DiscoverThe Edward Show
The Edward Show
Claim Ownership

The Edward Show

Author: Edward Sturm

Subscribed: 61Played: 6,133
Share

Description

Daily SEO advice, hacks, and interviews with some of the top voices in search engine optimization, as well as sit-downs with many undiscovered talents.
1232 Episodes
Reverse
E1235: Google's November 2026 core update is hitting some websites hard, particularly sites that have scaled AI-generated content. Some SEOs report traffic drops of 75% to 90%, while others are seeing major gains. I examine traffic data, reports from website owners, whether Google is targeting AI content, and what to do if your rankings have collapsed. Here's what I cover: 1. Websites losing traffic during Google's November core update - One website dropped from 200 clicks per day to 20 after its owner rebuilt it with Claude Code and published new content. - Another site publishing one AI-generated article daily experienced a sharp decline in clicks and impressions. - Malte Landwehr identified two domains that publicly discussed scaling AI content and subsequently lost rankings. - One business owner reported a 75% traffic loss despite being one of only two companies making its product. 2. Websites gaining traffic - One SEO reported growing from 5 monthly clicks to 21,540 in 16 days. - Another website owner reported a 6X recovery after the December 2025 core update. - Other site owners report stable rankings or modest increases. - Why overall industry chatter is quieter than during a typical core update. 3. Is Google targeting AI-generated content? - Reports of major losses from websites that scaled AI content. - Google's guidance on manually fact-checking and reviewing AI-generated content. - Why I believe Google could evaluate AI usage across an entire site. - Why Google's Deep Review fact-checking tool doesn't explain the changes. - The difference between AI-polished writing and unreviewed AI-generated articles. 4. Craig Campbell and James Dooley's AI content experiment - How they published 1,200 AI-generated articles on a website. - How traffic grew at first, then collapsed about six months later. - How removing and replacing the content failed to recover the domain. 5. Are social media platforms taking over Google? - Facebook's estimated organic traffic reaching an all-time high of 8.2 billion monthly visits, according to Semrush. - How Reddit, YouTube, Instagram, and X are below their previous traffic highs. - LinkedIn's estimated Google traffic falling from 769 million to 396 million monthly visits. - How LinkedIn remains useful for parasite SEO. 6. What to do if your website was hit - Why minor traffic fluctuations are normal, especially for smaller websites. - How you should wait for the core update to finish rolling out. - Identify the pages experiencing the biggest declines. - How to reassess search intent, content quality, and above-the-fold answers. - What to examine in page titles, URLs, H1s, and internal links. - Why you should keep publishing bottom-of-funnel landing pages. Don't confuse normal volatility with a major traffic collapse. If your site has suffered a steep decline, take a critical look at whether your pages deserve to rank. If your rankings are stable, keep building. 💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/ ⭐️ Noel Ceta's post on 𝕏 - https://x.com/noelcetaSEO/status/2123545906733584682  ⭐️ Zac Baldwin's post on 𝕏 - https://x.com/Zac_Baldwin/status/2123497728009474428  ⭐️ Andrei Saioc's post on 𝕏 - https://x.com/asaio87/status/2121933498772504870  ⭐️ Malte Landwehr's post on 𝕏 - https://x.com/MalteLandwehr/status/2122235819385598039  ⭐️ Google Deep Review - https://research.google/deepreview/  ⭐️ Google Search's Guidance on Generative AI Content on Your Website - https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/using-gen-ai-content ⭐️ Ep 1217 - Craig Campbell: The SEO Tricks Google Still Can't Stop - https://youtu.be/BX5Pir_5DFA  ⭐️ Google November 2026 Core Update Ranking Volatility (Search Engine Roundtable) - https://www.seroundtable.com/google-november-2026-core-update-ranking-volatility-42543.html  00:00 November Update Setup 00:22 Why Sites Are Tanking 00:44 Social Platforms Data 01:53 Real World Winners Losers 03:40 AI Content Hit Examples 04:58 Deep Review Tool Myth 06:42 How Google Detects AI 07:34 Google Guidance And Case Study 09:41 Update Context And Chatter 12:03 Advice For Drops And Volatility 13:33 Build BOFU Landing Pages The Edward Show. The #1 search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/  #searchengineoptimization #seo #performancemarketing #digitalmarketing
