DiscoverIn Their Own Words
In Their Own Words
Claim Ownership

In Their Own Words

Author: The Deming Institute

Subscribed: 153Played: 4,850
Share

Description

Interviews with members of The Deming Institute community, including industry leaders, practitioners, educators, Deming family members and others who share their stories of transformation and success through the innovative management and quality theories of Dr. W. Edwards Deming.
214 Episodes
Reverse
What if most CEOs misunderstand their real job? It's a question the legendary management thinker Dr. W. Edwards Deming loved to ask. Too often, leaders make decisions that seem smart for one department, only to create bigger problems somewhere else in the organization.   In this episode, systems strategist Dr. Sheila Ronis shares what she learned working alongside Deming at Bell, Ford, and General Motors. She takes you inside the breakup of the Bell System, when the whole country still needed to hear a dial tone, and explains why leaders must understand the whole system, not just its individual parts.   If you've ever wondered why well-intentioned decisions sometimes make things worse, this conversation will give you a simple, practical way to look at your own organization.   🎧 Listen to discover what Deming believed a leader's real job should be, and why his thinking matters today.   TRANSCRIPT 0:00:03.0 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz. And I'll be your host, as we continue our journey into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today, I'm here with featured guest, Dr. Sheila Ronis. And I am excited to hear about you and your journey. So are you ready to share your journey, Sheila?   0:00:23.5 Sheila Ronis: I certainly am.   0:00:25.1 Andrew Stotz: You've had quite a journey. I want to introduce you to the audience here. So I'm really delighted to welcome Dr. Sheila Ronis, President of The University Group Partners, a systems strategist, educator, and consultant who learned from, and worked with, Dr. W. Edwards Deming. She has applied systems thinking to business, government, national security, and strategic foresight, for more than five decades. And what you're gonna hear, as you listen to this story, is this journey that she's been through, from the Bell Systems, which is going back all the way... I think it was originally founded in 1870s, or something like that. And your journey from working at Bell Labs, and Bell System; to Ford, another giant; to GM, another giant; and then to the ultimate giant, the US government. So why don't you tell us a little bit about your journey?   0:01:26.2 Sheila Ronis: Okay. Well, I was really fortunate because I met Dr. Deming in 1979, when he gave lectures to every new Bell executive who was hired, and especially, young people who were in their high potential group. And I came to Bell, already having my doctorate, and a major assignment with Oak Ridge National Laboratory, before the Department of Energy even existed. And it was really wonderful, because it was very clear to me that the way he thought, was very similar to the way I thought. We were both educated as classical physicists. And so at the break, I went up to him and was just visiting, and saying how excited I was that he had his degrees in physics and mathematics, and that although, it was only my undergraduate degree in physics and mathematics. And he said, "Yes. But it says doctor on your tag." And I said, "Well, that's because my master's and doctorate, were in large complex social system behavior." And his eyes lit up, because he said, "Oh, my goodness." He said, "You and I need to talk more."   0:02:56.2 Sheila Ronis: And it began a dialogue and a discussion, that really didn't end until he passed away in 1993. And I was just so lucky to be able to work with him, first, in the Bell system, and during the Bell system reorganization, from 1982 to 1984. And then shortly thereafter, I worked with him at Ford Motor Company. And it was after that, that I worked with him, with Bob Dorn at General Motors. Bob Dorn then, was the chief engineer for the entire portfolio of General Motors vehicles. First, he was at Cadillac. And Cadillac won the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award while he was there, because he took... Bob took Dr. Deming very seriously. And it was just a tremendous experience to work, both with Bob, and with Dr. Deming.   0:04:04.6 Sheila Ronis: In fact, Bob and I wrote a paper that Dr. Deming helped us write. And I think we presented it at one of the Deming Institute events. And that was in 1990, I believe. And anyway...   0:04:26.3 Andrew Stotz: I wonder if we can go back to that first meeting, when you first... Yeah. Let's just try to understand, was it 20 people in the room? Was it 500 people in the room? And what was your first impressions, as you started listening to this guy that you'd never heard of before?   0:04:45.9 Sheila Ronis: That's true. I didn't know who he was. But it was really interesting. There were only about 30 of us, because we were hired into management directly. And that was very unusual for the old Bell System. They hired people, first, to be in the line, usually. And you didn't get into management automatically. But people, like me, who already had higher education and advanced degrees, we were in a special category. But I was very interested in becoming a line executive, because I wanted that experience, to actually manage people, not just be in a staff position of some kind. And it was really amazing, because it was very clear from his discussions... Even though he talked a great deal about statistical process control, and the need for the use of statistics in the management of process... He, really, was conveying a management philosophy toward people. And that was obvious from the beginning.   0:06:14.6 Sheila Ronis: And I thought to myself, "My goodness. This is not just a technical person. This is a very intense individual, but with a depth of understanding in the truest, Verstehen, German sense." And of course, that Verstehen led to Profound Knowledge, and his ultimate System of Profound Knowledge. And it was his management philosophy that, in my view, at that time especially, put him heads... And just way above all the other people who I had been reading about, who were trying to technically control processes in manufacturing sectors, and things like that. And it just made him a completely different kind of person, and a completely different kind of consultant, and somebody who really understood the human dimension of an institution, and an organization.   