Discover
Politics Politics Politics
Politics Politics Politics
Author: Justin Robert Young
Subscribed: 2,064Played: 89,754Subscribe
Share
© Justin Robert Young
Description
Unbiased political analysis the way you wish still existed. Justin Robert Young isn't here to tell you what to think, he's here to tell you who is going to win and why.
www.politicspoliticspolitics.com
www.politicspoliticspolitics.com
560 Episodes
Reverse
Jim Messina suggested that the Democratic debates could begin as early as April, and I’m here to tell you that I think he’s right. These things are going to start earlier than they ever have before, and it wouldn’t shock me if they began in the spring. The reason is simple: everybody who can move the calendar forward has an incentive to do it.Three groups are involved: the media organizations that produce the debates, the parties that sanction them and the candidates who participate. Candidates can always decline. Donald Trump skipped every Republican primary debate in 2024 and still became president. Enough other candidates will want the television exposure that those who sit out won’t decide the schedule. The networks and the parties will — and both have very big reasons to begin early.For the networks, it comes down to money. There are only two things Americans still want to watch live: football and politics, specifically debates. The first Democratic debate of the 2020 cycle drew 15.3 million viewers on its first night and 18.1 million on its second. Monday Night Football now averages about 19 million. A network can create a Monday Night Football-sized audience for two consecutive nights, sell advertising around it and program days or weeks of coverage about who’s in, who’s out and what the candidates will say.Politics Politics Politics is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.The audience declines after the first debate, unless you’re an absolute psycho like me, but even the later debates drew six to eight million viewers. That’s still a gigantic audience for almost anything on television. In 2019, CNN reportedly demanded a $300,000 advertising commitment before a company could even buy space surrounding its debate coverage. How are you going to tell me that networks won’t fall over themselves to make this happen?The party has a different incentive: thinning the herd. Twenty-nine people declared for the Democratic nomination during the 2020 cycle, and 19 were gone by Iowa. The average campaign survived about 280 days, or closer to 235 if you remove some edge cases. An April debate would leave roughly ten months before South Carolina opens the calendar. At the 2020 rate of spending, a candidate would need nearly $10 million just to survive that period, and closer to $11 million with a cushion.Starting early forces candidates to announce early, raise money early and survive the dead summer months when donors begin wondering whether they have any momentum. The networks want the advertising dollars, the party wants fewer candidates by the time voting begins and the candidates want television exposure so they can raise money and become one of the survivors. Some expected power players — Kamala Harris or AOC, for example — may stay out at first and see what happens.But you know who will be there for every second of every debate? Yours truly.Chapters00:00:00 - Intro00:02:26 - 2028 Debates00:12:28 - Update00:13:06 - Epstein00:15:17 - Senate Noms00:16:51 - Alaska00:18:00 - Tom Merritt on Jensen Huang, AI, and more01:14:42 - Feedback and Wrap-up This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.politicspoliticspolitics.com/subscribe
Jim Jordan is the new leader of a very small House Republican minority — one that Republicans didn’t expect to be this small. He came to Congress during the George W. Bush administration, made his bones as a Tea Party firebrand under Obama and later became one of the original cable-news dunk merchants. Since then, he’s tried to scrub himself up, distance himself from some of the party’s more extreme elements and become an elder statesman. After failing to become speaker during the last round of House chaos, he’s now outflanked Steve Scalise and become the Republican standard-bearer.I’d push back on the idea that this is Republicans tripling down on MAGA. My guess is that Jordan won because he felt more different from the previous leadership than Scalise did. The contest stayed civil, without the public intraparty fire we saw during the last two leadership fights. What Jordan actually does with the job remains to be seen, but his work is cut out for him. Nobody I’ve spoken to on the Republican side believes this is a two-year turnaround. The goal may be to get close in 2028 and hope for another opportunity in 2030.Politics Politics Politics is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.The other leadership races are making noise, but I don’t think they’re truly competitive. Chuck Schumer may face some wobbling from Chris Van Hollen, but Democrats just produced a historic victory on a bad map. Hakeem Jeffries protected his incumbents and assembled a significant House majority. John Thune doesn’t even have a challenger yet. The real questions involve priorities, subpoenas and the filibuster. With 56 Democratic senators, they’d need only four Republicans to reach 60. That’s doable, but there will still be pressure for a talking filibuster or its elimination.Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is also facing eight articles of impeachment from Thomas Massie, alleging unlawful military operations, War Powers Resolution violations and retaliation against Senator Mark Kelly. I expect the effort to pass the House, but removal would require two-thirds of the Senate, and I don’t expect that to happen. It’s also hard for me to argue that anything Hegseth did is uniquely his impeachable offense when these actions appear to have been approved by Trump. There’s a personal angle too: Hegseth campaigned against Massie in his primary, and this is Massie’s swan song — one final finger in the eye of the administration that defined the end of his career.The Senate has voted 73–25 to advance the American Affordability and Jobs Act, an energy-permitting package designed to accelerate construction and address energy costs. It changes federal reviews of energy projects and addresses the electricity demands created by data centers. This isn’t final passage, but it moves the legislation forward. Republicans are asking why they didn’t pass it before the election. My opinion is simple: they didn’t have the Democratic votes beforehand. Democrats weren’t going to touch it until the election was over. Now they will, and I expect it to pass alongside the must-pass legislation before January.Finally, Trump says renewed military action against Iran appears unnecessary and describes the conflict as effectively over militarily, though the naval blockade remains and Operation Iron Gate is restricting supplies by land. I don’t understand where the win is for Iran. They’re being choked out financially, oil is being rerouted around the Strait of Hormuz and that process will become cheaper as commerce adjusts. Their remaining leverage is the threat of attacking Gulf neighbors, oil fields, population centers or undersea cables. This looks like a slow bleed, which means Iran will eventually have to stir the pot. Their leverage is essentially: give me something, or I’ll keep shooting you in the foot.Chapters00:00:00 - Intro00:03:11 - Jim Jordan00:12:38 - Hegseth00:15:27 - Senate00:17:10 - Iran00:23:14 - Interview with Michael Cohen01:03:53 - Wrap-up This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.politicspoliticspolitics.com/subscribe
As Trump and the Republicans try to take stock of their midterm losses, Hakeem Jeffries is asking House Democrats to elect him speaker. His proposed first 100 days include reversing the Medicaid cuts, restoring food-assistance funding, extending the Affordable Care Act tax credits, ending Trump’s tariffs, stopping the Iran war and banning members of Congress from trading stocks. As of late Wednesday, Jeffries said he hadn’t spoken with Trump or House Republican leaders since the election.The question is how much Democrats were elected because voters believe in Democratic leadership and how much they were elected because voters wanted a check on the Trump administration. If you listen to Jeffries, what Democrats essentially want to do is restore the funding that was removed to pay for the Big Beautiful Bill’s tax cuts.That gets back to the problem Democrats have whenever they talk about affordability and why people don’t tend to trust them on the economy. It’s not that they’re proposing tax increases here. They want to restore cuts that were made to fund tax cuts. Whether voters read that distinction into it, we don’t know. Democrats will have a large enough majority to move what they want through the House. The question is whether any of it gets signed, beginning with the December 11 government-funding deadline.Politics Politics Politics is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.On the other side of the aisle, Mike Johnson won’t seek the House Republican leadership job in the next Congress. Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan are competing to lead Republicans in the minority after both unsuccessfully pursued the speakership in 2023, before Johnson emerged as the compromise choice. Austin Pfluger is also challenging Tom Emmer for whip as Republicans prepare for their November 10 leadership election.There’s jockeying on the Senate side too. Chuck Schumer appears to have the votes to remain leader, but Elizabeth Warren may try to move into the number-three position and become whip. Other Democratic senators could use the moment to extract guarantees from Schumer, including whether he’ll let them eliminate the filibuster. If Hawaii and Mississippi hold as they currently stand, Democrats would only need four Republicans to reach 60 votes.Finally, the first — but almost certainly not the last — Trump administration official has resigned. Harmeet Dhillon is leaving the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division, saying she made the decision weeks ago but was asked by the White House to wait until after the midterms. She says she wasn’t pushed out and wants to return to private practice. There are also rumors around Marco Rubio. I’ve long said he wasn’t leaving the State Department until there was an American flag flying over Havana, but maybe the Iran war has dragged on as far as it’s going to and he no longer has the juice to do anything in Cuba. We’ll wait and see.Chapters00:00:00 - Intro00:01:55 - Interview with Kirk Bado00:26:10 - Update00:27:18 - GOP Leadership00:28:59 - Democrats00:30:18 - Vance00:31:56 - Interview with Kirk Bado, con’t00:58:46 - Wrap-up This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.politicspoliticspolitics.com/subscribe
(This episode is the final chunk of a four-hour election night livestream.)This is a blue tsunami — an absolute wipeout of Republican power in the House and Senate. When Talarico is winning Texas by 20 points, Democrats are leading in Kansas and South Carolina is competitive, there’s nobody safe outside of maybe Tennessee and Kentucky. Democrats have a real shot at ending up with somewhere around 53 to 55 Senate seats, possibly more depending on races like Alaska and Iowa. I thought polarization would keep these midterms closer, and I was wrong. Justice for pollsters — they did the damn thing. Take your vibes and shove them.Republicans are going to have to look back at a campaign that went to the culture-war well again and again without understanding why those messages worked in 2024. The “Kamala is for they/them, Trump is for you” ad worked because it combined public money, an unsympathetic person and something voters viewed as frivolous, all overlaid on doubts that Harris knew what she was doing. This time, Republicans just screamed that Democrats were going to transition your children. Nobody bought