Discover
The Book Club Review
The Book Club Review
Author: The Book Club Review
Subscribed: 1,109Played: 24,983Subscribe
Share
© 2026 Kate Slotover
Description
Discussion, debate, even a little dispute – expect it all on The Book Club Review. Join host Kate and her guests as they explore contemporary and classic titles. From hyped new releases to word-of-mouth backlist tips, books are put to the book club test – do they live up to our expectations? Listen in for thoughtful insights, lively opinions and inspiration for your next great read.
205 Episodes
Reverse
It's time for the final six! In this second of our two special episodes on the 2026 Booker Prize, Kate is joined by co-host Laura Potter and regular contributor Phil Chaffee to debate the shortlist, compare notes and decide which book they think deserves to win. There are some strong disagreements along the way. Is Luke Kennard's Black Bag a comic masterpiece or an overpraised curiosity? Does Marlon James's The Disappearers justify its punishing intensity? And what are we to make of M. John Harrison's strange, unsettling and decidedly baffling The End of Everything?We also discuss the pleasures of returning to Douglas Stuart, the quiet emotional power of Elizabeth Strout, and the merits of Rebecca Perry's unusual historical novel. Along the way, we ask what the Booker Prize is really for, whether previous winners should be shortlisted again, and whether a novel has to be accessible to be great.Then, after the main discussion, you're invited to join our very exclusive watch-party as we tune in to the ceremony for the announcement of the winner. Expect predictions, live reactions and a fair amount of astonishment.The six shortlisted books discussed:Black Bag – Luke KennardMay We Feed the King – Rebecca PerryThe Things We Never Say – Elizabeth StroutThe End of Everything – M. John HarrisonJohn of John – Douglas StuartThe Disappearers – Marlon JamesJoin us on PatreonIf, like us, you're now desperate to read something that isn't on a Booker list, we've recorded an extra conversation about all the books we're lining up to read next. It's a bonus for subscribers, along with our monthly online book club and plenty more.Find out more at patreon.com/thebookclubreview.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
The Booker judges have made their choices, and six novels have made it through to the shortlist. But what about the books left behind?In this episode, Kate is joined by regular-contributor Phil Chaffee, and Elizabeth Eva Leach and Charlotte Kearsley (both Patreon members) to give the best-of-the-rest their moment in the spotlight. Between them, they've read their way through the Booker dozen, now it's time for their full and frank reviews.If the books on the longlist have one thing in common, Elizabeth thinks, it's a preoccupation with the idea of the failure of knowledge, while Charlotte noticed a split between authors who chose to be highly specific, and others who resisted doing that, which was a characteristic of many of the books on the list. Leaving no stone unturned, we're considering all seven books that didn't make the shortlist and singling out those books we don't want listeners to miss.And of course we're taking a brief look at favourites from the shortlist and thoughts on the potential winner. This is Part One of our Booker coverage. Coming soon Part Two: our discussion of the six shortlisted novels, and then our reaction to the winner.Books discussedThe Shadow of the Object – Chloe AridjisSwitzy – Emma ClineHelen of Nowhere – Makenna GoodmanThe Renovation – Kenan OrhanThe Palm House – Gwendoline RileyAll Them Dogs – Djamel WhiteThe Vivisectors – Missouri WilliamsOther books mentionedThe Rouse – China MiévilleThe Power Broker – Robert A. CaroThe Guest, Daddy and The Girls – Emma ClineMilkman – Anna BurnsHello Phantoms and First Love – Gwendoline RileyThe Finkler Question – Howard JacobsonFlesh – David SzalayConsider supporting the pod for a whole range of benefits, from book club membership to extra episodes, ad free listening and community membership. Find all the details and how to sign up at Patreon.com/thebookclubreviewSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Kate and Laura are back and diving in to two book club reads, one recent release and one modern classic. Transcription by Ben Lerner was published earlier this year to much critical fanfare. It's a