Craig revisits an April conversation with Andrew about Deafheaven's 2025 album Lonely People With Power. They talk about why it hit them so hard, how it balances heaviness with melody, and why it feels like a culmination of everything the band has done. They break down the intentional role of the three "Incidentals," highlight the musicianship of Kerry McCoy, George Clarke, Daniel Tracy, Shiv Murali, and Chris Johnson, and compare the production to the band's earlier work. Track standouts include Doberman, Magnolia, Amethyst, Body Behavior, Revelator, Winona, and The Marvelous Orange Tree. Both hosts agree the record may be Deafheaven's best and expect it to show up on year-end lists. Timestamp Notes 00:00 – Intro and setup for the replay 00:40 – Why this album will appear on year-end lists 01:20 – Opening banter 02:00 – First impressions: both hosts love it 03:00 – Craig's note on why Deafheaven isn't for everyone 04:00 – Andrew's early struggles with Sunbather 06:00 – Wondering if this record would continue Infinite Granite 07:00 – Roadrunner Records and the return to heaviness 08:00 – The band's mystery and unpredictability 09:00 – Where Deafheaven sits in the broader music world 10:45 – The "Incidentals" and how they shape the album 12:00 – Incidental I leading into Doberman 13:00 – Incidental II analysis and Jay Matthews's part 16:00 – Incidental III and Paul Banks 17:00 – Why the sequencing matters 19:00 – Doberman and Magnolia as re-introductions 22:00 – Where Deafheaven fits on festival lineups 25:00 – Their evolution from Sunbather to now 28:00 – George Clarke on feeling exposed during Infinite Granite 30:00 – Why Infinite Granite was necessary for this album 34:00 – The album's length and relentlessness 37:00 – Body Behavior and Chris Johnson's bass moment 40:00 – Overall musicianship discussion 48:00 – Amethyst as the emotional core 52:00 – Production shift with Justin Meldal-Johnsen 56:00 – Amethyst as the purest form of the band 58:00 – Winona vs. The Marvelous Orange Tree 1:00:00 – How critics are receiving the album 1:03:00 – Why the album feels personal to the hosts 1:05:00 – Is this their best album? 1:06:00 – Closing remarks and sign-off
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig Lyndall and Andrew Schnitkey discuss their personal experiences with back pain, share insights from recent live music shows, and dive into their year-end album rankings. They explore the challenges of ranking albums, the impact of live performances on their perceptions, and the significance of various records in their musical journeys. The conversation is filled with humor, nostalgia, and a deep appreciation for music. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Personal Updates 11:03 Live Music Experiences 21:30 Album of the Year Discussion 23:29 Negotiating Musical Tiers 25:35 Contrasting Album Achievements 26:44 Revisiting Early Favorites 28:29 Subjectivity in Music Appreciation 29:22 Initial Impressions vs. Lasting Impact 30:51 Reconsidering Overrated Albums 33:08 Rediscovering Hidden Gems 35:50 Talking Yourself Into Albums 37:04 The Allure of Live Performances
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss seasonal affective disorder, the latest music industry news, and the recent Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction ceremony. They delve into the Grammy nominations, highlighting Turnstile's historic nominations and the eclectic nature of the categories. The conversation shifts to Stereogum's relaunch and the impact of AI on ad revenue, emphasizing the challenges faced by independent music publications. The episode concludes with reflections on the importance of supporting music journalism. Chapters 00:00 Seasonal Affective Reflections 02:52 The Psychology of Extroversion and Introversion 05:53 Music Industry News: Red Hot Chili Peppers and More 08:58 Henry Rollins and Ian McKay: A Misunderstanding 11:58 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Induction Highlights 17:52 Performance Reviews: Outkast, 21 Pilots, and More 24:04 Emerging Bands: Geese and the Subculture Scene 26:30 Viral Commentary on Music Covers 35:01 Grammy Nominations and Turnstile's Impact 44:06 Stereogum's Relaunch and the Future of Music Journalism
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew discuss their excitement for upcoming concerts, new music releases, and the return of iconic bands like Radiohead. They delve into the impact of singles and album previews, as well as controversies surrounding artists' decisions to alter their music. The conversation also touches on cultural phenomena in music, the evolution of music consumption, and the differences between British and American rock. They reflect on influential bands and look ahead to future releases, wrapping up with thoughts on the music landscape. Chapters 00:00 Concert Excitement and Upcoming Shows 02:58 New Music Releases and Anticipation 05:51 Artist Evolution and Album Expectations 08:56 The Impact of Streaming on Music 11:54 The 1975 Controversy and Artist Integrity 14:58 Radiohead's Setlist and Live Performances 28:23 Night Two Setlist Highlights 32:01 The Anticipation of a World Tour 34:05 The Legacy of British Rock Bands 40:55 The Androgynous Nature of British Rock 45:00 Looking Ahead: Rancid's 30th Anniversary 52:59 Zach Bryan: A Cultural Phenomenon
