Discover
Broken Healthcare
Broken Healthcare
Author: Ray Kober
Subscribed: 4Played: 30Subscribe
Share
© 2025 Broken Healthcare
Description
“Broken Healthcare” isn’t just another podcast exposing flaws in the healthcare system—it’s a movement. Hosted by the entertaining and knowledgeable Ray Kober, we pull back the curtain on the hidden forces driving up costs and making care confusing. Whether you’re an employer, an industry insider, or just someone tired of overpriced, low-quality care, we arm you with the insights to fight back. Get real stories, expert insights, and actionable solutions to take control of healthcare decisions—because better choices start with better information.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
106 Episodes
Reverse
Healthcare insiders told him they'd "drain you of your funds, and you will cease to exist." His answer: "I'll be on podcasts. I'll go everywhere." For the 100th episode of Broken Healthcare, Ray sits down with Craig Rosenthal, Founder and CEO of HealthPlanIQ. Craig spent 18 years bringing fiduciary benchmarking to retirement plans, and now he's doing the same for the self-funded employer health plan. 👉 See whether your health plan's vendors are paid fairly: https://www.healthplaniq.ai Craig co-founded Fiduciary Decisions, which has benchmarked 60% of the 401(k) plans in the country. With HealthPlanIQ, he gives employers an independent fee reasonableness assessment of their network, TPA, PBM, stop loss carrier and broker. It shows what each vendor is paid and what you're actually getting for it. Craig tells Ray how he built a $100 million product line, was handed a $10,000 bonus, and quit on the spot with one child at home and twins on the way. He explains why moving into healthcare felt like stepping into "an episode of The Sopranos". He also tells the story of the bundled health plan contract he ran through AI, which came back asking whether it was even a contract, because "there are no commitments in it." Craig also gets personal. His insurer demanded 30 physical therapy appointments before it would approve his back surgery, then wanted more after the therapist said they weren't helping. His first wife's chemotherapy was turned down on the first pass. "Cancer is not optional treatment." Then comes the warning every large employer needs to hear. Some contracts stop you using your own data to check what you're paying. A lawsuit that asks to see your health plan's fiduciary process could be "game over" for almost every large plan in the country. And Craig shares a simple move the biggest employers already use on the retirement side: have your attorney request the benchmarking report, so it stays attorney-client privileged. Ray also has a message about the courtside tickets, Masters passes and private jets some brokers and carriers lavish on their clients. ABOUT HEALTHPLANIQ HealthPlanIQ delivers an annual, independent fee reasonableness report for self-funded health plans, for $2 PEPM. Plans with 200 to 7,500 employees can be benchmarked today. 🔗 Website: https://www.healthplaniq.ai 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/healthplaniq/ ✉️ Email Craig: [email protected] MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE 🎧 Al Lewis on Broken Healthcare: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSzYDe8X-jk 📄 Prevent Consent (Quizzify): https://quizzify.com0:00:00 Welcome Craig Rosenthal 0:07:13 $100M Product, $10K Bonus 0:09:53 "The Hammer" Quits 0:16:14 ERISA & the Fiduciary Turning Point 0:20:47 Retirement Advisors Move Into Health 0:24:24 $100K Advisor vs. $2M Broker 0:36:58 "You Will Cease to Exist" 0:39:51 A Hospital Built for Today 0:45:24 Surgery & Chemo Denied 0:49:08 AI: "Is This a Contract?" 0:55:02 Banned From Your Own Data 0:58:42 Rigged RFPs 1:04:21 Three Lawyers in Two Years 1:11:15 Inside HealthPlanIQ 1:22:04 The 10% Goal 1:30:03 Broker Perks 1:32:03 Mark Cuban & 5500 Tools 1:38:37 Executives Personally Liable 1:39:59 Attorney-Client Privilege 1:42:20 Pay Attention Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
