DiscoverGood VR Podcast
Good VR Podcast
Claim Ownership

Good VR Podcast

Author: Ian Hamilton

Subscribed: 3Played: 74
Share

Description

Audio from people building toward good VR. Read more about Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com and support independent journalism directly.

www.goodvirtualreality.com
69 Episodes
Reverse
At the start of October Kent Bye joined the Good VR Podcast for a discussion about his work in VR over the last decade. He’s a regular on the festival circuit and can often be found at VR-focused conferences standing in a hallway holding a microphone and in conversation with someone for the Voices of VR Podcast.He’s closing in on 2,000 episodes for his podcast and he’s caught up with me four times between 2019 and 2026, giving me space to offer my perspective on the changing landscape of technology. Now I’ve been able to pull him onto the Good VR Podcast.“I feel like we’re still the very nascent phases,” he said. “I do actually think that the grammar of VR has reached a certain level of maturity and that we’re still at the very early beginnings and that so much of what people think about the industry has been driven by Meta and gaming. But there’s all these other things that I think we’re kind of at the very beginning of Meta taking a bit of a step back and letting the more organic innovation come out of things like Steam Frame and no sort of arbitrary walled barriers to entry based upon Meta’s own interest. Now developers are able to develop their own interests.”This episode published first to paid subscribers of the Good VR Podcast. Thank you so much for your support. I recorded a another podcast with Bye publishing publicly on November 12 that will appear alongside a video interview with RUST LTD.’s Anton Hand as well as a review of Hot Dogs, Horseshoes & Hand Grenades 2.This post has bonus content for paid subscribers. Upgrade to get full access. Get full access to Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com/subscribe
Successfully loading a single round into a Springfield 1884 rifle brings my ear about half a dozen sounds from over 150 unique audio samples recorded for that gun. When I try operating a particular handgun and can’t manage, I think I’m encountering a bug and tell game director Anton Hand. He asks if I’m left-handed. That particular handgun’s safety can only be switched off in the right hand of the operator.“I told you,” he writes. “We built a simulator.”VR is maturing as a medium and H3VR2 is the proof:* Beat Saber had appeal from early access in 2018, but H3VR2 challenges in more ways than speed slicing.* Half-Life: Alyx introduced gorgeous environments and carefully animated characters to marvel at from 2020, but in H3VR2 I feel good just loading up my gun in the corner of a room and counting the rounds in my chest pocket to strategize how I get past my next challenge.* Movements in H3VR2 don’t have the waggly feel of Bonelab or The Walking Dead: Saints & Sinners.* RUST LTD. does more with the processing power of Quest 3 than Meta’s dramatically more expensive productions Asgard’s Wrath 2 and Deadpool VR.* Watching a ball bounce around the greens in Walkabout Mini Golf is an enticing sight, but in H3VR2 I’m mesmerized by accidentally dropping rounds on the ground and watching half a dozen cylinders roll in different directions.When I leave a room and realize halfway across the map I left an important tool lying on a table, it’s still sitting right where I left it when I get back. When I cower in a bathroom I can hear through the walls exactly where my enemies are shuffling through the nearby hallway. So much of this experience is totally rewarding.I find it a little bit more unsettling to shoot a human in VR than on a screen. Some VR developers feel the same and choose zombies or shadowy figures as targets. RUST LTD. chooses big meaty wieners. What do you feel when you press a button to shoot people with guns in your interactive fiction? How often do you feel anything? Playing as The Handy in H3VR2, I feel immense relief and personal satisfaction every time I see yellow mustard spurting from a hot dog I beat.“Death by Handy?” one hot dog asks before splattering. “Oh god.”I’m in another hallway beating a hot dog into submission.“Do I have a wife?” it asks. “Wait. Am I a wife?”“Facility” is defined in multiple ways, including “something that is built, installed or established to serve a particular purpose” or “the quality of being easily performed.” H3VR2 as a work of art fits the first definition and the player embodies the second definition. This creates the most satisfying VR game ever designed. Interactions in Hot Dogs, Horseshoes & Hand Grenades 2 engage players constantly to reward facility.Hands & FacilityI explore H3VR2 in almost exactly the opposite way as Grand Theft Auto. In a GTA game there’s a chance after 10 hours of play I haven’t engaged with the campaign at all. I’ve spent 100% of my time playing as an agent of mayhem in a sandbox respawning from run-ins with the cops every few minutes. In H3VR2, I visit the certifications to learn how gun handling works and then immediately focus on runs of the Facility campaign. I play the game simply hiding from active engagement with guards and still end up respawning every 20 minutes or so. After death, each player retubes back at the hub in another squirt of mustard and meat. You don’t see a body when you look down at yourself. The Handy, however, does get visible hands in a key design departure from H3VR1.The player saw nothing of their own body and hands from the release of the original game in 2016. That design decision emerged from a long look at VR hardware across the decade. Every controller through Quest 2 in 2020 featured a bulky tracking ring. Since Quest Pro in 2022, controllers ship as ringless rumbling handheld objects. For Hand, those rings blocked players from certain kinds of intricate mechanical gesturing ideal for the precise simulation of showing your hands handling a gun.In H3VR2, pinch a single round between your thumb and index finger by pressing the trigger or wear a controller strap to grasp the grip button