Discover
Collector Investor Podcast
Collector Investor Podcast
Author: Chris Sewall and Jeremy Donson
Subscribed: 7Played: 168Subscribe
Share
© Copyright 2026 All rights reserved.
Description
Welcome to Collector Investor Podcast, a show hosted by Chris Sewall and the Texas Snowman!
This is a weekly show of 2 friends that discuss their love for sports cards!
44 Episodes
Reverse
If you're interested in reaching out to Chris and Jeremy to sell your collection, you can email them directly at [email protected]
If you would like to consign your collection or bid in the next CIA auction, you can visit- https://collectorinvestorauctions.com
CIA YouTube Channel- @CollectorInvestorAuctions
Check out Chris YouTube Channel- @collectorinvestordealer
VCP for 2 Weeks FREE- http://thevcp.com/?promo=CIACARDS
Disclaimer: This channel is for entertainment and hobby discussion purposes only. Nothing discussed should be considered financial or investment advice.
A potentially $500,000+ 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle turns out to be FAKE! 😱 Plus, the sports card market hits a historic $1 BILLION in monthly sales! Is the hobby booming, or are warning signs starting to appear?
On this episode of the Collector Investor Podcast, we dive into one of the craziest stories from the Dallas Card Show. A collector brings in a beautiful raw 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle that has been passed down through his family, only to discover that the card isn't authentic. We break down the warning signs and how to spot counterfeit vintage baseball cards.
But that's just the beginning!
🔥 IN THIS EPISODE:
⚾ FAKE MICKEY MANTLE! A heartbreaking discovery involving a potentially half-million-dollar 1952 Topps Mantle, plus a counterfeit Shohei Ohtani Kaboom.
💰 $1 BILLION SPORTS CARD MARKET! Card Ladder reports a record-breaking month in card and wax sales. Is the hobby still growing, or is a market correction coming?
📉 IS VINTAGE CARD COLLECTING DYING? We discuss whether younger collectors will embrace vintage baseball cards and what the future holds for pre-war cards, set collecting, and legendary players.
🏪 LOCAL CARD SHOPS VS. CORPORATE STORES! Are businesses like Tom Brady's CardVault good for the hobby, or could they hurt independent card shops?
🏀 $600,000 MICHAEL JORDAN CARD DRAFT! Chris and Jeremy battle to build the ultimate five-card Michael Jordan investment portfolio, featuring rare autographs, iconic rookie cards, and legendary 1990s inserts.
🏆 COLLECTOR INVESTOR AUCTIONS! We preview incredible cards from our November auction, including Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, Mickey Mantle, and more!
🎙️ LOVE THE HOBBY?
Follow the Collector Investor Podcast on Spotify and Apple Podcasts for more sports card market discussions, vintage baseball cards, hobby news, collecting stories, and investment debates!
Leave us a rating and review, and share the podcast with fellow collectors!
⏱️ EPISODE CHAPTERS:
00:00 – Introduction & Collector Investor Podcast
01:53 – Dallas Card Show: The Fake 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle
04:21 – How to Spot a Fake Vintage Baseball Card
06:27 – Fake Shohei Ohtani Kaboom Card
09:10 – The Heartbreaking Story Behind the Mantle
10:36 – Sports Card Market Hits $1 BILLION
13:08 – Is the Sports Card Market Cooling Off?
15:38 – PSA vs. CGC: Card Grading Numbers
18:23 – Are Card Shows Slowing Down?
20:04 – Sports Card Market Predictions
22:25 – Is Vintage Card Collecting Dying?
27:54 – The Future of Vintage Set Collecting
34:18 – Local Card Shops vs. Corporate Card Stores
38:17 – Tom Brady's CardVault & Fanatics Allocation
41:39 – $600,000 Michael Jordan Card Draft
46:22 – The Jordan Investment Picks Begin
54:55 – The Cards Nobody Picked
56:04 – Michael Jordan Draft Winner Revealed
58:48 – Collector Investor Auctions November Preview
59:44 – Final Thoughts & Consignment Information
📩 CONTACT CHRIS & JEREMY
Interested in selling your sports card collection? Reach out to Chris and Jeremy directly!
