The Blue Frontier - American Everton Analysis

In a tale of two halves, Everton make their half count more and the Blue Frontier is here to analyze all the details from this one. Shan and Ryan get into the match, the tactics, Marco Silva vs. David Moyes, and so much more.  But first, the duo gets into a hearty debate on the lineups and the approach from Moyes with Tyler Dibling and other young players at Everton.  Then it's an objective look at a match that Everton were probably fortunate to even be in at half time, but made some interesting adjustments to get back into it and change the story.  Listener comments probe the sustainability of slow starts, while data from FBref and Understat flags Everton's eighth-place overperformance (14th in expected points). Balancing optimism with realism, this pod offers vivid insights for Toffees fans pondering Europe and where this club could realistically finish. You will not want to miss this one!

The January transfer window closed with a strategic pivot that signals Everton's commitment to a younger, more dynamic squad profile. James, Ryan, and Shan break down the arrival of Tyrique George, the 19-year-old Chelsea prospect whose high-tempo style and directness offer a much-needed spark in attack. The scouting report weighs George's raw potential against the physical demands of the Premier League, drawing comparisons to fellow youth standouts like Tyler Dibling. The conversation then shifts to the Deadline Day absurdity involving Crystal Palace and the collapsed £20 million sale of Dwight McNeil. The crew dissects the bizarre sequence of events and the reputational fallout for the South London hierarchy after "ghosting" the deal, ultimately assessing the tactical implications of McNeil remaining at Goodison Park. Moving beyond the headlines, the trio utilizes custom data models to rank individual performances, highlighting persistent voids at fullback and holding midfield. Capping the episode with a window "report card," the panel provides a post-mortem on how Everton navigated the winter market's chaos under David Moyes while keeping a steady eye on the summer rebuild. LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

Everton secured a dramatic point at the Amex as birthday boy Beto bundled home a 97th-minute equalizer to keep the Toffees in the Premier League's top half . Facing a late injury to Vitaliy Mykolenko, David Moyes opted for a "Tall Guys FC" approach, deploying four natural center backs across the defensive line, including Jarrad Branthwaite at left back and Jake O'Brien at right back . While the first half was a statistical desert for the Blues with zero shots and conceding possession, the match transformed into a second-half rescue mission .  James and Shan analyze James Garner's "menace" performance in midfield and the tactical impact of Moyes' proactive triple substitution . The episode also breaks down the late-breaking transfer news regarding Chelsea winger Tyrique George and what the potential loan-to-buy deal signifies for Everton's long-term squad building . With the club sitting comfortably in eighth place, the discussion weighs the relief of being "on the beach" against the aspiration for a European push . LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

On this episode, James and Shan break down Everton's 1-1 draw vs Leeds United at the Hill Dickinson Stadium. Trailing after James Justin's first-half opener, David Moyes flipped the script at halftime, switching to a three center back formation and introducing Jarrad Branthwaite (his season debut) alongside a returning Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall. The changes sparked a second-half revival, capped by Thierno Barry's equalizer, his fifth goal in 7 games. The duo dissect Barry's hot streak, Branthwaite's immediate impact (14 final-third passes in 45 minutes), and Dominic Calvert-Lewin's return to face his old club. They also tackle Jack Grealish's three-month injury setback, Everton's middling home form, and the promise of a fully fit squad pushing for mid-table security in the Premier League. Packed with stats and listener takes, the guys attempt to take a slightly discouraging result and examine the more positive implications for the rest of the season.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

The full triumvirate of James, Shan, and Ryan is back to unpack the Toffees' gritty 1-0 Premier League triumph at Aston Villa. It's Everton's first league win at Villa Park since 2016, shattering Villa's 11-match home streak in a match that started as a tactical chess game between injury-hit sides and evolved into a showcase of disciplined grit. Thierno Berry's exquisite chip over Emi Martinez sealed the deal, underscoring Everton's resilience amid their own absences. The hosts dive into the back four's return to natural positions: Nathan Patterson suprisingly steady showing at right-back and Jake O'Brien physical dominance in the middle, while youngsters Merlin Rohl and Harrison Armstrong flashed potential in midfield. James Garner's performance and ABSURD numbers (ex: 14 recoveries, 7 tackles) gets major props, contrasting Villa's frustrations (and their +17 expected points overperformance per Understat).  Amid breakdowns of David Moyes' savvy tweaks, like Dwight McNeil tucking centrally to counter Unai Emery's buildup, and Villa's midfield voids (Kamara and Onana out), the pod mixes stats, transfer chatter, and morale-lifting optimism for a top-half push. A fun one to record, and we hope you enjoy!    LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

