DiscoverYou Can't Comp This: NBA Trading Card Podcast
You Can't Comp This: NBA Trading Card Podcast
Claim Ownership

You Can't Comp This: NBA Trading Card Podcast

Author: Adam Amy & Russell Gibson

Subscribed: 15Played: 1,747
Share

Description

Co-Hosted by Adam Amy and Russell Gibson we deliver a weekly podcast that discusses current NBA news and how this impacts the trading card market. Each week we deep dive into a larger more timeless hobby related topic.
256 Episodes
Reverse
Send us a text Halfway through the NBA season already? We dive into the hobby's latest whinges: Topps Chrome Mega Box blue X-Fractor packing mishap – error or nitpick? LeBron's revolutionary 23rd season jersey patch cards get Russell's thumbs up. Cade Cunningham's recent 1/1 sale that's melting brains (Nebula jumps big while Gold Vinyl lags?). Kuminga trade rumors (again), Luka Downtown Topps whispers, Trae Young's hobby impact post-trade to Washington. Plus: SGC/BGS grading updates, Wemby 50...
Send us a text Episode 254 is a New Year check-in that quickly turns into a wide-ranging hobby and NBA discussion. The episode opens with reflections on the start of 2026 and how collectors are thinking about the year ahead, before moving into current NBA storylines that are already shaping card conversations. Trae Young’s situation and on-court narrative are discussed in the context of perception versus production, and how quickly hobby sentiment can shift. From there, the conversation turns...
Send us a text This episode focuses on growing scrutiny around PSA and its position within the hobby, sparked by a letter written by a US Senator raising concerns about market dominance and monopoly behaviour. The discussion centres on what that letter actually says, why it matters, and whether hobby participants should be paying closer attention. The conversation then shifts to a voicemail sent in by Ryan from GemRate. This is not a listener question, but a direct response addressing grading...
Send us a text In Episode 252, the conversation turns to a growing pattern in the hobby: collectors and capital circling grading companies, regrading cycles repeating themselves, and whether we’re learning anything from the past. Russell and Adam unpack what it really means when collectors become stakeholders, how BGS and PSA fit into the current regrading narrative, and why trust, transparency, and incentives keep coming back into question. The episode digs into: • collectors influenci...
Send us a text In Episode 251, Russell and Adam take a hard look at one of the most debated behaviours in the hobby right now — PSA regrading their own cards Is PSA regrading a smart optimisation strategy… or has it become a dangerous numbers game that distorts populations, pricing, and trust? The discussion covers: • How the situation came to light • Is this actually a scam? • who publicly defended PSA? • what can be done to regulate this A must-listen for anyone slab...
Send us a text In Episode 250, Russell and Adam dive into one of the spiciest conversations of the season — should OKC make a play for Giannis, and is the NBA heading for a team-building arms race? They also unpack the new “Silvers /8” concept and whether this kind of manufactured scarcity actually helps collectors… or just adds confusion. The lads get into the ethics of community pricing, why collectors feel more pressure than ever, and whether some sellers are crossing the line between fair...
Send us a text In Episode 249, Russell and Adam break down a huge week in the hobby. Snype — once buzzing with momentum — has quietly disappeared, leaving collectors wondering what happened and what’s next in the “AI grading” rush. The lads also dive into the latest wave of Prizm Black hype, how scarcity really works when breakers dominate supply, and whether some cards are becoming impossible for collectors to touch. Plus: a temperature check on the market, a discussion about risk, and...
Send us a text In Episode 248, Russell and Adam tackle one of the biggest wake-up calls the hobby has seen — a major data breach affecting collectors, marketplaces, and the way personal information is handled across the industry. We also break down: Should the Grizzlies keep Ja or their coach?Fanatics pricing on Topps ChromeFantasy Surprises this year and hobby pricing. Gamestop banning customersIt’s a serious one — but an important conversation every collector needs to hear. Sup...
Send us a text In Episode 247, Russell and Adam break down the ten things they genuinely like about Topps — from fresh product design to global outreach, cleaner parallels, better photography, and the hobby energy Topps has brought back. They also talk about player selection, accessibility for new collectors, and why some innovations are quietly improving the landscape. It’s a surprisingly positive episode… with just enough spice to keep things honest. Support the show Thank You to our Pr...
Send us a text In this week’s You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adam unpack one of the wildest weeks in the hobby. They dive into Panini’s latest courtroom battle with Wildcard, the gambling scandal updates, and the eye-watering pull of a Luka Doncic 1/1 Logoman in Lakers colours. Plus — underrated legends finally getting their shine, from Hakeem to Duncan, and the rookies shaking up the season: Vijay Edgecombe, Derek Queen, and Dylan Harper. Is the hobby entering a new golden age, or just a w...