0:07:30.1 Sheila Ronis: And without that, US industry was going nowhere. Because they didn't care about the human dimension. They thought that, what they called, soft issues, were of little value, and were not even important enough to invest in. And of course, they were dead wrong. Whereas, as Dr. Deming started to address the issues with the Japanese, he basically said, "It's the human dimension. You lead people, you manage process. And when something goes wrong, it's the system you have to look at, not the people. You give them the right tools, they will do fine, because they want to do a good job for you." And it was that philosophy that was very much conveyed in that very first day of that meeting, of that training.   0:08:36.3 Andrew Stotz: There was no ambiguity of what he was saying. You were... How old were you, roughly, at that time?   0:08:42.2 Sheila Ronis: 29.   0:08:43.8 Andrew Stotz: Okay. So '79, and...   0:08:47.2 Sheila Ronis: He was 50 years older than me.   0:08:48.8 Andrew Stotz: Yeah.   0:08:50.9 Sheila Ronis: And it was after he passed away, that I learned that he gave the famous 1950 lecture, literally, while I was being born on the same day. At about 8:30, it was an after-dinner speech, he made to all the industrialists of Japan, or 75% of them, or something. Well, at 8:30 in the morning, which was about the same time as he was speaking in Japan, I was born.   0:09:19.1 Andrew Stotz: Mm-hmm. A connection.   0:09:20.8 Sheila Ronis: I always knew I had a karmic relationship with this man.   0:09:23.7 Andrew Stotz: Yeah. And I was just thinking about, I was 24 in 1989, so 10 years later, when I first sat in front of him. And I got the same thing. And I was working on the factory floor at Pepsi, in manufacturing, and warehouse distribution. And I saw all the troubles. And it was clear, as a young guy with no experience, really, of managing anything, it was clear to me... Everything he said, was just so clear. And I think what you've expressed, is something that people that never have met him, or study with him, don't realize that he really is a humanist, and he believed in the potential of people, and he believed in the potential of intrinsic motivation. So that's a great, great way to start of the... Think about that. Day one, of your Deming journey, started with this incredible awakening. Or maybe, it's not even an awakening, because part of what he was trying to teach was that it's inherent in us. He was just letting it... "Hey, here's how we bring it out."   0:10:33.8 Sheila Ronis: And it was very contrary to a lot of the scientific management principles, that I think led a lot of people astray in many ways. Because they treated the human being as a cog in a wheel. And people are not cogs in wheels. They are agents. And the moment you put an agent into a system, first of all, it's nonlinear, it is complex, and you can't predict it. And management is supposed to be able to predict and control. And yeah, they can predict and control some things, like process, if they're in control. But people are a whole different story.   0:11:22.3 Andrew Stotz: Exactly. And okay. So let's go from 1979, to... Where is the next time that you have the next meaningful interaction? But before you go there, I just want to highlight one thing that you mentioned about when you went up to him to talk at the break. Here's a guy, 79 years old... And when I saw him, he was 89... And he just welcomed people coming up and talking. And that was his break time. For me, I'm like, "I need a rest."   0:11:47.6 Sheila Ronis: He was. He was so approachable. And I was so excited that he would talk to me. Who was I? This little girl from Cleveland, Ohio. And of course, it was later that I realized he was from Wyoming. So it was okay.   0:12:05.2 Andrew Stotz: Yep. Okay. So what was the next meaningful step in that jou
What do you fix first when everything seems to need attention? Caroline faced that question while helping former students navigate life beyond United Schools. She wanted to jump in and start fixing everything, but she took a surprising step instead. In this episode, John Dues shares how a simple Post-it exercise helped them clarify what was affecting much of her department's work and gave Caroline a direction for her energy. Along the way, he and host Andrew Stotz get into "solutionitis," the danger of seeing too much, and why tempting solutions can lead us astray.   If you've ever felt the pull to just do something, this one is for you.   TRANSCRIPT 0:00:02.1 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz and I'll be your host as we dive deeper into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today I'm continuing my discussion with John Dues, who is part of the new generation of educators striving to apply Dr. Deming's principles to unleash student joy in learning. Now, the topic for today is See Before You Solve, and it gets to a tension that I think we all face and leaders face. We know something needs to improve and our instinct is to immediately start figuring out what to do about it. Like, "Do something, don't just stand there." And John, before we turn on the recorder, you mentioned something about the alumni services department at United Schools and what you were doing with it and what was happening a few years ago. Maybe you can kick off with that.   0:01:00.2 John Dues: Yeah, I thought, well, it's good to be back, Andrew. And I thought it'd be interesting... This has come up and in my work, and kind of, applying some of these Deming ideas. The Deming philosophy to something real life sometimes can help kind of bring it alive. So I thought this could be an interesting topic for this episode. And for folks that... We haven't mentioned United Schools in a while, but that's where I work. It's a K-8 system. It's a bit unique in that our relationship with our students doesn't end after that eighth grade year. We don't have a high school in our system right now. And so what we do have, kind of