Discover
Executive Functions Chat
Executive Functions Chat
Author: Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith
Subscribed: 25Played: 440Subscribe
Share
© Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith
Description
74 Episodes
Reverse
Jack Goldsmith chats with Stephen Vladeck, the Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts at Georgetown University Law Center, about Vladeck’s Foreword in the Harvard Law Review, “The Court Against the Courts.” In an office at Gannett House, the home of the Harvard Law Review, they discuss the caseloads, impeachment resolutions, and threats that district judges have faced since early 2025, and Vladeck’s argument that the Supreme Court bears significant responsibility for their predicament. They also cover whether the Court is likely to change its behavior in anticipation of reforms that Congress may pursue beginning in 2029, as well some of the reforms Vladeck proposes in his upcoming book, The Court We Need.This chat is cross-posted at One First. Get full access to Executive Functions at www.execfunctions.org/subscribe
Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith discuss the administration’s warnings that Democratic lawmakers’ planned oversight could merit criminal investigation, including letters from a U.S. attorney in Texas directing members of Congress to preserve documents. Bauer and Goldsmith agree that there is no legal basis for such an investigation, debate the importance of some Democrats’ potentially imprudent rhetoric about planned oversight in light of the limits described by the Court in Mazars, and consider what the administration may hope to gain from the warnings. They close by weighing whether Will Scharf’s conduct as White House counsel, including his letter to the incoming House Oversight chair, bears out the criticism that the office is too political and strengthens the case for shrinking it. Get full access to Executive Functions at www.execfunctions.org/subscribe
Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith discuss Bob’s recent piece, “Why the Trump Election Interference Strategy Failed.” Bob describes three factors: flawed strategy resting on a “constitutionally doomed” theory of executive power over federal elections and on tenuous noncitizen-voting claims; the courts, which repeatedly ruled against the administration, capped by the Supreme Court’s same-day denial in the California ballot-segregation case; and a decentralized election system whose officials, in red and blue states alike, carried out their work as in any other election. Bauer and Goldsmith also chat about the solicitor general’s final emergency application, and how the president’s political weakness and the polls’ forecast of decisive Democratic win decreased the viability of election denialism. Get full access to Executive Functions at www.execfunctions.org/subscribe
Jack interviews Caleb Nelson, the Emerson G. Spies Distinguished Professor of Law at the University of Virginia School of Law, about his working paper, “Against the Dictatorial Presidency.” They discuss the modern history of unitary executive theory, Nelson’s criticisms of the theory in Slaughter, the relevance of the Necessary and Proper Clause, and the dangers of Slaughter, with special focus on the civil service. Goldsmith and Nelson close by discussing the Court’s unexplained Fed carve-out, with Nelson lamenting the Court’s selective willingness to consider consequences in crafting the unitary executive. Get full access to Executive Functions at www.execfunctions.org/subscribe
Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith discuss Jack’s October 19 piece on Senator Elissa Slotkin’s recent viral remarks at the University of Chicago, where she said she wanted accountability for the people who enabled President Trump, at least in part with the goal of sending a “deterrence message” to new graduates who might consider working for the administration. Jack explains why he thinks Senator Slotkin’s remarks were imprudent, and why he finds the prevailing reaction from pro-Trump quarters hypocritical. Bob presses on whether congressional investigation is different from weaponizing law enforcement, and whether worry about retaliation could lead to the most lawless conduct going unanswered. They also discuss Jack’s prediction that Trump will issue thousands of pardons, his case for prioritizing transparency, and why it is, and will continue to be, incredibly challenging for either side to de-escalate. Get full access to Executive Functions at www.execfunctions.org/subscribe