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew engage in a lively discussion covering a range of topics from personal anecdotes about blood donation to the upcoming Rock Hall ceremony. They delve into the speculation surrounding Soundgarden's induction, share thoughts on Chris Kirkpatrick's recent antics, and announce the Foo Fighters' upcoming tour. The conversation shifts to album reviews, including Spiritual Cramp and White Reaper, before wrapping up with a discussion on the Psychedelic Porn Crumpets' latest release and other new music. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Light Banter 03:08 Blood Donation Experience and Personal Anecdotes 06:06 Rock Hall Ceremony and Soundgarden Induction 08:47 Discussion on Chris Kirkpatrick and Artistic Integrity 11:44 Foo Fighters Tour Announcement and Opener Speculation 17:37 Mark Lanegan's Music and Personal Connection 29:35 Nirvana's Live Albums and Legacy 31:18 The Evolution of Nirvana's Live Sound 35:36 Exploring New Music: Spiritual Cramp 45:35 The Impact of Drummers on Band Sound 51:10 White Reaper: A New Wave of Rock 52:17 Psychedelic Porn Crumpets: A Fun Musical Journey
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss their personal lives, including parenting challenges and the impact of busy schedules. They pay tribute to rock legends who have passed away, reflecting on their influence in the music community. The conversation shifts to new music releases, festival lineups, and the excitement surrounding upcoming albums. They also delve into the ethics of publishing personal journals of artists and share their thoughts on various bands and their legacies. The episode concludes with recommendations for new music and reflections on the current state of the music industry. Chapters 00:00 Life Updates and Parenting Challenges 02:46 Tributes to Rock Legends: Ace Frehley and Sam Rivers 05:33 Reflections on Personal Loss and Health Concerns 08:10 The Impact of Unpublished Writings in Music 11:04 Soundgarden's Future and Legacy 13:36 Reunions and the State of Iconic Bands 16:26 Festival Experiences and Personal Preferences 29:43 Festival Changes and Preferences 31:00 Lineup Highlights and Nostalgia 32:38 Live Performances and Band Dynamics 35:26 Deer Tick and Personal Connections 37:59 Public Enemy and Cultural Impact 42:40 Switchfoot and Live Performance Insights 44:03 Militarie Gun's New Album and Evolution 50:18 Lyrical Depth and Personal Struggles 55:12 Upcoming Releases and Anticipations
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss various new albums, focusing on their experiences with lossless Spotify, the latest Taylor Swift album, and insights from Haley Williams' interview. They explore the evolution of Taylor Swift's music, the production quality of recent albums, and the impact of artists like AFI and Foxing on the music scene. The conversation highlights the importance of music in connecting different generations and the significance of artistic expression in today's music industry. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Lossless Spotify Experience 02:37 Exploring New Albums and Their Impact 05:33 Taylor Swift's New Album Discussion 08:03 Comparing Taylor Swift's Musical Evolution 10:52 Cultural Impact and Listening Obligations 22:22 The Cultural Impact of Music Icons 25:48 Hayley Williams: A Dynamic Performer 35:31 The Evolution of Paramore and Feminism in Music 40:31 AFI's New Direction and Davey Havoc's Unique Persona 44:39 Podcasting Challenges and Future Plans
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss their experiences at recent concerts, including Turnstile and Greet Death, while reflecting on the indefinite hiatus of the band Foxing. They explore the emotional impact of Foxing's music, the diversity of concert audiences, and the significance of live performances. The conversation also delves into the ranking of Foxing's discography, highlighting the unique qualities of each album and the personal connections listeners have with their music. Ultimately, the episode captures the bittersweet nature of music fandom and the importance of supporting artists in their journeys. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Birthday Reflections 02:39 Turnstile Concert Experience 05:13 Diversity and Community at Concerts 07:47 Setlist Highlights and Performance Details 10:41 Greet Death Show Experience 17:21 Foxing's Indefinite Hiatus Announcement 36:01 The Emotional Journey of Music Creation 38:09 Promotional Strategies and Artistic Intentions 40:14 The Legacy of Foxing: A Band's Journey 43:23 Personal Connections and Farewell to Foxing 46:29 Ranking the Discography: A Deep Dive 56:43 Reflections on Music and Personal Growth
