Murder, Not Murdering

In this episode, Erin and Autumn explore the details surrounding Nancy Guthrie’s kidnapping, the emotional impact on her family, and the ongoing search for her. Then the conversation shifts to discussing two significant cases Brandon Swanson’s disappearance and the St. Valentine's Day Massacre. Brandon Swanson's mysterious disappearance, highlighting the challenges faced by his family and the changes in missing persons laws that resulted from his case. Finally, they delve into the infamous St. Valentine's Day Massacre, examining the historical context, the key players involved, some modern UPDATES, and the various theories surrounding the event, ultimately reflecting on the lasting impact of these cases on society and law enforcement.Chapters00:00 Introduction to the Case of Nancy Guthrie04:47 The Disappearance of Brandon Swanson17:39 The St. Valentine's Day Massacre: A Historical Overview46:29 Theories and Speculations Surrounding the MassacreTakeawaysNancy Guthrie's case highlights the emotional toll on families during kidnappings.Brandon Swanson's disappearance led to significant changes in missing persons laws.The St. Valentine's Day Massacre remains one of the most infamous unsolved cases in American history.The use of ballistics in the St. Valentine's Day Massacre was a groundbreaking moment in forensic science.Public trust in law enforcement was severely impacted by the events of the St. Valentine's Day Massacre.Brandon's Law ensures prompt investigations for missing adults, changing how such cases are handled.The emotional weight of unresolved cases can linger for years, affecting families deeply.The St. Valentine's Day Massacre was not just a crime; it was a public execution that shocked the nation.Theories surrounding the St. Valentine's Day Massacre continue to evolve as new evidence emerges.The importance of community awareness in missing persons cases cannot be overstated.KeywordsNancy Guthrie, Brandon Swanson, St. Valentine's Day Massacre, true crime, kidnapping, unsolved mysteries, organized crime, Al Capone, forensic science, missing persons

This week Autumn and Erin delve into two tragic true crime stories: the case of Ashley Kline, a young woman with developmental disabilities who was murdered, and the Parker-Hulme murder, where two teenage girls conspired to kill one of their mothers. The discussion highlights the vulnerabilities of individuals in the justice system, the psychological motivations behind violent crime, and the impact of these tragedies on families and communities. Through these narratives, the importance of advocacy and understanding the complexities of crime is emphasized.Chapters00:00 Introduction to Crime and Documentaries02:14 Ashley Klein: A Life Cut Short29:48 The Tragic Fate of Ashley Kline31:43 The Parker-Hulme Murder: A Dark Tale of BetrayalKeywordscrime, murder, Ashley Kline, Parker Hulme, true crime, documentaries, criminal justice, missing persons, advocacy, violence against women

In this episode of "Murder Not Murdering," hosts Erin and Autumn delve into two intriguing cases. Erin discusses the historical case of Hippolyte Visart de Bocarme, a nobleman who attempted to commit the perfect murder using nicotine, a then-undetectable poison. The case revolutionized forensic science, proving that no poison is truly undetectable. Autumn covers the tragic story of Beverly Carter, a real estate agent who was kidnapped and murdered by a couple who mistakenly believed she was wealthy. The episode highlights the dangers faced by real estate agents and the importance of safety measures in the profession. Murder Not Murdering, Erin, Autumn, Hippolyte Visart de Bocarme, nicotine poison, forensic science, Beverly Carter, real estate safety, true crime podcast, historical murder case, true crime

In this episode, Erin and Autumn delve into two harrowing true crime cases: the tragic story of Andrea Yates, a mother who suffered from severe postpartum psychosis, and the chilling Snowtown murders, where a group of men committed horrific acts of violence under the guise of vigilantism. The conversation explores the complexities of mental illness, societal expectations, and the manipulation that can lead to devastating outcomes. Through these narratives, the hosts emphasize the importance of understanding mental health and the need for support systems to prevent such tragedies.Chapters00:00 Welcome to 2026: A New Year of True Crime02:49 The Andrea Yates Case: A Tragic Story of Mental Illness35:01 The Snowtown Murders: A Tale of Horror and ManipulationKeywordstrue crime, Andrea Yates, Snowtown murders, mental health, postpartum psychosis, serial killers, crime podcast, murder cases, psychological horror, criminal justice

