DiscoverThe Uncertainty Podcast
The Uncertainty Podcast
Claim Ownership

The Uncertainty Podcast

Author: Miles K. Donahue

Subscribed: 20Played: 277
Share

Description

A philosophy Ph.D. student working his way, with the world's leading thinkers, through the problems of philosophy, religion, science, and the existential struggle with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) - similar to Alex O'Connor, but more American. Who wants to come along for the ride?

mileskdonahue.substack.com
106 Episodes
Reverse
Graham Oppy, professor of philosophy at Monash University, is widely regarded as one of philosophy of religion's foremost atheistic thinkers. Here, Graham and I discuss our foundational disagreements: probability in philosophy of religion, branching actualism, what counts as an "explanation" of fine-tuning, John Norton's material theory of induction, and much else besides.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:00:47 What makes a good argument?00:06:39 Arguments versus making a case00:08:42 What is naturalism?00:13:55 Why compare specific worldviews?00:17:47 Oppy's method for theory comparison00:25:17 Animal suffering and the problem of evil00:33:37 Is naturalism simpler than theism?00:44:35 Is Oppy's method really Bayesian?00:48:38 Can we compare theories without probabilities?00:58:01 The Bayesian turn in philosophy of religion01:00:59 Branching actualism and cosmic fine-tuning01:06:19 Does necessity explain fine-tuning?01:14:52 Can fine-tuning count against necessity?01:17:02 Divine psychology and the limits of Bayesianism01:23:42 What is Oppy most uncertain about?01:25:39 Can philosophy make progress? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
Graham Oppy, Dan Linford, Nathan Bray, Kenny Boyce, R.T. Mullins, and myself come together to ask (and answer) the question: does natural theology succeed?Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:01:46 R. T. Mullins opening speech00:05:45 Miles Donahue opening speech00:09:56 Dan Linford opening speech00:14:22 Kenny Boyce opening speech00:18:15 Nathan Bray opening speech00:25:30 Graham Oppy opening speech00:30:23 R. T. Mullins cross-examination00:40:29 Miles Donahue cross-examination00:56:14 Dan Linford cross-examination01:07:11 Kenny Boyce cross-examination01:16:50 Nathan Bray cross-examination01:31:18 Graham Oppy cross-examination Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
Kenny Boyce discusses the recent critiques of probability in the philosophy of religion, principally by John Norton. Kenny is an all-around great guy and (given his considerable philosophical overlap with my own views) a genius.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00 Introduction00:06 What is the fine-tuning argument?01:40 Epistemic vs. objective probability03:40 Why epistemic priors are necessary07:39 Can probability apply without empirical data?09:41 John Norton's material theory of induction13:05 Bayesianism vs. Norton's approach to induction18:55 The outcome space objection to Bayesianism26:02 The problem of the priors28:08 Evidential support and rational belief33:01 Must rational credences obey the probability axioms?36:45 Can credences be incomparable?42:24 Are fine-tuning probabilities unjustified?50:20 Could deeper physics explain fine-tuning?52:34 The prior probabilities of theism and naturalism58:55 Kenny's greatest philosophical uncertainty Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
The brilliant Substacker Both Sides Brigade joins me for a discussion about three hot topics in our corner of the philosophy of religion internet: the omission theodicy, the miracle case for Catholicism, and the doctrine of eternal conscious torment.Check out Brian Cutter and Philip Swenson's defense of the archon abandonment theodicy, as well as Brian Cutter's paper on Hell and justice.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:06:32 The Archon abandonment theodicy explained00:12:09 Natural evil and the free will defense00:16:42 The expected costs of Archon failure00:26:35 Divine foreknowledge and God's failure to intervene00:34:04 The epistemology of Catholic miracles00:41:56 Padre Pio's stigmata and carbolic acid00:46:07 Divine hiddenness and conflicting miracle evidence00:53:19 The miracle of Calanda and the restored leg00:59:46 Fátima and the miracle of the sun01:08:29 Eternal conscious torment and its defenders01:14:31 Can Catholic miracles justify eternal conscious torment?01:24:19 The noetic effects of sin and moral skepticism01:34:09 Can hell be good for those in it?01:42:05 Can eternal punishment involve finite suffering? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
Noah McKay, a philosophy Ph.D. student at Princeton, joins me to discuss his recent conversation to Catholicism, Catholic miracle evidence, whether the Bible predicts a succession of popes, and Catholic sexual ethics.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:01:53 From Protestantism to Catholicism: the initial case00:02:24 Craig Keener and the evidence for Christian miracles00:04:35 Fine-tuning, the resurrection, and other arguments for Christianity00:05:33 How Joe Schmid helped change his theological views00:07:13 Marian apparitions, Eucharistic miracles, and Catholicism00:11:18 Overcoming objections to Catholic theology and history00:14:26 Why Noah initially rejected the papacy00:16:24 The biblical case for papal authority00:22:19 Scripture, tradition, and divine revelation00:24:21 Does the papacy preserve Christian unity and truth?00:30:11 Peter, Paul, and the case for apostolic succession00:48:10 Can the Catholic Church really claim to preserve unity?01:06:08 How strong is the evidence for Catholic miracles?01:14:00 Can miracles override moral and philosophical objections?01:19:07 Catholic sexual ethics, moral intuitions, and disagreement01:32:37 What philosophical position is Noah most uncertain of? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
loading
Comments