DiscoverShort Circuit
Short Circuit
Claim Ownership

Short Circuit

Author: Institute for Justice

Subscribed: 317Played: 19,335
Share

Description

The Supreme Court decides a few dozen cases every year; federal appellate courts decide thousands. So if you love constitutional law, the circuit courts are where it’s at. Join us as we break down some of the week’s most intriguing appellate decisions with a unique brand of insight, wit, and passion for judicial engagement and the rule of law. http://ij.org/short-circuit
466 Episodes
Reverse
Our long march through the federal circuits, via our #12Months12Circuits series, is almost up. To celebrate we take a vacation to the beaches of the Eleventh Circuit, which encompasses the states of Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Joining us are two Eleventh Circuit—and IJ—attorneys, Justin Pearson and Katrin Marquez, both of IJ’s Florida office. We begin with some background about the Eleventh, how busy its district courts are, and how its “deep bench” of senior judges keeps its docket ticking. Then Katrin brings us a recent ruling about a pretrial detention policy in Alabama where people are stuck behind bars for weeks before having their bail set. A woman was arrested for forging a $75 check when she was seven months pregnant. Nevertheless, her bail was automatically set at around one hundred times that amount. The court seems to think that’s a problem despite the government’s attempts to make the matter go away. Then Justin tells us of Florida’s protectionist bar licensing rules, highlighted in a dormant commerce clause challenge. The challengers lose despite it being very clear that Florida’s rules and fees are the way they are in order to keep interlopers from other states taking away Florida attorneys’ business. Edwards v. Randolph County Sheriff Hernandez v. Florida Board of Bar Examiners Short Circuit 421 (with Tom Metzloff) Is Drink Killing England?
Ever seen a hamburger UFO? A town in Kansas tried to make sure its residents couldn’t. At least regarding a mural at a hamburger joint. The restaurant tried to paint a picture of hamburger flying saucers on the side of its building but local officials told it to stop because the picture wasn’t a legal “sign.” The restaurant argued this was a First Amendment violation. And the Tenth Circuit agreed. IJ’s John Wrench flies us around this free speech case and also gives some examples of excellent deposition questions. Then Eliana Fleischer of IJ gets into a hugely topical case on the Fourth Amendment and cell phone locations, from the Fourth Circuit. Some Baltimore police used a cell-site simulator—called “Hailstorm”—to figure out where a suspect’s cell phone was. Trouble is they didn’t get a warrant and the technology also tells the police where a bunch of other people’s cell phones are and can disrupt their calls. Was this constitutional? No. Was it clearly established? No also. So qualified immunity applies. There’s also a wild sidenote about a nondisclosure agreement and the FBI. Plus, Eliana tells us a bit about one of the best kept secrets in the federal courts of appeals: the Seventh Circuit’s staff attorneys office. Cozy Inn v. Salina Andrews v. Baltimore IJ’s donut mural case
With a live audience in Cambridge, Massachusetts, we mark (not celebrate) the 100th anniversary of Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty, where the Supreme Court ruled it was constitutional for cities to “zone” land into separate uses. We’re in Cambridge for two reasons. First, we also mark (and celebrate) a forgotten follow-up case from 1928: Nectow v. City of Cambridge. There, the Court clarified that there are situations where zoning rules can be unconstitutional and said that about a particular rule in the city. Second, we hear about the great zoning reforms Cambridge has pursued in recent years, giving it a much simpler zoning code and making it a much better place to build housing. Before an audience of Cambridge residents we hear from a panel of zoning experts: Harvard Law’s Molly Brady, the Vice Mayor of Cambridge, Burhan Azeem, and IJ’s own Ari Bargil. We discuss the two SCOTUS cases and their influence on constitutional law today, hear from Vice Mayor Azeem about the reforms he’s pursued in Cambridge, and speak more generally about whether the future, and property rights, will give us a little more Nectow and a little less Euclid.  Euclid v. Ambler Realty Nectow v. City of Cambridge Molly’s article on deeds Welcoming Neighbors Network Bound By Oath episode on Euclid
Vote early. But maybe don’t vote often? That’s the bottom line from Short Circuit’s biannual election special. With the 2026 General Election only days away, IJ’s Diana Simpson and your host bring you some of the latest cases from the federal courts of appeals on elections and political speech. There’s a polling place full of rulings on speech and paperwork burdens, what you can say about who can vote, the Founder’s fondness for anonymous pamphlets, the motor voter law, the Purcell principle, preliminary injunctions, prefilling voter applications, public records requests, and a real-life Twenty-Sixth Amendment case. Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Ellison AFP v. Meyer AFP v. Albence VoteAmerica v. Schwab Grant v. Belangia Red Wine & Blue v. LaRose PILF v. Wolfe PILF v. Simon
John Wrench is joined by Diana Simpson and Patrick Jaicomo to discuss the truly frightful! Like, what to make of the Supreme Court’s latest refusal to address whether the government needs to pay innocent people when it destroys or damages their property, and what can be distilled from the justices’ insistence on further “percolation” of the issue? Speaking of which, the Court will weigh in on a challenge to the federal ban on distilling spirits at home; might it rein in horrifyingly broad interpretations of the Necessary and Proper Clause? Finally, they speculate about law’s experiences with the spectral, including witness testimony about ghostly encounters and the practical challenges of selling a haunted house. Diana’s Chicago impound case IJ’s SWAT takings cases McNutt at SCOTUS
loading
Comments