DiscoverThe ThoughtStretchers Podcast
The ThoughtStretchers Podcast
Claim Ownership

The ThoughtStretchers Podcast

Author: ThoughtStretchers Education

Subscribed: 335Played: 11,028
Share

Description

Dialectic Conversations For Intellectually Rigorous Educators
468 Episodes
Reverse
Drew Perkins talks with James Shuls, head of the Educational Liberty branch of Florida State University's Institute for Governance and Civics and co-editor, with Jason Bedrick of the Heritage Foundation, of The Phoenix Principles. The book grew out of a conservative convening that set out to say what education reformers are for, not just what they're against, and it lays out seven principles: parents as primary educators, transparency and accountability, truth and goodness, character formation, academic excellence, cultural transmission and the formation of citizens. James explains why the group framed it as an American vision rather than a conservative one, and he and Drew dig into the tensions: parents' rights and the state's role in civic education, school choice and federalism, book bans and "haggling over the price," shared cultural knowledge versus the trivialization of civics, and where explicit instruction and inquiry each belong. They close on what a Phoenix Principles education would produce: a more measured society, more boring politics, and citizens who recognize the dignity of the people they disagree with. Links & Resources If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected] Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways Say what you're for: The Phoenix Declaration began at a convening of conservative education reformers who wanted to stop playing whack-a-mole against what they opposed and articulate a positive vision. The book expands its seven principles into essays that give readers the arguments to defend them. Education is formation, not just job prep: James argues that schools should transmit cultural knowledge and values, form character and form American citizens. Preparing people for jobs matters, but it isn't the whole purpose. Parents first, but the state isn't neutral: Parents have the pre-political right to direct their children's upbringing. The state still has an interest in forming citizens, and school choice acts as a check if the state gets too heavy-handed. Everyone is haggling over the price: Whether it's book bans or rules for private schools in choice programs, nearly everyone draws a line somewhere. James prefers letting states experiment over uniform national rules. Knowledge, not trivia: Content knowledge is essential, but turning civics into trivia doesn't make good citizens. Students need to wrestle with primary sources and opposing arguments, with time for both direct instruction and inquiry. Aim for more boring politics: A Phoenix Principles education, James hopes, would produce a more measured society that understands majority rule, minority rights and the dignity of people we disagree with. Episode highlights and timecodes 0:00 – Introduction: James Shuls and Florida State's Institute for Governance and Civics. 1:48 – Civic pragmatism and the four pillars of liberty: Great books plus statistics, and the new Civics and Liberty Studies degree. 3:45 – Will civics institutes survive political change?: Why bipartisan relevance matters. 5:17 – Where the Phoenix Principles came from: From a conservative convening to the Phoenix Declaration and the book. 8:09 – A vision of education: formation, not just job prep: Transmitting culture and forming citizens. 10:05 – The seven principles: From the primacy of parents to the formation of citizens. 12:05 – The primacy of parents and the role of the state: Federalism, the common schools and school choice as a check on the state. 18:12 – Can parents get it wrong?: Individual bad choices versus statewide ones. 21:44 – "Haggling over the price": book bans and school choice: Everyone draws a line somewhere. 26:30 – Is the Department of Education shrinking?: Why lasting change takes Congress. 29:14 – The federal tax credit program: A school choice win, and federalism concerns. 30:07 – Pluralism, transparency and illiberal bills: Classroom video and anti-DEI bills. 32:57 – An American vision, not just a conservative one: Federalists and Anti-Federalists, Marx and Smith. 35:22 – Knowledge, inquiry and the pedagogy wars: Drew on the tension in the book. 37:45 – Shared cultural knowledge and the trivialization of civics: Knowing Harry Potter trivia doesn't make you a wizard. 40:09 – Wrestling with primary sources: Malcolm X, MLK and a favorite teaching moment. 42:54 – Direct instruction and inquiry: Times and places for each. 44:29 – The pendulum swing: Drew on rigid models and rote memorization. 48:37 – In defense of memorization: Kipling, the Gettysburg Address and "Paul Revere's Ride." 51:24 – School choice as a release valve: The growth of classical education. 52:57 – What success would look like: more boring politics: Majority rule and minority rights. 57:37 – Inoculating students against tribalism: Human dignity at the core. 1:00:34 – Where to find the book: The Phoenix Principles from Encounter Books.
