DiscoverCreative Alchemy
Creative Alchemy
Claim Ownership

Creative Alchemy

Author: Alexandra Amor

Subscribed: 334Played: 1,403
Share

Description

Creative Alchemy explores the healing properties of creative expression after a cult or other traumatic experience.
260 Episodes
Reverse
Sometimes helping and healing ourselves can turn into helping others. Author and former Scientologist Chris Shelton has turned his love for learning and understanding into a multi media business that includes books, podcasts, and lots of informative YouTube videos. From the very earliest days after Chris left Scientology he began sharing what he was learning. And that continues to this day. In the introduction I talk about how humans are wired to learn from the stories we hear and how Chris reminded me that cult recovery is not one big ‘light bulb’ moment, but a slow, sometimes halting, journey of educating ourselves and gradually understanding what has happened to us. Chris Shelton, MSc, is an author, consultant, and educator specializing in cult dynamics, coercive control, and recovery from psychological manipulation.He is the host of the podcast Speaking of Cults (formerly Sensibly Speaking), where he interviews cult survivors, therapists, psychologists, and intervention specialists about recruitment, indoctrination, and recovery from high-control environments. He also maintains a widely viewed YouTube channel dedicated to critical thinking, cult education, and recovery resources.Chris published What Now? A Practical Guide to Life After a Cult in April of 2026. He is also the author of Scientology: A to Xenu – An Insider’s Guide to What Scientology is Really All About and has appeared in numerous media discussing cult dynamics, including the Emmy-winning television series Scientology and the Aftermath with Leah Remini, for which he also served as a consultant. Learn more about Chris Shelton at ChrisSheltonMSC.org This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the audiobook version of my award-winning, Amazon best-selling memoir, Cult, A Love Story. Readers call the book ‘compelling’ ‘gritty’ ‘intimate’ and ‘not boring’ – which is what an author loves to hear. I narrated the audiobook and if you have a Spotify premium subscription you can listen to the audiobook for free as part of that subscription at alexandraamor.com/spotify. You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below. Guests appear on Creative Alchemy in a personal capacity. Any views or claims they share are their own personal perspectives. Show notes Growing up in Scientology Signing the billion year Sea Org contract at 25 years old Leaving Scientology at 42 years old How none of us are impervious to being fooled How realizing a group is a cult is not a binary change Waking up to the prison of belief we find ourselves in Recovering by learning about totalist systems and how cults work Sharing what he’d learned and helping others Compiling that information into book form Resources mention in this episode Chris’s first book, Scientology: A to Xenu Chris’s second book, What Now? A Practical Guide to Life After a Cult Transcript of the interview with Chris Shelton Alexandra: Chris Shelton, welcome to Creative Alchemy. Chris: Thank you very much for inviting me. I’m happy to be here. Alexandra: I’m so happy to have you here. Tell us a little bit about your background and your time in Scientology. Chris: I was raised as a Scientologist, so it was part of my upbringing and part of my worldview from when I was a very young child. My parents got involved with Scientology when I was about three or four years old, so it was kind of always part of my life. And I don’t have any memories that are pre-Scientology, so to speak.  But I attended public school, had a fairly regular-looking life growing up. It’s not like we were living on a compound, and I was sequestered away from the rest of society. I had a regular experience that way. I just had things at home a little different as far as how we thought about the world and the people in it and what was going on in the world.  So I grew up with these sort of basic ideas of what Scientology teaches, and we can talk about those. And then when I graduated high school, I was recruited to start working for the Church of Scientology in Santa Barbara, California. I was born and raised out in California, and I’m in Denver now, so that was the beginning of a 25-year journey of working for the church in Santa Barbara.  Then when I was 25 years old, I really tripled down and signed the billion-year contract of commitment, where I joined what’s called the Sea Organization-that’s S-E-A, as in the ocean. It’s a sort of paramilitary outfit that L. Ron Hubbard created to run Scientology at its sort of highest levels. I was part of that activity for about 17 years, and I finally got out in 2012 and escaped Scientology entirely-the mindset, the beliefs, everything-in 2013. Basically after that, I started speaking out, started letting people know publicly what this was all about, and of course, I was joining a long line of people who had been doing this. I was not the first by any stretch, I’ve I’ve said many many times I stand on the shoulders of giants in many ways in terms of  what they had to go through versus what I’ve had to go through. I have been working for the last 13 years on recovering from Scientology and helping others in that process. And then growing out from there to learn more about psychology and social psychology and sociology, and interviewed a number of people across a number of disciplines on my channel. All in an effort to sort of figure out what happens to people in these groups, what happened to me in this group, and what these groups are all about, and then how to get over them, how to recover from them.  