Discover
Getting Granular
Getting Granular
Author: Granular
Subscribed: 2Played: 23Subscribe
Share
© 2023+ Granular
Description
Welcome to Getting Granular; the podcast where digital marketing experts from the agency Granular talk about the latest trends, tried and true best practices, and share their unfiltered thoughts about the industry. Based in Milwaukee, and laser-focused on PPC.
67 Episodes
Reverse
Emily Anderson is back from maternity leave, and The Click Brief duo is officially reunited! After three months of Jeremy flying solo (and Emily pointing out just how short those episodes were), they're back to breaking down the latest developments in paid media.October brought new campaign controls, expanded automation, and more opportunities for advertisers to reach customers through AI-powered search experiences. Google introduced channel prioritization and budget allocation tools, expanded Promotion Mode ahead of the holiday shopping season, and added new customer acquisition reporting options. Meanwhile, ChatGPT Ads introduced default creative enhancements, and Google continued expanding advertising within AI Mode conversations.Top TakeawaysBiggest Platform UpdateGoogle began rolling out channel prioritization and budget allocation controls, allowing advertisers to prioritize certain networks and limit spending on lower-priority inventory. While it's a step toward giving advertisers more control, limitations within Performance Max and Demand Gen mean the new settings may not offer quite as much flexibility as marketers hoped.Feature Worth TestingGoogle expanded Promotion Mode for eligible Search and Performance Max campaigns, allowing advertisers to schedule temporary ROAS adjustments and additional daily budget during promotional periods. With Black Friday and Cyber Monday approaching, Jeremy and Emily see this as a useful tool for capturing increased demand, although questions remain about how the new budget settings interact with Google's existing spending limits.Customer Acquisition UpdateGoogle introduced a reporting-only option for new customer acquisition, allowing advertisers to monitor new customer performance without changing bidding strategies. Additional updates include re-engagement capabilities in Performance Max and expanded loyalty features, giving advertisers more ways to understand and target different customer groups.Creative Reality CheckChatGPT Ads turned on AI-powered creative enhancements by default for new and existing self-service campaigns. These features can rewrite headlines and descriptions, translate copy, resize images, and select relevant landing pages. While the flexibility could improve ad relevance, Jeremy and Emily raise concerns about advertiser control, limited reporting, and changes being made without individual approval.Conversational Advertising WatchGoogle expanded AI Mode advertising to include ads during follow-up questions within conversations, while also extending availability to additional countries. As search becomes more conversational, advertisers have new opportunities to reach users throughout the research and shopping process rather than only during an initial search. Other Platform UpdatesGoogle introduced channel prioritization and budget allocation controls across eligible campaign typesPerformance Max channel controls still group Search, YouTube, Gmail, Discover, and Maps together, limiting more granular budget managementPromotion Mode expanded to eligible Search and Performance Max campaigns with scheduled promotional periodsGoogle added reporting-only new customer acquisition options without requiring acquisition-focused biddingPerformance Max introduced additional re-engagement capabilities for reaching lapsed customersLoyalty Mode became generally available in Performance Max and Shopping campaignsChatGPT Ads enabled creative enhancements by default for new and existing self-service campaignsAdvertisers can manage ChatGPT creative enhancements through campaign-level settingsGoogle introduced multi-turn ads within AI Mode conversations in the U.S.Google expanded AI Mode advertising to 10 additional countriesExisting eligible Search, Shopping, and Performance Max campaigns can participate in AI Mode ad placements without separate campaigns or budgetsFinal TakeOctober's updates highlight the ongoing push toward greater automation, along with advertisers' growing demand for transparency and control. Google's new channel prioritization tools are a step in the right direction, but limitations remain. Meanwhile, expanded promotional controls, customer reporting, and conversational advertising create new opportunities for advertisers willing to test.As Jeremy and Emily point out, the challenge isn't simply adopting the latest features. It's understanding how they work, knowing what settings are enabled by default, and making sure automation supports actual business goals.And with Emily officially back, The Click Brief is once again bringing two perspectives (and a little more back-and-forth) to the biggest changes in paid media.Follow The Click Brief for fast, no-fluff performance marketing updates every month.
