Discover
The Harvard EdCast
The Harvard EdCast
Author: Harvard Graduate School of Education
Subscribed: 1,349Played: 34,298Subscribe
Share
© All rights reserved
Description
The Harvard EdCast asks a simple but complex question: What makes a difference for learners, educators, families, and communities?
We talk with teachers, researchers, policymakers, and education leaders about the ideas shaping learning—from early childhood through college and career. Together, we explore promising approaches to education’s biggest challenges and inequities, and make complex ideas accessible to everyone.
Produced by the Harvard Graduate School of Education, the podcast is hosted by Jill Anderson, Senior Lecturer Junlei Li, and Ryan Nagelhout.
Guest opinions are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
We talk with teachers, researchers, policymakers, and education leaders about the ideas shaping learning—from early childhood through college and career. Together, we explore promising approaches to education’s biggest challenges and inequities, and make complex ideas accessible to everyone.
Produced by the Harvard Graduate School of Education, the podcast is hosted by Jill Anderson, Senior Lecturer Junlei Li, and Ryan Nagelhout.
Guest opinions are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
486 Episodes
Reverse
Strict cellphone bans in schools may give student achievement a small boost, adding the equivalent of one to two weeks of instruction each year, according to new research by Harvard economist Tom Kane.The study, which analyzed data from 3 million students and thousands of schools, found that schools using lockable cellphone pouches saw greater academic growth than schools that did not restrict phone access.“What our results suggest today is, yes, cell phones in schools are having a negative impact, at least that's what our findings imply,” Kane says.“Since 2013, there's been almost a whole grade equivalent loss in eighth grade math and reading. And what we find is that when you take phones away, you boost achievement growth per year by about half of the rate that it had been declining at,” he says.Although the gains are modest, Kane points to the potential for academic growth to accumulate over time, and how these bans may offer a more cost-effective intervention for schools. The study found improvements in both math and reading, with similar effects across grade levels and student groups.The research also raises a much bigger question: What role has social media use outside school played in the decline in student achievement? While researchers have been able to study the effects of restricting phones in classrooms, they have had little access to the data needed to connect students' social media use with academic outcomes.Kane sees a recent settlement between states and Meta as a potential opportunity to close that gap, provided researchers can gain access to meaningful data on how young people use social media. “It could be that cell phone use out of school are having even bigger negative impacts, but we just don't have the data yet to be able to draw that link as clearly as we should be able to,” he says.In this EdCast episode, Kane discusses what the new findings reveal about cellphone bans, why even modest gains in achievement matter, and what researchers still need to understand about the relationship between technology and learning.In This Episode· Why student achievement has been declining since around 2013, and how that timeline overlaps with the rise of smartphone use among children· What a study of 3 million students across thousands of schools found about strict cellphone bans and academic achievement· Why cellphone bans produced a modest but meaningful boost equivalent to one or two additional weeks of instruction per year· What researchers learned about differences across grade levels, student groups, math, and reading· Why taking phones out of classrooms doesn't address the larger question of social media use outside school· How the settlement between states and Meta could create new opportunities to study the relationship between social media and student learning· What educators and policymakers should consider when implementing cellphone restrictions, including potential unintended consequencesEpisode Timestamps00:00 Why researchers are connecting smartphones to declining student achievement02:00 What a study of 3 million students found about cellphone bans04:00 How much difference do cellphone bans actually make?06:30 What the research reveals about reading, math, and different student groups09:00 Why researchers still know so little about social media and student learning11:30 Are cellphone bans a cost-effective intervention for schools?14:00 What the Meta settlement could mean for future education research17:00 The bigger questions about phones, social media, and student learningAbout the guestThomas J. Kane is the Walter H. Gale Professor of Education and Economics at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and faculty director of the Center for Education Policy Research. An economist, his research spans K–12 and higher education, including school accountability, teacher effectiveness, college access, and student achievement.Learn more about the Harvard EdCast.