Everton's FA Cup hopes crumbled in the third round as they fell to Sunderland at Hill Dickinson Stadium, drawing 1-1 before a dismal 3-0 penalty shootout defeat. Hosts James and Shan dissect the frustrations: a bare-bones squad ravaged by suspensions, injuries, and AFCON absences forced youngsters like Harrison Armstrong, Merlin Rohl, and Tyler Dibling into the spotlight. James Tarkowski and Jake O'Brien reunited at center back, while Nathan Patterson slotted in at right back. Sunderland's Enzo Le Fee struck first with a stunning volley off a long throw, but debutant Adam Aznou sparked a late equalizer via a controversial penalty converted by James Garner. The pod breaks down tactical woes: Everton's reliance on long balls and deep crosses; amid a lack of cohesion and quality. Positives? Aznou's electric cameo hints at untapped potential, but penalties from Garner, Thierno Barry, and Beto were woeful. Despite benefitting from no VAR, the Blues extend their trophy drought, shifting focus to Premier League banality and January transfers. Up the Toffees, onto Aston Villa.   LINKS: linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

The full trio reunites on The Blue Frontier to unpack Everton's bizarre 1-1 Premier League draw against rock-bottom Wolves at Hill Dickinson Stadium on January 7, 2026. Michael Keane's pinpoint volley handed the Toffees an early edge, but stagnation set in after the break, letting Mateus Mane curl home an equalizer that highlighted cracks in the Keane-Tarkowski center-back duo. Chaos ensued with Keane's red for an accidental hair pull: flagged as violent conduct by VAR Chris Kavanagh, and Jack Grealish's second yellow for... sarcastic clapping? This stranded Everton in the final minutes with nine men.   James, Shan, and Ryan spotlight Harrison Armstrong's composed full debut, blending sharp ball control with forward thrust, while ripping Dwight McNeil's misplaced right-wing role for its toothless attack and dismal defending. They probe David Moyes' hesitation to counter Wolves' midfield flood and dual forwards, plus youth dilemmas around Tyler Dibling and Merlin Rolle. Jordan Pickford's stunning save snatched a point, yet broader chats hit squad thinness from AFCON call-ups, Moyes' in-game tweaks, and Everton's steadfast mid-table grind. LINKS: linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

Everton's grim New Year tradition continued with a chastening 4-2 home defeat to Brentford at Hill Dickinson Stadium, marking their eighth loss in the opening match of the last nine seasons. Shan and Ryan deliver a candid, data-informed autopsy of a performance that started brightly (effective pressing and a couple of early chances) before unravelling after Igor Thiago's 11th-minute opener. The Brazilian forward ran riot with a hat-trick (11', 51', 88'), finishing with 5/6 shots on target and a 2.42 PSxG masterclass, while Nathan Collins added a header from Brentford's first Premier League corner goal in ages. They dissect Brentford's tactical sharpness, the swift collapse of Everton's high press, the limitations of the Tarkowski–Keane centre-back pairing, and glaring fullback deficiencies (Jake O'Brien 16 ball losses, Vitaliy Mykolenko 18). Moyes' halftime switch to two strikers gets scrutiny, though Beto's 66th-minute header and Thierno Barry's late consolation showed fight. Listener reactions bring sharp insight, with the conversation turning to January priorities: two new fullbacks and rethinking the backline. The episode closes with the usual thoughts & prayers (West Ham, Dyche, Wolves' first win, Chermiti haters). Up the Toffees!   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