Jeremy Packee is flying solo again for September's Click Brief, covering another busy month of paid media updates, emerging advertising opportunities, and AI developments.Amazon introduced fully automated, full-funnel campaigns, while ChatGPT Ads expanded its capabilities with new Shopify and HubSpot integrations. Google continued improving measurement and first-party data tools, Pinterest introduced new visual search ad placements, and AI agents from Meta and OpenAI ofTop TakeawaysBiggest Platform ShiftAmazon launched its new full-funnel campaigns for U.S. advertisers, combining Sponsored Ads, display, video, and streaming TV into a single AI-optimized campaign. While the format promises simplified management and long-term growth, advertisers have limited control over placements and audiences, making careful testing and performance evaluation essential.Platform to WatchChatGPT Ads introduced new integrations with Shopify and HubSpot, making it easier for advertisers to manage campaigns, connect product data, track performance, and follow up on leads. Jeremy sees these integrations as a significant opportunity for e-commerce advertisers heading into the holiday shopping season.Visual Search OpportunityPinterest announced new visual search ad placements for Performance+ campaigns, combining keyword relevance with AI-powered image recognition. Advertisers can reach shoppers as they explore products visually, creating additional opportunities to connect with users who may not know exactly what they're searching for.Measurement UpgradeGoogle expanded Data Manager integrations and introduced a new metric showing conversions recovered through first-party data. GA4 also added hostname include filters, giving advertisers more control over which domains can send event data and helping improve reporting accuracy.AI Agent WatchMeta introduced Muse, a personal AI agent capable of shopping, booking travel, and completing tasks, while OpenAI began rolling out Dots for ongoing work and research. These developments point toward a future where AI agents play a larger role in how consumers shop and how businesses manage everyday tasks.Other Platform & AI UpdatesGoogle made Meridian GeoX generally available for geographic experimentsGoogle expanded Data Manager integrations and enhanced conversion capabilitiesGA4 introduced hostname include filters to help manage incoming event dataAmazon announced a pilot partnership bringing advertising campaigns into ChatGPTAmazon introduced Branded Conversations, allowing shoppers to ask follow-up product questions through sponsored Alexa experiencesTikTok and Shopify expanded connections between affiliate creator content and Spark AdsReddit opened Max campaigns to all advertisersMicrosoft made campaign experiments generally available and added a HubSpot integrationMeta introduced additional AI tools for small businessesOpenAI and Anthropic released new AI modelsOpenAI began rolling out Dots, designed to manage ongoing tasks and provide updates between conversationsFinal TakeSeptember's updates highlight two major trends shaping digital advertising: platforms are continuing to automate campaign management, while AI-powered shopping and personal agents are changing how consumers discover and purchase products. From Amazon's full-funnel campaigns to ChatGPT's expanding advertising integrations, new opportunities are emerging for advertisers willing to test. The key remains understanding where automation adds value, maintaining visibility into performance, and making sure new technology delivers measurable business results.Follow The Click Brief for fast, no-fluff performance marketing updates.Visit The Click Brief blog for more in-depth analysis and updates from September.