In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss two tragic holiday murder cases: the Christmas Tree Farm Murders of Ed and Minnie Maurin and the Covina Christmas Massacre. They explore themes of family, community impact, and the long-lasting effects of violence during what should be a joyful season. 00:00 Introduction and Self-Confidence02:02 Severe Weather and Podcast Hiatus03:45 Holiday-Centric Cases04:55 The Christmas Tree Farm Murders19:49 The Covina Christmas Massacre47:25 Reflections on Family and TragedyKeywordsMurder, Christmas, True Crime, Podcast, Family, Tragedy, Ethel, Covina, Murders, Holiday, InvestigationChapters

In this episode, Erin and Autumn delve into two haunting cases: the mysterious disappearance of Asha Degree a young girl who mysteriously disappears in the night during a storm and the chilling story of Cari Farver, a woman whose life was stolen by obsession and stalking. KeywordsAsha Degree, Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, Dave Kroupa, true crime, missing persons, Washington crime news, murder, podcast, Erin, Autumn, crime storiesChapters00:00 Introduction and Snoring Surprise04:29 Washington Crime News: Deaths of Notorious Criminals09:42 The Disappearance of Asha Degree31:35 The Mysterious Case of Carrie Farver01:10:15 Conclusion and Reflections on the Cases

In this episode, Erin and Autumn explore two gripping true crime stories. The first is the murder of Jacques Mossler, involving his infamous wife Candy with her nephew and lover Mel Powers, leading to a sensational trial filled with intrigue and manipulation. The second story follows Tanya Nicole Kach, who endured a decade of captivity at the hands of a trusted security guard, highlighting themes of grooming and survival. Both narratives delve into the complexities of human relationships, the quest for love, and the dark side of manipulation.keywords: true crime, murder, podcast, Candy Mossler, Tanya Nicole Kach, survival, manipulation, grooming, trial, justiceChapters00:00 Introduction and Name Meanings03:38 Transition to Murders07:39 Candy's Land: The Glamorous Life of Candace Mossler27:36 The Murder of Jacques Mossler41:34 The Trial of Candy and Mel53:10 Candy's Life After the Trial01:21:49 Tanya Nicole Kach: A Survivor's Story

In this episode, Autumn and Erin delve into two intriguing cases. Autumn discusses the mysterious disappearance of Tammy Kingery, a nurse and mother who vanished from her home in South Carolina, leaving behind a puzzling note and no trace. The episode explores the theories surrounding her disappearance, including a possible mental health crisis, involvement of another person, and a mysterious motorcycle sighting. Erin then shifts to the historical case of Jim Fisk, a flamboyant financier of the Gilded Age, whose life was marked by scandal, betrayal, and ultimately murder. The episode unravels the dramatic love triangle involving Fisk, Josie Mansfield, and Edward Stokes, leading to Fisk's murder and the sensational trial that followed.Keywords:Tammy Kingery, disappearance, mystery, Jim Fisk, Gilded Age, murder, love triangle, Josie Mansfield, Edward Stokes, historical crimeChapters00:00:00 Introduction and Thanksgiving Chat00:00:00 Tammy Kingery's Disappearance00:00:01 Theories and Investigations00:00:02 Jim Fisk: A Gilded Age Scandal00:00:03 The Love Triangle and Murder00:00:04 Trial and Aftermath

