DiscoverIndustry Relations
Industry Relations
Claim Ownership

Industry Relations

Author: Rob Hahn and Greg Robertson

Subscribed: 25Played: 898
Share

Description

This is Industry Relations, a podcast that is at the intersection of real estate and technology from an insider's perspective. Hosted weekly by Rob Hahn (The Notorious ROB) and Greg Robertson.
304 Episodes
Reverse
NAR re-enters the chat

NAR re-enters the chat

2026-11-1801:02:56

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player! Overview Rob and Greg look at the four new MLS policy recommendations from NAR's Multiple Listing Issues and Policies Committee and end up in one of their most heated debates yet. Most of it is about a new optional policy that lets MLSs require brokers to assign up to 50% of the copyright in listing photos and descriptions. Greg points to support from CRMLS, the Realty Alliance and a unanimous board vote. Rob calls the policy a giant mistake and argues for a voluntary, opt-in program based on the ASCAP/BMI model instead. They also argue about new qualifications for NAR MLS committee members, which leads Rob to propose that NAR hand MLS policy over to CMLS entirely. The episode opens with a preview of a future topic: whether the new American dream is being able to afford to live near your family. Key Takeaways Rob suggests a future topic: can multiple generations of a family afford to live in the same community? Rob sees NAR's optional MLS data-feed policy as political cover for things MLSs already do. The new data-use policy bans uses not allowed by participation agreements, which Rob says those agreements already cover. The revised Policy 7.85 says brokers must own or have authority to license their listing content. A new optional policy lets MLSs require participants to assign up to 50% of the copyright in photos and descriptions, with an opt-out. CRMLS (Art Carter, Ed Zorn) proposed the copyright policy, and the Realty Alliance (Craig Cheatham) endorsed it. Greg backs it as an industry-wide answer to scraping and AI misuse. Rob says brokers can already assign rights voluntarily, so making it a condition of participation is the mistake. Rob urges MLSs to ignore the policy and look into the ASCAP/BMI collective rights model. New NAR MLS committee qualifications include real estate tech familiarity, MLS/association leadership, and training such as CMLX. Rob argues "real estate technology" isn't the same as MLS expertise. Rob proposes that NAR leave MLS policy to CMLS and that CMLS hand lobbying to NAR. Links Craig Cheatham / Realty Alliance letter to the MLS Issues and Policies Committee Rob's article on the new NAR MLS policies Connect with Rob and Greg Rob's Website  Greg's Website  Watch us on YouTube Our Sponsors: Cotality  Notorious VIP The Giant Steps Job Board  Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios
Thirty Shades of Active

Thirty Shades of Active

2026-11-1101:03:35

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player! Overview Rob and Greg are back from the NAR annual convention in New Orleans. They talk about lower attendance, whether NAR committee meetings should be open to members and the press, and Compass's new policy barring its W-2 employees from NAR volunteer leadership roles. Greg shares what he heard in 14 meetings with MLS executives about OpenRE, and the hosts disagree over whether OpenRE is a national data repository, a listing input tool, or mostly a lobbying effort. They close with their favorite conversations from the convention. Key Takeaways NAR attendance fell from over 30,000 in past years to about 10,000 this year. Greg blames a perfect storm: the lingering effects of COVID, a down market, and infighting within the industry. Rob suggests NAR could focus only on business (votes and committee meetings) and open those meetings to members and the press. Greg points out that companies commonly keep the press out of strategy meetings. Compass now bars its W-2 employees from NAR volunteer leadership positions. Rob sees the policy as a way to reduce antitrust risk, not as retaliation against NAR. Greg thinks announcing it during the NAR convention was gamesmanship. The policy could affect NAR First Vice President Jennifer Branchini's path to the presidency. MLS execs placed OpenRE somewhere between "nothing burger" and "distraction." MLS execs say they understand brokers' frustrations and are open to working with them. Greg believes the real broker pain point is double entry across multiple MLSs, which is a problem BLX could solve. Greg wonders when Cotality might acquire Ocusell. A broker consortium might reach about 30% of a market's data, while the MLS has all of it. Portals want complete, checked, ad-quality listings, and they doubt OpenRE can deliver that. Rob argues OpenRE either adds little value or would end up replacing the MLS. Greg gives OpenRE about a 10% chance of success and warns against reading too much into so few details. Q1 will show whether OpenRE is a real company or just a press release. One MLS has over 30 active status types, an example of how complex listing data is. Connect with Rob and Greg Rob's Website  Greg's Website    Watch us on YouTube   Our Sponsors: Cotality  Notorious VIP The Giant Steps Job Board    Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios
Trade-offs