Email: [email protected]
🏆 COLLECTOR INVESTOR AUCTIONS
Looking to consign your collection or bid in the next CIA auction?
Visit: https://collectorinvestorauctions.com
📺 CHECK OUT OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS
Collector Investor Auctions:
https://www.youtube.com/@CollectorInvestorAuctions
Chris – Collector Investor Dealer:
https://www.youtube.com/@collectorinvestordealer
🔥 SPECIAL OFFER – VINTAGE CARD PRICES (VCP)
Try VCP FREE for 2 weeks!
https://thevcp.com/?promo=CIACARDS
🎥 CLIP CREDITS
Topic from- Midlifesportscards on Youtube
⚠️ DISCLAIMER
This podcast is for entertainment and hobby discussion purposes only. Nothing discussed should be considered financial or investment advice.
#SportsCards #MickeyMantle #MichaelJordan #VintageBaseballCards #SportsCardInvesting
🚨 FAKE PSA SLABS, a $288,000 Fanatics sale, and potential SHILL BIDDING concerns! Is the sports card hobby facing a major trust problem?
In this episode of the Collector Investor Podcast, Chris, Jeremy, and Thor dive into the growing controversy surrounding counterfeit PSA graded card holders, including a Pokémon Dragonite reportedly sold for $288,000 through Fanatics Collect.
Could the same thing happen with vintage baseball cards, Ken Griffey Jr. rookies, Michael Jordan cards, or even a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle?
We discuss how convincing fake PSA slabs can be, why certification numbers alone may not be enough, and what collectors should look for before buying expensive graded cards.
🔥 ALSO IN THIS EPISODE:
🔴 Fanatics FanCash & Shill Bidding Concerns – Could Fanatics' 0% selling commission option create opportunities for auction manipulation? We discuss the potential loophole and its impact on collector confidence.
⚾ 16 MILLION Sports Cards! – Jeremy shares details of a massive collection containing approximately 25,000 graded cards and thousands of vintage cards. Is it even worth buying?
💰 The Sports Card Market Is Softening – Are dealers offering just 75% of comps while sellers expect 125%? We break down changing buying strategies, market trends, and the widening gap between buyers and sellers.
🏆 How to Value Vintage Baseball Card Sets – Learn how experienced dealers evaluate complete Topps sets from the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s.
🏝️ Desert Island Card Challenge – If you could only have one case of trading cards for the rest of your life, what would you choose?
💬 JOIN THE CONVERSATION! Do you trust PSA graded cards as much as you used to? Should Fanatics reconsider its FanCash promotion? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!
🔗 Collector Investor Auctions: https://collectorinvestorauctions.com Check out our upcoming auctions, consign your collection, and discover vintage and modern sports cards.
👍 LIKE this video if you enjoy honest discussions about the sports card hobby.
🔔 SUBSCRIBE to the Collector Investor Podcast for sports card market news, collecting insights, auction analysis, and hobby conversations.
Featured discussions and commentary reference reporting from Rattle Pokémon and Spitballin' Cards.
Allegations and suspected fraud discussed in this episode may remain under investigation and are not presented as independently verified findings.
#SportsCards #PSA #FanaticsCollect #SportsCardInvesting #CollectorInvestorPodcast
If you're interested in reaching out to Chris and Jeremy to sell your collection, you can email them directly at [email protected]
If you would like to consign your collection or bid in the next CIA auction, you can visit- https://collectorinvestorauctions.com
CIA YouTube Channel- @CollectorInvestorAuctions
Check out Chris YouTube Channel- @collectorinvestordealer
VCP for 2 Weeks FREE- http://thevcp.com/?promo=CIACARDS
We used a clip from @RattlePokemon @SpitballinCards
Disclaimer: This channel is for entertainment and hobby discussion purposes only. Nothing discussed should be considered financial or investment advice.
