Discover
The Debate
34 Episodes
Reverse
Gang of three or glorified photo op? Chinese President Xi Jinping is hosting his US and Russian counterparts Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC summit. Already, our Monday panel rejected attempts to paint the three-way meeting as a new Yalta, in reference to the 1945 sit-down on the Black Sea that defined the post-war security architecture of Europe. We ask if the trilateral meeting was indeed little more than a PR exercise and what the leaders of China, Russia and the United States have in common. Could the trio even go "full Yalta" if they wanted to and carve up Ukraine? Kyiv is sending quite the calling card to the parties in Shenzhen by knocking out Putin’s jewel: the bridge that leads from the Russian mainland to Yalta in the Crimean peninsula. To show Ukraine is not alone, European backers are staging what some have billed as a counter-summit in Berlin, with the Franco-British led coalition that some have dubbed the "coalition of the willing", others "NATO without the Americans". Is this a message of resolve for the Kremlin? A way of telling pro-Ukraine lawmakers in Washington that traditional allies are leaving the light on for them? Or a way to remind China – whose strength rests on its export-driven economy – that Europe imports a significant amount of goods that are made in Shenzhen? Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Léonore Jaury.
You can strike Jensen Huang from the guest list, but good luck steering dinner conversation away from the topic in Shenzhen. The co-founder of the AI computing giant was set to accompany the US president to the APEC summit before he was undone by revelations of a dalliance with a Chinese national that happened to coincide with a Singapore client's backdoor skirting of sanctions on its powerful H200 chips. We ask about the fallout and the subsequent tightening of restrictions on US exports of chips to China, the infighting within the Trump administration and whether Huang's fall from grace marks a high point in Silicon Valley's bid to quickly corner the market on artificial intelligence. A comeuppance for the likes of OpenAI and Anthropic, one day before its launch on the stock market? Or will the United States simply double down on export restrictions and impose its will where it can? What consequences will there be in the host city of the summit, Shenzhen, which is home to huge homegrown tech and industry champions but also, for instance, the Chinese headquarters of US retail giant Walmart? Summits can assuage some of the planet's biggest fears. But how did we get from a world where that biggest fear was nuclear proliferation to one where it's artificial intelligence? Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Charles Wente.
There's just five months to go before the French vote in the presidential election first round to choose Emmanuel Macron's successor. But it's not much of a race so far for the top two spots in the May 2 run-off: there's the far right's Marine Le Pen, the far left's Jean-Luc Mélenchon, with the other candidates lagging far behind. Whether it's on social media or in the streets, Le Pen and Mélenchon's supporters rule, in a radical break with the mainstream. A decade ago, it also felt like unchartered territory: when Macron was first elected, the 39-year-old had never run for public office. He promised political transgression: "en même temps" or "at the same time" politics, tapping into the best of the left and the right, but that promise never became a coalition of movements. France's institutions answer to a strong executive power. That has enabled Macron to govern alone, very alone, even when in the present day his minority government is badly outnumbered in the current parliament. We ask about the deep resentment many French people feel towards their outgoing president, a resentment that can surprise international audiences that still have the image of a charismatic wunderkind who stands for mainstream values. Amid a splintered field, as parties from the conservatives on the right to the Socialists on the left try – and so far fail – to build excitement around a candidate who can rally moderates, we ask which way to tack: insurgent or back to more traditional politics? With what messaging and, most importantly, on what political platform? Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Charles Wente.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is asserting that the United States has asked him about a straight-up swap: Russia gets the Donbas and the rest of Ukraine gets NATO membership – a guarantee against Moscow later having a second go and annexing the entire country. Whether or not the offer is real, serious or either side would accept it is another matter. We ask if the talk of partition signals some kind of turning point in a nearly five-year war that's at a brutal stalemate. The remarks came just days ahead of a three-way summit in Shenzhen, China that some have likened to Yalta, the 1945 carving up of Europe between the Soviets and Anglo-Americans. Is that a fair comparison? From weekend border tensions between Russia and Estonia to EU leaders' inability to agree on a single name to represent the bloc in Ukraine war talks, we ask what this crucial week means for the future of the continent, where some of Ukraine's strongest backers may be on borrowed time. Enter French presidential frontrunner Marine Le Pen, the far-right leader whose 2017 campaign was financed by a Russian bank. She knows that a majority of her compatriots support Ukraine, hence a courtesy call this Monday to its ambassador in Paris. But she repeated afterwards that if elected, she'll pull the plug on financing for Kyiv. Produced by Rebecca Gnignati, Elisa Amiri, Ilayda Habip.
It's sweater weather in Paris. But even though November brings brisk temperatures and autumn foliage, it doesn't mean last summer's record heat should fade from our memories. One of the suggested reasons why students are so boiling mad is the hell they endured back in June in overheated classrooms and baking shoebox apartments. The global warming issue is compounded by the war in the Gulf driving up prices at the pump and in stores. In this, an El Niño year where the whole planet is prey to extreme weather, the hosts of the annual UN climate summit in Turkey tout a remedy: turbo-charge the electrification of the world. We ask about what they mean and whether it will work, particularly for the likes of India, whose carbon footprint is growing alongside its economy and its population. Many look at the smog this time of year and compare it with the China of the early 2000s. What lessons can Delhi learn from its neighbour's energy transition? China, meanwhile, remains the planet's manufacturing powerhouse. Produced by François Picard, Théophile Vareille, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Charles Wente.