A hospital sued her for over $200,000. A Colorado jury said she owed $766 - and the case went all the way to the Colorado Supreme Court. Atlanta attorney Ted Lavender of Lavender Hoffman LLC joins Ray in the studio to tell the story of Lisa French, a patient with a GED whose self-funded employer health plan (administered by ELAP, now Imagine 360) paid around $70,000 for her spine surgery. The hospital had quoted her $1,336. She emptied her $1,000 rainy day fund. Then came a bill of roughly $300,000, and a lawsuit for the rest. Ted breaks down the six-day trial, the $90,000 expert the hospital flew in from Florida, the lawn-mowing contract that explains why "reasonable price" is the law in all 50 states, and the juror question that exposed what the hospital missed on her insurance card three times.He also walks through hospital financials he pulled from American Hospital Directory, shows why full billed charges are a fantasy, and tells the story of throwing 30 diapers across a Las Vegas stage to prove a $35-per-diaper hospital charge was fiction. Then Ray and Ted get into what it means for employers: why healthcare is often a company's second-largest expense, how reference-based pricing grew from one client file into federal guidance, and why fiduciary-duty lawsuits may be next. 📌 Subscribe for more conversations on fixing the broken healthcare system. Guest: Ted Lavender, Lavender Hoffman LLC (Atlanta) #BrokenHealthcare #SelfFundedHealthcare #EmployerHealthcare #CFO #HRLeaders #HealthcareCosts #HealthcareTransparency #Podcast #HospitalBilling #ReferenceBasedPricing #MedicalBilling 0:00:00 Intro 0:00:44 How Ray Met Ted at RosettaFest 0:02:01 29 Years Practicing Law in Atlanta 0:05:03 Why Ted Became a Lawyer 0:09:20 From Suing Doctors to Defending Them 0:11:56 Why Plaintiff Lawyers Turn Down 90% of Cases 0:12:35 Georgia's "Apology Statute" 0:17:04 How Malpractice Fees and Costs Really Work 0:22:05 How Imagine 360 Disputes Work 0:27:38 Why Hospital Sticker Prices Mean Nothing 0:29:38 The Lisa French Case Begins 0:31:23 The $1,336 Estimate and the Rainy Day Fund 0:33:40 A $300,000 Bill and a Lawsuit 0:35:37 The Six-Day Trial and the $766 Verdict 0:36:43 The Hospital's $90,000 Expert 0:37:54 The Ford F-150 Argument 0:41:07 The Lawn-Mowing Contract 0:44:14 Hospital Billing vs. Collections: The Actual Numbers 0:50:28 The Hospital's "Social Cost" Argument 0:52:08 Court of Appeals vs. the Colorado Supreme Court 0:56:52 Why the Jury Said $766 0:57:42 Jurors Who Ask Questions 0:59:25 The Juror Question That Exposed the Hospital 1:04:21 Sharon Stone, Casino and the $35 Diaper 1:07:03 The Big Short and Healthcare Billing 1:09:14 Will Healthcare Ever Change? 1:24:42 Who Ted Helps 1:25:32 From One Client File to Federal Guidance 1:28:35 Why Employers Don't Know Their Biggest Hidden Expense 1:30:32 Employer Fiduciary Duty and Healthcare Lawsuits 1:33:42 Ray's Advice: Ask for the Cash Price 1:36:44 Why Patients Have Zero Bargaining Power 1:39:01 The Texas Trial Where the Hospital Quit Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
200 Navy SEALs started Hell Week. 28 finished. Aaron Tucker was one of them. Now he's COO of Parity Plus, and he's applying that same mindset to the most brutal number in your health plan: autism spectrum disorder claims. 