Drew Perkins talks with Colleen Shogan, the former Archivist of the United States and the first woman to hold the role, who is now a senior adviser at More Perfect, where she leads the history-based civics initiative In Pursuit, and a senior fellow in civics education at Stand Together. Six years after her last visit to the podcast, Colleen describes being fired as Archivist as a civics lesson in resilience, then lays out what civics education needs beyond memorizing the three branches: knowledge, skills and character, all aimed at the practical wisdom she calls civic judgment. Along the way they dig into the state of civic knowledge, how to teach controversial topics without picking sides, why teachers need support from administrators, the case against book bans from either side, and whether the fragmented civics movement can come together during the "civic decade." Links & Resources If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected] Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways Civic knowledge is alarmingly thin: Colleen cites 22% of eighth graders scoring proficient in civics, and surveys finding that 35% of adults can't name the three branches of government, 25% can't name a single First Amendment freedom and only 45% know senators serve six-year terms. Knowledge is the baseline, not the goal: Both agree that knowing how a separated-powers system works is necessary but not sufficient. Colleen adds skills (compromise, active listening, productive disagreement, coalition-building) and character (humility, patience, responsibility, courage). The aim is civic judgment: Knowledge, skills and character come together in what Colleen calls civic judgment, Aristotle's phronesis or practical wisdom: the ability to decide well in situations no one can rehearse for. Measure impact, not just reach: Impressions and readership are easy to count. Knowing whether minds and habits changed takes before-and-after work in classrooms, such as running the same decision-making scenario at the start and end of a semester. Controversial topics need practice and backing: Start with low-stakes questions and build toward hot-button issues, as UW–Madison's deliberative dinners do. Teachers who push back on every view model good disagreement, but they need support from principals and school boards to do it. Civic action and civic knowledge aren't rivals: Petitioning for a stop sign requires knowing how local decisions get made. Knowledge, skills and dispositions together make civic action thoughtful, including how to handle losing. Episode highlights and timecodes 0:00 – Introduction and catching up: From the White House Historical Association to the National Archives, More Perfect and In Pursuit. 0:50 – First woman Archivist, and the only one fired: Colleen on her dismissal in February 2025. 3:11 – Setbacks as a civics lesson: Resilience for individuals and for institutions. 5:09 – The state of civic knowledge: The numbers on students' and adults' civic knowledge. 8:29 – Knowledge as a baseline: Necessary but not sufficient, and why a separated-powers system needs explaining. 10:33 – Three pillars: knowledge, skills and character: Compromise, active listening, productive disagreement and coalition-building. 12:50 – Civic judgment and practical wisdom: Aristotle's phronesis, and preparing for situations no one can predict. 17:16 – Measuring reach versus impact: Why before-and-after classroom measures matter. 19:18 – Working through controversial topics: Evidence, stakeholders, competing values, discussion, decision. 21:47 – Low-stakes simulations: The million-dollar school budget scenario, before and after instruction. 24:04 – UW–Madison's deliberative dialogue dinners: From cafeteria hours to immigration and abortion. 28:35 – What great civics teachers do: A history teacher who pushed back on every opinion. 31:39 – Teachers need administrative support: Why principals and school boards matter. 33:46 – Enlightenment principles and intellectual freedom: Book bans, the public library and letting ideas compete. 39:38 – Time, budgets and A Nation at Risk: Why social studies keeps getting squeezed. 42:11 – Better preparation for civics teachers: Graduate courses and summer institutes. 45:23 – Explicit instruction, inquiry and informed skeptics: Drew on inoculating students against tribalism. 47:32 – The role of school librarians: Information professionals in every classroom. 49:27 – "Tell me more": Responding to students' provocative questions. 51:18 – A fragmented civics movement and the civic decade: Can the field agree on shared goals? 54:14 – What role for the federal government?: The founders on civic education. 56:30 – Civic action versus civic knowledge: A false dichotomy, illustrated by a stop sign. 59:54 – The Consent of the Governed project: Students persuading their city council. 1:01:02 – Where to find Colleen's work: In Pursuit, Stand Together and an Adams family Thanksgiving.