Trade-offs

2026-11-0401:03:35

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player! Overview In this Election Day special, Rob and Greg step outside their usual real estate coverage to talk about the midterms and what they mean for housing. Greg voted; Rob didn't, and won't. They debate whether any election outcome can fix housing affordability, how to frame the trade-offs of adding supply, and whether AI changes the equation entirely. They also preview their trip to NAR NXT in New Orleans. Key Takeaways Both expect Democrats to take the House and Senate, with Texas, South Carolina, and Michigan as races to watch. Rob argues no matter who you vote for, you get John McCain. Greg says housing policy is mostly local, so federal races change little. Rob argues the midterm housing agenda (NAR, Inman coverage, "Let America Build") is tinkering on the edges. Democratic housing proposals center on low-income housing credits and Section 8 vouchers. California's ADU rules are one example of deregulation from the left. Greg's pitch to NIMBY neighbors: more housing means your kids can live next to you. Rob counters that adding real supply means existing home values drop, and no candidate campaigns on that. Rob says affordability requires a 50% price drop, doubled real incomes, or sub-2% rates. Greg argues it can be a combination of smaller moves rather than one big fix. Greg suggests AI-driven abundance could make today's affordability formulas obsolete. Rob says housing predates industry and will always have an economy around it. Both agree "a rising tide lifts all boats" has broken down, and housing shows it most clearly. Charles Murray's "super zips" illustrate how rich and poor no longer share towns or schools.   Connect with Rob and Greg Rob's Website  Greg's Website    Watch us on YouTube   Our Sponsors: Cotality  Notorious VIP The Giant Steps Job Board    Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios
ListHub  2.0?

ListHub 2.0?

2026-10-2801:03:35

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player! Overview Rob and Greg break down Open Real Estate (ORE), a new initiative from eXp, Real, RE/MAX, Keller Williams, and Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices to build a broker-run listing cooperative. They debate whether ORE is a national MLS or a syndication platform, whether a Q1 2027 launch is realistic, and what ORE could mean for MLSs, Compass, and government regulation of the industry. Key Takeaways ORE aims to prevent inventory fragmentation driven by Compass's private listing strategy. Greg gives ORE a one-out-of-ten chance of success but thinks MLSs and portals should help anyway. Rob says mandatory submission plus cooperation makes ORE a national MLS, whatever it's called. Greg sees ORE as closer to ListHub 2.0, a data feed that works alongside MLSs. Rob asks why ORE doesn't just buy ListHub from Realtor.com instead of building from scratch. Neither host believes ORE can launch by Q1 2027 with RFPs only now going out. ORE's early principles include submission within one business day and public or participant-only listing options. ORE could become the industry's new rulemaker, giving MLSs cover against Compass. Pricing like a dollar per listing could push smaller MLSs toward consolidation. Greg credits ORE for bringing a solution to the table instead of filing lawsuits. Greg wonders if ORE gives Robert Reffkin a face-saving way out of his fight with MLSs. Rob argues ORE's real goal is removing inventory as a way for brokerages to compete for agents. Rob warns that ORE's consumer-protection rhetoric could invite government regulation of the MLS. In 2004 congressional testimony, industry leaders defended the MLS as a private broker-to-broker cooperative. Links Vendor Alley: Upstream 2.0? Not Quite.  Inman: KW, AGNT, HomeServices of America, Real REMAX fight private listing with new collaboration  BAM (Video) : REAL, eXp, Keller Williams & Berkshire Hathaway Announce Historic Team Up  Notorious POD (Video): Reaction Video - Open Real Estate Are you an MLS Exec going to NAR NXT?  Book a meeting with Greg/Giant Steps  Connect with Rob and Greg Rob's Website  Greg's Website    Watch us on YouTube   Our Sponsors: Cotality  Notorious VIP The Giant Steps Job Board    Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios  
Spinning Compass

Spinning Compass

2026-10-2101:01:23

The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player! Overview Rob and Greg break down Compass's newly filed lawsuit against CRMLS in the Central District of California. They cover the eyebrow-raising $175 million figure tied to commission settlement costs and why Rob thinks Compass has a strong case that's badly packaged. They also debate MLS "transparency" claims and OneHome, revisit precedent from Cantor v. Multiple Listing Service of Dutchess County and RealComp, and look at what MLSs facing Compass threats, like Unlock MLS and OneKey MLS, should do next. Key Takeaways Compass's suit against CRMLS shifts the main legal action to California. Compass appears to seek recovery of commission settlement costs (Sitzer/Burnett, Gibson) from MLSs. Rob sees strong arguments in the complaint but a weak, overly combative narrative. The complaint doesn't explain why CRMLS's board would adopt rules that bind its own members. Rob argues MLS transparency claims fail because consumers can't join MLSs directly. Greg counters that OneHome gave roughly 12 million consumers CRMLS data access in a year. Rob says an MLS's customer is the agent who pays, not buyers or sellers. Cantor v. MLS of Dutchess County struck down a rule that had little to do with the cooperative: mandatory MLS yard signs. The core question is whether MLSs should regulate how properties are marketed. NAR's 2004 change, dropping the advertising restriction from the 14 points, was followed by DOJ action. Greg questions whether MLSs can negotiate in good faith with Compass, given its shifting demands. Rob urges MLSs to try to avoid costly litigation before going to "war." Greg notes MLSs feel squeezed between Compass suits and potential seller lawsuits. The 1983 FTC Butters Report shows the MLS is anti-competitive by design but delivers major consumer benefits. Rob predicts private and office-exclusive listings will grow, driven by buyer demand in a K-shaped economy. Connect with Rob and Greg Rob's Website  Greg's Website    Watch us on YouTube   Our Sponsors: Cotality  Notorious VIP The Giant Steps Job Board    Production and Editing Services by Sunbound Studios
loading
Comments