In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss two gripping true crime cases: the kidnapping burying alive case of Barbara Jane Mackle and the murder of Tanya Marie Frazier. They explore the chilling details of Mackle's abduction, the subsequent investigation, and the eventual rescue that captivated the nation. The conversation shifts to the long-awaited justice for Tanya Frazier, whose case remained unsolved for over three decades until advancements in forensic science led to a breakthrough. Throughout the episode and the hosts reflect on the importance of keeping victims' stories alive.Keywordstrue crime, kidnapping, survival, FBI, investigation, justice, cold case, music, podcast, pacific northwest, seattleChapters00:00 Introduction and Music Preferences02:54 Listener Feedback and Episode Recap05:49 Erin's Health and Podcast Milestones08:48 The Kidnapping of Barbara Jane Mackle11:41 The Kidnapping Details and the Kidnapper's Plan14:37 The Ransom Note and FBI Involvement17:25 Barbara's Experience Underground20:31 The Search for Barbara and the Ransom Drop23:32 The Capture of Gary Christ26:08 Aftermath and Reflections on the Case27:40 The Vanishing and Return of Barbara Jane Mackle30:00 The Trial and Sentencing of Gary Christ31:55 Life After the Kidnapping33:40 Gary Christ's Downward Spiral36:19 The Impact of the Mackle Case on Law Enforcement38:43 Barbara's Resilience and the Aftermath40:37 The Legacy of Barbara Jane Mackle45:15 The Murder of Tanya Marie Frazier50:30 The Breakthrough in Tanya's Case54:41 Closure and Justice for Tanya Marie Frazier

In this episode, Autumn and Erin delve into two chilling true crime stories. Autumn recounts the tragic tale of Laurie Dann, a woman whose mental health struggles led to a devastating school shooting in 1988. Erin explores the mysterious case of the Lady of the Dunes, a woman found murdered in 1974, whose identity was only recently uncovered. These stories highlight the complexities of mental illness, the failures of societal systems, and the enduring quest for justice.Keywords: Laurie Dann, school shooting, mental health, Lady of the Dunes, Ruth Marie Terry, true crime, justice, murder mystery, societal failures, mental illness

In this episode, Erin narrates a gripping tale involving a mysterious figure dressed in white, initially perceived as a ghost, but later revealed to be Thomas Millwood. The discussion delves into themes of mystery, storytelling, and the unexpected twists in narratives with the Hammersmith Ghost case. This is the story of fear turned fatal — the case thatforced England to ask a haunting question: Can you commit murder... if you truly believe your victim was already dead?Chapters00:00 Introduction to Halloween Cases00:14 The Aftermath and Legal ImplicationsKeywordsghost, mystery, Thomas Millwood, storytelling, true crime

In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss their recent outing to a live podcast event, share personal stories about their pets, and delve into two captivating true crime tales: the Greenbrier Ghost, a case where a ghost's testimony helped convict a murderer, and the haunting legend of Resurrection Mary, a ghostly figure seen on Archer Avenue in Chicago. The conversation blends humor, personal anecdotes, and chilling stories, creating an engaging experience for true crime enthusiasts.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Public Outing02:16 Inspiration from My Favorite Murder03:46 Rocky Horror Picture Show Excitement05:57 Pet Sharing and Animal Stories11:49 The Greenbrier Ghost Case28:39 Resurrection Mary: A Haunting TaleKeywordstrue crime, ghost stories, Greenbrier Ghost, Resurrection Mary, podcast, Halloween, murder, folklore, paranormal, storytelling

This episode explores two tragic stories: Autumn tells of the murder of Rachel Burkheimer, a young woman whose life was cut short by betrayal and violence, and then Erin explains the historical investigation of Duffy's Cut, where the remains of Irish immigrant workers were uncovered, revealing a dark history of violence and discrimination. The hosts discuss the importance of remembrance, the impact of violence on communities, and the ongoing discoveries that continue to shed light on these haunting narratives.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Fall Adventures03:30 The Tragic Story of Rachel Burkheimer20:49 Legacy and Remembrance of Rachel Burkheimer22:34 Tragic Loss and Unnecessary Violence24:42 Ghosts in the Cut: The Beginning of a Mystery32:48 Uncovering the Truth: The Investigation Begins40:33 Forensic Revelations: The Dark History of Duffy's Cut47:20 Identifying the Victims: A Journey of Closure50:57 New Discoveries: Expanding the Tragedy of Duffy's Cut58:53 outro.wavKeywordsMurder, Rachel Burkheimer, Duffy's Cut, Ghost Stories, True Crime, Domestic Violence, Immigrant History, Forensic Investigation, Seattle, Paranormal