Drew Perkins talks with Pamela Snow, Distinguished Professor of Cognitive Psychology in the School of Education at La Trobe University and co-founder of the Science of Language and Reading (SOLAR) Lab, about flourishing versus learning, where explicit instruction and inquiry each belong, and why teacher preparation has so often left out the science of how children learn. Links & Resources Mentioned In This Episode Have feedback or a question? Email [email protected]. If you find this episode useful, please share it and leave a review wherever you listen. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected] Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways Learning is part of flourishing, not its rival: Pamela treats wellbeing, safety and belonging as the "wallpaper" of school, but argues students can't be called flourishing if they aren't learning. Drew worries that "school is for learning" can shrink into a narrow, rigid set of outcomes. Pedagogy is a continuum: Both reject the explicit-versus-inquiry dichotomy. The real question is where a given task and a given group of learners belong on that continuum. Explicit instruction today is interactive: Pamela describes fast-paced, inclusive classrooms with mini-whiteboards, turn-and-talks, warm calling and constant checks for understanding, not lecturing, followed by project-based application once students are proficient. Skill tends to come before thrill: Pamela points to a 2023 Finnish twin study suggesting that reading skill drives reading enjoyment rather than the other way around. Inquiry first is the real disagreement: Drew sees a well-designed driving question as a primer and a builder of long-term dispositions like informed skepticism. Pamela worries about misconceptions, efficiency and equity for novices who start furthest behind. Teacher prep needs the science of learning, and context: They agree pre-service teachers need cognitive load theory and executive function. Drew adds that without classroom experience, those ideas may not stick. Episode highlights and timecodes 00:00 – Introduction: Pamela's path from speech-language pathology and brain injury research into education. 02:28 – Oral Language And Youth Justice: Hidden oral language gaps among young people in youth justice, and literacy as a protective factor. 05:22 – Moving Into Education: La Trobe's 2020 restructure to align its School of Education with learning science. 07:06 – The SOLAR Lab: Founding the lab with Tanya Serry and what teachers need to know about how the English writing system works. 09:55 – Pamela's Own Schooling: Explicit phonics in the 1960s and a "choose your own adventure" secondary school in the 1970s. 14:52 – Social Media And The Pedagogy Wars: Why this conversation, and whether the debate is productive. 15:53 – How Teacher Education Changed In Australia: The Dawkins reforms and the rise of sociology in education faculties. 19:05 – The Martian Test: Who owns the question of how children learn? 24:47 – Flourishing Versus Learning: Drew's flourishing question and Pamela's two-part answer. 29:35 – Teacher Autonomy And Professional Status: Comparisons to medicine, aviation and nursing, and the soft bigotry of low expectations. 32:19 – What School Signs Say: Virtues on the walls, and how rarely learning makes the list. 34:33 – Pedagogy As A Continuum: Types of knowledge, and why inquiry and discovery shouldn't be conflated. 36:48 – Where Explicit Instruction Fits: Efficiency and equity when teaching new material to novices. 40:37 – Explicit Instruction In 2026: Interactive classrooms first, then project-based application once students are proficient. 44:10 – Motivation And Scaffolding: A zoo enrichment analogy, gradual release, and "I do, we do, we do, we do, you do." 50:28 – Skill Before Thrill: The Finnish twin study on reading skill and reading enjoyment. 51:56 – Inquiry As A Primer?: Drew's case for inquiry before knowledge building. 56:49 – The New Zealand Example: How an open start can spread misconceptions. 1:00:38 – Slow To Go Fast: Driving questions and inquiry as a design problem. 1:01:53 – Inquiry, Civics And Informed Skeptics: Long-term outcomes that are hard to measure. 1:04:53 – How Would We Measure Success?: Hope as a strategy versus qualitative evidence. 1:07:17 – NAPLAN And Math: Reading-heavy math problems and teacher math anxiety. 1:09:53 – Explicit Instruction Inside PBL: The pizza restaurant tipping guide project. 1:11:41 – Cognitive Science In Teacher Prep: Can novices use it before they have classroom context? 1:18:17 – "Cognitive Load Theory Doesn't Matter": A teacher's realization, and Drew's view of cognitive load in well-designed inquiry. 1:21:50 – Variability And Social Justice: De-implementing practices that don't deliver for students. 1:23:13 – Closing Remarks: On disagreeing and still listening and learning.
