Discover
Two Peaches in a Pod
19 Episodes
Reverse
Happy New Year peaches!
We come to you today with the firs true crime case of 2025- the disturbing crimes of Shanda Vander Ark against her son, Timothy Ferguson. Part 2 coming next week!
Content Warnings:
- extreme child abuse (physical, verbal, emotional)
-ableism
- abuse against disabled children
- forced disordered eating
Follow us on Instagram at @twopeaches_inapod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com! Also, check us out at BlueSky :)
Happy Holidays From Eli and Jinx here at Two Peaches in a Pod! Snuggle up, grab your eggnog, family, and friends, and enjoy this tipsy AITA Holiday Edition! Please stay safe and tell Santa we said bring you lots of gifts!
In 2017, 19 year old Kenneka Jenkins went missing in a Chicago hotel. Where she ended up and how she exactly got there is still unsolved.
Content Warning:
- Graphic description of crime scene and autopsy
Let us know on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod or email us topeachtheirown@gmail.com if you have any more knowledge of this case. We would love to hear from you on case suggestions or personal stories!
Happy Thanksgiving peaches! We have a morbid mini episode this holiday for you. On Thanksgiving 2009, Paul Merhige carried out a horrifying plan after family dinner. We are so thankful for our listeners!
Content Warnings:
- Gun Violence
- Violence against/Murder of women and children
Follow and DM on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod or email us topeachtheirown@gmail.com if you have any additional information on this case. We would love to hear from you on case suggestions or personal stories!
Sources: ABC News, CBS News, Palm Beach Post
For the third and final part of our series on the Menendez brothers, we discuss the final details of the trials, Erik and Lyle's lives in prison, and most recent events within their case.
Content Warnings:
- discussion of sexual abuse against children
- victim blaming/dismissal of abuse
If you have any additional details or opinions you would like to share with us, comment down below, DM us on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod, or email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com!
In part 2 of this three-episode series on the Menendez case, we cover most of the brothers' first and televised trial. We hope you enjoy, and please feel free to give us feedback or anything you feel is also important to cover in this case!
PLEASE READ: Content Warnings
- Sexual Abuse against children, from parental figures
- Vivid descriptions of SA
- COCSA (child on child sexual abuse)
- Physical abuse
Follow us on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com !
Hey peaches... here's a little treat! We collected a small blooper reel from our last few episodes. Hope you enjoy!
This might be the most popular true crime case in pop culture currently- due to the newest Netflix series and documentary. In this mini-episode we give you the background information for the case, before we cover the trial in a much longer episode coming up soon.
Content Warnings:
- mentions of physical and sexual abuse
- discussion of gunshot wounds
- mention of suicide/suicidal ideations
Resources:
Menendez: Blood Brothers - Lifetime Original Movie- 2017 (dramatized)
The Menendez Brothers - Netflix documentary, 2024 (Alejandro Hartman)- interviews with brothers on May 10, 2023
Follow us on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod and email us your opinions, stories, and suggestions at topeachtheirown@gmail.com!
Leave us a review and rating please!
We’re back to true crime! Today we cover the recent (and current) cult “Love has Won” led by a woman who called herself “Mother God.” A segment of this cult is still active today.
Let us know on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod or email us topeachtheirown@gmail.com if you have any experience with this group or others. We would love to hear from you on case suggestions or personal stories!
Content Warnings:
Alcohol and substance abuse
Abuse of spirituality and religion
Racism, antisemitism
Mentions of pedophilia
Discussion of death and abuse of a corpse
Sources:
Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God - HBO, 2023
Archived web sources from group(s)
Join us this week for some fun AITA readings! We thought we would give y'all some light content before we get into the true crime soon. Enjoy!
Follow us on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod and email us suggestions, spooky/crime stories at topeachtheirown@gmail.com !
We do not own these stories or music.
hey peaches! We're Eli and Jinx, and we've revamped our podcast! Formally known as To Peach Their Own, we are now Two Peaches in a Pod. For updates and more to come, give us a listen!