The Blue Frontier steps away from its usual post-match grind to reset the conversation around Everton's January transfer window. With the Blues sitting eighth in the Premier League, James and Ryan dig into what the table says versus what the numbers actually show, using expected points, xG, and xGA to separate genuine progress from mild overperformance. The core argument is simple: Everton are more stable than they've been in years, but that doesn't mean January is the moment to force ambition. The positional needs identified in the summer still hold. Right back stands out as the cleanest way to raise the team's floor, defensive midfield remains structurally unresolved, and center forward only enters the picture if Beto''s departure creates an immediate need for backup. The episode also weighs how returning players like Harrison Armstrong factor into squad planning, whether a loan move (including links like Adam Aznou) makes sense, and how realistic January markets actually operate, from Ligue 1 pressure sales to short-term stopgaps. The conversation remains rooted in Everton's long-term trajectory: improve where it matters, stay flexible, and avoid confusing a decent league position with a reason to gamble the club's long term ascent.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier    

In the first Blue Frontier episode of 2026, James and Ryan unpack Everton's hard-earned 2-0 win at Nottingham Forest, a result that felt far more impressive than the scoreline suggests. Facing Sean Dyche's expensively-assembled side with a threadbare squad (Keane and Alcaraz sidelined, AFCON call-ups still thinning the bench), the Toffees delivered an opportunistic, disciplined performance that turned the City Ground the venue for frustrating afternoon for the home side.The duo zoom in on the decisive first goal from James Garner, the clinical late sealer by Thierno Barry, and the defensive wall built by James Tarkowski and Jake O'Brien (who won the aerial war despite Forest's barrage of crosses). They dissect Moyes' improved away form, the mismatch of Dycheball with Forest's current personnel, and the stark contrast in finishing quality (1.55 xG for Forest, 0.94 post-shot). Listener comments and sharp stats on Garner's monster game, Dibling's dribbling threat, and Iroegbunam's PSR steal round out a thoughtful, data-rich review.A fitting close to 2025 and a promising start to the new year for Evertonians! Links: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

In the last fixture before Christmas, The Blue Frontier wishes everyone a Merry Christmas and happy holidays, while hoping the PGMOL gets a dose of consistency in the new year.   James and Ryan dissect Everton's gritty 1-0 defeat to Arsenal at Hill Dickinson Stadium: a tough outing for a depleted Toffees side missing Iliman Ndiaye and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall to injuries and looming AFCON duties. Arsenal's lone goal stemmed from Jake O'Brien's bizarre handball penalty, buried by Viktor Gyokeres, amid a match where Everton struggled to create, posting zero xG in the first half per Opta and Wyscout data.   The dynamic duo explores tactical mismatches, like Dwight McNeil's ineffective right-wing shift (zero forward passes, zero duels won) against Bukayo Saka's flair, while praising James Tarkowski's defensive clinic (18 recoveries, vital line clearance) against Arsenal's possession machine driven by Declan Rice and Rodri Zubimendi. Listener comments fill in for absent co-host Shan, highlighting curious individual efforts and set-piece woes in a relatively dull affair. Looking ahead, they assess AFCON's impact on fixtures against Burnley, Nottingham Forest, and Brentford, urging youth integration like Tyler Dibling to spark the attack. A data-packed pod attempting to turn a frustrating loss into thoughtful Everton analysis.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

Everton haven't had much luck at Chelsea lately, but they rolled into this one in solid form. Sadly, it wasn't the day to snap their winless streak at Stamford Bridge, tumbling 2-0 and pushing that drought to 31 years. On this episode, James and Ryan zero in on a game defined by big chances: eight in all, with Chelsea converting theirs amid Everton's near-misses from Jack Grealish and Iliman Ndiaye.   The duo dissects tactical headaches, like fullback frailties with Jake O'Brien and Vitaliy Mykolenko getting torched by Pedro Neto and Alejandro Garnacho, plus debates on Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall dropping deeper, the Tarkowski-Keane partnership's limits, and Idrissa Gueye's defensive slide (tackles per 90 down 47%). They praise James Garner's midfield tenacity while flagging injuries to Dewsbury-Hall and looming AFCON hits on Gueye and Ndiaye, sparking calls for January reinforcements. Listener takes add cautious optimism for a top-eight push, set against Chelsea's depth under Enzo Maresca. Stats, wit, and realism abound, with a nod to Arsenal at home in a jammed Premier League table.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

