DiscoverThe Catholic Thing
The Catholic Thing
Claim Ownership

The Catholic Thing

Author: The Catholic Thing

Subscribed: 54Played: 3,175
Share

Description

The Catholic Thing is a daily column rooted in the richest cultural tradition in the world, i.e., the concrete historical reality of Catholicism.
1143 Episodes
Reverse
By Francis X. Maier But first a note from Robert Royal: We're at the end of another week and I'm grateful for the generosity readers are showing. But this thing still just won't work unless many more of you step up. And soon. It really isn't right to make me beg. Is it? Be merciful and swift in supporting TCT. Today. Now for today's column... Proverbs has two verses – 31:26 and 28 – that lift the heart of any man astute enough to marry a woman of deep Christian character: "She opens her mouth with wisdom, and the teaching of kindness is on her tongue. . . .Her children rise up and call her blessed; her husband also, and he praises her." My life is filled with women I love: a beautiful wife (and veteran educator) of 56 years; a wonderful daughter, the mother of seven; two daughters-in-law, each a successful executive; and six granddaughters. Together they shape my world. Their happiness matters to me. So it seems reasonable to ask if and how modern feminism serves that goal. Opinions are mixed. We might start with this quotation: "The rule of law will not survive the legal profession becoming majority female." Those are incendiary words. They're designed to sting. But they're not the bile of some misogynist male. They're taken from "The Great Feminization," an October 2025 essay by Helen Andrews, based on conference remarks she delivered a month earlier. The video of those remarks has – so far – drawn 373,000 views. On the web, her essay has millions more. Simply put, it hit a nerve. Andrews is an author of significant intellect and skill. She's willing to make people uncomfortable when it comes to matters of substance and notes that women increasingly populate our society's major institutions like medicine, business, journalism, and law. And as they become majorities, those institutions change, sometimes for the better and sometimes not. Why? Because women differ from men in how they think, act, and exercise power. "Cancel culture," she argues, "is simply what women do whenever there are enough of them in a given organization or field. . . .Everything you think of as 'wokeness' is simply an epiphenomenon of demographic feminization." The philosopher Carrie Gress takes a different but equally critical approach toward feminism in her books The End of Woman and Something Wicked. She notes – as did James Billington in his classic study of the revolutionary spirit, Fire in the Minds of Men – that prominent early feminists toyed with, or actively pursued, the occult. They despised Christianity and viewed the family as a trap for female servitude. As a result, for Gress, modern feminism is poisoned at its root. In effect, it functions as a shadow anti-Church. It cannot be purified or "baptized." Gress is a gifted, articulate scholar, as evidenced here and here. She has a keen grasp of the costs mainstream feminism has inflicted on women. The movement's "sacrament" of abortion, for example, is both an expression of self-harm and a license to kill millions of unborn children. Thus, in Something Wicked, she argues that "Christianity, at its core, is built on richness of relationships, family, and tradition. Feminism was built on an ideological system that denies the goodness of all three. The two simply cannot be blended." Alas, the problem with a word like "feminism" is twofold. First, as with "socialism," "liberalism," or even "Christianity," different people use the same word to mean very different things. Second, all enduring ideas, even the worst ones, have some sustaining seed of truth. Modern, mainstream feminism, whatever its flaws, is the flower of legitimate grievance. In this case, it's women's experience of mistreatment and discrimination over centuries. So the question becomes: In the world as it is, how should Christians respond? In recent decades, organizations like ENDOW — "Educating on the Nature and Dignity of Women" — have reached hundreds of thousands of women with a Biblical vision of feminine dignity and leaders...