the next best thing, is this alumni services department that serves those eighth graders once they leave our program and then go on to high school. And they not only follow them... The folks in that department... They don't just follow them into high school, but beyond too.   0:01:55.8 John Dues: So once they get through high school and they help them sort of navigate that, then whatever it is they do next, whether that's college or military, trade, or a career, we continue to provide follow-on services. And that department has a director that I work with on a regular basis. Her name's Caroline Durbin, and she was kind of a high school counselor and then came to work for us about seven years ago and has kind of built this department from scratch. And so she... Lots of things kind of went off the rails during the pandemic in schools. And kind of, along those lines, she's thinking about, as we're kind of, turning a corner a few years ago from that pandemic time, or at least the heart of it, she knew that her department needed to improve too. And I think the thing that she was struggling with, though, was where does she start? There's no shortage of possibilities when you run a department like that.   0:02:58.3 John Dues: She was thinking about things like, how do you increase alumni engagement? How do you get kids, once they leave us, to enroll in those services? How do you deal with information about alumni that's incomplete? And there were some other pain points too. Any one of these things could have become its own improvement project. And I think that's a situation that a lot of leaders face. It's like, you know things aren't working as well as they should. You see five or [chuckle] even 10 legitimate problems that you could tackle, and the natural reaction is then, "Okay, which one of these are we going to fix? Where do we start?" That's the kind of thing.   0:03:42.0 Andrew Stotz: Yeah. And before we get to where you're going to start, I want to tip my hat to Caroline and also to my counselor from high school, Fred Zigler. Fred helped a lot of us at a very challenging time in our lives. And I was thinking about this idea of alumni services for you guys. Like, "Oh, just let them go, kids go." But really, the relationships that we build are so critical. And Fred helped me address alcohol and drug addiction and get me into treatment, talked with my parents, helped me. And to this day. Now, that was 1982 when he helped me, and to this day, I'm still in touch with him and still see the value that he brought to my life at that moment. So just tipping my hat there. So, John.   0:04:29.9 John Dues: Yeah, that's incredible. In fact, Caroline, just this week, one of the things they do is they take our alumni once they get into high school, they take them on college visits. So they just went to Kent State and Xavier, two different groups this week, and she led them on those college visits. Pretty cool stuff.   0:04:46.5 Andrew Stotz: I imagine the Kent State campus has changed a lot since I was there studying, but yeah, just a good memory right there. So tell us, where did you start?   0:04:57.8 John Dues: Yeah, I mean, I think that's a great question. What we did was we didn't just pick one of those problems and immediately get to work. The first thing that we did together was just sort of slow things down a bit and really what we were trying to do is just kind of step back and start by trying to better understand what was happening. And so basically, we just literally took the various pain points that Caroline brainstormed, the different things she was seeing in her department. We just literally wrote each one on a Post-it note. Then we took the Post-it notes and kind of grouped them into common themes. And then we basically looked at how each of those themes was impacting the others. And over time, we basically used this exercise to see which one had the most arrows pointing away from it, meaning it was causing other problems. And the thing that came out on top was unknown alumni data.   0:06:09.8 John Dues: So basically, what was happening was that we didn't always have or completely capture students' data as they were leaving us or, over time, things would change. They would change high schools or change programs or whatever. And so we had all this incomplete information about our alumni. And that really was impacting Caroline's ability to understand other parts of the department's work. I mean, it made it hard to know how former students were doing, where did they need support, and it also made it hard to understand where our efforts were actually making a difference. So that gave Caroline a place to start.   0:06:51.5 Andrew Stotz: So she knew she had problems before you did the exercise. So what changed?   0:06:58.8 John Dues: Yeah, I mean, I think she didn't necessarily have more information, but she just had this better way of seeing the information that she already had, frankly. And that's an important distinction. Caroline knew something needed to improve, but she didn't start by choosing a solution. She started by literally stepping back and seeing her alumni system.   0:07:27.0 Andrew Stotz: And I guess this is probably pretty hard for all of us in leadership in that we get caught up in what we're doing and then we kind of narrow our focus, I'm thinking. So we tend to jump from seeing a problem directly to just trying to say, "Let's fix this. Do something."   0:07:45.2 John Dues: Yeah. And I think, that's what we're paid to do as leaders. We're paid to solve problems. And I think it's natural that when something isn't working, we turn our attention toward some type of action because that feels good. What are we going to change? Who's going to do it? How quickly can we get started? And I don't think that bias towards action is inherently bad because organizations, you don't improve your organization by endlessly discussing your problems or admiring your problems. Eventually, you have to act. But I think knowing that a system needs to improve, it's not the same as knowing where to begin. And I think that's really where leaders can get into trouble. This disappointing result appears and then immediately plausible solutions start coming to mind. This happens all the time. Your reading scores are low, adopt a new curriculum. Your team has communication problems, let's add another meeting to the calendar. A department's having trouble keeping track of its work, let's buy a new technology platform. And sometimes those things can be useful, but I think that the key thing is that seeing a problem isn't the same as understanding what's producing that underlying problem.   