Follow us on Instagram @twopeaches_inapod and email us with suggestions, spooky and true crime stories at topeachtheirown@gmail.com! Thank you :)
It's the final part! ANDDD Gypsy Rose is being released from prison TODAY. Join us in discussing the trials and court cases of Gypsy Rose and Nicholas Godejohn, and where they are now. As always, trigger warnings are listed at the bottom of the episode description- please check these, as we discuss very sensitive topics in our true crime episodes. Thank you for following along, and stay tuned for more true crime content from us in the new year!
Sources are the same as listed in our previous part episode.
Follow us on Instagram at @twopeaches_inapod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com! We are looking for true crime ideas, your own AITA stories, or maybe your own true crime stories!
TW:
- ableism and discussion of disabilities and neurodivergencies
- manipulation and narcissism
- murder and crime scene descriptions
- sexual assault and coercion, r@pe, mention of necrophilia
- discussion of sexual encounters
- medical abuse and gaslighting
- extreme mental illness
Happy true crime Thursday! We have the continued part 2 of Gypsy Rose Blanchard's story for you, and stay tuned in one week for the final part! Sources and trigger warnings listed at the end of the episode description. We also hope you like our new intro music!
Sources: Mommy Dead and Dearest (2017) -HBO
The Act- Hulu
Official Police Interrogations of Nicholas Godejohn & Gypsy Rose Blanchard - public domain
Snapped: Killer Couples- Gypsy Rose and Nick: A Love to Kill For (2019)
Follow us on Instagram at @twopeaches_inapod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com.
TW:
- ableism
- assault, coercion, and inappropriate usage of BDSM concepts
- unspecified mental illness
- codependency, manipulation, narcissism
- alternate personalities/misrepresentation of personality disorders
- discussion of pornography, extreme violence
- emotional/medical abuse and gaslighting
- r@pe and mention of n*crophilia
Thank you and Happy Holidays!
We are so back! It's true crime Thursdays for the rest of December with a super special case- Gypsy Rose and Deedee Blanchard: Munchausen by Proxy. This is part 1, so stay tuned every Thursday for the next parts! Trigger warnings will be listed at the end of episode description. Also, apologies for the volume discrepancies in this episode... we hope your eardrums are okay.
Sources: Mommy Dead and Dearest -HBO Documentary
The Act -Hulu series (fact checked)
Follow us on Instagram at @twopeaches_inapod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com! Give us your requests, questions, comments and theories!
TW:
- ableism and discussion of disabilities
- domestic violence and abuse
- medical gaslighting and substance abuse
- fraud, manipulation, narcissism, emotional and mental abuse
- discussion of medical side effects
- Munchausen by proxy
Hey peaches! Today we are reading some AITA stories from the deep dark throes of reddit... and find out some bad news in the process :(
Send us your own AITA and drama!! DM us on Instagram @topeachtheirownpod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com :)
*all stories come from reddit.com & all credit due to users*
Happy belated Halloween!
This was supposed to be our Halloween episode, but our stories were too scary for our tech to handle.. so enjoy our second version!
Send in your own stories at topeachtheirown@gmail.com, and follow us on Instagram @topeachtheirownpod !
Our first True Crime Thursday!! We discuss the case of Elisa Lam's disappearance in 2013.
Link to elevator footage from Cecil Hotel: https://youtu.be/_rfLSVIA0L0?si=DuE9TkK9-SHs78oK
TW for this episode: mention of violence, discussion of autopsies and human decomposition.
Please excuse the decrease in audio value for this episode- we are trying new ways to record :)
Follow us on Instagram at @topeachtheirownpod and email us at topeachtheirown@gmail.com!
This was supposed to be a mini episode...
The gals (fems and non-men) talk college and music taste with a hint of horror movies and whatever else. Thanks for listening!
Follow us on Instagram at @topeachtheirownpod! Email us with spooky stories, tea/AITA, and suggestions at topeachtheirown@gmail.com
Welcome to To Peach Their Own! Alanna, Eli, Ethan, Salem and Kenny introduce themselves and talk about the future of the podcast.
-
Follow us on Instagram at @topeachtheirownpod and email us story submissions/requests at topeachtheirown@gmail.com!
-
Shoutout to the Morbid True Crime podcast! Find them on Spotify and Instagram at @morbidpodcast