Because when you come out, that’s really just the beginning, not the end of the experience. So, that’s kind of me in a nutshell what my life was, and really the most exciting time has been the last decade. The 27 years that were in Scientology were a whirlwind of chaos, confusion, and violence. But since leaving that behind, it’s been all about sort of figuring things out, learning, growing, being more myself, figuring out what that is, and helping other people to do the same thing without pretending to be a therapist or offering people some kind of clinical assistance. I don’t do that.  I just help people with education and with information and with perspective shifting and how do you look at things differently when you get out? That’s an educational process more so than I think a therapeutic one. And by teaching people or helping people learn what this is all about, how these groups do what they do, I hope to help people detraumatize from them, but also sort of proof them up to not let it happen to them again, or at least not as easily. We’re all capable of being fooled till the day we die. There’s nobody impervious to that, and all the folks who might think they are, I don’t know. I just I just kind of find that cute at this point. That’s where I’m at on things, and I’ve spent an awful lot of time learning an awful lot about all this stuff to try to help other people understand it. Alexandra: One thing you said there that really piqued my interest: you left in 2012, but you started to realize more about Scientology as a cult in 2013. Would you say that’s true?  What led you to leave if you hadn’t figured that out? Chris: It was a gradual process, like it is with a lot of people. It was really for me because I grew up in Scientology, especially as a second generation member, which is what we call the kids of cults, right? The people who grow up in these groups, whether and they can be third, fourth, fifth generation. I mean, there’s terms for this, but we tend to call it that. And when you’re in a headspace like that, growing up, then that is your normal. That is what the world is supposed to look like. Is the cult belief set?  So that’s the normal, and everything else that’s not that is abnormal. They’re wrong. We’re right, and that’s how it is. So it it installs a layer of certainty and positivity about the group and its beliefs that you have to overcome, and it takes more, in my experience at least, it seems to take more abuse and more opportunities to wake up before you do kind of wake up.  Waking up as a is not a binary light switch. It’s a gradual process. I’ve tracked it down for myself to it being something of a 10 year process for me. The point where I first hit my initial, “Wait a minute. Something’s really wrong with this place. Hold on.” Really seeing it. There’s something really fundamentally wrong here. To I want to leave.  There’s a lot of space in between those two statements, and that’s what it took for me to unconvince myself that I was part of a group that I really needed to be part of. I wasn’t there because I was getting a paycheck, or because I liked the people I was working with. I certainly made friends and married within the group. But Scientology was something that was a responsibility for me. It was something I was doing and dedicating my life to, and I was really thinking of myself as a bit of a martyr at certain points too. That I was giving up so much to be part of this. It wasn’t like I didn’t know there was an outside world, but I was in it, and I put myself harder and harder in it because I thought by doing so I was going to be directly contributing to making the world better, to literally saving the world. That was the concept I had, and L. Ron Hubbard wasn’t bashful in the way that he convinced me that that’s what we were doing. I mean, Hubbard’s writings about this were pretty clear. Those writings were used with me when I was not critically thinking, when I was literally 17 years old, no world experience, and I’m getting love bombed and recruited and told I’m the best possible person, the most brightest, smartest, most amazing person. So I need to join right now. That was the headspace I was in when I joined this thing, and there was a lot of ego
Rich Dunning appeared to have it all; a lovely wife, beautiful children, a successful and lucrative career. And yet, none of that was enough to heal the wounds that had been inflicted upon him by a severely abusive childhood. Often with a huge measure of innocence we push the difficult and traumatic things that happen to us deep down inside us. I can say with a large measure of confidence that this almost never works. Rich found this out firsthand. And now he’s here to talk about bringing his experiences into the light through writing and how that has helped him move into fully embracing all the gifts in his life. Trigger warning for this episode: childhood abuse and suicidal thoughts. In the introduction I talk about the support systems required for writing a book about a traumatic experience and how it can take some time to find the right fit when we’re looking for these things. And how knowing that writing a book about a cult or other traumatic experience can be difficult and a stop-start process actually prepares us for that experience and can support us along the way. Rich Dunning is a senior executive in the medical device industry with more than two decades of experience leading in high-stakes environments. Raised in the Bronx in an environment defined by instability, exposure, and the absence of protection, he developed, from an early age, a level of awareness and control that shaped how he moved through the world. Those conditions did not remain confined to childhood—they inform his approach to leadership, decision-making, and, ultimately, his writing. Learn more about Rich Dunning at RichDunningBooks.com This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the Creative Alchemy journaling handbook. This free ebook guides cult and other trauma survivors into the healthy and healing practice of journaling. With a gentle hand and