Chasing Evil

What's coming up!

They thought they had gotten away with murder. They were wrong.After surviving a brutal gang execution attempt, Brianna Arrington identified the people who tried to kill her. What followed was one of the largest coordinated fugitive operations in the history of the U.S. Marshals Service's Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task Force.In Part Two of this extraordinary story, the investigators reveal how they tracked ten violent gang members across multiple cities, coordinated nearly one hundred law enforcement officers, and arrested every suspect in a single day.You'll also hear how detectives, prosecutors, and the U.S. Marshals turned gang members against one another, ultimately securing guilty pleas from every defendant.This is the story of justice—and the remarkable teamwork that made it possible.Show NotesEpisode 2: Brianna Arrington - The Girl Who Wouldn't Die - Part IIBrianna Arrington survived the impossible.Now, the hunt begins.After identifying the members of the Rollin' 20s Outlaw Bloods responsible for her torture and attempted execution, investigators faced an enormous challenge: arrest ten dangerous gang members before anyone could flee, destroy evidence, or retaliate against witnesses.In this conclusion to Brianna's story, host Christopher Godsick is joined once again by the detectives, prosecutors, and U.S. Marshals who orchestrated one of the most ambitious fugitive operations in the region's history.Together, they reveal how patience, intelligence gathering, surveillance, and teamwork resulted in every suspect being taken into custody in a single coordinated operation. They also take listeners inside the interrogation rooms, plea negotiations, and courtroom strategy that ultimately dismantled the gang's defense and secured guilty pleas from all ten defendants.In this episode:The investigation that followed Brianna's miraculous survival.How detectives identified all ten suspects.The planning behind an operation involving nearly 100 law enforcement officers.How the U.S. Marshals executed simultaneous arrests across multiple jurisdictions.The role of surveillance, search warrants, social media, and digital evidence.Inside the interrogations as gang members began turning on one another.How prosecutors leveraged cooperation agreements and plea negotiations.Why every defendant ultimately pleaded guilty.Brianna reflects on justice, healing, and rebuilding her life after unimaginable trauma.Featured GuestsBrianna ArringtonDetective Matt Walsh – Chesapeake Police Department (formerly Norfolk Police Department)Nicole – Task Force Officer, U.S. Marshals Service Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task ForceLance Roberson – Task Force Officer, U.S. Marshals Service Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task ForceChris Lure – Senior Inspector, U.S. Marshals ServiceKatie Beye – Former Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney, City of NorfolkSupport BriannaAlthough justice was achieved in court, Brianna's recovery continues. She lives with lasting physical and emotional injuries from the attack.If you'd like to help Brianna rebuild her life and support her family, please visit the Helping Brianna GoFundMe campaign.SubscribeIf you enjoy Chasing Evil, please:Follow the podcast.Leave a five-star review.Share this episode with friends and family.Your support helps us continue bringing you the remarkable stories of the investigators, survivors, and law enforcement professionals who pursue justice every day.

She survived what should have been impossible.When 23-year-old Brianna Arrington asked to leave a violent Norfolk street gang, its leaders decided she knew too much to be allowed to walk away.Over the course of one horrific night, Brianna was beaten, stabbed multiple times, choked, forced to drink bleach, and shot point-blank in the head before being left for dead.Against all odds, she survived.In this first of a two-part special, Brianna tells her story publicly for the very first time alongside the detective, prosecutors, and U.S. Marshals who would later bring every person responsible to justice.This is the story of survival, courage, and the beginning of one of the most extraordinary gang investigations in recent memory.Show NotesEpisode 1: Brianna Arrington – Surviving the UnthinkableOn April 23, 2020, Brianna Arrington believed she had finally found stability.After years of childhood abuse, foster care, homelessness, and abusive relationships, she accepted a room in a Norfolk apartment occupied by people she believed had become her family.She had no idea they were members of one of Virginia's most violent Bloods street gangs.When Brianna decided gang life wasn't for her and asked for her "walking papers," the gang concluded there was only one way she could leave.She had to die.In this emotional first episode, Brianna recounts the events that led her into the gang, the manipulation that drew her in, and the terrifying night that changed her life forever.Joining host Chris Godsick are:Brianna ArringtonDetective Matt Walsh (Norfolk Police Department/Chesapeake Police Department)Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney Katie ByMembers of the U.S. Marshals Service Capital Area Regional Fugitive Task ForceLaw enforcement officials directly involved in the investigationTogether they examine:Brianna's difficult childhood and years in foster care.How vulnerable young people are recruited by violent gangs.The family atmosphere that concealed a criminal enterprise.The initiation process into the Rollin 20s Outlaw Bloods.What happened after Brianna requested to leave the gang.The brutal torture and attempted execution that she miraculously survived.How investigators began piecing together one of Norfolk's most disturbing attempted murder cases.Episode 2 follows the massive law enforcement operation that led to the arrest of every suspect and the courtroom strategy that ultimately secured guilty pleas from all ten defendants.Support BriannaBrianna continues to recover from the physical and emotional trauma of the attack.If you'd like to help her rebuild her life and support her family, please visit the Helping Brianna GoFundMe campaign.SubscribeIf you enjoyed this episode, please:Follow Chasing EvilLeave a five-star reviewShare this episode to help Brianna's story reach more people