Chapters
00:00 Intro & Collector Investor Podcast
02:07 Massive Vintage Collection & $50M Mantle Rumor
03:26 The 16 Million Sports Card Collection
08:01 Fake PSA Slabs Rock the Hobby
09:47 How to Spot Counterfeit PSA Holders
11:56 The $288K Fanatics Dragonite Controversy
14:38 How the Fake PSA Slab Was Discovered
15:20 Can Auction Houses Prevent Fake Slabs?
19:44 Could Sports Cards Be Next?
23:50 Fanatics FanCash & Shill Bidding Concerns
28:08 Should Fanatics Eliminate the Promotion?
33:43 Sports Card Market: 75% vs. 125% of Comps
37:24 Jordan Rookies & Manipulated Comps
39:26 How to Value Complete Vintage Topps Sets 45:44 Desert Island Sports Card Challenge
50:08 Final Thoughts & November Auction Preview
Is the sports card hobby becoming a CASINO? With approximately $15 MILLION spent on three massive NBA debut patch cards connected to the repack market, collectors are asking serious questions about the future of sports card collecting!
On this episode of the Collector Investor Podcast, Chris, Texas Snowman, and the crew dive into the explosion of digital mystery packs, the impact of repackers on sports card prices, and whether the hobby is heading toward another major market correction.
🏀 THE $15 MILLION REPACK CONTROVERSY The Cooper Flagg, Dylan Harper, and Kon Knueppel NBA debut patch cards have sparked a massive debate. What happens when multimillion-dollar sports cards become prizes in digital mystery packs? Are these legitimate market values, or are repack companies driving prices higher?
📉 IS ANOTHER SPORTS CARD MARKET CRASH COMING?
We look back at the 2022 sports card market downturn and discuss whether Michael Jordan, Tom Brady, Shohei Ohtani, and modern sports cards could experience another major correction. Is vintage safer than modern?
📦 SHIPPING & INSURING EXPENSIVE SPORTS CARDS What's the safest way to ship valuable cards? We compare USPS Registered Mail, UPS, FedEx, private shipping insurance, and high-value courier services. We also discuss PSA declared values and what collectors should consider when submitting expensive cards for grading.
🏆 PSA vs. SGC vs. BGS vs. CGC Why do so many dealers prefer PSA slabs? We break down resale value, liquidity, grading market dominance, and what could happen if PSA suddenly disappeared.
⚾ VINTAGE CARD INVESTING & MICHAEL JORDAN Are rare O-Pee-Chee, Venezuelan, and Milton Bradley vintage cards undervalued? Plus, which Michael Jordan card would we rather hold for 25 years: the 1986 Fleer Rookie PSA 5 or the 1988 Fleer PSA 10?
🔥 IN THIS EPISODE:
00:43 Welcome to the Collector Investor Podcast
03:14 $15 MILLION NBA Debut Patch Repack Controversy
08:57 Should Digital Mystery Packs Be Regulated?
11:09 Are Repacks Inflating Sports Card Prices?
14:44 The Snowman Gets Compared to a Simpsons Character!
17:16 Is Another Sports Card Market Crash Coming?
19:33 Vintage vs. Modern Card Investing
22:46 Are 90s Inserts Getting Overvalued?
24:46 Safest Ways to Ship Expensive Sports Cards
29:24 Private Couriers and High-Value Card Shipping
31:12 PSA Declared Values and Shipping Insurance
36:38 PSA vs. BGS vs. SGC vs. CGC
41:46 Why Other Grading Companies Can't Compete with PSA
45:22 What Happens if PSA Shuts Down?
48:33 Are Vintage O-Pee-Chee Cards Undervalued?
52:59 Michael Jordan Rookie PSA 5 vs. 1988 Fleer PSA 10
💬 JOIN THE CONVERSATION! Are repacks GOOD or BAD for the sports card hobby? Are we watching the future of collecting, or is the hobby becoming too much like a casino? Drop your thoughts in the comments!