relying on her decades of writing experience, cult survivor Alexandra Amor encourages readers to develop a journaling practice as part of their healing path. Click here to get your complimentary copy. You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below. Show Notes Growing up in an extremely abusive household Entering adulthood with no skills and an alcohol dependency Hitting bottom and pushing off from there with the help of a 12 step program Taking care to proceed cautiously when writing about trauma On the importance of working with editors The importance of investing in the production of a quality book How telling the truth releases shame Transcript of the interview with Rich Dunning Alexandra: Rich Dunning, welcome to Creative Alchemy. Rich: It is a pleasure to be here. I’m honored to be here, and I love what you do on your platform, and I’m glad to be on it. Thank you so much. Alexandra: Oh, you’re so welcome. Well, thank you for being here with me today. Tell us about growing up in your family home in the Bronx. Rich: I have such vivid memories of that time, and I mean, I have such vivid memories as early as three. My earliest memories were living in this three room basement apartment that had really high hat windows, like you would normally see in a basement. So it was a bedroom, literally a living room, and then you had your kitchen. Very dark. It’s the only place we knew.  My parents, my biological parents, were literally off the boat. I’m first generation American, and it was kind of a scary place. But I didn’t know that we were at that point. I didn’t know that we were, in poverty or what have you. All I knew is that I thought the family unit was happy. It was me and my sister at that point, but the nights would be scary because it would get, especially in the winter, it was cold in New York City in the Bronx, and we had no heat.  I remember that they would turn on the oven for flames to heat up the room, we’d sleep in the kitchen, but the problem with that was that when you do that, you bring the roaches and the rats out. So you’re on the ground and you’re kind of just like mummified in your blankets because you don’t want them touching you or biting you or anything like that. Those are some of the not so happy moments when I was a kid.  Ultimately, they split up, right around when I was three years old. I remember him walking out, and then about a year or so later, this I don’t even want to call him my stepfather because I don’t want to insult stepfathers. This monster charismatically comes into our lives, and things within a year of that, things really become unraveled, and that’s when I first discovered that silence would be my armor and my protection and the only way to survive. Hence, the name of the book. Silence Was My First Language. Alexandra: I gather he was abusive towards you and your sister. Is that right? Rich: Yeah, he was a very, very violent, violent man. The first time I remember him putting his hands on me, I didn’t speak a word of English until I was five years old. We were just, I mean, literally sequestered into these three rooms. I had no outside exposure to whatever was going on in the world.  I remember it was the first day of elementary school, and I am freaking out. I don’t know what I’m doing, and I don’t speak English. So, I remember just pouting and crying and being so upset. I’m in my pajamas. It’s the morning of first day of school. My mom doesn’t know what to do with me.  All of a sudden, I see this man stand in front of me and close his fist and struck me so hard across the face that knocked me to the ground, and I peed my pajamas. He proceeded to then take me to school in my wet pajamas, where I sat in elementary school in those pajamas, and no one said a thing. No one, and that was my first introduction to silence and and the violence that came along with it. If you didn’t remain silent in your home. Alexandra: Oh, I’m so sorry. It just sounds awful. So you and your sister then so grew up in this atmosphere.  Was he around until you left the home? Rich: Yeah. I always say I’ve seen so I’ve seen more violence in most in 17 years, or excuse me, the 14 or 15 years that he was in our lives, at least until I was able to break out of that situation, than most people have seen in a lifetime. Other than our our dear veterans that go off to war, it was a very violent, unimaginable household. I talk about in the book some of these really awful things that he would do to us.  For example, some of the punishments when he was cocaine fueled, and that was often cocaine was a big part of our lives growing up, as well as the alcohol that was always around us, and he would get so paranoid and so violent. He thought it would be cute that he would tie. And this is in one of the many homes that we were always being evicted and homeless and all the time. So this is in one of our places that we lived, we had a basement in this home that he would tie us up in the furnace room with zip ties, naked, facing each other, me and my sister, and kneeling on uncooked rice.  This could be a school night, by the way, and this would start in the evening, and you had to stay awake all night long while he just, paranoid, just walking back and forth, just saying horrible things to us. And if you, for once, let your butt touch your heels, he would whip us with those long branches. We would call them switches in Spanish. The long branches that you would find on a tree. He would have us pick them out that evening before we went down for our what quote unquote we used to call a torture session, and that’s just one example. And then we were expected to just from there, get ready for school. We hadn’t slept, and continue on like we’ve lived a normal life. Alexandra: Goodness me, Rich. I’m so sorry. It’s just abysmal. Rich: It is. Alexandra: When you became an adult and were out on your own, I don’t imagine you had many skills to cope with and to understand what had happened to you. Rich: No, here and here’s the issue, right? With someone that grows up like me, I mean, I’ve lived in poverty, I lived in violence, I lived. I was homeless. Where at the point where, for a good stretch of nine months, I would live in an abandoned train station, for example.  