Apple Podcasts Episode DescriptionGo behind the scenes of one of the most complex missing persons investigations we've ever covered on Chasing Evil. In this special live Q&A, host Christopher Godsick is joined by the investigators who solved the murder of 17-year-old Valerie Tyndall.Rush County Detective Randy Meek, Detective Shawn Smallwood, Senior U.S. Deputy Marshal Tom Abreu, and Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department K9 Officer Tony Weaver discuss the investigative decisions that ultimately exposed Patrick Scott's lies and led to his conviction. From preserving critical digital evidence and analyzing surveillance footage to the remarkable work of cadaver dog Bailey, the panel answers listener questions and reveals the challenges that couldn't fit into the original two-part series.The investigators explain how teamwork between local, state, and federal agencies helped solve the case, why the first days of a missing person investigation are so critical, and what they learned from one of the most difficult cases of their careers.If you listened to Parts 1 and 2, this conversation provides an inside look at the investigation from the people who lived it.Show NotesIn this special live listener Q&A:Detective Randy Meek explains when Valerie Tyndall's disappearance became a homicide investigation.Detective Shawn Smallwood discusses Patrick Scott's deceptive interviews and how investigators recognized the inconsistencies.Senior Deputy U.S. Marshal Tom Abreu shares how the U.S. Marshals Service joined the investigation and why a fresh set of eyes proved invaluable.IMPD K9 Officer Tony Weaver explains how cadaver dog Bailey is trained and how human-remains detection dogs work.The panel discusses using digital evidence, surveillance cameras, social media, and search warrants to reconstruct Valerie's final movements.Learn how investigators unexpectedly discovered critical evidence through Apple Health data.Hear why preserving digital evidence in the first hours of a missing person investigation can determine whether a case is solved.Discover how local, state, and federal agencies coordinated their efforts during the six-month investigation.The investigators answer audience questions about Patrick Scott, the search for Valerie, sentencing, investigative strategy, and lessons learned from the case.GuestsRandy Meek – Rush County Sheriff's OfficeShawn Smallwood – Rush County Sheriff's OfficeTom Abreu – Senior Inspector, Great Lakes Regional Fugitive Task Force, U.S. Marshals ServiceTony Weaver – Detective, Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department Missing Persons UnitBailey – Human Remains Detection (HRD) K9Listen to the Patrick Scott SeriesIf you haven't already, be sure to listen to Part 1 and Part 2 of the Patrick Scott investigation before this Q&A for the complete story.This live discussion expands on the investigation featured in Episodes 1 and 2, providing additional insight into the forensic techniques, investigative strategy, and teamwork that ultimately brought justice for Valerie Tyndall.

When 17-year-old Valerie Tyndall vanished without a trace, investigators believed they were chasing a missing persons case. By Part Two, they were racing to prove something far more sinister.Rush County detectives and the U.S. Marshals uncover a series of contradictions that place Valerie's last known moments at Patrick Scott's home. A search of his property reveals hidden evidence, suspicious electronics, and a carefully concealed collection of personal mementos that raises even more questions.As investigators analyze mountains of digital evidence, GPS records, surveillance footage, and phone data, a chilling timeline begins to emerge. An unusual trip to a distant Home Depot, unexplained purchases, and a carefully orchestrated pattern of movement point detectives toward a terrifying possibility.Then comes the breakthrough no one expected.Four highly trained human remains detection dogs independently converge on the same location near Patrick Scott's property. But when divers search the pond where every dog indicated, they find... nothing.What seemed like a dead end instead becomes one of the most important moments in the investigation.In this episode, detectives Randy Meek and Sean Smallwood of the Rush County Sheriff's Office, Senior Inspector Tom Abreu of the U.S. Marshals Service, and Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department K9 handler Tony Weaver explain how modern technology, forensic mapping, and the extraordinary abilities of cadaver dogs transformed an impossible investigation into a case that was finally beginning to break open.Sometimes the biggest breakthrough isn't what investigators find.It's what they almost miss.Show NotesIn Part Two of our investigation into the disappearance of 17-year-old Valerie Tyndall, detectives begin dismantling Patrick Scott's carefully constructed timeline. Digital forensics, surveillance footage, GPS data, and countless hours of investigative work slowly reveal inconsistencies that point directly back to Scott's property.This episode explores:Patrick Scott's changing account of Valerie's final hours.The discovery of hidden photos and personal items linking Scott to Valerie.The seizure and forensic examination of multiple electronic devices.How investigators analyzed more than a terabyte of digital evidence.Apple Health data and GPS records that narrowed the critical timeline.Surveillance footage revealing suspicious purchases made the day after Valerie disappeared.The remarkable work of human remains detection dogs.Why four independent cadaver dogs alerted on the same location.How water runoff and geospatial analysis reshaped the investigation.The role of the FBI, U.S. Marshals Service, Rush County Sheriff's Office, Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, Indiana State Police, and multiple forensic specialists.The painstaking process investigators followed before seeking another search warrant.GuestsDetective Randy Meek — Rush County Sheriff's OfficeDetective Sean Smallwood — Rush County Sheriff's OfficeSenior Inspector Tom Abreu — U.S. Marshals ServiceDetective Tony Weaver — Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, Missing Persons Unit & K9 HandlerAbout Chasing EvilHosted by Emmy Award-winning producer Christopher Godsick, Chasing Evil goes behind the headlines to tell the real stories of America's most significant fugitive investigations and major criminal cases—through the voices of the investigators, victims, survivors, and U.S. Marshals who lived them.