E1234: James Norquay bought an affiliate website making $200 per month for $4,000. He changed its targeting from the UK to Australia, published hundreds of pages, built relevant backlinks, and eventually grew it to $30,000 per month. James has spent 21 years in SEO. He runs a major Sydney SEO and digital PR agency, manages around 30 affiliate websites, and organizes the Sydney SEO Conference. We discuss how he scaled that site, what he'd do if starting today, and the strategies he uses for his own websites and enterprise clients. Here's what we cover: Buying and Scaling Affiliate Websites - How James bought a mattress affiliate site after its earnings fell from $5,000 to $200/month. - How he shifted its focus from the UK to Australia, added hundreds of pages, and earned local backlinks. - Why he published all the new content at once rather than gradually. - How it reached $30,000/month before a Google update reduced its earnings. - Why he prefers buying established websites over starting from scratch. - Where he finds deals through private Slack groups and paid SEO communities. - How recurring affiliate commissions can keep paying even when rankings fall. - Whether affiliate SEO still works, and the opportunities in local lead generation and SaaS affiliates. Link Building and Digital PR - Why one relevant, high-quality backlink can outweigh 100 low-quality links. - How to evaluate links by real traffic and topical relevance, not just Domain Rating. - Why James recommends pitching regional journalists who receive fewer pitches. - How his team sources data through surveys, public records, purchased datasets, and freedom of information requests. - How to find journalists covering stories related to your data. - Why personalized outreach and journalist relationships beat sending mass emails. - How to find popular statistics pages and create local versions that attract links. - How a reactive digital PR campaign earned around 40 news links in 24 hours. AI Content, Google Updates, and AI Search - What happened when James published thousands of AI-generated pages on test sites. - How one site grew to roughly 40,000 clicks/month before traffic crashed. - Why mass-produced AI content isn't his long-term SEO strategy. - How AI information pages can correct inaccurate brand information in AI search. - How digital PR can increase brand mentions in AI-generated answers. - How technical issues can block ChatGPT and other AI systems from accessing sites. Enterprise SEO and Running an Agency - What small businesses can learn from enterprise SEO teams. - How hacked subdomains, legacy systems, and unauthorized page changes put rankings at risk. - Why dedicated developers can speed up SEO implementation. - How James manages 37 staff and approximately 48 clients. - Why quarterly reviews, clear reporting, and in-person meetings matter for client retention. - How interest in AI search has changed conversations with CEOs and CMOs. - Why relationships and professional networks matter when building an agency. We also discuss James's priorities for organic growth in 2027: digital PR, technical SEO, and building a website that looks and functions like a real business. If you're running an affiliate site, working in SEO, or growing an agency, this interview covers lessons James learned over 21 years in the industry. ⭐️ Sydney SEO Conference & Mastermind - https://prosperitymedia.com.au/sydney-seo-conference/  ⭐️ Prosperity Media - https://prosperitymedia.com.au/  ⭐️ James Norquay on LinkedIn - https://au.linkedin.com/in/norquay  ⭐️ James Norquay on 𝕏 - https://x.com/connections8  💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/  00:00 Welcome and Connections 00:32 James SEO Origin Story 02:28 Affiliate Lessons and Niches 06:58 Testing Sites and Agency Ethics 08:31 DMCA Risks and Avoiding iGaming 11:36 Scaling a Mattress Site 14:35 Buying Sites and Paid Communities 19:01 Link Building and Digital PR 27:13 Data Assets and Journalist Outreach 31:48 Real Business Signals for Links 35:54 Sourcing Data Providers 36:15 Surveys and Journalist Outreach 