I was an athlete. I would always try to overachieve because, for during the time that he lived with us, or we, I lived with him. My name was Dog, and that’s how I was referred to. I don’t know what it was, but it was always something in me that’s like I’m not a dog. I’m going to be the first one to graduate high school, go to college, etc.  I played sports, so I had access to our high school, where I would keep my clothes in the gym locker, and change into it that the morning after spending a night with strangers afraid for my life literally every night, and I would shower at school. And again, no one knew anything. All those things stayed. I got a partial scholarship to play baseball at college. That’s how I got out. Alexandra: Thank God. Rich: But to your point, no one teaches you. I was never a child, for example. I never experienced how to be a child. Number one, I literally became a parent at the age of 10. Not only taking care of my sister, but my then step kids, step brothers and sisters that came along when  he came along, so I mean, if I didn’t, we would go hungry. I would literally beg, borrow, and steal for money, or or worked on top of doing everything else, staying focused to get out of this whole mess that I was in.  And for a lot of times, I mean, I was ashamed and I blamed myself. But then you take all of this armor that you’ve never shed, and now you’re introduced to the world-the most anxious, paranoid, untrusting person you can ever meet. And now I’m supposed to tackle the world with that character that’s living, and so those traits that are living inside me.  I started drinking when I was se
You. Are. Creative. I know that sometimes it can seem as if that’s not true, especially if you’re attempting to work on a creative project for the first time. But I promise you, you are creative. That’s one of the messages of my guest today, Susan Stirling. Susan is a trauma-sensitive coach with training in somatic approaches to healing. She walks alongside her clients as they explore grief, spirituality, healing, reclaiming narratives and much more. Susan has been involved with no less than three high-demand organizations, starting when she was just a child in the rocky mountains of the British Columbia Alberta border. But, as she explains, among other things, creativity helped her eventually return to herself. In the introduction I mention that the International Cultic Studies Association has announced the dates and location for their 2027 conference. The conference will be held in Oslo, Norway on June 24 – 27, 2027. Learn more at InternationalCulticStudies.org. Susan Stirling works with individuals untangling their own complex histories—especially those navigating patterned self-abandonment, undue influence, or religious trauma. With a trauma-sensitive lens, as well as being a certified coach based on the neuroscience of human development, Susan help others discover the power of small steps, safe connections, and living from the inside out. Learn more at SusanStirling.com This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the audiobook version of my award-winning, Amazon best-selling memoir, Cult, A Love Story. Readers call the book ‘compelling’ ‘gritty’ ‘intimate’ and ‘not boring’ – which is what an author loves to hear. I narrated the audiobook and if you have a Spotify premium subscription you can listen to the audiobook for free as part of that subscription at alexandraamor.com/spotify. You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below. Show Notes On growing up in a ‘house church’ Being called to creativity in a prophetic church How writing helps us return to ourselves Finding the support and encouragement to write a book Building a ‘coherent narrative’ as part of the healing process Discovering ‘the art of falling’ and why it’s so important to healing Living from creativity rather than looking at it like a practice Deciding what spirituality means from the inside out Transcript of the interview with Susan Stirling Alexandra: Susan Sterling, welcome to Creative Alchemy. Susan: Thank you, thank you for having me. Alexandra: Oh, it’s my pleasure to have you on the show.  Give us a little bit about your background and growing up in the church that you were in on the Alberta BC border. Susan: I guess what I can say or share is that is an incredibly beautiful area. I grew up within a community of family upon family upon generations of family, and so being seen, heard, known was very real for me in many ways of my growing up. So I have to say I’m very grateful for that aspect of my childhood. Alexandra: Nice. And your family was involved with a church, is that right? Susan: My mother became involved with a church, so part of my story is no. It was only my mom who took me into some of those house church meetings, and that was part of what actually created the disassociation for me. Alexandra: I hadn’t heard that expression “house church” until I heard you on a different podcast. Can you explain what that is? Susan: Yes. So, think of the time period early ’70s. So, it was at the end of the Jesus People movement, and so at that time, house churching or shepherding movement kind of sort of came into being. There were these offshoots from organized churches.  