By Brad Miner But first a note from Robert Royal: Brad Miner. On movies. Enough said. Support The Catholic Thing. Now for today's column... Who was America's greatest Roman Catholic movie director? My answer is Leo McCarey. But I need to acknowledge other great Catholic directors. There's John Ford, whose The Quiet Man is a candidate for the greatest Catholic movie – or should that be the greatest Irish movie? There's Alfred Hitchcock, whose I Confess is certainly a candidate for the most interesting Catholic film. There's Frank Capra. His It's a Wonderful Life is among the most beloved movies ever made, although it's not specifically Catholic. In fact, Capra never made what we could call a Catholic movie. And there's Henry King, a Catholic convert, whose The Song of Bernadette received 11 Oscar nominations and has become a classic. Martin Scorsese? Francis Ford Coppola? Mel Gibson? No. One sees Catholicism in their work, but it's subsumed under a veneer of, well, godlessness, in the case of the first two, and recklessness in the case of the third. Which brings me to Leo McCarey. He's my choice, primarily because he made two of Hollywood's most explicitly Catholic films: Going My Way (1944) and The Bells of St. Mary's (1945). And there are two other films of great merit that I'll get to in a moment, although neither was "Catholic," except in the sense that everything McCarey directed was shaped by his Catholic humanism. Let me define that: It's the deep respect for human dignity, reason, culture, and creativity. It's the idea that being fully Catholic and fully engaged with all that is human – through art, literature, philosophy, the sciences, and ordinary life – reinforces each other. Grace doesn't bypass nature but perfects it. So cultivating stories of the human person is itself an essential part of Christian life, and never a distraction from it. For me, the best expression of what I think characterizes McCarey's view comes not from a Roman Catholic but from an ancient Roman, the playwright Terence: "I am a man; I consider nothing human alien to me." McCarey often pursued this in his films through comedy, beginning with Laurel and Hardy and the Marx Brothers, the screwball comedies The Awful Truth (which catapulted Cary Grant to superstardom), Once Upon a Honeymoon, and My Favorite Wife, and then, of course, those two great films about the amiable priest, Fr. Chuck O'Malley. Going My Way and The Bells of St. Mary's were almost unimaginably popular and, in my opinion, culturally transformational. I don't want to overstate the fact, but those films portrayed Catholic life in America in such a way as to diminish anti-Catholicism in the U.S. McCarey's films did not eliminate that prejudice, any more than the films starring Sidney Poitier eliminated racism a generation later. But those men did move the ball closer to the goal. McCarey also directed one of Hollywood's most successful romantic films – actually, one film in two versions. He made Love Affair in 1929 (with Charles Boyer and Irene Dunne), and then remade it as An Affair to Remember in 1957, the latter being his fourth film with Cary Grant (and also starring Deborah Kerr). The Awful Truth (1937) was an awful experience for Grant because McCarey favored improvisation to an extent that frazzled his star's nerves. But it was McCarey who taught Grant how to be a comic actor. One sees Grant's comic timing and wonderful double takes in My Favorite Wife, and it is listed among McCarey's films, and it should be, despite the fact that he didn't direct it. He intended to (and it was based on his original story). But a horrific automobile accident, in which he was badly injured and lucky to survive, put him in the hospital just before filming began and kept him there until after the movie wrapped. It seems clear this near-death experience was very much why his next films were very Catholic. Going My Way and The Bells of St. Mary's were the most commercially successful films...
By Michael Pakaluk But first a note from Robert Royal: Professor Pakaluk takes a careful - and much-needed - look today at a piece of bad news about low levels of belief about the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist among Catholics. Things may not be as bad as a recent survey suggested. But Vatican II said the Eucharist is the "source and summit" of Christian life. So if Catholics are wavering about that teaching, it may mean things are very precarious indeed. We now have to pursue all available means - teaching, preaching, devotions - to restore that understanding. That's one of our central commitments here at TCT. If that's important to you, too, please help. Now for today's column... A recent study reports, once again, that only about three in ten American Catholics believe in the Real Presence. Suppose someone asks you the question the study posed: "Do you believe that when the priest consecrates the host during Mass: (1) the bread and wine are transformed, actually becoming the body and blood of Christ, or do you believe (2) the bread and wine are symbols of his body and blood, or (3) are you not sure what happens?" You should reply that it's a deeply confused question. Any educated Catholic ought to say that he doesn't quite know how to answer it. Answer (1), as ordinary English would understand it, is false. It's not true that the bread and wine are "transformed." The substance of the bread and the substance of the wine are changed, indeed, but the accidents (appearances) remain the same. Since the bread and the wine just are the substances together with their accidents, they are not transformed. Even if (1) were revised accordingly, it would still be misleading, because it is incomplete. The substance of the bread is changed into the body of Christ, yes; but the whole Christ is present in the consecrated bread, His "body, blood, soul, and divinity," and so too in the consecrated wine. Christ is living, not dead. Therefore, He must have a soul. He is