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew reflect on their recent concert experiences, particularly focusing on the Deftones and Idles performances. They discuss the impact of live music, the dynamics of concert crowds, and the evolution of bands over time. The conversation also touches on gaming, particularly the new Borderlands 4, and concludes with a review of the new album by Saturdays at Your Place, highlighting its emotional depth and musicality. Chapters 00:00 Concert Reflections and Post-Concert Malaise 02:45 Gaming and Music: The Perfect Combo 05:36 Idols: A Surprising Opener 10:44 Deftones Concert Experience 16:26 Setlist Surprises and Fan Reactions 26:43 The Evolution of Deftones' Sound 29:08 Live Performance Highlights 32:57 Setlist Insights and Fan Reactions 34:29 The Encore Experience 36:47 Reflections on the Concert 42:42 New Music Review: Saturdays at Your Place
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, Craig and Andrew discuss their in-person podcasting experience while anticipating a Deftones concert. They reflect on the evolution of Deftones' sound, their new album, and the expectations for the concert setlist. The conversation also touches on the legacy of new metal bands, personal connections to music, nostalgia for the 90s music scene, and the impact of streaming services like Spotify on music quality. They conclude with a discussion about Turnstile's recent Tiny Desk performance. Chapters 00:00 In-Person Podcasting Experience 02:43 Anticipation for Deftones Concert 05:39 Evolution of Deftones' Sound 08:37 Discussion on New Album and Music Trends 11:23 Setlist Expectations and Concert Dynamics 14:04 Reflections on Music's Impact and Nostalgia 17:13 Comparative Analysis of Bands and Genres 19:47 Streaming Services and Music Quality 23:00 Final Thoughts and Concert Experience
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew discuss their recent concert experiences, focusing on Chevelle and the evolving legacy of Deftones. They delve into the new album by Deftones, highlighting its quality and emotional depth, and compare it to the latest release from The World Is a Beautiful Place and I Am No Longer Afraid to Die. The conversation touches on the political themes present in the new music and the artistic expressions of both bands, concluding with reflections on the significance of music in today's context. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Engagements 01:07 Concert Experiences and Chevelle 08:13 Nostalgia and Deftones' Rise 09:35 Reviewing Deftones' New Album: Private Music 17:19 Chino's Evolution and Band Dynamics 24:56 Legacy and Current Relevance of Deftones 27:55 Deftones: A Turning Point in Music 28:51 The World Is: Dreams of Being Dust 31:35 Exploring the New Sound of The World Is 34:23 The Emotional Depth of Music 36:18 Song Analysis: Heavy Influences and Guest Vocalists 37:46 The Transition: From Aggression to Beauty 40:36 Political Commentary in Music 45:03 Exploring Violence and Empathy in Lyrics 47:23 Final Thoughts on the Album 51:22 The Future of The World Is and Their Sound
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew discuss a variety of topics ranging from personal anecdotes about running injuries to the latest music releases and concert experiences. They delve into the recent Taylor Swift album announcement, share their thoughts on concerts they've attended, and review new music from bands like Deftones, AFI, Militarie Gun, and Pool Kids. The conversation also touches on the legacy of Death Cab for Cutie and the challenges of vulnerability in songwriting. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Podcast Insights 00:58 Injury Tales and Running Experiences 03:54 Taylor Swift Album Announcement Discussion 07:48 Concert Experiences and the Avett Brothers 10:29 Chautauqua Concert Series Overview 15:13 New Music Releases: Deftones and AFI 24:56 Navigating Parenting and Teen Choices 25:48 AFI's Musical Evolution and Personal Connections 27:23 Concert Experiences and Band Discoveries 30:29 Exploring Camp Trash's Sound and Influences 31:59 Anticipation for Pool Kids' New Album 34:29 Militarie Gun: Personal Struggles and Artistic Expression 39:45 The Bravery of Vulnerability in Music 44:32 Comparing Frontmen: Ian Shelton and Jeff Rickley 46:07 Death Cab for Cutie: Legacy and Critique