And so, being in the small town that we were in, what I remember, because I don’t remember all the events of it, but I remember my mom taking me to a house church, where in the living room, you have worship, sing songs with a guitar, and then you have the sermon. Children go off to the room, and then afterwards we may join back into the larger fellowship for prayer or closing or whatever that might be. But the context or the structures were in houses, not necessarily church buildings. Alexandra: Was it a certain type of church, like a denomination? Susan: I would say, if looking back now over the storyline of it, it would have come out of the Pentecostal, so very charismatic. Today, I would call it hyper charismatic within that context. Alexandra: Okay, and you mentioned disassociation. Tell us a little bit about that. Susan: So in my book and in my story, and I think this is the power of writing as well, which we’ll talk about today, is that it wasn’t until I began to write my story and the context of my story and creating that coherent narrative. When I went back to my childhood and I saw the events that happened, I literally saw myself when I stepped out of a vehicle, my mom’s vehicle that I was sent to because I was bad.  I had a conversation with God in that vehicle, and then when I stepped out of that vehicle, I truly stepped out of parts of myself-the fully integrated part-and I created what I termed a spiritual self and a normal self. In many ways, reading-if you read my story-you would see that a lot of my childhood was normal, growing up in the small town, going to school. But there was this spiritual side of me that developed that was incredibly fear-based and catastrophic-based because I was waiting for the end of the world. Jesus was coming back any day. You had that apocalyptic narrative going on. So I literally split in for survival. Alexandra: For a young child to be told that the world is ending when I mean you’ve barely got your feet under you. That would be so terrifying. Susan: It was incredibly overwhelming to my brain nervous system. I think for my story, what’s unique about that to me is it was me and my mom versus the rest of my family would have been left behind. So there’s that context. We weren’t all together going to heaven, getting taken, you know, up and out. There was a lot of mixed and layered to a child’s brain. How do you work that out? Alexandra: Yeah, exactly, and so you did what worked for you, which is, as you say, is to create these two selves. Very skillful for someone so young. Susan: That’s what we do, though. That is part of how we survive. That is human. Alexandra: Exactly. One of the things that I found so interesting about your story is that then in adulthood you became involved in two more sequentially high demand groups. So large group awareness training first, and then another prophetic church community.  When we spoke the first time, you mentioned that in the prophetic church you were ‘called to creativity’, and I was really interested when you said that.  Please tell us about that, what it means, what it looked like, and how it affected your relationship with creativity. Susan: If I can go back just a little bit and say, because the world didn’t end right as I was always waiting. My brain could only move the markers of life ahead just a little bit because I never knew when the end was coming, and so I became really goal orientated. Well, what can I do before the end?  I graduated high school. Well, I didn’t plan a career and what the future would look like. I would just go, “What can I do now? Oh, maybe I can get married before the end of the world. Maybe I could this before the end of the world.” So I became really goal orientated.  Fast forward into the time of the church and creativity. I remember my husband and I went to the states, and we were becoming friends with a pastor there. One of the things when you become friends with a pastor prophet is you get second row seats. You don’t sit at the back of the church, and so we’re sitting second row seats. In front of us were these dancers, and I had never seen dance in a church up until that point. At first when worship started and they took up the flags and began to move their bodies across, it was quite annoying to me. I just was, it was, pay attention. I can’t pay attention, but as I settled into them, because they were in front of me and watching them, and they would pick up a flag, and I just began to sob. My spirit, my heart, was connecting to what they were doing. It was bypassing the the logical side of me, and so that was a profound experience.  So I came back to Canada with that, just the experience, nothing else. I went to a church in Edmonton, and there I saw another dancer for the first time in Canada, and she had flags, and she moved, and she did a prophetic drama dance, as we would call it. And again, I just started to bawl, I just started to cry, tears would come. That was my language, but I had no words to put to it.  Those pastors came to our church, brought a prophetic team with them, and they spoke over me, and they said that there was creativity in me, that God wanted to bring it out, and that they asked me, “Do you play an instrument?” And I was like, nope. Do you draw? Nope. And they just said, well, it’s as though music is built in you, and God’s going to take that and use that in this church, et cetera, et cetera. And so that was truly the first knowing from the outside in that God wanted me to have creativity. Alexandra: What kinds of things did you do for the church in that way? Susan: I was already part of the worship team. So you could say maybe that’s part of a little bit of creativity. But what I did do was now that I saw flags and dance and drama within from not only in the U.S. but in Canada.  I went to our church, our pastor, and spoke with them and said, “I want to bring this to our body. I want to release this here. I believe God wants me to.” It was like a permission slip, and so that’s what I actually did. I gathered a team of five. At first, they didn’t give me permission to do it. They sa