too, grabbing a handful of rounds in your whole hand in the process. Push a magazine into your handgun with your hands brushing one another, before pulling back the slide. You can even move it forward to slowly watch the round slip into the chamber. You can’t jam a gun in the launch version of H3VR2 but Hand says that’s on the roadmap. Reach over your shoulder to grab your backpack or reach a little further to pull forward your rifle or shotgun. Learn to keep your finger off the trigger when you’re not ready to fire so you don’t accidentally spend a much-needed round. “Don’t point your gun at anyone” is the first rule of real-world safe gun handling. If you follow that rule in H3VR2, you can probably get through the first two levels of the Facility campaign.At launch in late 2026 there are just five levels in Facility and, for each, a distinct procedurally generated map. At the end of each run, you return to the hub where you process your loot or play in the sandboxes, challenges, and certification training. After roughly 15 hours of play I reached level three of the main Facility campaign about half a dozen times, with some combination of procedurally generated bad luck, lack of preparedness, or limited skill ending each run. I reached the fifth level at 20 hours of play with difficulty on easy.You extract meat, mustard, and metal from your runs. The vending machine, aka VendO, carries a collection of apps accessible through a menu you’ll need to understand to access better gear. The recycling chute is for tossing in items and raw resources. You can also pull chips out of the side of the VendO machines you find in your runs and extract them from the map to insert them into the machine in the hub and spawn new items. Spawning new rounds, guns, and items can give you an advantage heading into your next run. You can increase your capacities for resources and squeeze a little bit of efficiency out of your economy. Examples include expanding the number of slots for extracting resources after each level of a run, increasing the resources you gain from recycling, and a discount for items you purchase from the store using currency found in your runs.Developing Hands From H3VR1 To H3VR2H3VR1 debuted in 2016 when PCVR headsets were the only path to good VR. Its release marked the culmination of roughly a decade of experience in VR for Hand. In the decade since, he’s eked out an existence in PCVR only by adding new pieces to this title designed in an ancient version of Unity. As Meta pushed standalone headsets, Hand kept the flame of PCVR computing alive. Year after year he sold his $20 early access game to players forced to look for uncompromising simulation by streaming it from Steam on powerful PCs to their underpowered wireless VR headsets. Earlier this year, that title reached version 1.0 on PCs and RUST LTD. ripped off the early access label.Now I take the $40 price of H3VR2 as a bold statement from its creators. The decisions that went into this game position it as both an argument and a platform. The argument? Simulation as an art form is distinct from all others. When you respect the differences between VR and flatscreen gaming in the fundamentals of your design, a small independent team can ship something more complex and satisfying than anything made by Valve, Meta, or Sony.The platform? The most advanced and satisfying gun handling ever devised for interactive software. RUST LTD. packaged it up in a clean user interface that runs wirelessly in standalone VR. H3VR1 is Certified Good VR and H3VR2 builds on what I wrote about it:H3VR reaches with two hands into VR and grasps what traditional games overlooked as too mundane to be interesting for the press of a button. In these moments and their interactions H3VR proves VR’s worth not as a videogame platform but as a place worth… Get full access to Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com/subscribe
Today on Good Virtual Reality you can read my review of Hot Dogs, Horseshoes & Hand Grenades 2. That piece is combined with an interview with game director Anton Hand where I asked about the hard pills that need to be swallowed now by his existing PCVR fans. They have to decide whether they can wait for the PCVR release or want the game now so much that they’ll get a Quest 3 for it. Paid subscribers also have early access to a discussion I recorded back in October with Voices of VR Podcast host Kent Bye as we consider the long road ahead for VR. When I heard that Bye put dozens of hours into H3VR2 pre-release, I scheduled another discussion with him earlier this week to make sure we marked this moment in time. I was shocked when I heard he started playing the game one day at 1 p.m. and broke only for the restroom and food through 3 p.m. the following day. Outside of VRChat, a 26-hour VR binge session like that is basically unheard of. I also understand it. H3VR2 is an extraordinary piece of software and I’ll be curious to see if anybody else finds themselves this hooked by the work.“I’m gonna call it the best VR game. I’m gonna call it for myself,” Bye said on the Good VR Podcast. “I don’t know if anybody will agree, but I’m gonna call it because I have my own experience of it…I feel the same way that I felt when I saw Beat Saber at GDC in 2018. I was like, there is something here that is going to sort of take off and go viral. I feel something similar with this in terms of [being] really excited to see what people do when they get a hold of this game and have their own exploration about what kind of world that he’s creating.”H3VR2 Review & Anton Hand InterviewYou can donate any amount via Stripe to support my work at Good Virtual Reality and thank you to my paid Substack subscribers for supporting independent journalism.https://buy.stripe.com/7sY8wPeTAcnG3eD1vZao800For those interested in diving deeper into H3VR and H3VR2, I have a two-hour video interview with Hand covering his full journey as an artist published when he announced H3VR2 as well as a conversation covering the development of H3VR1 when the game exited early access after 10 years. Get full access to Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com/subscribe