1 in 31 American children is now diagnosed with ASD. In North Carolina alone, ABA therapy costs exploded from $270M in 2022 to $1.1B in 2025. A single child in inpatient care can run $200,000 to $240,000 per month and for a small employer, that one claim can drive 35% of their entire renewal. Aaron breaks down exactly how this happened (private equity bought 2,000+ ABA centers worth $870M and is billing accordingly), what self-funded employers can legally do about it, and why mental health parity law is both the problem and the solution. Plus: Aaron briefed Condoleezza Rice during active operations. He ran a 60-mile ultra. And he explains why "embrace the suck" is the best framework for fixing American healthcare. This one goes deep. Clear your schedule. 🔗 Learn more about Parity Plus: https://parityplus.com 00:00 — Intro: Who is Aaron Tucker? 02:15 — From Navy SEAL to healthcare: the unlikely pivot 06:40 — BUD/S Hell Week: 200 started, 28 finished 11:20 — "Embrace the suck" and what it means for healthcare 16:05 — What is Parity Plus? The 12-week-old company solving a billion-dollar problem 22:30 — ASD and autism: why 1 in 31 kids changes everything for employers 28:15 — The $240K/month child: a real case study 33:50 — North Carolina ABA costs: $270M to $1.1B in three years 39:20 — Private equity's role: 2,000 ABA centers, $870M valuation 44:10 — Single case agreements (SCAs) explained 49:35 — Mental health parity law: how it protects (and fails) employers 55:00 — TPAs, BUCAs, and stop-loss: the full cast of villains1:01:20 — The 1-3% driving 15%+ of your health plan costs 1:07:45 — "Don't pay us if we don't save you money" 1:13:10 — Medicaid waivers and why they matter 1:18:30 — AI claims analysis: how Parity Plus actually works 1:24:15 — Parity Plus in talks with the US government and Canadian provinces 1:29:40 — Aaron briefed Condoleezza Rice (yes, really) 1:35:20 — The Kandahar Giant: best moment of the episode 1:41:05 — 60-mile ultra, psilocybin, and Ray's 6-month sobriety reveal 1:47:30 — Advice for employers drowning in healthcare costs right now 1:53:50 — Where to find Aaron and Parity Plus 1:57:50 — Parityplus.com - final call to action 🎧 BROKEN HEALTHCARE PODCAST Ray Kober exposes the systems, incentives, and bad actors driving American healthcare costs, and finds the people actually fixing it. New episodes every week. Subscribe so you don't miss one. #BrokenHealthcare #HealthcarePodcast #SelfFundedEmployers #ASDClaims #AutismAwareness #NavySEAL #ParityPlus #MentalHealthParity #HealthPlan #EmployerHealthcare #ABATherapy #StopLoss #HealthcareCosts #PodcastClips #RayKober Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
He told a $30 billion hospital system's CFO "sue me" - and won. David Silverstein, founder of Amaze Health and former U.S. Navy submarine officer, joins Ray in-studio to break down what's really broken in self-funded employer health plans and how one standoff over a $20,000 ER bill turned into a career fixing them.David's daughter racked up three ER visits and $20,000 in bills her freshman year of college. He escalated the fight all the way to the C-suite, and when the hospital's CFO asked what he actually wanted, David told him to sue him. The CFO refused, not realizing his own hospital system was already a client of David's consulting firm. That standoff became "the denial of payment system," and it eventually pulled David into Washington, where he helped shape federal price transparency rules and the "right to self-pay" buried in the No Surprises Act - a right most patients don't even know they have.David also breaks down the "grand bargain": pay a hospital in 3 days instead of 90, and they'll knock 25-30% off the bill, no negotiation required.. even on a $2 million NICU stay. He explains why employers have had the legal power to fix their health plans since ERISA passed in 1974, and why big broker and consultant firms have misaligned incentives with the clients they're supposed to serve.If you're an employer, CFO, HR Director or benefits consultant - this one's for you.📌 Subscribe for more conversations on fixing the broken healthcare system.