When Matthew Castle was 17 he took a small duffle bag and his violin and slipped out of a bedroom window of his family home. He was escaping a life in the high demand religion, the Institute of Basic Life Principles. Music had sustained him while he was growing up in IBLP and it would continue to do so once he was free and living an autonomous life. In the introduction, I talk about how I could especially relate to part of Matthew’s story where he talks about taking a break from the violin after he left IBLP. He wanted to see if his love for the violin was truly authentic and the way he found to do that was by taking a break from it. I went through a similar process post-cult where I examined many (many!) things in my life to determine if they were things I liked because liked them or because the cult told me I should like them. I also talk about this week’s Memoir Monday blog post where I explore the creative healing that can come from a psychological practise called Internal Family Systems (IFS). I will be doing a series of posts about IFS and creativity over the coming weeks. Matthew Castle is a violinist, creator, and advocate based in Seattle. He was raised in the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP), the fundamentalist Christian homeschooling movement founded by Bill Gothard, where authority was abused and families were encouraged to isolatethemselves from society.Today Matthew and his husband, author-illustrator Paul Castle, share their life and advocacy with a large online audience and publish children’s books together. Learn more about Matthew Castle at PaulCastleStudio.com/pages/Matthew This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the audiobook version of my award-winning, Amazon best-selling memoir, Cult, A Love Story. Readers call the book ‘compelling’ ‘gritty’ ‘intimate’ and ‘not boring’ – which is what an author loves to hear. I narrated the audiobook and if you have a Spotify premium subscription you can listen to the audiobook for free as part of that subscription at alexandraamor.com/spotify. You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below. Show Notes Growing up in Bill Gothard’s Institute of Basic Life Principles (IBLP) Questioning the blind obedience in IBLP Leaving home at age 17 through a bedroom window How Matthew’s music was a threat to the Bill Gothard’s community How music became the one thing Matthew felt accomplished at How music brings us into our bodies How music gave Matthew his life back Assisting husband Paul’s writing and illustrating children’s books How music transcends language Transcript of the interview with Matthew Castle Alexandra: Matthew Castle, welcome to Creative Alchemy. Matthew: Thank you so much for having me. Alexandra: It’s so good to have you here.  Please tell us about your background growing up in IBLP and those sorts of things? How you left? Matthew: My parents around the age of 12, and I don’t, yeah, I waffle on exactly what age because you know I part of my PTSD from my upbringing is is memory gap, memory gaps, memory holes, and so reconstructing my childhood has been a challenging process of trying to put together pieces and trying to to remember dates and times. So most of the ages I give are my best guess, my best memory.  I’m not in contact with all my family, so I can’t reach out to them to say, “What? How old was I? When did this happen?” So, to my best recollection, sometime around the age of 12, my parents signed up for ATI, the Advanced Training Institute, which was Bill Gothard’s homeschool program.  If we back up from there, IBLP, which was the Institute in Basic Life Principles, put on seminars across the country. I think it started in the ’60s or ’70s. Bill Gothard was traveling to major cities, speaking to tens of thousands of people in major arenas in your local city, whether it was Denver or Saint Paul or Minneapolis or Kansas City. Evangelical Christians of all denominations would show up and hear him speak for a week on God’s principles: how to live a godly life, how to raise godly children. All very inspirational stuff that everybody could use and apply to their lives, and that was kind of the gateway in. And my parents did that.  I don’t know how young I was, but at some point they went to the Institute in Basic Life Principles Basic Seminar, and after that there was an advanced seminar. And so at some point my parents decided to go to the advanced seminar. You had to go to the basic one first, then the advanced, and again this was just for adults. So we kids, me and my brother and sister, were not part of it. But they went through a week of that, probably another city, another year.  Bill Gothard’s third step in his program was the Advanced Training Institute. You had to go through the basic seminar, then the advanced seminar, and then you could sign up for his homeschool program called ATI, or the Advanced Training Institute. And somewhere around the age of 12, more or less, give or take a year or two on either side, they signed us up for that program. We began attending yearly summer conferences in Knoxville, Tennessee, where he held his big gatherings.  I think at times there were maybe 50, 60,000 people in attendance, families from around the world and all over the country who came to be there for a week of teachings and instruction, and we started attending those. And then during the year, we received Bill Gothard’s curriculum.  He wrote a series of wisdom booklets. I think there’s 50 some of them. I remember 59. I’ve looked it up online, and I think it’s online. There’s some different numbers out there, like 54. But there was a series of these wisdom booklets that he wrote, along with a whole bunch of other material. He was constantly publishing books and educational material. Families were supposed to basically apply everything that Bill Gothard taught to their families, and he had a lot of rules, a lot of guidelines for what you did and you didn’t do.  