For more than 60 years, Head Start has been a cornerstone of early childhood education, shaping everything from classroom requirements and family support services to the standards educators are expected to meet. The federally funded program serves more than 700,000 children, and families across the country have come to rely on it.“Head Start is one of the nation's most successful programs. It's something that Congress has historically, on a bipartisan basis, invested in. And taxpayers and Congress want to know that when they pay for the Head Start model, they are getting the Head Start model,” says Katie Hamm, former deputy assistant secretary for early childhood development at the Administration for Children and Families. “The regulations, the Head Start Performance Standards, are really designed to make sure that we're getting the gold standard in early care and education and that communities can expect that.”But those standards are now in jeopardy. The federal government's proposed changes to Head Start’s quality standards could fundamentally alter the longstanding program and the services families have come to depend on.The proposal drew more than 40,000 public comments in August. It would eliminate 90% of the program’s existing performance standards, raising questions about the future of the services, protections and quality requirements that have defined Head Start for decades.“[Head Start] is really a holistic approach to child development to make sure children from the most impoverished communities around the country have that opportunity to get ready for success in school,” Hamm says. She emphasizes that the program focuses on the whole child, with standards that include family support, nutrition, physical development, medical and dental care, and school readiness. The proposal would let state and local rules determine classroom sizes and child-to-staff ratios; require English-language instruction, with an exception for Tribal languages; remove federal minimums for home visits and protections against suspension or expulsion; drop requirements such as daily toothbrushing and monthly mental-health consultations; and cut the administrative-cost cap from 15% to 5%.The Administration for Children and Families reports the proposed changes could allow Head Start to serve 236,000 more children. Its estimate relies largely on reducing administrative spending by about $754 million a year and allowing larger classrooms with fewer teachers per child.“If we have fewer Head Start programs, we obviously can't serve more children,” Hamm says. “The other challenge is with the ratios that they propose to change -- that would mean more children in a classroom.”In this episode, Hamm discusses what the proposed changes could mean for children, families, and an already strained early childhood workforce. She challenges the assumption that reducing requirements will necessarily allow Head Start to serve more children and considers how the program can evolve while keeping children at the center of decisions about what makes it effective.In this episode· What the proposed federal overhaul of Head Start’s quality standards could mean for the future of the program.· What makes Head Start distinct from other early childhood programs, including its focus on the whole child and comprehensive family services.· Why the Head Start Performance Standards matter for ensuring consistent quality and services across communities.· The administration’s rationale for reducing regulations—and why critics question whether the proposed changes would improve the program.· Whether larger classrooms and reduced administrative costs could realistically allow Head Start to serve more children without additional funding.· How the proposed changes could affect children and families experiencing homelessness, including access to services and enrollment flexibility.· What the changes could mean for Head Start educators, including classroom conditions, wages, job losses, and workforce retention.· What happens next in the federal rulemaking process following the public comment period.· How Head Start standards can evolve with research and changing needs while keeping children and families at the center.Episode timestamps00:00 – What’s at stake in the proposed federal overhaul of Head Start?02:38 – What makes Head Start different from other early childhood programs—and why its whole-child approach matters.05:29 – Why change the Head Start Performance Standards, and what are the arguments for reducing regulations?08:48 – Could larger classrooms and lower administrative costs really allow Head Start to serve more children?11:58 – What could the proposed changes mean for children and families experiencing homelessness?15:37 – How could the changes affect Head Start educators, including jobs, wages, classroom conditions, and teacher retention?19:01 – What happens next in the federal rulemaking process after the public comment period?21:14 – How can Head Start standards evolve while keeping children’s needs at the center?About Katie HammKatie Hamm is a public policy consultant in the field of early childhood. From 2021 to 2025, she served as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Early Childhood Development at the Administration for Children and Families, where she oversaw Head Start.Listen to more conversations about education, research, and learning on the Harvard EdCast.