playful, intellectually ambitious exploration of writing, memory, technology and the slippery relationship between fiction and reality. When the narrator's phone fails to record his final interview with an eminent cultural figure, he reconstructs the conversation from memory. But does the truth of an encounter depend on an accurate transcript? And what happens when a novel begins to fold back on itself?We discuss Lerner's auto-fictional project, his fascination with the act of writing, the glass flowers at Harvard's Natural History Museum, and whether Lerner's novels are genuinely profound or sometimes guilty of taking themselves a little too seriously. Laura’s book club, meanwhile headed back to the mid-20th century with Dorothy Baker’s classic Cassandra at the Wedding, a brilliantly funny, unsettling and surprisingly contemporary novella about an intensely self-absorbed young woman determined to prevent her identical twin sister from getting married. With its claustrophobic family setting, unreliable narrator, dark comedy and complicated portrait of sisterly love, it's a novel that raises questions about identity, dependence, artistic ambition and the difficulty of allowing the people we love to become themselves – but what did Laura's book club make of it? As ever in addition to the book club catch up we’re also swapping notes on recent reads and upcoming plans, including diving in to the Booker prize shortlist – the most enticing, we both agree, in years. Notes and books mentionedThe Ware Collection of Blaschka Glass Models at Harvard A Portrait of the Artist as an Artist Portraying the Artist by Nathan Anthony WestIndiana by George SandBriefly, A Delicious Life by Nell StevensThe Romantics by Pankaj MishraA Place of Greater Safety by Hilary MantelThe Great Dictator by Matthew SweetWhen the Going was Good by Graydon CarterReading Lolita in Tehran by Azar NafisiJoin The Book Club Review on PatreonBecome a subscriber for extra episodes, access to our community chat groups, and the chance to join our monthly podcast book club.Our next reads are A Severed Head by Iris Murdoch (October '26) and Helm by Sarah Hall (November '26).Find out more at patreon.com/thebookclubreviewThe Book Club Review is a podcast about books, book clubs and the books that get people talking.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
It’s the end of summer, so Kate and Laura are looking back over their holiday reading, the books they loved, the ones that disappointed them, and the unexpected discoveries that made their reading lists longer rather than shorter.We talk about Alex E. Harrow’s huge fantasy novel The Everlasting, and why it turned out to be a surprisingly divisive read. Kate reports back on her pick from the Booker longlist, The Palm House by Gwendolyn Riley. She's also recently completed The Power Broker, Robert Caro's iconic book on New York master-builder Robert Moses, but was it worth the read? She's also discussing The Silver Book, Olivia Laing's most recent work of fiction. In Pankaj Mishra’s The Romantics, Laura found an interesting book club choice, while Kate's flagging up Vladimir by Julia May Jonas, and while on the campus novel theme she also read Joanna Miller’s The Eights, set in 1920s Oxford. Laura wraps things up with the wonderfully atmospheric The Night Tiger by Yangsze Choo.But there’s more as pod-regular Phil Chaffee joins us with two of his favourite summer reads, Sue Prideaux’s Wild Thing: A Life of Paul Gauguin and Bret Easton Ellis’s The Shards.As summer comes to an end, we’re also looking ahead to Booker season, with the shortlist just around the corner and plenty more reading on the horizon.PatreonCome and find the pod on Patreon at patreon.com/thebookclubreviewKeep up with the pod between shows on Instagram @bookclubreviewpodcastFor all other information and our episode archive find The Book Club Review online at thebookclubreview.co.ukComplete booklistThe Power Broker by Robert CaroGideon the Ninth by Tamsyn MuirThe Everlasting by Alex E. HarrowThe Calculation of Volume by Solvej BalleStarling House by Alex E. HarrowJonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna ClarkeThe Palm House by Gwendolyn RileyFamesick by Lena DunhamMy Phantoms by Gwendolyn RileyThe Silver Book by Olivia LaingThe Garden Against Time by Olivia LaingCrudo by Olivia LaingThe Romantics by Pankaj MishraThe Golden Mean by Annabel LyonFathers & Sons by Ivan