both God and man. Therefore, He must possess divinity. As the question is written, it invites us to picture the bread becoming the body, and the wine the blood, and nothing more, which is to picture Christ as a corpse, because only when He was lying in the tomb was His body separated from His blood and from His soul. The question leaves out exactly what makes Eucharistic devotion the love of a divine person. Given these difficulties, a thoughtful person might prefer (2), because it is true that "when" the priest consecrates the host, just as "before" he does so, the bread and wine are symbols of Christ's body and blood (that is, they stand for them). Answer (2), then, looks more truthful than (1). Note that answer (2) does not concern what happens after or by the consecration. In particular, it does not affirm that the bread and wine remain unchanged, or that they are "merely" symbols. A sacrament does what it symbolizes: of course they are symbols. Anyone, then, who thought carefully about (1) and (2) might feel constrained to endorse (3) as a failsafe, with "I'm not sure what happens" coming to mean "I'm not sure I can endorse either of the two alternatives you've given me." After all, a faithful Catholic is free to endorse (3) if he means by it, "I'm not sure of the mechanism or means by which it happens," which is to say, "It's a mystery." Are you really "sure what happens" at the moment of consecration? Should we judge it a worthwhile goal that everyone who checks off a box identifying himself as "Catholic" should also respond (1) to the question above? I don't see that it is. Is it a great failure if someone does not? The greater failure is that most such Catholics are seldom at Mass. And yet it is the checkbox that is decried when it is reported that only one-third of Catholics believe in the Real Presence. The goal seems stranger still when the question appears in a survey series that also asks, "Do you agree or disagree that it is sometimes okay for a marr...
By Fr. Raymond J. de Souza But first a note from Robert Royal: One of the greatest things about being Editor in Chief of The Catholic Things is that I get to read authors like Fr. De Souza - a day before you do. If you appreciate our authors as much as I do, you know what I'm going to say next. They work for very modest compensation, but their contributions are great. So please help keep this marvelous Catholic Thing going. You know the drill. There's the button, you, TCT. Now for today's column... Saint Peter's Basilica is the world's most Catholic thing. The image of it, in a news video or a movie scene, stands for the Catholic Church. EWTN, the world's largest religious network, includes just the silhouette of Michelangelo's dome in the logo, sufficient by itself to manifest Catholic identity. Pope Leo XIV concluded his long homecoming trip to South America – including Argentina, in place of the homecoming trip never made by Pope Francis – in time to be back at St. Peter's on Wednesday, the four hundredth anniversary of the dedication of the basilica. It is not the most important liturgical site in Rome – St. John Lateran is Rome's cathedral. But it is the largest and most impressively decorated. Every church serves as an analogous sacrament, a visible sign of the invisible reality of the Church. St. Peter's, from cupola to colonnade, does so on such a grand scale and with such surpassing beauty that the whole world recognizes it. It manifests the reality of the Church, in the world for the world, to point worldly eyes toward heavenly things. And it is very much of the world, touched by the various vainglories and venalities of the very peak of the High Renaissance. Like Dante for the Italian language, or Shakespeare for English, St. Peter's is the summit of sacred architecture and art. The pilgrim knows that he is visiting the best that has ever been built – and the best that ever will be. It is of the world not only in its human origins, but of the world in that it is the best the world has to offer. Nothing greater will be seen this side of Heaven; indeed, it exists precisely to allow Heaven to be seen from this side of earth. At four hundred years, St. Peter's is not even half as old as its predecessor, the first St. Peter's, which lasted more than a thousand years. The earlier church's origins under the worldly power of Constantine reflect the Christian insistence that it supremely matters where God traced his finger in the world. In 326, thirteen hundred years before the current St. Peter's dedication, Constantine and his mother, St. Helena, gave the orders to build the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem. The first St. Peter's was built precisely over Peter's relics, venerated on the same Vatican hill where he was crucified. It was the triumph of particularity over practicality. Building St. Peter's over St. Peter meant leveling a good part of the hill itself, when nearby there was already a convenient imperial circus, flat and ready. But Peter was not buried there, and the difference between here and there is the story of salvation. By 1503, when Pope Julius II was elected, the papacy was in bad shape. Pope Pius III, his immediate predecessor, reigned for only twenty-seven days, fewer even than Blessed John Paul I in 1978. They called Julius il papa terribile, meaning both fierce and warlike. He was, though, not as terrible as Alexander VI Borgia, who died that same year before Pius III. Rome: The Interior of St. Peter's by Giovanni Paolo Panini, 1735 [The National Gallery, London] Old St. Peter's was in bad shape too, dilapidated after a millennium. Replacing such a venerable edifice seemed impossible. Very much like how only Mussolini could bulldoze the buildings around St. Peter's to create the magnificent Via della Conciliazione, Julius gave the order to demolish the old and build anew. It takes a certain tyrannical cast of mind to do such things; and the mind of Julius, it is said, thought of Julius C...