Most of it was centered around protecting your family, your children from outside influences, influences of the world, secular influences, and to really make that work, he had a very strong teaching around authority, and the term that he liked to use was the chain of authority, and that was basically from God to the government, all the way down from national government to local government to the father of the home, to the mother of the home, and then to the children. Each of those authority structures was represented very visually in in a diagram that he would draw in front of 10s of 1000s of people, is all these umbrellas, and if you stayed under as many of those umbrellas as possible, you were more protected from harm, from danger, from outside influences. That really encouraged blind obedience, not only to him, but basically to any authority. Through that he was able to cultivate very loyal, very devout disciples of his of his cult through the homeschool program, and so that’s kind of the journey that got us into IBLP, and then into his homeschool program and kind of the basic teachings. Alexandra: Obviously it had a negative effect on you because I know a little bit about your story, and you ended up escaping from your family home through a window with your violin. Tell us what led up to that escape. Matthew: Yeah, it’s interesting. Through the years in IBLP, I always felt like an outsider. I was always questioning the blind obedience, the abuse of authority that I saw.  Bill Gothard had these various training centers around the world that young people, in their teens, like me, could volunteer at. He was getting a lot of free labor, and families were sending off their children to these various events, either to work for him, to do work for him, or to attend training.  As I went to these every year, I just started to notice like there’s this blind obedience, there’s this thoughtless conformity to whatever he says, without really thinking about it, without questioning it. That began to sow seeds of doubt in my mind about the program, and then I also witnessed personally some misuses and abuses of it, and an attempt to kind of force me into obeying through threats.  There was one time when I was working at an IBLP program, and an accident happened, and the leader tried to blame the accident on me. Then also said that it was God’s punishment because I was not toeing the line, I was not doing exactly what I was told. I wasn’t. I was questioning some of the things that were being said, and that really struck me because I’m like, accidents happen to everything. Accidents happen to everyone. That that doesn’t mean that God is punishing you. It was funny because he said, “Good things happen to good people, and bad things happen to bad people.” I wanted to quote back to him from the book of Job, where the most righteous man in the Old Testament has all these horrible things happen to him, where God is testing him, and there are all these things where I am [thinking] this doesn’t make sense. They’re cherry picking what they say always to try to get blind obedience, always to try to get people to conform to whatever it is they want to happen.  So that was a number of years where I was really just questioning everything. There were things I liked about it, things that I enjoyed, things that were good, but there was a lot that really made me uneasy with the whole program.  I also realized that we were very weird. It was a very weird group. There was so much that we didn’t do. We were not exposed to so much. I mean, popular music, TV shows, movies. You weren’t supposed to really expose yourself or watch any of that, and so we were very isolated. You weren’t supposed to really see other people in the cult to go to spend time with, you were supposed to find a church where mostly
Secrets are toxic and damaging. If you’ve been in a cult you know this and you may also know how secrets can be used to control us when we’re in a high demand situation. When today’s guest Esther Friedman left the cult she belonged to she took a very firm stance against secrets and I loved talking to her about this during our interview. I related to so much of what she had to say and since we spoke I’ve been reflecting on the destructive power of secrets. In the introduction I talk about this conversation with Esther has had me reflecting on secrets and how cults use them. I was thinking about the concentric circles of secrets in the cult I belonged to. As a tactic for control and manipulation the cult leader I followed would keep secrets from the group and/or would let certain people know certain secrets and others in the group would be aware of this and know that they weren’t high enough in the group hierarchy to know those secrets. In the sociological and psychological study of cults this is often called ‘information control’. Robert J. Lifton calls it ‘millieu control’. Steven Hassan talks about how cults teach different levels of information to different members of a group. Margaret Singer talks about how controlling information and keeping members unable to fully evaluate what is happening is central to coercive persuasion.  So, secrets are a valuable tool to the cult leader. I experienced that and so did Esther. If you’ve been in a cult I think you’ll enjoy hearing about how Esther used creative expression to work through her feelings and process her anger after leaving ‘The School’. I also reflect on the unexpected pleasure this podcast has brought me because it allows me to connect with other cult survivors. Interviewing my guests and talking about our shared experiences is healing something in me, and that’s not something I’d planned for with this show, but it’s a very welcome part of my experience. Esther Friedman is a licensed mental health counselor (LMHC), expressive art therapist, songwriter, recording artist, performer, and author of The Gentle Souls Revolution. This book depicts her 5-year misadventure in a “secret mystery school” that taught her how cults exploit human nature. She embraced her anger, formed a personal policy of No More Secrets, posted a blog, and started protecting her time and energy fiercely.