👍 LIKE this video if you enjoy honest sports card discussions.
🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more sports card market analysis, vintage collecting, grading discussions, and hobby news!
#SportsCards #SportsCardHobby #SportsCardInvesting #SportsCardMarket #PSAGrading #CooperFlagg #SportsCardRepacks #VintageBaseballCards #CollectorInvestorPodcast #MichaelJordanCards
🚨 $1,000,000+ in PSA graded cards STOLEN, Shohei Ohtani rookie cards dropping in value, and counterfeit PSA slabs showing up at card shows! The sports card hobby has some major stories to discuss this week!
Welcome back to the Collector Investor Podcast! Jeremy (The Texas Snowman), Chris, and Thor break down some of the biggest controversies and questions facing sports card collectors, dealers, and investors.
🔥 IN THIS EPISODE:
🚨 PSA / FedEx Card Theft – A FedEx vehicle transporting PSA submissions was reportedly burglarized, with one collector reporting more than $1,000,000 in stolen cards. Who is responsible, how will collectors be compensated, and should high-value graded cards receive better shipping security?
📉 Shohei Ohtani Card Market CRASH? – Some popular Ohtani rookie cards have dropped roughly 25–33% in the charts discussed. Is this the time to buy the dip, sell before prices fall further, or hold until baseball season returns? We discuss PSA populations, supply, demand, and long-term investment strategies.
⚠️ FAKE PSA SLABS at Card Shows! – Counterfeit-style PSA holders and proxy cards are appearing at dealer tables. Even when disclosed, should these products be allowed at shows? We discuss the risks to collectors and the importance of protecting the hobby.
⚾ $100,000 MICKEY MANTLE DRAFT! – Jeremy and Chris go head-to-head building their ultimate $100K Mickey Mantle collections! With vintage rookies, rare food issues, high-grade cards, and autographs available, who makes the smarter investment picks?
💰 COLLECTOR INVESTOR AUCTIONS UPDATE: We also discuss major upcoming consignments, including an impressive 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan sticker PSA 10, a potential 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle consignment, and our expanded auction facility.
👇 JOIN THE CONVERSATION!
• Would you BUY, SELL, or HOLD Shohei Ohtani rookie cards right now?
• Should card shows ban fake PSA slabs, even when they're labeled as replicas?
• Who won the $100,000 Mickey Mantle draft — Jeremy or Chris?
👍 LIKE this video if you enjoy sports card market discussions!
🔔 SUBSCRIBE for vintage sports cards, hobby news, auctions, market analysis, and collector debates.
Chapters
00:00 Intro & Collector Investor Podcast Banter
04:09 Major Consignments & Upcoming Auctions
06:18 Inside the New Collector Investor Auctions Facility
11:34 PSA FedEx Heist: 1M+ in Cards Stolen
19:20 Should Card Shows Provide Better Security?
21:56 Shohei Ohtani Card Market Decline: Buy or Sell?
33:18 Fake PSA Slabs at Card Shows
38:36 $100K Mickey Mantle Investment Draft
49:09 Mickey Mantle Draft Results & Winner
If you're interested in reaching out to Chris and Jeremy to sell your collection, you can email them directly at [email protected]
If you would like to consign your collection or bid in the next CIA auction, you can visit- https://collectorinvestorauctions.com
CIA YouTube Channel- @CollectorInvestorAuctions
Check out Chris YouTube Channel- @collectorinvestordealer
VCP for 2 Weeks FREE- http://thevcp.com/?promo=CIACARDS
Disclaimer: This channel is for entertainment and hobby discussion purposes only. Nothing discussed should be considered financial or investment advice.
#SportsCards #PSA #PSAGrading #ShoheiOhtani #MickeyMantle #BaseballCards #SportsCardInvesting #VintageBaseballCards #CardCollecting #CollectorInvestor