I finally became a paid subscriber to The Verge after reading a thoughtful piece titled “Can VR glasses save VR?” based on Sean Hollister’s time with the Meta VR Glasses at the recent developer conference.Here’s the bit that pushed me over the edge as Hollister breaks down the difference between transparent AR optics and VR optics with passthrough video:Virtual objects can seem ghostly unless you activate electrochromic lenses, which turn the clear lenses dark at the push of a button, blocking your view of the world.Even then, you can see games, movies, and virtual desktops far better in a VR headset, where virtual light and real light don’t have to compete. You see the real world through what’s called “passthrough vision” — a live camera feed — with virtual objects realistically appearing at the correct depth and blocking real-life objects behind them.This breakdown highlights a conclusion I’ve held closely for a long time about the race to make computerized eyewear. Fundamentally, optics that are transparent show the physical world in higher fidelity at the cost of virtual content appearing ghostly. Meanwhile, opaque optics for virtual reality experiences deliver higher fidelity content at the cost of the physical world appearing dramatically lower fidelity than what your eyes can see directly, using what Hollister calls “passthrough vision”.“I would not say it was always a given that it would move faster, it would get better quickly enough, more quickly, than transparent optics would get better,” Hollister said on the Good VR Podcast.This simple sentence outlines why Magic Leap was able to raise billions for its AR headsets and Microsoft shipped multiple HoloLens generations before that optical pathway faltered. Ultimately, Snap’s Specs at $2200 and Meta VR Glasses at $1300 emerge as the latest examples of these opposing optical paths, with the XREAL Aura powered by Android XR emerging as an intriguing in-between solution. I believe the micro‑OLED panels found in the Meta VR Glasses and Apple Vision Pro put VR on the path to benefitting from economies of scale that will, over time, enable VR to ship with less weight on the head, lower prices, and with the visual quality necessary to jump past our 4K televisions.“3D movies have been a revelation for me on headsets,” Hollister said on the podcast. “Disney’s Moana where…you’re in a normal 2D theater or watching it on your big screen OLED TV, the colors are beautiful. The waters part to let baby Moana scoop up the heart of Te Fiti on the beach. The ocean has entrusted her with this precious jewel that she needs to restore. And so the water scoops out of the way and it’s like there’s this wall of water surrounding her. And that’s really cool, very cool CG. And then you see the same scene in 3D and you’re like, this is not a wall of water. This is a block of water. This is a three-dimensional prism made of water. It is the ocean with life swimming inside of it. And you can see the life swimming…and the depth of that. And this is a kids’ movie that I was really tired of my kids making me watch over and over again. And I’m experiencing it again like I’m seeing it for the first time. And it is incredible.”I recorded a video version of this podcast with Sean Hollister which I’m publishing first to paid YouTube members. In the weeks since recording this episode, I’ve gotten my personal Recreation Room into camera-ready shape and am readying to produce more video content overall. My first paid member happens to also be the person who wrote for Good Virtual Reality about using Vision Pro as a sleep aid, so I’ve published the video version first for him and I encourage you to become a member on YouTube to see it early as well as to receive my upcoming video reports first.I’ve got audio-only chats with Voices of VR’s Kent Bye, Walkabout art director Don Carson, and more coming first in the days ahead to paid subscribers on Substack. As always, thank you for the support.This post has bonus content for paid subscribers. Upgrade to get full access. Get full access to Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com/subscribe
The Ferryman Collective and Virtual Worlds Company just won an Emmy for their production of Uncanny Alley: A New Day performed inside VRChat.The Good VR Podcast hosted the Ferryman Collective’s Deirdre V. Lyons and Stephen Butchko in the weeks before the awards ceremony and now I’ve spoken with Brendan A. Bradley, who performed as nine different characters in Uncanny Alley: A New Day. “When the metaverse became a company and not a community, that was fundamentally a problem. Because then I can’t go off and build my nerdy theater, and someone else can’t go off and build their business and their interest, and someone can’t start an architecture firm and someone else can’t start a library,” Bradley said on The Good VR Podcast. “Because we’re not building a community and a protocol for everyone to build on top of. We’re trying to limit a storefront of what then goes on the shelves and what doesn’t go on the shelves…that need to transact can often disrupt the techniques that make for best practices, especially in an emerging market and an emerging industry.”Bradley began making VR Theatre in 2020 with Jettison in Mozilla Hubs which was nominated for the Producer Guild of America’s Innovation Award alongside Tender Claws’ run of The Tempest in VR, Alex Coulombe at Agile Lens and the Ferryman Collective’s early work in VRChat. Overall, he’s focused on fostering an ongoing collaborative community of best practices for live performance in XR.“I think that it is always extremely exciting when outsiders value the work that we’re doing…ever. It has been very, very difficult to get people to understand the why of virtual reality. And so the award itself, I think, is a helpful marketing tool…My parents know what an Emmy is. They do not know what an Auggie is. They were very proud of me for both. But they can tell their friends about an Emmy. They couldn’t tell their friends about an Auggie.” Get full access to Good Virtual Reality at www.goodvirtualreality.com/subscribe
loading
Comments