What Is Mind? with William Gadea

What if the self you think you are… doesn’t actually exist?In this conversation, philosopher Jay L. Garfield argues that the “self” is a powerful cognitive illusion – and that letting go of it can make us more ethical, more compassionate, and more free, not less. Drawing from Buddhist philosophy, David Hume, and contemporary cognitive science, Garfield explains why consciousness isn’t a “thing,” why free will doesn’t mean what we think it means, and how living without a self can actually lead to a better life.We discuss:Why the question “What is consciousness?” may be ill-formedThe Buddhist and Humean critique of the selfThe difference between self and personWhy free will outside causation is neither real nor desirableHow meditation and practice reduce sufferingWhy ethics improves when we stop seeing ourselves as isolated agentsThe role of philosophy inside Buddhist practiceLinksWebsite: https://www.williamgadea.comSubstack: https://williamgadea.substack.comBuy ARROW: The Power and Poison of Story on Amazon: https://a.co/d/aPjKbcg

Do we really have free will — or is that just an illusion? Are our choices the result of physical and biological processes? In this video, I explore the classic free will debate from a scientific and philosophical perspective. Drawing on neuroscience, psychology, Buddhism, and contemporary philosophy, I ask two questions: 1) What is doing the willing? and 2) Is it free of causation? We look at:• Neural correlates of consciousness • Determinism vs unpredictability • The ethical implications of rejecting free will • Compatibilism • Jay L. Garfield’s view of persons without selves • How ethics can survive — and even flourish — without free willLinks: • Buy my book ARROW: The Power and Poison of Story https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FD94LW5G• Subscribe to my substack for free essays and videos: https://williamgadea.substack.com • You can learn more about me here: https://www.williamgadea.com

Dr. Andrew Newberg is one of the pioneers of neurotheology – the scientific study of what happens in the brain during prayer, meditation, and mystical experience. In this conversation, we dig into what the brain is doing during spiritual practice – and how he studies it, how different practices produce both shared and distinctive neural patterns, and why sexuality and religious experience may be more closely linked than they seem. We also explore the evolutionary question: is religion an adaptation, a by-product, or something in between? A grounded conversation at the intersection of neuroscience, spirituality, and human nature.RELATED LINKS:Buy Dr. Andrew Newberg's new book here: https://www.amazon.com/Sex-God-Brain-... Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/ Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Po... Follow the YouTube channel —    / @whatismind-williamgadea   Follow us on X — https://x.com/willgadea You can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you. #neurotheology #neuroscience #religion #religionandscience

In this AI-assisted conversation, I speak with 18th-century Scottish philosopher David Hume — the great skeptic of the Enlightenment and one of the first thinkers to question the idea of a permanent self. We discuss his early years in Edinburgh, his philosophy of ideas and impressions, his views on morality and motivation, and how his insights anticipate modern neuroscience and Buddhism alike. Voice actor: David McNeillRELATED LINKS:If you are new to Hume, don't start with A Treatise of Human Nature. Instead, try a more accessible volume like this one: https://www.amazon.com/Enquiry-Concer...Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Po... Follow us on X — https://x.com/willgadea You can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you. #davidhume #philosophy #skepticism #AI

Could today’s AIs already be conscious? Before you say no, let’s look at what “consciousness” really means – and why machines may already qualify.In this episode of What is Mind?, William Gadea looks at:Why definitions of consciousness depend on purpose and context.How Thomas Nagel’s “What is it like to be…” definition breaks down for AIsWhy Alan Turing’s famous test no longer satisfiesWhy “intent,” “self-preservation,” and “sub-goals” emerge naturally in intelligent systemsWhether machines might someday deserve ethical considerationHow a self-driving car already meets a functional definition of consciousness RELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator https://www.williamgadea.com/ Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20 Follow us on X — https://x.com/willgadea You can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you. #AI #MachineConsciousness

In this episode of What Is Mind?, I speak with Dr. Swayam Bagaria, Assistant Professor of Hindu Studies at Harvard Divinity School. Trained as an anthropologist at Johns Hopkins, Bagaria explores how religion, cognition, and technology intertwine in shaping human experience. We discuss Hinduism’s pluralistic and decentralized nature, how seekers find their spiritual paths, and why Hinduism both frees and binds through its deeply woven traditions.The conversation also ranges into mental health and religion, the intersection of spirituality and technology, and how AI and neuroscience are challenging traditional ideas of identity and consciousness.RELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.If questions about mind and consciousness interest you, please consider subscribing!