Jeremy Packee is flying solo for August's Click Brief while Emily Anderson is out on maternity leave, breaking down another busy month of paid media, measurement, and AI updates.Google completed its budget-limited bidding rollout, expanded AI Max testing and Performance Planner controls, and introduced more flexibility within GA4. Meanwhile, Microsoft followed Google's lead with AI Max, ChatGPT continued expanding its advertising platform, and new AI-powered analysis and reporting tools made their way into Google Ads and Analytics.Top TakeawaysBiggest Change to WatchGoogle completed its budget-limited bidding rollout for campaigns using Target CPA and Target ROAS. Advertisers may see changes in auction activity, CPCs, and overall efficiency, making these campaigns especially important to monitor.Testing UpgradeGoogle expanded AI Max experiments with multi-campaign testing and additional brand and location controls, giving advertisers more flexibility to test automation under conditions that better reflect how campaigns actually run.Measurement WinGA4 added custom conversion windows and a campaign data import validation report, giving advertisers more control over how they evaluate performance and making it easier to incorporate and troubleshoot non-Google campaign data.Default Setting to CheckMicrosoft made AI Max generally available and is moving toward enabling it by default for new Search campaigns. As with Google, advertisers should review campaign settings carefully rather than assuming the defaults are right for every account.AI Tool Worth WatchingGoogle continues adding AI-powered analysis across Ads and Analytics, including personalized insight cards, prompt-built dashboards, automated summaries, and benchmarking through Ask Advisor. These tools can speed up first-pass analysis, but still require human context and review.Other Platform UpdatesChatGPT expanded self-service advertising internationally and added new campaign controls and automated bidding optionGoogle's Search language targeting phaseout is moving into implementationGoogle Tags are becoming full Tag Manager containers to simplify deploymentDemand Gen is expanding view-through conversion bidding, with video view-through conversions becoming more important to optimizationGoogle Ads added AI-powered homepage insights and prompt-generated dashboardsGA4 added AI overviews highlighting notable performance changesAsk Advisor can now compare performance against anonymized benchmarks from similar businessesGoogle continued expanding generative video and multimodal tools for Demand GenMicrosoft and Snap opened read-only advertising connections for AI assistantsOpenAI and Anthropic outlined additional safeguards following separate AI agent security incidentsFinal TakeAugust's updates show just how quickly AI and automation are becoming built-in parts of everyday campaign management. The new tools can make testing, reporting, and analysis faster, but defaults still deserve scrutiny. Whether it's AI Max, automated bidding, view-through conversions, or AI-generated insights, the best approach remains the same: test intentionally, understand what the platform is optimizing toward, and validate the results against actual business outcomes.Follow The Click Brief for fast, no-fluff performance marketing updates.Visit The Click Brief blog for more in-depth analysis and updates from August.
Episode Highlights
Biggest Platform Shift
Google is beginning to move Local Services Ads into Google Ads as specialized Performance Max campaigns. While bringing everything into one platform should make management easier, advertisers will lose some control, including manual bidding and service-level target CPA settings. Historical performance reports also won’t transfer, making it important to export data and establish benchmarks before migration.
Platform to Watch
OpenAI continues building ChatGPT Ads into a more complete performance advertising platform with conversion optimization, geographic exclusions, automatic budget pacing, advanced matching, bulk management through the Ads API, and updated product feed ads. Jeremy sees ChatGPT becoming a legitimate channel worth testing heading into Q4 for advertisers with the available budget.
AI Advertising Watch
Google is testing AI-generated summaries beneath paid search ads, with similar descriptions appearing on Shopping and product ads. The experiment raises questions about advertiser control when AI-generated copy can potentially appear alongside ads without being directly written or approved by the advertiser.
Competitive Landscape
One year after Amazon withdrew from U.S. Google Shopping auctions, the competitive landscape continues to shift. Some advertisers gained traffic and impression share, while competitors including Walmart, Temu, and SHEIN have moved in and out of the space, creating a different mix of competition.
AI Lab Watch
The Click Brief adds a new AI Lab Watch section covering developments beyond the advertising platforms themselves. July included new models from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Grok, Meta, and China’s Moonshot AI, along with the growing conversation around open-weight models, AI capabilities, and claims that the industry is approaching the singularity.