In a commanding 3-0 Premier League victory at Goodison Park, Everton dismantled Sean Dyche's Nottingham Forest, climbing (briefly) to fifth in the table and marking four wins in five under David Moyes.   The Toffees struck early with a deflected own goal off Nikola Milenkovic from Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall's delivery, disrupting Forest's defensive setup and exposing vulnerabilities without key players like Murillo and Chris Wood. Thierno Barry finally broke his scoring drought with a clinical finish on a blistering Iliman Ndiaye counterattack, while Dewsbury-Hall sealed the rout with a sharp late strike.   Hosts James and Shan dissect the tactical edge of that opening goal against Dyche's low-block style, Barry's physical duel with Milenkovic, and Dewsbury-Hall's midfield dominance despite squad rotation forced by injuries and suspensions. Amid broader discussions on Everton's mid-table surge, Europe aspirations, and upcoming Chelsea clash, the episode highlights defensive solidity from James Tarkowski and Michael Keane, plus fan reactions celebrating a revitalized Blues side. Perfect for Evertonians tracking form trends, player breakthroughs, and Premier League narratives.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

In this episode of The Blue Frontier, the hosts dissect Everton's historic 1-0 victory over Bournemouth at the Vitality Stadium, marking the Toffees' first-ever away win against the Cherries in the Premier League.   James, Ryan, and Shan break down Jack Grealish's late deflected goal that sealed the gritty bounce-back from the Newcastle defeat (complete with his cheeky badge-kiss celebration that has them asking: is it true love with David Moyes?   They highlight tactical shifts like James Garner's role at right-back, Jake O'Brien's solid center-back performance, and Tim Iroegbunam's disciplined midfield display, while exploring Bournemouth's threats, particularly Antoine Semenyo's dominance.   Critiquing Everton's finishing woes with Thierno Barry and Beto underperforming expected goals (xG), the pod blends data-driven insights on possession stats, duels won, and post-shot xG with passionate Evertonian optimism. Ryan even manages to shoehorn yet another silly detour into chat about the Everton Happy Sad Reversible Critter plushie. The discussion touches on squad depth challenges amid injuries, potential January transfers, and the upcoming Nottingham Forest clash.    LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier  

  Everton's three-game momentum ended in emphatic fashion as Newcastle United walked out of Hill Dickinson Stadium with a 4–1 win. On this episode of The Blue Frontier, James, Shan, and Ryan take a clear-eyed look at a first half that collapsed: a set-piece breakdown, midfield gaps, and a back line repeatedly exposed. They explain why the James Garner/Tim Iroegbunam pairing "was just really suspect… a very passive duo," how Tino Livramento and Anthony Elanga repeatedly created overloads down the flank, and why Newcastle's physicality forced Everton out of shape. Beyond the match moments (the blocked Dewsbury Hall chance, Charlie's thunderbolt that nearly changed the game, and the ruled-out Barry goal) the trio interrogate David Moyes' post-match framing and substitution patterns. There's a sustained conversation about youth minutes and recruitment, notably Adam Aznou's lack of opportunities, and what this means for quick turnarounds against Bournemouth and Nottingham Forest. This episode balances match dissection with bigger-picture questions about squad depth and identity as Everton navigate a wildly congested midtable. LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

Everton's 1–0 win at Old Trafford was both the strangest and most satisfying result of the season, and this week The Blue Frontier tries to make sense of all of it. James and Ryan walk through a match that swung from meltdown to resilience in minutes, starting with Idrissa Gana Gueye's surreal red card ("It was bizarre… I've never seen him so angry") and ending with Jordan Pickford putting on yet another display of goalkeeping excellence.  The episode digs into Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall's solo winner, the way David Moyes re-shaped Everton's structure after going down to ten men, and why the team still managed pockets of ambition before settling into the long defensive grind. Along the way, the hosts look at Michael Keane, Berry, and Dewsbury-Hall's shift-by-shift contributions, supported by some sharp listener comments and the kind of numbers that explain how Everton survived 51 United touches in their own box. It's a rare away win against a "big six" side, one that pulls Everton level with Manchester United and Liverpool on 18 points, and one the hosts are more than happy to savor.   LINKS:  https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