0:09:13.1 Andrew Stotz: And I think you use the term solutionitis. [laughter] What…tell us about that?   0:09:20.7 John Dues: Yeah, I mean, I like a lot of these ideas. I can't take credit. I'm sure I came across it in a book. I think maybe Learning to Improve, Tony Bryk's book, is maybe where I originally saw that. But basically, solutionitis is this tendency to prescribe changes before we've adequately understood what's happening. So the thing is we make this leap almost immediately from "something isn't working" to "here's what we should do about it." And I think the real problem is when that solution comes before an adequate diagnosis. And one of the dangers there is that then the most visible problem or maybe the most frustrating problem, it isn't necessarily always the best place to focus improvement or where to start, 'cause problems rarely exist in isolation. They're part of a system, and it's the relationship among those parts that can be just as important as the individual problems themselves. And I think that's really what that Post-it exercise, a very simple Post-it exercise with Caroline, it helped us to kind of, see together eventually.   0:10:31.4 A
What if the way you measure performance is actually making your organization worse? Balaji Reddie and Andrew Stotz dig into Points 7 through 9 of Deming's 14 Points: leadership as a Socratic act of asking rather than answering, why 'drive out fear' is really about removing the fear of telling the truth, and how breaking down departmental silos sometimes means one team taking a loss for the good of the whole. Along the way: KPIs, internal competition, and why they so often undermine the system they're meant to improve. The episode closes with Dr. Deming's own words: leadership carries a responsibility to make a difference. TRANSCRIPT 0:00:02.4 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz, and I'll be your host as we dive deeper into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today, I'm continuing my discussion with Balaji Reddie, an educator and trainer in the teachings of Dr. Deming and quality management more broadly. Balaji, how are you?   0:00:17.3 Balaji Reddie: Oh, I'm fine this morning. How are you, Andrew?   0:00:19.8 Andrew Stotz: I'm excited. Last time we talked, we talked about points four, five, and six. We packed a lot into that one.   0:00:25.5 Balaji Reddie: Oh, yeah.   0:00:25.8 Andrew Stotz: I'm interested in what we'll get through today.   0:00:28.9 Balaji Reddie: Yeah, right. And as we logged off the last time, of course, I had a hard stop to be made because I had another engagement at the end of the hour that we had. But it occurred to me later on that I should have mentioned something more. So I thought I'll just do a quick recap about what we did the last time we met, and then we proceed from there on.   0:00:54.4 Andrew Stotz: Oh, that's neat.   0:00:54.8 Balaji Reddie: Best part about doing this is there is no time limit, right? So we're taking it easy to finish whatever we have. But here we go. So points number four, five, and six is what we discussed the last time. And point number four, working very closely with your suppliers, don't go for the cheapest, go for the best, and calculate life cycle cost and things like that. So, I should have mentioned a particular person at that time. This was the lady who was working on behalf of MIT CAES, Center for Advanced Engineering Study, they are the people who originally published Out of the Crisis and The New Economics. And if you know, The New Economics second edition came out in '94, March '94, after Dr. Deming had passed away. And that's when in my early days in the Deming world, and I was when the internet came in and I was sending out emails to people I knew, might've seen... Whose pictures I saw on the net, including Henry. Henry was... We started a correspondence first by what you call snail mail, if I may call it. And then when the internet came a year after we were corresponding, that's when we started corresponding on email. And that too, he was not very conversant with it initially. He had a secretary, and so she would send me the mail and I would send her the mail, and then... It was on her ID. And then slowly she, I think, left the British Deming Association, and then Henry was all on his own. And that's when email, then one after the other started sending. So I needed to cite some portions of the book, and then I got in touch with the Deming Institute, and Dave Nave used to look into the emails in those days. Dave Nave and, bless his soul, Bill Ratcliff, if you know, Dr. Deming's son-in-law. So, they guided me. They said that you need to speak to Elizabeth Dorenzo, the lady who edited the second edition of The New Economics, which came out in March '94. So...   0:03:10.7 Andrew Stotz: It's the one I have right here, second edition.   0:03:13.5 Balaji Reddie: Yeah. That's the one. Yeah. It had a different cover, by the way, but this is an, I think, the 2000 print. This is a 2000 print.   0:03:22.1 Andrew Stotz: Right.   0:03:22.9 Balaji Reddie: Yeah, they changed the cover in the year 2000. In 1994 to 2000, the cover was quite different. I have that. I don't have it with me right now. But she told me something very interesting. First of all, she said she was expecting twins at that time. And the joke was, what will come out first, the book or the twins?   [laughter]   0:03:46.7 Balaji Reddie: Because she was racing against the clock and trying to get that book published. And the one point she said that he kept working on, because she kept getting notes from Joyce and Cecelia Kilian, his secretary, typed out notes, handwritten notes, which he wanted to be put into the book, was on point number four. So he was working on that till the day he passed away, about different worlds, different scenarios of working with suppliers, especially the point which we spoke of, work towards a single source. And he said it cannot happen overnight. However, he said in certain scenarios, if all of them are offering the same quality, then you'd be a fool not to go for the cheapest among those, right? And he was giving his... Trying to be... So there were many... There's World 1, World 2. So if you have the book The New Economics, these appear in the appendix: World 1, World 2, World 3, World 4, et cetera. And later on I found that he also gave them these as handouts during his four days... The four worlds in which you work with your suppliers and so on and so forth. So, being very, very practical in the application of what he meant. So that was one. And point number five, of course, we spoke about that you need to constantly improve. But he also cautioned what he meant by improvement, because he said here that improvement is of course taking the performance to another level, but these were in a different sense. He said when people come to you with problems. And remember, a problem is something that you did not anticipate that could happen. So, be welcoming of problems, and you need to look at it as a ways and means of understanding your process better. So the spirit was more of that. That was point number five.   0:05:37.0 Balaji Reddie: And then point number six we looked at, training should be reconstructed from ground up. And he meant in both ways, training on the job and off the job training. But the main thing is, he said that you need to help a person as a part of the training understand how they're contributing to the entire system. Because when a person knows why, they always perform the job better. I think he gave some examples of what that meant. So that was the point number six. Now we get to point number seven, which gets really interesting. So let me just pull up what he had to say in the text of point number seven. So here we go. Right, this is four, five, six, and now we come to seven. Now he says here, "Adopt and institute leadership." And interestingly, in the mimeographed book, the word was "supervision." And then he replaced it. In fact, I have that copy of that book where his handwriting is there, he's scratched out "supervision" and written "leadership." So he had it in mind. The 1982 edition of the 14 points, he wrote "supervision" there. But let's understand why he wrote that word, because I saw that word even in Dr. Juran's book, the 1964 edition of his book called 'Managerial Breakthrough.' And both he and Deming came from the same era, right? And so obviously their understanding of the word "supervisor" was a person with "super vision." In other words, the person who would see things that the people inside the process or system could not see. He actually meant manager, leader, call it what you will, right?   0:07:31.1 Andrew Stotz: Right.   0:07:31.3 Balaji Reddie: And so later on, I think it was Bill Latzko who told Deming to use the word "leadership." And so in the 1986 edition, in Out of the Crisis, he brought in "Adopt and institute leadership." And he said the aim of leadership should be to help people and machines do a better job. And he elaborated this a bit more in the 1990 edition, saying, "Adopt and institute leadership for the management of people, recognizing their different abilities, capabilities, and aspirations." And then he adds, "The aim of leadership should be to help people, machines, and gadgets do a better job. Leadership of management is in need of overhaul, as well as leadership of production workers." So that's what he wrote in 1990. Then he says here, "Transformation in any organization will take place under a leader." Now, this is profound knowledge, when he reworded it. And we started with this, and that's why when we started this series, this podcast series, I started with 14 principles of leadership, if you remember.   0:08:33.8 Andrew Stotz: Yeah. We're back to leadership.   0:08:37.6 Balaji Reddie: Yeah. So what I had to say actually for point number seven is in that podcast, because he actually elaborated 14 principles of leadership as an elaboration of this point. And he says here, "The transformation in any organization will take place under a leader. It will not be spontaneous. How may he accomplish transformation? First, he has a theory. He understands why the transformation would bring gains to his organization and to all the people that his organization deal with. Second, he feels compelled to accomplish the transformation as an obligation to himself and to his organization. Third, he is a practical man. He has a plan step-by-step, and he can explain it in simple terms. But what is in his own head is not enough. He must convince and change enough people in power to make it happen. He possesses persuasive power. He understands people." So, in other words, profound knowledge. You saw people, you saw theory, right? And of course, the variation in the sense that when you're making this transformation, don't expect the system to behave in a predictable manner. Sometimes it'll behave unpredictably. So if you understand that and you know what to do in such circumstances, you need to be prepared. And when you get prepared, you can manage. As he used to often say, "Management is prediction," right? And ev
What if your AI strategy is creating more risk than progress? John Willis joins Andrew Stotz to trace how Deming's System of Profound Knowledge shaped the way he thinks about organizations, learning, and change. From his early days building DevOps to the AI transformations he's navigating with CIOs today. Along the way, John connects Deming to fast feedback loops, explains why leaders keep mistaking a learning problem for a technology problem, and shares stories that never made it into his book, Deming's Journey to Profound Knowledge.   A fresh conversation for longtime Deming thinkers and those just beginning the journey.   TRANSCRIPT 0:00:02.0 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz and I'll be your host as we continue our journey into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today I'm here with featured guest, John Willis. John, how are you doing?   0:00:15.7 John Willis: Great, Andrew. I was just thinking, I feel like that song, like I got my picture on the cover of Rolling Stone. Like, I'm on the Deming Institute podcast. Yay.   [laughter]   0:00:24.9 Andrew Stotz: We finally got you on.   0:00:27.8 John Willis: Yeah, yeah.   0:00:30.3 Andrew Stotz: Actually been a while and I wanna introduce you just briefly and then I'll let you do a little bit more of the introduction. But basically on Amazon, a book popped up and I was just looking at the date of that. That book popped up on, for me, it popped up on September 6, 2023 on Audible and I immediately bought it and I got the Audible book and the book's called 'Deming's Journey to Profound Knowledge. How Deming Helped Win a War, Altered the Face of Industry, and Holds the Key to Our Future'. And I immediately got it. Didn't know you, listened to it, loved it. Later you reached out on LinkedIn and we started communicating and you were kind enough to send a copy of it, which I then went through in more detail. I love the book. I really highly recommend the Audible version because it's just fun. Because the book is opening up a whole new Deming lens, a whole new way from somebody that never met Deming, and I just found that fascinating. So maybe why don't you take a moment and introduce yourself to the audience so that people know who you are, where you've been, what you've been doing and what you're doing now?   0:01:41.4 John Willis: Yeah, no, no, great. I... So, yeah, I... I've been doing technology, usually high consequence business, regulated industry, banks, retail, the biggest of the bigs, where the technology is incredibly important. Right? And I've been doing five decades of basic technology transformations, and I'm kind of the person who gets bored real easy. So I've literally gone through, like, you name it, mainframe, centralized computing, client server, distributed computing, priority systems, the Linux Open systems, you know, owned infrastructure cloud, and I'm consider one of the founders of the DevOps movement. And now today, like the cliché that I am, I've been doing a lot of organizational strategy on AI. So I don't come in and tell you how to turn 4,000 developers into AI coders. I kind of tell your CIOs to slow down. Wait a minute. So, yeah, so my day job today is I'm... I think these days finally in my life I would call myself an author first. I've written a number of books. The one you did, I had... My last book was a history of 100 history, 100 Year History of AI. And... But I'm an advisor, so I sort of... I take inbounds. I don't really look for work. Usually it's a chief of staff for a CIO who either has worked with me in the past and hey John, we're underwater with AI. Can you come in? Or they hear something I've said or I do a lot of podcasts and then I'm sort of a quasi investor. Although I probably should listen to your stuff a little better because I'm typically... I'm one of those guys that like, if I invest in it, you go short on it right away. So... [laughter] But yeah. But, yeah, no, so... But my day job today is really, is doing research. I'm actually just sure, this probably opened up a whole another discussion. Maybe later but I'm writing a book about the history of quantum computing right now and that's been just fascinating. So...   0:03:41.7 Andrew Stotz: Yeah.   0:03:41.8 John Willis: But my day job is helping CIOs and large high consequence organizations try to shuffle through technology transformations.   0:03:50.7 Andrew Stotz: And for the audience there that didn't catch what you were saying at the beginning, it kind of dated you because you were talking about the song called Rolling Stone by Dr. Hook.   0:03:59.9 John Willis: Yeah, yeah, totally.   0:04:01.3 Andrew Stotz: Dr. Hook published this in about 1972. And here are the lyrics. "Wanna see my picture on the cover? Wanna buy five copies for my mother? Wanna see my smiling face on the cover of Rolling Stone?" So here...   0:04:12.8 John Willis: Totally. Yeah. There you go. Deming Institute. Yeah, no, great.   0:04:16.7 Andrew Stotz: And one of the things that I found fascinating was just how you came to Deming from a very different angle. I was lucky enough that my boss at Pepsi sent me to study with him and I did two different seminars. The last one was in 1992. So I was 24, he was 92, was gonna live about one more year. I had... I could literally reach out and touch the man and hold his hand and sit next to him. I got a great picture of me sitting next to him. And I was just a young guy with a fresh mind compared to the 500 guys behind me that were older that he was bashing at times. But tell us a little bit about how you stumbled upon this topic and why you decided to do what you did with writing the book?   0:05:03.7 John Willis: Yeah, no, it's sort of interesting. I sort of say that for the first, I don't know, probably from 1980, my first job was running five distributed large computer systems for Exxon Research and Production, basically the geophysics work, right, during the most hottest period of the oil industry. And there were people doing that part of variation and understanding, but that didn't sort of hit my world. I was supporting geophysical processing and then so I rolled into other jobs. And then probably the closest I came... So in other words, I'm dealing with a lot of these major transformations and always focusing on the meta side, like the organizational. What are the things that are wrong? How do we fix the human and technology? There's a phrase called sociotechnical systems, right? And that's always where I've been most interested. And then even I was at GE Capital and I'll say this with all honesty, I was a Green Belt, but they gave out Green Belts for Six Sigma, [laughter] right? My wife was actually a Black Belt. And... But we would do... And I know Deming hated Six Sigma and all that, but we were doing... It was all around me, right? And then it wasn't until really the DevOps age that we really... That was a major shift in my career because before everything was sort of first generational from a technology or sociotechnical system, very command control, you sort of you installed software in a certain way. There were so many principles that were being broken by DevOps. And I was already an older guy at that point, but I was learning from these young kids and I'm known as the person who introduced DevOps to the US.   0:06:52.3 John Willis: And... But so there is where we