 A funny thing happened: as she exposed cult secrets and reclaimed her voice, her heart calmed and her mind cleared. She took the narrative back, and her truth contradicted the group’s claimed ideology. Esther discovered that what was good for her was also good for the people that she loves. That’s the basis and therapy model for her clinical practice, The Gentle Souls Revolution. Learn more about Ester Friedman at GentleSoulsRevolution.com This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the audiobook version of my award-winning, Amazon best-selling memoir, Cult, A Love Story. Readers call the book ‘compelling’ ‘gritty’ ‘intimate’ and ‘not boring’ – which is what an author loves to hear. I narrated the audiobook and if you have a Spotify premium subscription you can listen to the audiobook for free as part of that subscription at alexandraamor.com/spotify. You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below. Show Notes On being deliberately groomed and recruited into a secret cult Leaving the group five years later and realizing how much secrecy was involved The difference between secrecy and privacy The cognitive load that secrets create Reclaiming ownership of personal time How expressing our feelings in writing can help us find our voice again Only understanding what we’ve gone through when we write it down How high-demand groups deliberately create confusion  And how reverse engineering this confusion is healing Reclaiming our identity in the cult recovery process Knowing when to take a break from a writing project for self-care Resources Mentioned in this Episode Esther’s book The Gentle Souls Revolution Dan Shaw’s book Traumatic Narcissism Martha Beck’s book Leaving the Saints Transcript of the interview with Esther Friedman Alexandra: Esther Friedman, welcome to Creative Alchemy. Esther: Thank you, Alexandra, for having me. Alexandra: You’re so welcome. Please tell us a little bit about your background and also about the cult that you were involved in. Esther: Well, maybe we’ll start with the cult. Because that led to the background, I guess. Although I had a master’s degree as an expressive arts therapist before the cult, but the cult is what led me to what I’m doing today.  So the cult is something that you probably have not heard of because it’s very, very secretive. When I was in it, it was simply called School. It has also been called Odyssey Study Group. Back in the 60s and 70s, it was called the Theater of All Possibilities. But it was this very hush hush mom and pop. I sometimes jokingly call it cult light, but I think I just didn’t experience cult dark.  It was philosophical, although it borrowed from the Bible, but I shouldn’t say borrowed. It stole from the Bible and New Age Oprah Winfrey type things, but really the main thing was a teaching called the Fourth Way, which started in the early 1900s with this George Ivanovich Gurdjieff that was kind of the main philosophical I guess underpinnings.  Except that they never mentioned the Fourth Way or the man, they just trotted out the ideas. So I think I’m just giving you an example of how secretive the information was, the lack of transparency. But it was also the kind of thing where when you stumbled into this group and their recruitment process was-I’ll get-I’ll get into that if you want me to.  It was very, very deceptive. That what you learn is like this is a secret, esoteric mystery school, and we considered ourselves to be the invisible world. It wasn’t like a living group, right? But we weren’t supposed to talk about it outside the group, which of course is a red flag-a screaming siren, right? So is that enough information about?  Alexandra: How did you get involved, and what drew you to it?  Esther: I like to say I wasn’t adulting well at that time in my life. I don’t know if you’re aware of Dan Shaw? He wrote the book Traumatic Narcissism. He’s a therapist in New York. He’s also a fellow survivor, but he has a formula that just fit my experience perfectly. It’s bad luck plus timing. Things weren’t going well in my life. Like nothing was going well I was just at the tail end of a relationship. It was clear we were going to break up. I felt really lost with my career. I just felt like this adulting thing is just beyond me. I can’t figure it out. I feel like I don’t belong in the planet.  So I’m feeling sorry for myself in line at Whole Foods, and a woman struck up a conversation with me. This is how the recruitment works for this school. It’s somebody just strikes up a conversation with you, and then foments.  I use the word foment because it’s not nurturing; it fosters a friendship. So I spent a good couple of months with this woman, Lisa, calling me. Let’s get together. Let’s take a walk, and she was really nice and fun, and she would listen to me, and I was kind of yammering on and on about myself while she gathered the data.  At the time, of course, I was pretty naive to all of this because she didn’t tell me much about herself at all. But I was yammering on and on. She gave me an opportunity because she wasn’t talking, and I was going on and on about how I can’t figure the world out. And so then after a couple of months, she said, “Oh, I want to introduce you to a friend.”  She introduced me to Robert, who was really the leader of the group, but I didn’t find that out until I actually went to my first class and he pitched it as a five-week experiment. It sounded very innocuous. The grooming begins in the friendship. At the time I’m looking for something and they’re like oh we offer these ideas and we help each other and Alexandra I honestly thought I was going to a potluck. I thought I was going to go to someone’s house, and there’d be a potluck, and we’d talk about ideas and laugh, and that it’d be really casual. And of course, it wasn’t that at all. Alexandra: How long were you involved? Esther: Five years. Alexandra: And so, as you said, that led you to what you’re doing now, and I mentioned in my email that I sent you as we were setting up to do this interview, that I found this sentence on your website that just blew my socks off. So I want to read it for our listeners, and then we’ll talk about various pieces of it.  You say, “I embraced my anger, formed a personal policy of no more secrets, posted a blog and started protecting my time and energy fiercely”, which I just love. I really want to delve into all of this. So the first thing you mentioned is that you embraced your anger.  Why was that first on the list, and why was it so important? Esther: I love this question because I think it’s important for every former cult member. I had spent five years increasingly losing any confidence. I didn’t have much confidence when I entered, right? And, of course, the first little bit is love bombing. But then, of course, that alternate starts alternating with the feeding frenzies, and of course, then the love bombing falls away, and you’re always getting hammered, right?  I spent five years investing in this group, feeling like it was going to help me, feeling worse and worse about myself, and honestly, Alexandra, by the fifth year, I mean, if I had gone to an ER, I think they would have said, “We think you should stay.” I was really falling apart.  And it’s kind of a longer story about how my husband really confronted me and woke me up, but the timing of that was really
loading
Comments