Deeper Look At The Parsha

Ancient idol worship sometimes turned desecration itself into ritual: stones were thrown, and degradation became devotion. Watching the latest UN General Assembly, Rabbi Dunner sees an unsettling parallel. From Javier Milei’s blistering attack to António Guterres’s rhetoric and the walkout during Netanyahu’s speech, the institution’s sacred status seem increasingly at odds with how it is treated. Sukkot offers a radically different vision of nations gathering together.

Sukkot begins with a flimsy hut and ends with dancing around a Torah scroll. In between come the four species, Kohelet, Hoshana Rabba, Shemini Atzeret, and a series of rituals that seem oddly disconnected. Rabbi Dunner shows how they form one argument: life is temporary, joy is deliberate, belonging requires participation, and every apparent ending is really another fresh beginning.

Jonas Hanway became famous in eighteenth-century London for carrying an umbrella when respectable Englishmen considered them ridiculous. Sukkot asks us to do something almost opposite: leave our solid homes and sit beneath a deliberately incomplete roof. Rabbi Dunner explores security, vulnerability, happiness, and the crucial difference between protecting ourselves wisely and imagining that we are somehow invulnerable.

Can a Jew ever be too far gone? In 1917, more than four centuries after Portugal forced its Jews into hiding, Polish Jew Samuel Schwarz found a community still guarding fragments of Judaism in secret. From the anusim and Dona Gracia Nasi to Menashe ben Israel and modern genetics, Rabbi Dunner explores an astonishing truth at the heart of Shabbat Shuva: Jewish identity can be buried, but it refuses to disappear.

Barney Barnato rose from London’s East End to become one of the richest men in the British Empire, only to die at forty-six after going overboard in the Atlantic. His extraordinary life reads almost like all of the contrasts in Unetaneh Tokef. Rabbi Dunner explores uncertainty, reversal, despair, hope, and why Yom Kippur refuses to let any of us believe the story is over yet.