started going back and understanding... We thought everything was new. We were creating DevOps, we were doing all this crazy awesome stuff. And I remember a friend of mine, well, a good friend of mine wrote a book called 'The Phoenix Project' by Gene Kim and it's a rewrite of Eliyahu Goldratt's 'The Goal'. And I was like, oh my God. And I read all of Goldratt's books and I was like, okay, this is the way, this is the way. I've seen a glimpse of some 30 or 40 year knowledge that I was missing. And then it was an open space seminar. A good friend of mine says, "John, you know." and I'm going off about Goldratt and he's like, "You know this all goes back to Deming." I'm like, "Who's Deming?" I'm like, "I just spent a year learning everything I could about Goldratt. He is my North Star. And now you're telling me..." And he challenged me. He said, "John, I'll leave it at this. You go read Deming's 14 Points and if you don't... I know you. I know what you're gonna do once you do that." And he was spot on. That was it. I was... And I don't... I'm more into the Profound Knowledge and we could talk a little bit about my journey there. But I was like, oh my goodness, this is the real and I love Eliyahu Goldratt and I love 'The Goal' and I love all his books. But Deming was hitting... Was like punching me right square in the face.   0:08:12.0 Andrew Stotz: So to what gap did it close for you? I mean, Goldratt is very specific about the main limiting point...   0:08:23.2 John Willis: Yeah.   0:08:23.3 Andrew Stotz: The bottleneck, how do we solve this?   0:08:25.6 John Willis: So the 14 Points, sort of one of the jokes is that it's mandatory to put the 14 Points in a DevOps presentation. So we were doing that dance a little bit, but then when I got a little serious about it, actually me and Gene Kim, we did a book. Goldratt has this book called 'Beyond the Goal'. It's an audio-only book, right? And I convinced Gene about five years after he had written 'The Phoenix Project' to do a Beyond the Phoenix Project. And so he did Goldratt, I did Deming. And at that point, I knew enough about Deming to say, "Okay let's..." And then we talked about DevOps and the principles of Lean and we did... I always, when somebody says they bought that audiobook, I'm like, "Oh, you're the 15th person that bought it." right? But it sold more than that. But the... But that's when Gene tapped me on the shoulder and did that. We went to the studio. It was a highlight of my life, literally going to the studio with Gene and literally recording for a couple of weeks. And he's like, "John, you really need to w
What if your cheapest supplier is secretly your riskiest? Balaji Reddie unpacks Deming's Points 4, 5, and 6 with Andrew Stotz by exploring Deming's thinking on suppliers, continual improvement, and training. Why do strong relationships matter more than short-term savings? Why should problems be welcomed? Do people perform differently when they understand the purpose behind their work? Balaji uses stories to offer a practical look at what these three points can teach leaders today. TRANSCRIPT 0:00:02.0 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz and I'll be your host as we dive deeper into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today, I'm continuing my discussions with Balaji Reddie, an educator and trainer in the teachings of Dr. Deming and quality management more broadly. Well, we've had some great conversations so far on various points of Dr. Deming's 14 points. I think we're gonna try to get four or five, four, five, six. Let's see how it goes. So, Balaji, take it away.   0:00:32.5 Balaji Reddie: All right. So, good morning, Andrew. So I think the last couple of times we were together, we've spoken about point number one. I think the first thing I did say is that this is an entire system, so we can't isolate them. But he gave it some sequence and he gave it some structure. So... Is there disturbances that getting recorded?   0:00:54.3 Andrew Stotz: No. No.   0:00:55.0 Balaji Reddie: No? Okay. Right. So point number one, of course, was very much in sync with how he defined a system, where he said that every system must have an aim. Without an aim, there is no system. And when you read the commentary behind that, you see that it's not just aim what he meant was also purpose, the reason why a system exists. And so when we started seeing how he applied this to the running of an organization, that's why the first thing that crossed his mind was purpose. We, of course, discussed that in complete detail, what he meant by that. I think we also discussed about the actual text that he wrote where he said for quality and productivity and things like that. The second one, of course, how he changed the wording of point two, which was adopt the new philosophy. So when he first wrote it, it was philosophy of quality that comes first more than anything else. But when he professed Profound Knowledge, the wording changed to the new philosophy of win-win, right? Cooperate.   0:01:54.4 Balaji Reddie: And that's what we discussed last time, that cooperation in the broadest sense of the term with each other inside the company, with your competitors, with your suppliers, with your customers. And he says, "Teach and practice this." Those were the words. And the third one, of course, cease dependence on mass inspection. And it was a context in which he wrote it, but of course, he elaborated on that. You should understand why we use inspection. It is to keep us updated on what is happening in the process, not so much to sort bad from good. And that was basically, in fact, the wordings of the new point he wrote was understand the purpose of the system of inspection. He said there will always be inspection, but relying on that is not right. Using that to understand the process, that's the way to do it. So that's exactly what we spoke last time. Now we're taking it from there. Now talking about point number four, where... I'll just pull up the wordings for my sake so that I don't make a mistake in reading out what he actually said. Right? So the original wordings and then what it changed to later on, right? When he started professing. Now, so here's point number four, which goes like this. He says, "End the practice of awarding business on the basis of price tag alone. Instead, minimize total cost. Move toward a single supplier for any one item in a long-term relationship of loyalty and trust." And this did not change in 1986 or 1990.   