37:23 Is Affiliate SEO Still Viable 38:03 Local Lead Gen Niches 39:51 Buy Sites and Expired Domains 41:29 Long Tails and SaaS Affiliates 43:05 Brand Building Beats Slop 44:36 AI Content Updates and Risks 47:57 Why SEO Is Still Great 50:44 Enterprise SEO Playbook 53:51 Tech Audits and Security Finds 55:38 Enterprise Risks and Monitoring 58:35 Selling SEO in the GEO Era 01:00:36 Retention Through Reporting and Relationships 01:05:46 Attribution and Custom Tooling 01:11:03 GEO Strategies and AI Info Pages 01:16:02 SEO Testing Mindset 01:17:16 Agency Growth Advice 01:20:45 Mastermind Tactics 01:24:57 Doers vs Talkers 01:27:25 AI Slop Experiment 01:28:49 Three SEO Priorities 01:31:40 Running SEO Events 01:37:12 Landing Bigger Clients 01:39:22 First Enterprise Win 01:42:46 Wrap Up and Where The Edward Show. The #1 search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/  #searchengineoptimization #affiliateseo #seo #generativeengineoptimization
E1233: Affiliates are using public Google Docs to get cited by Perplexity, even when those documents barely rank in Google Search. Jonathan Berthold, VP of Revenue at Ziff Davis (owner of Moz), joins me to share findings from AI search audits across B2B, B2C, ecommerce, and local businesses. In one VPN analysis, roughly 16% of Perplexity citations came from Google Docs. Jonathan found 154 Google Docs pages across just 42 prompts, many targeting specific long-tail searches and containing affiliate links. We break down why this is happening, how ChatGPT and Claude differ, and what businesses should prioritize to get recommended in AI search. What we cover: - The Google Docs loophole: How affiliates get public documents into Perplexity answers. - 154 pages across 42 prompts: What Jonathan found when auditing VPN searches. - The 16% finding: Why Google Docs appeared so often among Perplexity's citations. - How the documents are structured: Long-tail titles, current dates, ranking tables, and lightweight /mobilebasic URLs. - Affiliate links: How tracking URLs remain in documents Perplexity cites. - Google vs. Perplexity: Why documents with almost no traditional search visibility still appear in AI answers. - ChatGPT's brand preferences: Why some ChatGPT query fan-outs already include Sony, Bose, Apple, or other specific brands. - ChatGPT vs. Claude vs. Perplexity: How their searches and citations differ. - Query fan-out research: How to find the questions AI search engines investigate and create pages that answer them. - Black hat GEO: My idea for independent-looking publishers targeting reviews, comparisons, and branded searches - and the problem with undisclosed sponsorship. - Brand marketing: The role of third-party publications, YouTube, Reddit, content creators, and affiliates in AI recommendations. - The 80/20 of AI search: Jonathan's highest-priority actions for businesses that can't pursue every tactic. - Product pages: Why listing concrete use cases, features, and supporting evidence matters. - Temporary loopholes: When a short-lived tactic is worth testing, and why it can be a bad investment for established brands. - Using video: Why customer experiences, product demos, and human-created content may become more valuable. Jonathan also explains how he builds his own tracking tools with Claude Code and Codex, why AI visibility scores are only directional, and identifying the third-party sources influencing recommendations. What this means for your SEO: Don't just track whether AI tools mention your brand. Look at which websites they cite, which competitors appear, and what their query fan-outs reveal. Then improve your own pages and pursue relevant third-party coverage. Different AI search engines rely on different sources. A tactic that succeeds in Perplexity may not work in ChatGPT, Claude, or Google AI Overviews. ⭐️ Jonathan Berthold on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonathanberthold/  ⭐️ Jonathan Berthold on 𝕏: https://x.com/j_bertho  ⭐️ Moz (my affiliate link): https://edwardsturm.com/refer/moz/  💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/  00:00 Parasite SEO on Perplexity 01:35 Why Google Docs Win 04:22 Bias and Fan Out Queries 05:43 Niche Differences and Affiliates 07:08 Omnichannel GEO Signals 11:33 Tools for Fan Out Analysis 14:18 Gaming Perplexity with Docs 18:10 Affiliate Links Still Included 20:33 Indexes and Black Hat Opportunity 22:52 Industry-Specific GEO Strategy 23:55 Prompt Tracking Value 25:38 Brand Marketing Defined 25:47 Brand Marketing Meets SEO 27:59 AI Search Rewards Real Brands 29:24 Shell Publisher Black Hat Tactic 33:07 Disclosure and Ethical Risks 35:10 Turn Customers Into Creators 37:04 Pareto Playbook for GEO 40:37 Human Video Beats AI Slop 42:59 Loopholes Versus Sustainability 47:51 Investing Analogy and Wrap Up The Edward Show. The #1 search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/  #generativeengineoptimization #answerengineoptimization #searchengineoptimization #seo
