DiscoverRelitigated
Relitigated

Relitigated

Author: Relitigated Podcast Team

Subscribed: 1Played: 0
Share

Description

A podcast about real Supreme Court cases. No law degree required.

Join hosts Jarret and Nikki as they re-argue a real Supreme Court case in front of 3 friends role-playing as "justices". Each episode includes an overview of the case, arguments from the hosts, deliberations and opinions issued by our panel of "justices", and finally a reveal of what the real Supreme Court ruled and how their decision impacts us today.

Also, we should mention no one on the show is a lawyer.

Our goal is to present the history and decisions of the Supreme Court in an engaging and accessible way. If you're not a lawyer, that's okay, we aren't either!

21 Episodes
Reverse
#20 McCleskey v. Kemp

#20 McCleskey v. Kemp

2025-09-0301:39:22

In the season 2 finale we re-argue the Supreme Court case McCleskey v. Kemp. WM, a Black man, was sentenced to death for murder. On appeal, he submitted statistical evidence to show that the race of the victim (and, to a lesser extent, of the defendant) is associated with whether the defendant gets sentenced to death or not. The question before the court: does statistical evidence of racial disparities in a state's capital sentencing system prove racism? Does the evidence make that system unconstitutional under the 8th and 14th amendments?
In this episode we re-argue the Supreme Court case Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. High school students wrote and edited articles as the staff for their school newspaper. One day, they found that their articles about divorce and teen pregnancy had been removed from their newest issue. The principal cut them because he thought they were "inappropriate." That's a violation of the First Amendment, right?
In this special episode we bring you the first ever edition of Objection! The Relitigated Game Show. 3 of our justices, Sarah, Adam, and Preston, compete for points to see who will be crowned the official Chief Justice of Relitigated and earn the commemorative gavel. To make things spicy, contestants can object when they believe a colleague is wrong and wager points to get either a boost or a setback. With 6 rounds of questions on the most recent Supreme Court term, and some of the, honestly, most unfair questions ever asked in a multiple-choice trivia game, the contestants have their work cut out for them. Who will be victorious and crowned the official Chief Justice of Relitigated?
In this episode we re-argue the Supreme Court case Griggs v. Duke Power Company. In the wake of the Civil Rights Act prohibiting discrimination in employment, a major company changed its hiring and promotion policies and implemented alternate requirements. Black employees, who largely did not advance, complained of continuing discrimination. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigated and substantiated their allegations. The employer denied. The question before the court: did the company's promotion requirements violate the Civil Rights Act?
#16 Watts v. United States

#16 Watts v. United States

2025-08-0601:17:01

In this episode we re-argue the Supreme Court case Watts v. U.S. At a protest, a young man made a statement about getting the president in the sights of his rifle, and was convicted of threatening the life of the president. Was he, though? The question before the court: Was his statement actually a threat? Was it prohibited by the law?
loading
Comments