Drew Perkins hosts a live conversation at the Festival of Education with Lianne Cottrell of the Jack Miller Center, Ronnie London of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) and Rachel Humphries of the Bill of Rights Institute on restoring Enlightenment civics. The panel asks how much the American founding rests on Enlightenment liberalism, why free speech is the engine of pluralism and social change, how students' and teachers' First Amendment rights differ between K-12 and higher education, and what society might look like if civic education were treated as the formation of humble, reasoning citizens. Links & Resources If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected]. Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways The founding rests on Enlightenment ideals, but which Enlightenment? Lianne notes that the Scottish and French Enlightenments color how we read life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Rachel argues most classrooms give the philosophy only a surface-level "this is what Locke said" gloss. Persuasion or force: Ronnie argues there are only two ways to get people to do what you want, convince them or coerce them. Free speech keeps us on the side of persuasion, lets us see the world as it is, and has powered every major social movement. Censorship is a position of weakness: Silencing someone signals you can't answer them. Students should learn early to hear others out and test their own thinking against them, as in Mill's On Liberty. K-12 and higher ed are different legal worlds: College students and faculty have broad First Amendment protection. K-12 students keep their rights at the schoolhouse gate within the limits of Tinker, while K-12 teachers' classroom speech is largely governed by curriculum and school authorities. Civic education is formation: The panel calls for teaching reasoning over feeling, building trust before hard conversations, supporting teachers to lead Socratic discussion, and aiming for citizens who are humble, connected and quick to find their own errors. Episode highlights and timecodes 00:00 – Welcome & Introductions: Lianne, Ronnie and Rachel introduce themselves and their organizations. 01:54 – Enlightenment Liberalism and the Founding: Drew asks how far our founding ideals rest on Enlightenment liberalism, and the panel weighs Scottish vs. French Enlightenments and the "history and tradition" lens. 06:50 – Traditional vs. Inquiry: Each panelist reflects on their own K-12 experience of civics and history. 12:51 – From Sputnik to A Nation at Risk: How accountability, fear and the STEM push changed the purpose of education. 19:34 – Why Free Speech Matters: Persuasion vs. force, "rhetoric is lawful magic," and why censorship is a position of weakness. 27:37 – K-12 vs. Higher Ed: Supporting teachers, the 1619 Project question, and how First Amendment rights differ for students and teachers. 33:35 – Imagining the Ideal: Humility, thick bonds and a literal American exceptionalism. 38:20 – Book Recommendations: From On Liberty to the Nicomachean Ethics. 42:34 – Closing: Jonathan Rauch's fallibilist and empirical rules.
