Predictably Unexpected

22 Episodes

Reverse

Unplugged and Unsure: Hallmark’s Who’s Coming for Christmas & Holiday Unplugged (S2:E6)

2026-11-0646:54

This week on Predictably Unexpected, we review our Predictability Scorecard results for Hallmark’s Who’s Coming for Christmas? Did we nail the guest list, or did the holiday houseguests show up uninvited and ruin our season? Then we move on to Hallmark’s Holiday Unplugged, a movie we’re predicting using nothing but the title, since we haven’t seen a single frame. The title has us curious. Is someone trading their phone for a digital detox? Or is this a holiday concert with acoustic guit...

Plus-Ones and Predictable Plots: Hallmark’s Who’s Coming for Christmas?

2026-10-2936:49

Like bundling up for a snowy small town Christmas market, this episode has layers and we are not apologizing for any of them. This week we are finally putting the tiebreaker to rest after last week delivered an outcome so unexpected it almost broke the show. We break down the results of Hallmark’s ’Tis the Season for Setups, compare our Predictability Scorecards, and figure out who owns the tiebreak for the rest of the season. We also revisit our scorecard results from Hallmark’s Mr. &a...

Tie the Knot, Break the Tie: Hallmark’s ’Tis the Season for Setups and Mr. & Mrs. Christmas

2026-10-2341:10

The Countdown to Christmas has officially begun, which means it’s time to put on a cozy sweater and ignore all of our responsibilities. We’re kicking off the season the way every Hallmark couple starts a movie: stuck in a situation we did not plan for. Our tiebreaker ended in an actual tie, a twist so unexpected it would get cut from a Hallmark script for being too dramatic. To settle it, we pulled in Hallmark’s ’Tis the Season for Setups and re-predicted from scratch, then compared our Predi...

Joust Getting Started: Hallmark's Countdown to Christmas Calendar and A Knight to Remember

2026-10-1248:20

It's a mega episode, and yes, we're calling it that because the Countdown to Christmas calendar is enormous and our scheduling spreadsheet has filed a formal complaint. First, we break down the full release calendar and try to figure out how Hallmark expects anyone to finish dinner between now and December. Then it's the Season 2 tiebreaker, where the Predictability Scorecard faces its toughest test yet: A Knight to Remember. Will there be a castle? A charming stranger with suspiciously good ...

Love Finds You, Right on Cue: Hallmark's Love Finds You and Much About Love

2026-09-0123:48

Season 2 is officially preseason, and love found us exactly where we expected it to. This episode is dropping a little later than planned, but in true Hallmark fashion, we knew it would find you eventually anyway. This week we break down Hallmark's Love Finds You, giving our full unfiltered opinions on whether the plot surprised us even once (spoiler: it did not). We're also taking a first look at what's coming next with Hallmark’s Much About Love, setting the stage for our Predictability Sco...

#box-pro-ellipsis-179428009977849{-webkit-line-clamp:2;}Predictably Unexpected