TurgenevThe Heart of the Nhaga by Lee Young-do (Anton Hur)Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt DinnermanLand by Maggie O’FarrellThe Chair (Netflix)Monsters by Claire DedererVladimir by Julia May JonasThe Eights by Joanna MillerThe Night Tiger and The Fox Wife by Yangsze ChooThe Digital Critic: Literary Culture Online (Houman Barekat, Robert Barry and David Winters, eds.)When We Talk About Love by Carl WilsonTimecodes for the time-poor00:00 — Welcome & summer reading02:00 — What did we actually read this summer?Holiday reading plans, library books and the perennial problem of taking too many books away with you.04:00 — The Everlasting by Alex E. HarrowTime loops, quests and a very divided reaction.15:30 — The End of the Power Broker by Robert CaroKate tackles another Booker longlist book and asks: why is this on the longlist?20:00 — The Booker longlist pickA frank discussion of Gwendolyn Riley's The Palm House and the pleasures (and pains) of reading for the Booker.22:20 — The Silver Book by Olivia LaingA surprise for Kate after her mixed reaction to Laing’s Crudo.27:30 — An accidental book-club adventureLaura's brilliant idea: abandon the overheated book-club meeting and send everyone into Foyles to choose books.28:40 — The Romantics by Pankaj MishraA chance discovery — and a Hilary Mantel endorsement that seals the deal.35:50 — Vladimir by Julia May JonasSex, power, academia and the deliciously murky moral territory of a campus novel.40:00 — The Eights by Joanna MillerWomen in academia, 1920s Oxford and coming-of-age just after World War I42:40 — The Night Tiger by Yangsze ChooMystery, folklore, tigers and colonial Malaysia, Laura's perfect summer read50:45 — Phil’s summer readingWild Thing: A Life of Paul Gauguin by Sue Prideaux and The Shards by Bret Easton Ellis54:20 — Booker season beginsThe shortlist is coming, and summer reading gives way to required reading.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Looking for the perfect summer read? Kate is joined by Laura Potter and returning guest Phil Chaffee to compare recent reads before putting this year's biggest summer books to the test. Inspired by reading lists from The New York Times, The Times, Lit Hub and The Booker Prize, they decide which books are beach reads, suitcase books, and which they'd happily leave behind at the airport. Plus, they reveal the books they're packing for their own holidays.Books discussedRecently readThe Golden Mean — Annabel LyonPlato and the Tyrant — James RommGlorious Exploits — Ferdia LennonThe Game of Kings — Dorothy DunnettThe House of Niccolò series — Dorothy DunnettWe Are Green and Trembling — Gabriela Cabezón Cámara (trans. Robin Myers)Evaluating the picks from the summer reading listsHot Milk — Deborah LevyThe Eighth Life — Nino HaratischwiliA Month in the Country — J. L. CarrWhistler — Ann PatchettThe Things We Never Say — Elizabeth StroutLand — Maggie O'FarrellInstructions for a Heatwave — Maggie O'FarrellJohn of John — Douglas StuartI Want You to Be Happy — Jem CalderThe Director — Daniel KehlmannVilla Coco — Andrew Sean GreerOur holiday recommendationsThe Feast — Margaret KennedyFree Food for Millionaires — Min Jin LeeFamesick — Lena DunhamSwimming Home — Deborah LevyRadiant Star — Ann LeckieThe Balkan Trilogy — Olivia ManningWait for Me — Deborah, Duchess of DevonshireThe Pursuit of Love — Nancy MitfordAlso mentionedPachinko — Min Jin LeeShuggie Bain and Young Mungo — Douglas StuartLess — Andrew Sean GreerTranscription — Ben LernerReading Lolita in Tehran — Azar NafisiTimecodes00:00 Welcome02:44 Phil on The Golden Mean07:39 Laura on Dorothy Dunnett11:55 Kate on Green and Trembling16:54 Beach read game rules18:20 Booker picks: Hot Milk19:40 Doorstop epic The Eighth Life21:46 Classic: A Month Country23:07 NYT Beach Reads, Whistler by Ann. Patchett25:33 Elizabeth Strout and American vibes28:22 Switching to the (UK) Times list28:29 Times list features29:03 Maggie O'Farrell debate30:51 Douglas Stuart pick John of John33:05 New paperback picks35:03 Kehlmann masterpiece The Director38:28 The LitHub list of lists38:55 Villa Coco verdict41:44 Get more from the pod on Patreon43:26 Our personal holiday reads44:03 Phil recommends The Feast46:01 Min Jin Lee deep dive48:18 Lena Dunham Famesick51:44 Laura's summer stack53:56 Mitfords and Tana French01:02:20 Final wrap and farewellSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.