In this episode, Erin and Autumn explore the chilling story of the Ouija board murder that took place in Buffalo, New York, in 1930. The narrative unfolds around Nancy Bowen, a grieving widow who, after a seance, believes her husband was murdered by a witch named Clothilde Marchand. The episode delves into the murder, the subsequent trial, and the sensational media coverage that followed. The conversation then transitions to the haunting history of Northern State Hospital in Sedro Woolley, Washington, where the hosts discuss ghost stories and the lingering memories of those who suffered within its walls. The episode reflects on themes of grief, memory, and the impact of societal perceptions on marginalized communities.Chapters00:00 Introduction to the Spooky Season03:18 The Ouija Board Murder: A Grieving Widow's Descent06:08 The Murder of Clotilde Merchand11:09 The Trial and Media Sensationalism17:00 The Aftermath and Societal Implications25:42 The Haunting of Northern State Hospital38:36 The Woman in White: A Tale of Loss40:40 Remembering the Forgotten: Echoes of the PastKeywordsOuija board murder, Nancy Bowen, Clothilde Marchand, Buffalo history, Northern State Hospital, ghost stories, spooky season, true crime, indigenous history, mental healthTakeawaysThe Ouija board murder highlights the intersection of grief and superstition.Nancy Bowen's actions were driven by manipulation and emotional turmoil.Media sensationalism played a significant role in shaping public perception of the trial.The case reflects deep-seated prejudices against indigenous people.Northern State Hospital's history reveals the dark side of mental health treatment.Ghost stories often serve as a way to remember and honor the past.The haunting of Northern State is tied to the memories of those who suffered there.Community efforts have been made to restore the names of forgotten patients.The episode emphasizes the importance of listening to marginalized voices.Both stories illustrate how history can haunt the present.

In this episode of 'Murder Not Murdering,' hosts Autumn and Erin delve into the tragic Yogurt Shop Murders case, where four girls were killed in 1991, and the subsequent investigation that led to wrongful convictions. The hosts highlight the recent identification of a new suspect through advanced DNA testing. They also explore the historical Madeline Smith case, discussing its implications on forensic science and societal views on women. The episode reflects on the complexities of justice and the evolving nature of crime investigation.Chapters00:00 Welcome Back and Podcast Updates02:53 Excitement for October and Creepy Episodes05:49 The Yogurt Shop Murders: A Case Overview11:30 Investigation and Arrests: A Twisted Journey17:30 DNA Breakthrough: New Suspect Emerges23:34 Reflections on Justice and Forensic Science29:14 The Madeline Smith Case: A Historical Perspective43:55 Conclusions and Final ThoughtsKeywordsMurder Not Murdering, true crime, podcast, yogurt shop murders, Madeline Smith, forensic science, DNA evidence, October episodes, creepy stories, justice

This episode delves into the infamous Career Girl's Murder case of 1963, where two young women, Janice Wiley and Emily Hoffert, were brutally murdered in New York City. The investigation led to the wrongful conviction of George Whitmore Jr., who was coerced into confessing to the crime he did not commit. The real killer, Richard Robles, was eventually apprehended, but the case highlighted significant issues within the justice system, particularly regarding police interrogation practices and the treatment of women. The episode reflects on the broader implications of the case, including societal attitudes towards women's independence and safety.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Anticipation for Halloween03:33 The Career Girl's Murder: Setting the Scene09:50 The Investigation Begins: A Shocking Discovery16:22 The Wrongful Accusation of George Whitmore Jr.21:59 The Real Killer: Richard Robles Unveiled27:16 The Aftermath: Justice and Injustice31:39 Reflections on Ambition and Consequences34:45 outro.wavKeywordsCareer Girl's Murder, George Whitmore Jr., Richard Robles, true crime, justice system, wrongful conviction, women's rights, police interrogation, 1960s New York, murder case

