO excuses.
Craig Carton goes completely off the rails as a massive snowstorm sparks talk of stranded relationships, divorces, baby booms, and WFAN reality-show ideas. Then the conversation turns serious as Craig and C-Mac break down the Mets trading top prospects for Freddy Peralta — is it a smart win-now move or an overpay for a rental? From crowd mentality psychology to Mets roster philosophy, this segment has everything only the Carton Show can deliver.
Craig Carton goes full Mr. Positive as the Mets finally make a splash, landing Freddy Peralta — and somehow fans are STILL complaining. Craig unloads on miserable Mets fans, fires shots at Evan Roberts’ negativity, defends trading prospects to win NOW, and declares the Mets a better team today than yesterday. Plus, a classic Carton rant on why fans can’t have it both ways. Passion, arguments, and laughs to kick off the Carton Show.
The Mets finally trade for Luis Robert Jr. and the Yankees finally sign Cody Bellinger. It's a good day in New York sports.... right? Wrong... These two teams have done the bare minimum to keep afloat this offseason. Neither team is better. There's a rumor going around that the OC job with Eagles is extremely unwanted. Where the rumor came from? It comes from the fact that no one is interviewing for it! Plus, Carlos Beltran gets his ticket to the hall of fame. $20 million dollars is that direct deposit or in a big check? Do you think Bo Bichette is walking around with his big ass signing bonus? Plus, another edition of What the F*** Wednesday! The biggest game of the Nets season may be the biggest game of the Knicks season as well. Lock it up; Knicks are going to beat the Nets tonight. It's not panic mode for the Knicks just yet and of course Yankees hot stove.
The Mets finally trade for Luis Robert Jr. and the Yankees finally sign Cody Bellinger. It's a good day in New York sports.... right? Wrong... These two teams have done the bare minimum to keep afloat this offseason. Neither team is better.
There's a rumor going around that the OC job with Eagles is extremely unwanted. Where the rumor came from? It comes from the fact that no one is interviewing for it! Plus, Carlos Beltran gets his ticket to the hall of fame.
$20 million dollars is that direct deposit or in a big check? Do you think Bo Bichette is walking around with his big ass signing bonus? Plus, another edition of What the F*** Wednesday!
The biggest game of the Nets season may be the biggest game of the Knicks season as well. Lock it up; Knicks are going to beat the Nets tonight. It's not panic mode for the Knicks just yet and of course Yankees hot stove.
Pure, unhinged WFAN chaos from Craig Carton and Big Mac. Craig explains why owning a flamethrower guarantees a snow-free driveway, prepares for an apocalyptic grocery run built entirely around French toast, and uncovers the unbelievable true story behind Dave’s Killer Bread. The segment spirals into prison crocheting, bad movie takes, Jersey pride, cartoon crushes, and one of Craig’s most infamous teases yet. revealing that the real reason the Seahawks didn’t hand the ball to Marshawn Lynch in Super Bowl XLIX has never been told publicly.
Craig Carton unloads on everyone during his weekly “WTF Wednesday” segment on The Carton Show with Big Mac. From Terry Pegula contradicting himself over Josh Allen and the Bills, to Jeanie Buss torching LeBron James, to baseball writers putting Carlos Beltran in the Hall of Fame while still freezing out Bonds and Clemens. Carton also shreds the Indiana “Cinderella” national title story after learning how much NIL money they really spent, calls out CJ Stroud’s playoff excuses, and rips Mets fans for convincing themselves they’re having a great offseason.
Comments
Download from Google Play
Download from App Store
United States