0:03:39.1 Balaji Reddie: Now, he writes there in the commentary, which is taken from his text, "The aim in purchase of tools and other equipment should be to minimize the net cost per hour of life. Price has no meaning without a measure of quality being purchased. Without adequate measure of quality, business drifts to the lowest bidder, low quality and high cost being the inevitable result. Estimate the total cost of use of materials and services, the first cost, purchase price, plus the predicted cost of problems in use of them and their effect on the quality of final product. As the relationship between supplier and customer grows tighter and tighter, renewal of a contract year after year may appear to be a formality. This even tighter and tighter relationship will, under good management of producer and customer, ensure better and better quality and lower and lower costs as the years go by. A long-term relationship with a single supplier may be a wise decision if customer and supplier play their parts for optimization of the system. However, a sudden jump to a single supplier is inadvisable. There are risks. Go slow. It is not a relationship to enter into lightly. An overriding criterion is the supplier's burning desire to work with the customer on a long-term relationship backed up by a demonstrable store of specialized knowledge with management that is trying to adopt the new philosophy."   0:05:01.8 Balaji Reddie: And beautifully written. So the new wordings would now be, "Work towards having an arms-around relationship with your suppliers. Invest in them through education and training so that they can contribute effectively towards the organization. And when purchasing, do not focus on price alone without a measure of quality, and reduce variation by practicing cooperation with your suppliers." Now, coming to this, not many people are aware of what he spoke in Japan to the organizations there, but one of the major points he did say was to work very closely with their suppliers, right? And this text... The funny thing is, you know, about his works in Japan that he never gave any handouts or material, unlike Dr. Juran, who gave a lot of notes before he landed there. Right? Dr. Deming just handed out certain standards and just some pamphlets, I think Z1, Z2, and Z3, the standard copies. But what he spoke there was recorded by them. And the notebook, the book that came out, Elementary Principles of the Statistical Control of Quality, were essentially transcripts of what he spoke there. Right? It's later on when they showed him that they had made a book that he assisted. They expected him to get a little, I can't use a very strong word, upset, but that he would chide them for having done something without his knowledge. But instead, he was very happy, apparently, and added on to it and gave them the second edition and asked them to add an extra chapter and things like that. So when he went through those notes, obviously it was their translation of English to Japanese and then Japanese to English and things like that. But strong messages came out, and one of them was to work very closely with their suppliers and treat them as an extension of themselves, right? Extension of the company itself.   0:07:09.7 Balaji Reddie: Now, the thing about the lectures that he gave there, it's very interesting, that the arrow diagram, if you remember the famous arrow diagram which he drew there. If you see, it appears on Out of the Crisis in the new edition, page three, but the original edition, page four. But that arrow diagram in his mimeographed book, Quality, Productivity, and Competitive Position, comes on page number 103. And if you see the Elementary Principles of the Statistical Control of Quality, the arrow diagram is just directed towards the consumer. That does not have consumer research, right? And I think even he was... When he wrote... When the final edition of The World of W. Edwards Deming came out, the Lecture to Top Management, actually that was a lecture which he gave to the statisticians and engineers. To top management, there were two instances. One was July 1950 where he spoke to 20 people... Or 21 out of the 40 people who were invited. And then there was another one in August 1950. And August 1950, that took place at Hotel Diama, and that's where he added consumer research and completed the diagram. And that's the one he reproduced ever since in all his papers. But funnily, in The World of W. Edwards Deming, they've reproduced the first arrow diagram that he came up with, which did not have consumer research. It just shows the arrow pointing towards. But in both there, there was the presence of suppliers. Right? And he said that now... We used to have this group on the internet. It was called DEN, Deming Electronic Network, the D-E-N, the DEN, and we used to call ourselves the DENizens. And there was a gentleman, Jim Clauson, who used to... Who was a moderator and he had everything. It's unfortunate, I don't know where he is now. Not kept in touch with him. The last, I think, I interacted was many years ago.   0:09:16.7 Balaji Reddie: But all that... That's a treasure house of conversations, emails, which he has. Unfortunately, some cybersquatter hacked into the server and was asking for a ransom of $28,000 or something like that. And this guy didn't... He said, "Obviously, I can't pay that kind of money." So I don't know whether he's managed to retrieve all of that, because that's a treasure house. We used to have a lot of chats on that, and I interacted a lot with two very, very famous people who also worked very closely with Dr. Deming. One, of course, the great Myron Tribus, and the other one was John Dowd. And John Dowd... We had this chat and we said there is a difference between July 1950 and August 1950. And he took it on himself to find out what exactly was spoken in both these. Because July 1950, yes, Dr. Deming himself gave some notes and said, "This is what it needs to be." But August 1950, the people sitting there. So there were 80 people in that room. And I think he got in touch with so
loading
Comments