E1232: Can Google detect AI-generated content? Does Google treat fully AI-written articles differently from content carefully edited by humans? Julian Goldie and I discuss AI content detection, Google's approach to AI SEO, and how to use AI without sacrificing quality. I tested GPTZero, a free AI writing detector, on two SEO pages: an entirely AI-generated article and a landing page largely written with AI but edited line by line. GPTZero identified the first as AI-generated and classified the second as human-written and AI-polished. If a free detector can make that distinction, what can Google detect? We discuss whether the degree of AI involvement could affect rankings, the risks of scaled AI content, and why using AI thoughtfully is different from publishing hundreds of unreviewed articles. Julian also shares how he uses X (Twitter), Claude, and AI automations to drive traffic and sales. In this episode: - AI-generated vs. AI-polished content: My GPTZero experiment and what the results suggest. - Can Google detect AI writing? Why I believe Google can distinguish different degrees of AI-generated content. - Does Google penalize AI content? What Google's guidelines say versus what may happen in search results. - AI watermarks: How identifying AI-generated material could change SEO and AI model training. - Google's quality signals: Our theories about user behavior, content quality, and site-wide trust. - Scaled AI content: Why publishing large numbers of pages without fact-checking or editing could be risky. - AI content and LLM training: Why AI companies may want to separate human-created information from AI-generated text. - Google AI Overviews: Why Google generates AI answers while warning publishers about low-quality AI content. - Google Preferred Sources: Why encouraging readers to select your website as a preferred source matters. - X (Twitter) SEO: How Julian uses X for visibility in Google Search, AI Overviews, and Grok. - Claude and Apify: How Julian researches successful X posts, identifies hooks, and creates content based on what's working. - Elon Musk's repost: How one entirely AI-generated post and video caught Musk's attention. - Three ways to use X for SEO: Build topical authority, appear in search features, and publish keyword-targeted X Articles. - Common AI automation mistakes: Too many subscriptions, poor quality control, and automating processes that haven't produced results. - Julian's AI workflow: Focus on one tool, provide constant feedback, and automate tasks that already generate leads and customers. The main takeaway: Using AI for SEO isn't the same as blindly publishing AI articles. I use AI to create landing pages for a SaaS company I'm funding. Before writing, we establish who's searching, why they're searching, and what they want to accomplish. Then we edit every page line by line, focusing on search intent and conversions. Julian and I also discuss why you should succeed with a marketing process before automating it. If you don't know what works, how can you teach AI to reproduce it? ⭐️ Julian's Free SEO Strategy Session - https://go.juliangoldie.com/strategy-session?utm=edwardshow  ⭐️ Julian's AI Profit Boardroom - https://www.skool.com/ai-profit-lab-7462/about  ⭐️ Julian Goldie on YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@JulianGoldieSEO  ⭐️ Julian Goldie on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/juliangoldieseo/?skipRedirect=true  ⭐️ Julian Goldie on Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/jules_goldie/  ⭐️ Julian Goldie on X - https://x.com/JulianGoldieSEO  💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/  00:00 Quick Intro Setup 01:20 AI Detection Degrees 06:37 Watermarks And Google 14:34 Preferred Sources Signal 15:52 X Twitter For SEO 18:23 Reverse Engineer With Apify 21:36 Common AI Automation Mistakes 24:42 Wrap Up And Where To Watch The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/  #searchengineoptimization #seo #aiseo #generativeengineoptimization