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew discuss a variety of topics related to music, including personal concert experiences, the tragic incident at an Oasis show, and the ongoing streaming wars between Spotify and YouTube. They delve into the new album by The Armed, exploring its themes, production quality, and lyrical content, while also reflecting on the challenges of discovering new music in today's landscape. The conversation highlights the importance of live performances and the emotional connections they create, as well as the complexities of the music industry. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Concert Experiences 03:34 Tragedy at Concerts and Its Impact 04:19 Streaming Wars: Spotify vs. YouTube 11:07 Quality of Music Streaming Services 16:54 Concert Reviews: The Mountain Goats and Guster 22:22 Emerging Artists: Leve and Her Impact 24:36 The Armed: A New Album and Their Evolution 29:13 The Importance of Lyrics in Music 34:49 Musical Production and Chaos 42:20 Niche Appeal and Audience Connection 50:49 The Challenge of Embracing New Music
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss a variety of topics including Coldplay's recent viral moment, the legacy of Ozzy Osbourne following his passing, and a deep dive into the album 'Painted Shut' by Hop Along. They explore the impact of these artists on music and culture, share personal anecdotes, and reflect on the power of live performances. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Local Sports Culture 02:52 Viral Moments and Public Shaming 05:25 The Legacy of Ozzy Osbourne 11:05 Osmosis: A Return to Form 22:11 Influence of the Osbournes on Pop Culture 29:54 Remembering Ozzy Osbourne 36:38 The Legacy of Hop Along's 'Painted Shut'
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew discuss their current podcasting preferences, share concert experiences, and dive into the evolution of various music artists including Wet Leg, Sam Fender, Deftones, The Armed, La Dispute, and Drain. They explore the impact of live performances, the anticipation of new releases, and the significance of personal favorites in their music journey. The conversation also touches on upcoming albums and the changing landscape of music appreciation. Chapters 00:00 Podcasting Fatigue and Escapism 02:39 Concert Experiences and Musical Discoveries 05:28 Wetleg's New Album and Live Performances 08:10 Sam Fender's Impact and Summer Vibes 11:14 Deftones' New Single and Band Dynamics 13:36 Generational Appeal of Bands 16:34 Cultural Commentary on Music Licensing 28:18 Exploring Deftones' New Sound 29:53 The Armed: A Unique Musical Journey 34:52 The World is a Beautiful Place: Anticipation for New Music 36:42 La Dispute: A Return to Form 42:10 Agriculture: Avant-Garde Black Metal 45:04 Drain: Hardcore Energy and Anticipation
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss the recent departure of Matt Cameron from Pearl Jam, the excitement surrounding new music from Deftones, and the long-awaited reunion of Oasis. They explore the dynamics of the Oasis brothers, fan reactions to their reunion, and speculate on the future of Pearl Jam and potential replacements for Matt Cameron. The conversation reflects on the legacy of Matt Cameron and the impact of these changes in the music industry. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Unexpected Topics 02:53 Deftones New Music Expectations 05:31 Oasis Reunion: A Long-Awaited Return 10:42 The Dynamics of the Gallagher Brothers 16:10 Fan Reactions and Emotional Connections 20:05 Matt Cameron's Departure from Pearl Jam 27:08 Speculations on Future Projects 30:33 Controversy Surrounding Taylor Hawkins' Comments 31:38 Understanding Context in Media Narratives 32:58 Speculating on Drummer Changes in Iconic Bands 35:37 Comparing Drumming Styles: Matt Cameron vs. Josh Freese 37:24 The Future of Soundgarden Without Chris Cornell 39:05 Reactions to Potential Soundgarden Reunions 42:21 The Dynamics of Replacing a Long-Term Drummer 45:08 Potential Replacements for Matt Cameron 46:47 Reflecting on Dave Abbruzzese's Legacy 49:39 The Emotional Impact of Drummer Changes 55:20 Matt Cameron's Influence on Pearl Jam's Sound
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig and Andrew reflect on the music landscape halfway through the year, discussing their favorite albums, the evolution of music criticism, and the impact of personal experiences on music appreciation. They delve into the new album by Greed Death, exploring expectations versus reality, and the dynamics of songwriting within the band. The conversation also touches on the influence of the pandemic on music, revisiting albums from 2020, and the emotional connections that music creates. They conclude with thoughts on the future of music and the intentions of artists in today's landscape. Chapters 00:00 Celebrating Independence and Music Mid-Year Review 02:42 The Evolution of Music Critique vs. Fan Perspective 05:36 Greet Death's New Album: Die in Love 10:54 Comparing New Releases: Anticipation vs. Reality 16:19 The Impact of Pandemic on Music Appreciation 21:48 Revisiting 2020 Albums: Hits and Misses 26:50 The Future of Music: Bands and Their Place in Time 29:04 Nostalgic Connections to Music 31:06 Exploring Albums from 2020 33:02 Mansions and Artistic Evolution 35:36 Reflecting on 2020's Musical Landscape 37:20 The Impact of 'Nothing' and 'The Great Dismal' 40:57 Spanish Love Songs: A Pandemic Companion 44:53 Contrasting Critical Reception of Albums 47:14 Taylor Swift's Pandemic Releases