Everton stop the slide with a 2–0 win over Fulham at the Hill Dickinson Stadium: a match that could've easily finished five if not for the linesman and VAR's meddling. The Blue Frontier crew dive into what made this performance click: Moyes' much-needed adjustments, Garner's surprising stability at right back, Tim's tidy control in midfield, and Barry's growing confidence up top. They dissect the three disallowed goals, highlight the press that throttled Fulham's buildup, and weigh how much credit belongs to Moyes versus the opposition's drop-off. Beyond the scoreline, the trio discuss what this could mean for Everton's balance going forward (do Garner, Barry, or "Tim the Enchanter" represent longer-term answers?) and what the result says about the club's December outlook. Plus, Shan shares some heartfelt thoughts and prayers for members of the Everton and broader football community. Up the Toffees! LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

The Blue Frontier is back to dissect the gory details of a post-Halloween clash at the Stadium of Light against top-five Sunderland. The podcast triumvirate of James, Ryan, and Shan grapple with an Everton side that dazzled for the first 28 minutes, capped by Iliman Ndiaye's stunning left-footed curler, only to morph into brainless zombies as Granit Xhaka's deflected equalizer sparked a second-half Sunderland siege.   They spotlight Thierno Barry's lively start, wrecked by a point-blank miss and a needless yellow that killed his bite.   David Moyes' baffling subs also face the torch: Why Dwight McNeil over Tyler Dibling or Charly Alcaraz for an injured Ndiaye?   Tactics unravel with Sunderland's midfield grip (Xhaka's 18 final-third passes) and Everton's collapse (second half: 61% possession conceded, 0.75 xG to 0.02). Alongside loyal listeners, the crew probes: Purely tactical? Getting the best from players? Right man for the job? Squad talent shortfall? Adam Aznou the fix?   They float tweaks (stick with Barry, shift Jack Grealish centrally, sub earlier) amid one win in eight. Tune in for data-backed takes, raw frustrations, and pragmatic paths ahead of Fulham and United. Up the Toffees.   LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier

Everton's first home loss at Hill Dickinson Stadium came with a hard lesson in margins. James, Ryan, and Shan return to sort through the frustration and the facts: two set-piece lapses, some dodgy refereeing, and not mention, another match where Everton's play looked better than the scoreline. This week's episode leans into a new format shaped by conversations in The Blue Frontier Discord. Less retelling, more reasoning. The hosts break down how Everton out-created Spurs from open play, and what the post-shot xG reveals about finishing and defensive shape. They also dig into listener-driven ideas on tactical tweaks and squad rotation, asking what realistically needs to change for results to match performances. Finally, the boys take us through a new segment, led by Shan, to give Thoughts and Prayers to two teams that are really struggling right now.  You might be surprised to know who those clubs are.  As always, please leave a rating and review if you enjoy the show. Reach out to us with any feedback at bluefrontierusa@gmail.com, or any of our socials! LINKS: https://linktr.ee/thebluefrontier 

Everton held their own for 45 minutes at the Etihad, but against Manchester City, fine margins always seem to go one way. James and Shan break down the Toffees' 2–0 defeat, where Iliman Ndiaye's electric first half and Jordan Pickford's shot-stopping weren't enough in the face of Erling Haaland's inevitable brace. The duo unpack David Moyes' setup: Everton's compact defense mostly worked until it didn't; the Beto chance early on could've flipped the game. There's also time spent on the neatly bypassed VAR handball controversy, and a forward line still searching for rhythm and confidence. With away matches vs City + Liverpool in the rearview less than 10 games into the season, Toffees can look forward to many more winnable games ahead. LINKS: linktr.ee/thebluefrontier