E1231: Google is testing removing AI Mode from Google Search, even though people predicted AI Mode would be the default search experience by now. And there's a possible reason: AI search isn't monetizing nearly as well as traditional search. I cover Google's latest AI Mode tests, a study examining why ChatGPT ads aren't delivering returns for advertisers, and what this means for SEO and digital marketing. Here's what I cover: - Google tests removing AI Mode: Search Engine Roundtable reports that Google is testing removing the AI Mode tab from search results, the AI Mode button from its homepage, and the "Ask Anything" follow-up box from AI Overviews. - Why Google might be testing this: AI Mode generates less advertising revenue than traditional Google Search. Could monetization explain these experiments? - Google's Q3 2026 earnings: Alphabet's revenue and advertising revenue missed Wall Street expectations, net income fell 25% year over year, and shares dropped approximately 10% in after-hours trading. - A study of ChatGPT advertising: Research analyzed nearly 1,900 online stores representing $16 billion in annual sales across 60 weeks of data. - ChatGPT ads versus Google Ads: According to the study, a paid ChatGPT visit generated $0.89 in revenue compared with $2.45 for a paid Google Search visit. - Why ChatGPT ads are overpriced: The researchers estimated that a ChatGPT ad click was worth approximately $0.26 at comparable paid-search returns, despite one major advertiser paying $1.72 per click. - OpenAI's monetization problem: The study examines the gap between current advertising revenue per free ChatGPT user and OpenAI's projected advertising revenue by 2030. - Google admits AI Mode monetizes less: Google's Chief Business Officer, Philipp Schindler, has acknowledged that AI Mode's growing query volume affects monetization because it generates less advertising revenue than traditional search. - What happened to Google's AI search announcements? I revisit Google I/O's May announcements, the predictions that traditional search results would disappear, and how AI features haven't materialized as expected. - Why traditional SEO still matters: AI search engines still need to retrieve information, identify relevant sources, and recommend businesses, products, and services. - What you should actually do as an SEO: Stop reacting to every prediction that SEO is dead. Keep targeting high-intent keywords, building conversion-focused landing pages, strengthening your website's authority, and earning backlinks. The takeaway: These experiments, combined with the challenges of monetizing AI search, are a reminder that predictions about the future of search aren't guarantees. People have been predicting the death of SEO for years. Meanwhile, businesses continue generating customers through search. The fundamentals of SEO that worked 10 and 15 years ago still matter today. Don't let predictions about AI distract you from implementing the SEO strategies that get sales. ⭐️ Google Tests Dropping AI Mode From Search Bar & Ask Anything - https://www.seroundtable.com/google-dropping-ai-mode-again-42534.html  ⭐️ Google: Ads In AI Mode Earning Less Than Traditional Search Ads - https://www.seroundtable.com/google-ai-mode-ads-earn-less-42417.html  ⭐️ Rand Fishkin sharing Christian Schulze's study on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/randfishkin_ive-been-asking-folks-about-their-experiences-share-7523123404594536448-CzR2/  ⭐️ Ep 1053 - The Era of 10 Blue Links Is Over (Google I/O Search + May 2026 Core Update) - https://youtu.be/eD6sNhLHM0I  💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/  00:00 AI Mode Default Hype 00:16 Google Tests Removing AI Mode 01:28 Monetization Concerns 02:10 ChatGPT Ads Study 03:14 Why ChatGPT Ads Underperform 04:39 AI Search Monetization Reality 04:59 Don't Panic SEO Mindset 06:06 Google IO Panic Recap 06:36 What Still Wins in Search 07:09 Wrap Up The Best SEO The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/   #searchengineoptimization #seo #generativeengineoptimization #digitalmarketing
loading
Comments