In this episode, I talk with Dr. Theodore H. Schwartz, neurosurgeon at Weill Cornell Medicine and author of Gray Matters: A Biography of Brain Surgery. We discuss what it’s like to operate under extreme pressure, the controversial legacy of Dr. William Scoville (the surgeon who operated on H.M. — and on my father), and what modern neuroscience tells us about free will, brain-computer interfaces, and the mystery of consciousness itself. Does a purely physical view of the mind make our experience less sacred — or more profound?RELATED LINKS:Buy Dr. Schwartz's book here: https://www.amazon.com/Gray-Matters-Biography-Brain-Surgery/dp/B0CPTDCCLX/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow the YouTube channel — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#Neuroscience #Neurosurgery #FreeWill #BrainSurgery #TheodoreSchwartz #GrayMatters

I was named after the neurosurgeon who operated on H.M., history’s most famous amnesiac. In this episode, I trace Henry Molaison’s case, the discoveries it unlocked about memory, and a parallel story from my own family that began in the same Hartford hospital.What you’ll learn (without spoilers):How H.M.’s case helped separate short-term vs long-term memoryWhy declarative and procedural memory are different (mirror-drawing!)The promise and perils of mid-century psychosurgeryA personal tale of diagnosis, risk, recovery… and unintended consequencesRELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow the YouTube channel — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the podcast by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#Memory #HM #BrendaMilner #WilliamScoville #Neurosurgery

What if the “Self” you take for granted isn’t what it seems? Neuroscience, psychology, and philosophy suggest that some of our deepest assumptions about who we are might be illusions. In this video, we’ll look at three powerful ways our sense of self misleads us—and why seeing through these illusions can change how we live, think, and connect with others. Along the way, we’ll explore groundbreaking experiments and ideas that challenge our everyday experience of being “me.”RELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Subscribe to the YouTube channel — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#Self #Philosophy #Neuroscience #WhatIsMind

Is religion a cultural parasite, a spandrel, an evolutionary adaptation – or evidence of God? In this video, we explore the main scientific and philosophical theories about the origins of religion.RELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow the YouTube channel — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#Religion #Evolution #Neuroscience

In this episode, I’m joined by futurist and author Richard Yonck. We talk about his new sci-fi novel Mindstock, and how fiction can help us imagine the future of human and machine minds. We also dive into his earlier work on emotions and machines—a topic at the frontier of AI, robotics, and human–computer interaction.LINKS:Buy Richard Yonck's book here: https://www.amazon.com/Mindstock-Novel-Richard-Yonck-ebook/dp/B0FHG18378/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Subscribe to What Is Mind? on YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#RichardYonck #Futurism #Mindstock #AI #EmotionsAndMachines

Is the brain a single, unified system—or a collection of specialized parts working in concert? In this episode, William Gadea explores the case for modularity of mind, from Paul Broca’s 19th-century discovery in a patient named Louis Victor Leborgne, to the insights of modern neuroimaging.What does it mean that speech, memory, face recognition, and even morality may live in different parts of the brain? And how does this relate to our experience of the self?LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase his book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow the YouTube channel — https://www.youtube.com/@whatismind-williamgadeaFollow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.#Religion #Consciousness #Evolution #Neuroscience

This is a solo episode.Philosopher David Chalmers is the leading advocate of modern dualism. He thinks we should face the fact that consciousness is a hard problem. I summarize and take a critical look at his views.RELATED LINKS:Learn more about the creator — https://www.williamgadea.com/Purchase William Gadea's book here — https://www.amazon.com/Arrow-Power-Poison-William-Gadea/dp/B0FD94LW5G/ref=nosim?tag=williamgadea-20Follow us on X — https://x.com/willgadeaYou can support the channel by purchasing from the affiliate links above, at no additional cost to you.If questions about mind and consciousness fascinate you, please consider subscribing!