it. The border had already been “solved,” the Iran war never had a clear explanation, and Republicans let Democrats completely own affordability. Everybody said, “Let the man cook.” Well, the meal’s on fire, the kitchen’s on fire and everybody got burned.Politics Politics Politics is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.This is the end of peak Trump power — the end of Trump as a cult-of-personality force capable of clearing the field and holding the party completely in line. He’ll still have a segment of the population that finds him persuasive, and Republicans will try to recobble parts of his 2024 coalition, but that version of MAGA is over. Now Democrats inherit the worst position in global politics: power. They can check Trump, force votes and attach priorities to government funding or defense authorization, but the real question is whether they fight for something effective or fight just to look like they’re fighting. They’ll call this a mandate for Democratic power. I think it was a vote against Republicans. Either way, the playtime’s over — the wide-open fight for 2028 begins now. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.politicspoliticspolitics.com/subscribe
I defy anybody to feel like they have an accurate read on the vibes going into these midterms.The polls look electric for Democrats, even if there’s a general belief that they’re overrepresenting Democratic support. Republicans seem depressed as they realize that Trump beat the party into submission, and that the coalition that won in 2024 could only be unlocked by tying themselves completely to him. MAGA Inc. has spent money and Trump has been on the road, but the war in Iran is unpopular, inflation remains a problem and the economy hasn’t been solved. Then, with Democrats gassed up to the nines, Michigan broke completely loose: Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed.El-Sayed beat Stevens in a primary that ended much closer than many people expected, and Stevens initially played the good soldier. But El-Sayed has run a campaign committed to his own point of view, even when reaching out could help him with voters who might have to hold their noses to support him. This is a common trait among the first candidates to break through from an electrified ideological movement. They’ve spent years believing the establishment strangled their momentum, so once they reach the big stage, they have a hard time shaking a hand. It’s something Trump is actually good at: he’ll scream a million nasty things while trying to win, but if the deal is the deal, he’ll shake hands afterward. El-Sayed hasn’t done that, and he’s struggled to make inroads with the Black community in Detroit and the Jewish community in the suburbs — precisely the voters for whom Stevens should’ve been a useful surrogate.Politics Politics Politics is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.The situation boiled over after El-Sayed was asked during a debate whether Israel or Iran posed the greater danger to the United States. He called it a ridiculous hypothetical. Then Rebellion PAC aired an ad suggesting Americans couldn’t afford groceries because their money was going toward killing Palestinians, before ending with a play on Trump’s “they/them” ad. The “they” and “them” in this version weren’t pronouns — they were Israelis, Jews or Zionists, depending on how you interpreted it. Stevens saw the ad as rank antisemitism and demanded that El-Sayed denounce it. His answer was that he had nothing to do with the ad. That wasn’t good enough for her.In another era, somebody with institutional power inside the Democratic Party would’ve removed Stevens from the situation before it reached this point. Eleanor Roosevelt would’ve put her on a one-way trip to Hawaii with a belly full of lithium and told her she could come back when permitted. It wouldn’t matter whether Stevens was right or wrong — she simply couldn’t be allowed near the race. But nobody has that power now. Stevens’ fiancé announced that he was voting for Rogers. Stevens went on CNN and said theirs was a split household but that she was still voting for El-Sayed. El-Sayed responded that she was insisting on relitigating a long-decided primary. Party elders tried to arrange a unity event, nobody could get the camps to shut up, and Stevens ultimately went to a church with Rogers instead.The professional Democratic class is aghast because politics is a team sport. If Stevens put herself ahead of the team, then she betrayed everybody. But I’ve also heard from Never Trumpers who see her decision as proof that politics isn’t all sociopathic laundry — that people don’t have to walk blindly toward whichever candidate has the correct letter beside their name. If Stevens genuinely believes there’s an antisemitism problem inside the Democratic Party, then she shouldn’t have to stand beside El-Sayed when he won’t make even a minimal peace with her or the voters who supported her. That primary was close, and El-Sayed still needs some of those people.I’m leaning toward this not mattering in Michigan. I still suspect El-Sayed will win, even if it’s close, and he’ll take that as a mandate to purge the Haley Stevens wing of the party. But if he loses, the stories coming out of that campaign will be like somebody turning off the containment vault in Ghostbusters — ghouls flying everywhere. This is a loser-leaves-town match now: either Stevens is finished in Democratic politics, or El-Sayed gets fired into the sun. The larger question is about coalitions. We’re in a warlord era with very little allegiance to the greater party, and “me over we” can look either righteous or cowardly depending on where you stand. If Democrats begin chasing away high-propensity Jewish voters, it may not decide this election, but over time it could put states in play that wouldn’t normally be there.Chapters00:00 - Intro05:10 - Haley Stevens30:54 - Wrap-up This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.politicspoliticspolitics.com/subscribe