In this episode, Erin delves into the chilling case of Angela and James Craig, exploring the betrayal and deception that led to Angela's tragic death by poisoning. The narrative unfolds from the initial symptoms Angela experienced to the shocking discovery of James's calculated actions and the subsequent investigation that revealed his guilt. The episode culminates in the trial, where the evidence against James Craig was laid bare, leading to his conviction for first-degree murder. Erin reflects on the impact of this case on the family and the broader implications of trust and betrayal in relationships.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Context02:06 The Case of Angela and James Craig11:13 The Investigation Unfolds18:05 The Trial of James Craig24:15 Conclusion and ReflectionsKeywordsmurder, true crime, poisoning, trial, betrayal, justice, family, forensic evidence, cyanide, podcast

In this episode, Erin and Autumn welcome Tim, a registered nurse, to discuss the dark side of nursing through the cases of Niels Högel and Charles Cullen, both male nurses who committed heinous crimes. The conversation explores the motivations behind their actions, the failures of hospital systems to protect patients, and the emotional toll on healthcare professionals. The hosts emphasize the importance of trust in healthcare and reflect on the need to appreciate the good nurses who work tirelessly to care for patients.Chapters00:00 Introduction and Guest Introduction02:36 Tim's Nursing Background and Role03:21 Exploring Cases of Male Nurses07:12 The Case of Niels Högel07:34 Understanding the Role of Nurses in Patient Care12:16 The Mechanisms of Medical Murder17:09 The Investigation and Arrest of Högel20:07 The Trial and Conviction of Niels Högel21:32 The Aftermath and Implications for Healthcare27:39 The Role of Nurses in Healthcare28:10 Introduction to Charles Cullen29:11 The Early Life of Charles Cullen31:09 The Start of a Nightmare32:58 The Pattern of Death35:29 The Arrest of Charles Cullen37:27 The Aftermath of Cullen's Crimes39:28 The Impact on Healthcare Practices42:11 The Importance of Trust in Nursing45:32 Conclusion and Reflection48:18 outro.wavKeywordsnursing, true crime, male nurses, medical murder, Niels Högel, Charles Cullen, healthcare, hospital safety, criminal cases, podcast

In this episode, Erin and Autumn discuss various topics, including their recent viral event announcement, the upcoming guest Nurse Tim, and the chilling case of the Doodler, a serial killer from the 1970s. Then they delve into the tragic story of Grace Brown and Chester Gillette, exploring themes of love, betrayal, and societal pressures that led to a murder that shocked the community. The episode highlights the importance of speaking out against injustice and the impact of silence in the face of fear.Chapters00:00 Welcome Back and Updates02:47 Viral Event Announcement05:39 Social Media and Content Creation08:22 Upcoming Guest: Nurse Tim14:21 The Doodler Case Introduction28:09 The Doodler's Victims and Community Impact40:06 Chester Gillette and Grace Brown's Tragic Story53:57 Trial and Aftermath of Grace Brown's MurderKeywordsMurder, True Crime, Podcast, Doodler, Grace Brown, Chester Gillette, Community

Erin dives into the chilling story of Louise Peete, a woman whose charm masked a sinister motive. This episode unravels the shocking crimes and multiple murders she committed and the gripping trial that captivated the nation. Discover how Peete's manipulative nature led to a series of tragic events, and explore the courtroom drama that ultimately sealed her fate. Join us as we delve into one of the most notorious criminal cases of the early 20th century.