Summary In this episode of the Album of Record podcast, hosts Craig Lyndall and Andrew Schnitkey discuss their recent concert experiences, focusing on Counting Crows and their live performance. They delve into the nuances of the band's evolution and the expectations of legacy acts. The conversation shifts to new music, highlighting the punk band Skinhead and their album 'What a Beautiful Day,' which showcases a unique blend of punk and hardcore influences. The hosts also revisit the 1995 album 'Subliminal Plastic,' reflecting on its eclectic sound and its place in the alternative rock landscape. The episode concludes with a discussion of upcoming releases, including new music from World is a Beautiful Place and the anticipation surrounding their next album. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Summer Concerts 09:12 Counting Crows Live Experience 18:18 New Music Discoveries: Skinhead 27:39 Hotline TNT: A New Indie Sensation 28:02 Exploring a Forgotten Album from 1995 34:45 Nostalgia and the Impact of Time on Music 40:06 The Evolution of Alternative Rock in the 90s 43:08 New Music Releases and Anticipation
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew discuss a variety of topics related to music, including the impact of Turnstile's new album, the evolution of concert experiences, and the appeal of minimalism in personal spaces. They delve into the significance of band merch, promotional strategies in the music industry, and the changing landscape of album sales. Nostalgia and its role in music consumption are explored, along with the experiences of live music and the influence of musical biopics. The episode concludes with a recommendation for Queens of the Stone Age's unique live performance. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Summer Vibes 02:45 Nostalgia and Home Spaces 05:23 Minimalism and Decluttering 08:03 Turnstile's Rise and Album Success 10:47 Marketing and Promotion Strategies 13:41 Haley Williams and Paramore's Influence 16:16 Concert Experiences and Merchandise 18:54 Reflections on Music and Nostalgia 21:43 Upcoming Turnstile Concert and Tour Details 27:56 Band Names and Their Impact 29:29 Concerts and Upcoming Shows 31:29 The Evolution of Music Genres 36:53 Filter and Their Legacy 41:21 Bruce Springsteen Biopic Discussion 47:19 Queens of the Stone Age: Alive in the Catacombs
Summary In this episode, Craig and Andrew dive deep into Turnstile's latest album 'Never Enough', exploring the band's evolution from hardcore roots to a more alternative rock sound. They discuss the mixed reception of the album, the significance of live performances, and the impact of diversity in the hardcore scene. The conversation also touches on the importance of authenticity in music, the band's creative choices, and the future prospects for Turnstile as they continue to redefine their identity in the music world. In this conversation, Andrew Schnitkey and Craig Lyndall delve into the dynamics of Turnstile's music, particularly focusing on their latest album 'Never Enough'. They discuss the excitement surrounding new collaborations, the energy of live performances, and the evolution of the band's sound compared to their previous work, 'Glow On'. The hosts explore individual tracks, highlighting their unique qualities and the overall consistency of the album. They also reflect on the live experience and the community aspect of music, emphasizing the joy of being a fan and the importance of supporting artists. Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Turnstile Week 01:44 The Hardcore Debate: Are They Still Hardcore? 05:11 Live Shows vs. Studio Recordings 10:52 The Polarizing Reception of 'Never Enough' 15:44 Turnstile's Unique Position in the Hardcore Scene 20:47 Bringing Diversity to Hardcore Shows 26:00 The Importance of Authenticity in Music 30:48 Production Choices and Band Evolution 35:52 Future Prospects for Turnstile 36:58 The Excitement of New Collaborations 39:01 The Dynamics of Live Performances 40:35 Musical Evolution and Album Comparisons 42:47 Exploring Individual Tracks 51:09 The Live Experience and Audience Engagement 56:46 Celebrating Music and Community