Send us a text We're back for a special Q&A, and the hobby is losing its mind over the new Topps NBA license. The main question on everyone's mind: Are we in Junk Wax 2.0? We dive into a wild calculation that puts the new Topps flagship print run at a staggering 429 MILLION cards. Adz and Russell debate what this massive number means, whether a product can be "junk wax" but still have hyper-collectible chase cards (like the new "All Kings" insert), and how Topps' massive marketing push is...
Send us a text In Episode 244 of You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adam take the hobby’s pulse after one of the craziest weeks in card news. They break down the LeBron James “All Kings” case hit — how hype drove prices from $4,000 down to $1,000 overnight — and debate whether collectors are falling into FOMO traps with new Topps Flagship releases. Then it’s onto the $2.4 million Kobe Bryant sale — raw, ungraded, and possibly sketchy — plus a look at Cooper Flagg’s rising market and the massive...
Send us a text It’s the start of a new NBA season — and the hobby is heating up! In this week’s episode, Russell and Adam dive into all the early-season hype, card market reactions, and hobby chatter that comes with fresh tip-offs. From Victor Wembanyama and Chet Holmgren’s breakout buzz to the rise of new products and collector energy, it’s a packed episode of laughs, takes, and trends. The guys also check the pulse of the hobby — exploring what’s exciting, what’s frustrating, and how collec...
Send us a text In Episode 242 of You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adam are joined by Alvie O’Hehir, from Fast Break Trading Cards, for an insider’s take on one of the biggest hobby weeks of the year. They dive into the Macao Card Show, the highly anticipated Topps Chrome NBA release, and how Asia’s growing collector scene is shaping the global market. Alvie shares behind-the-scenes insights into product strategy, design direction, and what’s next for Topps in 2025. The guys also chat about th...
Send us a text In Episode 241 of You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adam are back from holiday and hitting the ground running — covering a wild week across the hobby. They unpack the latest Wondershine Index drama, including the $4.7M Luka Doncic sale and renewed questions around transparency in the market. From there, it’s onto the Topps debut patch announcement, why it could rival Logomen in collector appeal, and the growing excitement for official game-used NBA memorabilia. The lads also cha...
Send us a text Episode 240 of You Can’t Comp This is packed with hobby buzz, NBA chatter, and on-the-road stories. Russell checks in live from San Antonio, sharing tales from his U.S. trip — including a first-hand look at Victor Wembanyama’s explosive play — before diving into the latest hobby headlines. The guys break down the massive $10 million Wondershine purchase of the Jordan–LeBron dual Logoman, debating whether the market’s high-end bubble is sustainable. They also revisit Panin...
Send us a text In this Timeless Moments episode, Russell and Adam dig into one of the darker sides of the hobby — market manipulation. From shill bidding on eBay to inflated comps, they break down how sellers can game the system and what that means for collectors. The discussion covers alleged practices tied to mega-sellers like Probstein, the risks for buyers, and how platforms like eBay and PSA play into protecting (or failing to protect) the community. The guys also speculate on Probstei...
Send us a text In this episode of You Can’t Comp This Podcast, Russell and Adam take the pulse of the hobby and dive deep into some of the biggest stories shaping the card market right now. We start with the Wondershine Index and what it really says about card values — from million-dollar grails to the pitfalls of hype. Then it’s onto PSA’s new Slab Review program, fees, and the opening of their German office. The guys also cover some eye-popping card sales — from Scottie Pippen’s surge...
Send us a text In Episode 237 of You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adz break down a huge week in the hobby: Oz Nationals Recap: The highs, lows, crowded aisles, and standout pickups. From Pokémon to NBA grails, what worked and what needs tweaking for next year.Panini Signings: Who’s putting pen to sticker? We run through the latest autograph deals and what they could mean for collectors.Hobby Movement: Market index trends, card ladder data, and why sales are climbing back toward pre-COVI...
Send us a text Body: In this week’s episode of You Can’t Comp This, Russell and Adam are joined by Alvaro O’Hehir from Fast Break Trading Cards. We talk about the huge year he’s had — from organising CollectFest Melbourne with Topps to preparing for Macau. Alvaro shares shop stories, lessons learned in prospecting, and why Pokémon and One Piece are taking over cabinets. Then, we shift gears to Caitlin Clark. With her injury sidelining her season, what happens to the value of her cards? Fro...
loading
Comments (2)

brendan dann

Shocking take on Ace Bailey. No way is this guy better then Maxey or Spider. He isn't even close to VJ.

Oct 25th
Reply

brendan dann

Guys love the show but as a 6ers fan if you think giving up the no 3 pick and PG for KD is a good trade you have rocks in your head. Philly need to be eyeing next season as a bell weather on whether Embiid can reach back to near prime. The no. 3 pick gives us a chance to get a jump on a rebuild, along with Maxey, McCain and Grimes. A 37 yo KD isn't going to help Philly unless Embiid can play a reasonable number of games. It's a poor trade for us!

May 21st
Reply