Other Platform & AI Updates
• Local Services Ads will remain keywordless and continue using a pay-per-lead model after moving into Google Ads
• Existing LSA customer contacts, messages, and eligible call recordings will move into Google Ads Lead Manager
• ChatGPT Ads added conversion-optimized CPC campaigns and refreshed product feed ads with prices and star ratings
• OpenAI expanded advertiser controls with geographic exclusions, automatic daily pacing, advanced matching, and bulk management
• Google’s AI-generated ad summaries remain a limited experiment, but Granular is watching for expanded testing and advertiser controls
• Amazon remains absent from U.S. Google Shopping auctions despite returning to some international markets
• New AI models and the growing divide between closed and open-weight models continue reshaping the broader AI landscape
Final Take
July was a quieter month for major paid media announcements, but the updates point to two trends worth watching: advertising platforms continue consolidating management while giving more control to automation, and AI platforms are quickly developing more sophisticated advertising capabilities. For advertisers, the priority remains the same—understand what control is being gained or lost, preserve the data you need, and test emerging channels based on real business results rather than hype.
Follow The Click Brief for fast, no-fluff performance marketing updates every month.
Visit The Click Brief blog for more in-depth analysis and updates from July
Introduction (00:23): Host Chris Cesar welcomes listeners back to Getting Granular for the 50th episode of the podcast and introduces Noah Hardy, one of Granular’s newest team members. Noah shares a bit about himself, including his nearly decade-long career in digital marketing, love of travel, video games, cooking, and life in Grafton, Wisconsin.
Getting an Early Start in Digital Marketing (03:58): Noah traces his PPC origins back to college, when he joined Milwaukee startup GenoPalate at just 19 years old. Working across everything from email and SEO to paid media and even supply chain gave him broad experience, but the speed and measurable results of PPC quickly stood out.
Why Paid Media Stuck (06:53): The ability to make a change and see tangible business results drew Noah toward paid media. He reflects on how PPC has evolved over the past decade, from granular keyword structures and easier tracking to increasingly automated platforms driven by algorithms, creative, and conversion signals.
Finding His Strength in Paid Social (09:17): Noah discusses his passion for paid social, particularly creative strategy and testing. He explains how developing new messages, formats, and creative concepts can produce significant growth when marketers find ideas that truly resonate with an audience.
From VaynerMedia to Granular (10:35): After working with e-commerce brands and major clients like Bose, Noah eventually found his way to Granular. He shares why the agency’s collaborative culture, experienced team, strong client relationships, and return to in-person work have made Granular stand out from previous roles.
Building Trust With Clients (14:32): Noah explains that strong client relationships start with understanding the business behind the campaigns. From margins and profitability to growth goals and individual communication needs, he believes good PPC management requires understanding both the numbers and the people behind them.
Reporting Beyond Surface-Level Results (17:48): When evaluating campaign performance, Noah focuses on incrementality, profitability, testing, and context rather than simply reporting that revenue went up or down. He discusses using experiments, historical comparisons, and seasonality to understand what actually drove performance and what marketers should do next.
AI and the Future of PPC (19:41): Noah sees AI as one of the biggest forces shaping paid media, but doesn’t believe PPC professionals are about to be replaced by AI agents. Instead, he’s excited about using AI to automate time-consuming tasks and tackle complex data analysis, freeing marketers to spend more time on higher-value strategic work.
Keeping Humans in Control of Automation (23:47): As Google and other platforms remove more manual levers, Noah discusses the shift from hands-on campaign management toward guiding increasingly sophisticated algorithms. While automation can improve performance, he cautions against a future of “just trust me, bro” campaigns where advertisers lose visibility and control.
The Evolution of YouTube Measurement (26:29): Noah and Chris explore the challenge of proving YouTube’s performance value, particularly for smaller advertisers without access to expensive measurement models. Noah highlights attributed branded searches as an especially promising development for connecting upper-funnel YouTube activity to measurable business results.
Words of Wisdom: Find Work You Enjoy (30:31): Noah encourages listeners not to waste years doing work they hate. After experiencing roles that weren’t the right fit, he says his first few months at Granular have reinforced the value of finding work—and a company—that makes the day-to-day genuinely enjoyable.
Wrap-Up (31:53): Chris thanks Noah for joining the podcast and helping celebrate Getting Granular’s 50th episode. Noah embraces the honor of becoming the milestone guest before Chris encourages listeners to subscribe for more PPC tips, insights, and digital marketing conversations.