🔗 Amaze Health: amazehealth.com📖 David's book: "The Lean Health Plan" — search his name on Amazon🔗 David Silverstein on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dsilverstein/#BrokenHealthcare #SelfFundedHealthcare #EmployerHealthcare #CFO #HRLeaders #ReferenceBasedPricing #HealthcareCosts #HealthcareTransparency #AmazeHealth #ERISA #Podcast0:00 Introduction & Welcome0:45 Growing Up in Brooklyn2:00 Life as a Navy Submarine Officer6:30 Founding a Six Sigma Consulting Firm9:00 The $12,000 ER Bill and the "Revenue Enhancement Specialist" Letter14:00 "I Want You to Sue Me" — The $30 Billion Hospital Standoff16:00 Building Amaze Health (2018–2020)20:00 Writing Input for the State of the Union24:40 The Call From the White House27:00 The Gas Station Story That Convinced the Economists30:00 Why Only the Free Market Can Fix Healthcare36:00 The Transparency Rules Already on the Books38:11 Sponsor Break43:45 The Right to Self-Pay Nobody Uses46:00 The "Grand Bargain" — Pay in 3 Days, Save 30%48:00 Why Reference-Based Pricing Alone Isn't the Answer51:00 The Lean Health Plan & How Employers Lost Control of Risk53:00 The McKinsey Report: 30% of Employers Reconsidering54:00 The $2,000,000 NICU Baby Story56:32 How Amaze Predicts a Hospital Visit Before It Happens1:00:53 PBMs, Rebates, and Formulary Control1:01:09 Employers Have Had This Power Since 1974 (ERISA)1:02:00 Why CEOs Tolerate It: Taxes, Complexity, Groupthink1:06:00 AI, Up-Coding, and the Next Wave of Cost Inflation1:08:24 The Employer Health Plan Maturity Curve1:12:28 Direct Contracts and How Amaze Actually Works1:13:59 The $4M Spend Example — Where's the Opportunity?1:15:24 Hitting the Reset Button — A 30-40% Correction1:16:12 Brokers' Private Jets and Masters Tickets — Who's Paying?1:18:49 The Coming Litigation Bubble Over the $6 Trillion Question1:20:26 Final Thoughts Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Todd Martin, Chief Sales Officer at NOVA Healthcare Administrators, joins Ray in-studio to break down what's really happening inside your health plan and why the arrangement most employers are in was never designed to protect them.Todd has 18 years in the TPA space and has seen it all. From a $600,000 radiation claim nobody caught, to a 1,200-employee company whose national broker never once mentioned reference-based pricing. He explains why a flat renewal means your carrier is making bank on your business, what private equity is doing to TPA service quality, and how an employer spending $10 million on healthcare could realistically save $2 million in year one.If you're an employer, CFO, HR Director or benefits consultant - this one's for you.📌 Subscribe for more conversations on fixing the broken healthcare system.🔗 NOVA Healthcare Administrators: novahealthcare.com📞 Todd Martin: [email protected] | 716-870-5916#BrokenHealthcare #SelfFundedHealthcare #TPA #EmployerHealthcare #CFO #HRLeaders #ReferencedBasedPricing #StopLoss #HealthcareCosts #HealthcareTransparency #NOVA #Podcast 0:00 Introduction & Welcome1:45 What Is a TPA and What Does NOVA Do?5:30 Why Large Employers Are Still Fully Insured8:00 Flat Renewals — Why Your Carrier Is Making Bank10:30 Level Funded vs Traditional Self Funded14:00 Minimum Group Sizes & Stop Loss Explained16:30 How NOVA Approaches Claims Management20:00 Reference Based Pricing — What It Is and Why It's Growing25:00 Realistic Savings Expectations — The $10M Example30:00 The $600,000 Radiation Claim Nobody Caught35:00 Pharmacy Costs — From 10% to Over 50% of Claims40:00 Why Big Box Brokers Won't Tell You About RBP45:00 The Boston Story — 1,200 Employees, Zero Options Presented50:00 Private Equity Buying TPAs — What It Means for Service55:00 The Crawl Walk Run Approach to Self Funding1:00:00 Saving $2M on Healthcare = $8M in New Sales1:05:00 How to Find a Quality TPA — Do Your Diligence1:09:00 How to Reach Todd Martin1:11:00 Final Thoughts Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.