Education has seen it all before. A promising approach to teaching catches on, and then it becomes the center of a heated debate. That's happening with the science of reading, and increasingly, the science of math.But Harvard Professor Jon Star says these debates get at a bigger question in education: What counts as good research, and how should it guide decisions about teaching and learning?“Anyone with a megaphone or a social media platform or a lot of money can advocate for a particular way to teach. And they can claim that their way of teaching is supported by research evidence…,” Star says. “The debate is less about whether one method of teaching is better than another method of teaching. But it's really a debate about the type of research that supports each of those methods.”And it's something that education hasn't been able to get away from throughout its history.If you look back far enough, Star says, you can see some of the same debates we're having now about math as long ago as the 1800s, including debates over discovery-based learning and explicit instruction.In math education, what may appear to be one central argument is actually a collection of overlapping disagreements. This is partly why Star thinks it's valuable for educators to understand the history of education and the debates that go along with it.It's also the focus of his course, “Controversy in the Classroom: Debates on the Learning and Teaching of Math, Reading, and Science,” currently offered for both HGSE and Harvard College students.“I don't want to use the oft-repeated 'those who don't know the past are doomed to repeat it' kind of idea, but it does seem like there's a bit of that,” he says. “We need to know the ways this played out in the past in order to better understand and participate in the debate in the present.”Ultimately, Star says we need to focus on what's best for students, even though there's no single instructional approach that meets every student's needs.Research can offer important guidance about what approaches work better under particular conditions. But the challenge is balancing the evidence with an individual student's needs and the realities of classroom teaching.In this episode, Star shifts the focus away from simply defending one side of an education debate. Instead, he considers how educators, researchers, and policymakers can remain open to different approaches, ask better questions about the evidence, and work together to understand what helps children learn.In this episodeWhy the science of reading and science of math have become central to education debates.What people really mean when they talk about the science of education.Why disagreements over teaching methods are often disagreements about what counts as credible research.The history of the reading wars and math wars.Explicit instruction versus discovery-based learning in mathematics.What historical math textbooks and research studies reveal about how students learn.Why there is no one-size-fits-all approach to teaching.How educators balance research evidence with classroom experience.How education research influences media coverage, classrooms, and education policy.How educators and researchers can move beyond polarized debates and keep students at the center.Episode timestamps00:00 – Why the science of reading and science of math have become central to education debates.01:15 – What people really mean when they talk about the "science of" education—and why the definition of good research is so contentious.03:00 – Why disagreements over teaching methods are often really disagreements about what counts as credible research.05:45 – The history of the reading wars and math wars, and why today's education debates aren't as new as they might seem.07:30 – The central debate in math education: explicit instruction versus discovery-based learning.09:30 – What a 200-year-old math textbook and a 1934 research study reveal about today's debates over how students learn math.10:45 – Why there isn't a one-size-fits-all approach to teaching—and how educators can balance research-based guidance with individual student needs.13:30 – What happens when education research moves from academic journals into the media, classrooms, and education policy.16:00 – How teachers navigate competing research claims while drawing on their own classroom experience.19:00 – How educators and researchers can move beyond polarized debates and keep the focus on what's best for students.About Jon StarJon Star is a Harvard professor and educational psychologist whose work focuses on mathematics education, teaching, learning, and educational research.Listen to more conversations about education, research, and learning on the Harvard EdCast.
00:00 – Rethinking the “Best Years” Narrative
01:30 – Are Students in Crisis—or in Transition?
03:00 – What the Data Really Says
05:00 – Loneliness as a Normal Developmental Experience
07:00 – The Expectation Gap
09:00 – When Language Gets Complicated
11:30 – The Institutional Dilemma
13:30 – Meeting Students Where They Are
15:00 – The W-Curve Explained
17:30 – Why the W-Curve Matters
19:00 – Beyond the Traditional Student
20:30 – Building Connection in Online Learning
22:00 – From Theory to Practice
23:30 – The Power of “Micro-Mentorship”
25:00 – Supporting Students Through Big Decisions
26:00 – Advice for Parents
27:00 – Final Takeaways
00:00The case for rethinking how we challenge advanced math students
00:49Why focus on high-performing students during a time of learning recovery
01:09The tradeoff: prioritizing struggling students vs. supporting advanced learners
02:51Inside the classroom: the real challenge of differentiation
03:17Why accelerating students can make teaching more difficult
05:21The downside of treating math like a race
06:37A better approach: depth over speed
07:44When accelerationdoesmake sense (and for whom)
10:43What “math enrichment” really means
11:07Why worksheets and puzzles aren’t enough
12:13Simple questions that push deeper thinking
13:39What to do with early finishers
15:06Practical strategies teachers can use right away
16:19Why grades 3–5 is a key turning point
19:13Why this issue looks different in high school
20:03The reality of teaching accelerated students
21:31How common is deep, discussion-based math teaching?