By Robert Royal But first a note: We're moving along well in our fundraising. Still, we really need more of you to step up now if we're going to be able to continue bringing you the many different "things" - from the columns to news and commentary, to podcasts and courses, even a weekly commentary on the Catechism - produced by TCT and the Faith & Reason Institute. There's great need for all of this - and more - in both the Church and the world. We're not giving up on any of it. In fact, we're planning on doing even more in the year to come. So please, if you recognize that need, here's a chance to do something about it. Be generous, be part of the work of The Catholic Thing. Now for today's column... It's been a real pleasure this past week to watch Pope Leo's impressive trip to Latin America. If there was any question about his health, the way he only seemed to gather energy as he made his way through Uruguay and Argentina and, finally, to the cheering crowds in Peru – a 12-day schedule that would have exhausted most people half his age – has demonstrated beyond doubt that, at least for the moment, we have a very vigorous pontiff. The media tended to focus on stray political remarks that the pope made (universal health care in Uruguay, justice for environmentalists killed in Peru) – the usual throwaway lines. His specifically Catholic messages were more interesting: prayer and fasting for vocations in Montevideo; not ignoring doctrine for "pastoral" reasons in Buenos Aires (a corrective to Pope Francis?); and staying faithful to Jesus' Church in Peru (Protestantism is growing throughout Latin America). These are all good words, but it would be good to see them followed up with strong action – especially with appointments in the same vein to the Curia and in nominations to the College of Cardinals. And with attention to several challenges elsewhere in the world. A wise Italian friend said something to me in Rome last week that's obvious, once you think about it, though we rarely do. The Vatican is the nerve center of Christianity and, as such, tries to advance Catholic spiritual and moral/cultural goals. But it is also a state and, as such, also seeks to have good diplomatic relations with other states and even large cultural groups. This has its positive side – Rome can be a disinterested broker when international tensions arise and has often played that role historically. But it also has costs, if badly pursued – witness the disastrous, still "secret" accord with China, or the way the two most recent popes have ignored plain historical truth and tried to make peace with – even deny threats from – Islam. Just this week, the Observatory on Intolerance and Discrimination against Christians in Europe (OIDAC), in its 2026 report on anti-Christian "hate crimes" (using the European Union's own criteria) found 2,465 instances in Europe. The breakdown by country is interesting: It's no accident that the countries that have permitted the largest influx of illegal migration from Islamic states – France, the UK, Germany, and Austria – have the largest numbers of incidents. Islamic radicals are not responsible for all these attacks, of course, but it would be very naïve to dismiss the correlation. Pope Leo has spoken several times about the need to be "less afraid" of Islam. The facts on the ground – rarely reported or played down by major news sources – say that it's simply truthful to have greater concern about Islam, both for what it's doing in the secular world and for how treating Islam as just another of the "world religions" is having tangible consequences for Christians. Aid to the Church in Need, too, has just issued a biennial report about Christian persecution in the world. (See our podcast with the main author of the report here.) Christians are under threat in 165 countries, over 220 million worldwide. You sometimes get the impression that, like European governments and the media, the Vatican doesn't want to call attent...
loading
Comments