Drew Perkins hosts a live panel at the Festival of Education with Elise Stephenson, Patrice Bain and Valentina Devid on the so-called pedagogy wars between explicit instruction and inquiry. Recorded in front of an audience, the conversation asks what role knowledge plays in critical thinking, where each panelist sits on the instructional continuum, and how formative assessment and making thinking visible help teachers meet students where they are. The panel's answer to "either-or?" is a firm "yes-and." Links & Resources If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected]. Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways It's yes-and, not either-or: All three panelists place themselves on a continuum between direct instruction and inquiry. They move along it depending on what students already know and what the learning goal demands. Knowledge is a starting point, not the finish line: Knowledge makes critical thinking possible and better, but the aim is to "play the game," not just learn the vocabulary of it. Students also arrive with more knowledge and thinking than test scores suggest. Thinking can be grown: Research from Project Zero shows students in classrooms that name and value thinking moves get better at using thinking strategies at every age. Modeling, think-alouds and self-regulation are key. Formative action and visible thinking are two names for the same idea: Constantly and purposefully checking what students understand challenges teachers' assumptions. It replaces rigid "novice or expert" labels with a picture of each learner. Watch for lethal mutations on every side: Retrieval practice done as a box to tick, and thinking routines done as one-off activities, both miss the point. Teachers need tools, skills and mindsets, plus a healthy skepticism of anyone selling "the one right way." Episode highlights and timecodes 00:00 – Welcome & Introductions: Drew introduces the panel and frames the pedagogy wars as a "yes-and" rather than an "either-or." 05:25 – Knowledge & Critical Thinking: Can students think critically with little domain knowledge? Valentina, Elise and Patrice push back on Drew's pushback. 10:08 – Can Thinking Be Trained?: Elise shares Ron Ritchhart's research on students' concept maps of thinking, and Patrice describes teaching students how to learn. 15:33 – The Pedagogy Spectrum: From drill-and-kill to free school, each panelist places their own practice on the continuum. 21:20 – Formative Action & Visible Thinking: The expertise reversal effect, checking for agreement vs. checking for understanding, and why teachers need tools, skills and mindsets. 28:54 – Lethal Mutations: How the science of learning, and inquiry approaches, can be reduced to box-ticking. 34:12 – Beyond the Tribalism: Curiosity, humility and healthy skepticism as the way forward. Frequently asked questions What are the "pedagogy wars"? The polarized debate between explicit or direct instruction and inquiry-based approaches. The panel rejects the either-or framing and argues that good teaching moves along a continuum between them. Can students think critically without knowledge? The panel agrees that knowledge strongly supports critical thinking. Valentina argues it's a prerequisite. Elise cautions that students always bring knowledge and ways of thinking, even when test scores don't show it. Drew argues some critical thinking is possible with little domain knowledge. Can critical thinking be taught? Project Zero research described by Elise suggests thinking strategies can be learned and improved. Students in classrooms that name and value thinking moves grow in their ability to name and apply them. Valentina adds that teaching self-regulation, through modeling and think-alouds, has a large impact. Where do the panelists sit on the instruction-to-inquiry spectrum? All three say they are "on the continuum." Patrice uses heavy direct instruction to build a foundation and scaffolds toward deep learning. Valentina adapts to where students are, aiming for independence. Elise braids required skills with students' own generative questions. What is the expertise reversal effect? A finding from cognitive load theory: techniques that help novices can hinder experts, and vice versa. The panel cautions against labeling whole students as novices or experts. Students can be ahead and behind at the same time, which is why ongoing formative assessment matters. What's the difference between checking for agreement and checking for understanding? Tools like cold calling and mini whiteboards can confirm a correct answer, which Drew calls agreement. Understanding requires seeing how students make sense of ideas. Valentina's formative action model adds dialogue and sense-making after the check. What is a "lethal mutation"? A practice that loses its purpose as it spreads. Examples include retrieval practice done just to tick a box, or a See-Think-Wonder routine used as a one-off activity. Teachers who understand the "why" behind a practice can adapt it well. How do we move beyond the tribalism? Ask "How do my students learn?" (Patrice). Model curiosity, open-mindedness and willingness to be wrong (Valentina). Bring healthy skepticism to anyone claiming one best way (Elise). Drew calls this an inquiry mindset.
loading
Comments