Untangled

Hi, it’s Charley, and this is Untangled, a newsletter about technology, people, and power. Today, I’m sharing my conversation with Evan Ratliff, journalist and host of Shell Game, a funny and provocative new podcast about “things that are not what they seem.” Evan cloned his voice, hitched it to an AI agent, and then put it in conversation with scammers and spammers, a therapist, work colleagues, and even his friends and family. Shell Game helps listeners see a li’l farther into a future overrun with AI agents, and I wanted to speak with Evan about his experience of this future.In our conversation, we discuss:* The hilarity that ensues when Evan’s AI agent engages with scammers and spammers, and the quirks and limitations of these tools.* The harrowing experience of listening to your AI agent make stuff up about you in therapy.* How those building these tools view the problem(s) they’re solving.* What it’s like to send your AI agent to work meetings in you place.* The work required to maintain these tools and make their outputs useful — does it actually help you save time and be more productive??* The lingering uncertainty these tools culitvated through its interactions with Evan’s family and friends.If you find the conversation interesting, share it with a friend.Okay, that’s it for now,Charley This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe

Hi, it’s Charley, and this is Untangled, a newsletter about technology, people, and power.Can’t afford a subscription and value Untangled’s offerings? Let me know! You only need to reply to this email, and I’ll add you to the paid subscription list, no questions asked.I turned 40 this week and I spent the weekend in nature, surrounded by my favorite people. While my cup is running over with friendship, love, and support, I’ll always take more 🤣. You can celebrate me and my next trip around the sun by becoming a paid subscriber and buying my first book, AI Untangled.This month:* I published an essay about the power of utopian thinking — how one version got us into this AI mess, and getting out will require a very different approach. (Remember, you have until August 31st to submit a vignette of your sociotechnical utopia.)* I shared my conversation with Shannon Vallor, the Baillie Gifford Chair in the Ethics of Data and Artificial Intelligence at the Edinburgh Futures Institute (EFI) at the University of Edinburgh. Vallor and I talk about her great new book, The AI Mirror: Reclaiming Our Humanity in an Age of Machine Thinking, and how to chart a new path from the one we’re on.This week, I’m resharing my October 2022 conversation with Brandon Silverman, co-founder and CEO of CrowdTangle, the data analytics tool once at the center of controversy inside Meta over just how transparent the company should be. Meta shut down the tool this week, and we’re all worse for it.In the episode, we get into Brandon’s time at Meta and the fights over CrowdTangle but we spend most of our time exploring his views on transparency — its utility and limitations, its relationship to accountability, power, and trust — and how they have evolved. Along the way, we discuss:* How Brandon initially got “red-pilled” on transparency.* How CrowdTangle challenged the stories Facebook leadership told themselves about the platform’s impact on the world.* How the scale of these platforms means that when it comes to solutions, “it’s tradeoffs all the way down.”This essay pairs nicely with the second-ever essay I wrote for Untangled, “Some Unsatisfying Solutions for Facebook,” which delves into the conceptual limitations of transparency. Just as we should never stop pushing for it, we can’t mistake it for accountability.🙏 Thank YouWhen I turned 39 last year, I wrote this:“I turn 39 today, so perhaps it’s fitting that I’ve been thinking a lot about time. I want time to feel slow and expansive. I want each day to feel justified on its own terms. I want the value of each activity to lie in the doing, not in the end result. That’s what Untangled has been for me. Not always — sometimes writing is the absolute worst — but on a good day, when I sit down at the keyboard, I enjoy the process, and it feels like flow.”I feel closer to this feeling as I turn 40. That’s partly because of you! The other part? Meditation! But the point is, your support allows me to show up to the keyboard every morning before the sun comes up, and write. It affords me glimpses of this feeling, of time slowing down, and joy in the moment. It turns out that enjoying the moment also produces results: last year, I wrote 51 issues and published a book. Thanks for being along for the ride. That’s it for now.Charley This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe

Hi, it’s Charley, and this is Untangled, a newsletter about technology, people, and power.This week I’m sharing my conversation with Shannon Vallor, the Baillie Gifford Chair in the Ethics of Data and Artificial Intelligence at the Edinburgh Futures Institute (EFI) at the University of Edinburgh. Vallor and I talk about her great new book, The AI Mirror: Reclaiming Our Humanity in an Age of Machine Thinking, and how to chart a new path from the one we’re on. We discuss:* The metaphor of an ‘AI mirror’ — what it is, and how it helps us better understand what AI is(and isn’t!)* What AI mirrors reveal about ourselves and our past.* How AI mirrors distort what we see — whose voices and values they amplify, and who is left out of the picture altogether.* How Vallor would change AI discourse.* How we might chart a new path toward a fundamentally different future — as a sneak peak, it requires starting with outcomes and values and thinking backward.* How we can become so much more than the limits subtly shaping our teenage selves (e.g. conceptions of what we’re good at, what we’re not, etc.) — and how that growth and evolution doesn’t have to stop as we age.It’s not hyperbole when I say Vallor’s book is the best thing I’ve read this year. If you send me a picture holding it in one hand, and my new book in the other, I might just explode with joy.More soon,Charley This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe

Last week, I analyzed a new lawsuit brought by University of Massachusetts Amherst professor Ethan Zuckerman and the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University. The lawsuit would loosen Big Tech’s grip over our internet experience if successful. In this conversation, I’m joined by , the creator of the tool Unfollow Everything, which is at the center of the lawsuit. Louis and I discuss:* What it’s like to be bullied by a massive company;* Why this lawsuit would be so consequential for consumer choice and control over our online experience;* The tools Louis would build to democratize power online.That’s it for this edition of Untangled.Charley This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe

Hello, welcome back to the podcast edition of Untangled. If someone forward you this link, it was probably my sister. Give it a listen — she knows what she's talking about. Then, if you're so inclined, become a subscriber.👉 Two things before we get into it. First, you can now listen to Untangled directly on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Second, if you haven't yet decided what you're going to get me for Christmas (I get it, I'm really hard to shop for), just forward this email to 10 friends and kindly ask that they smash the subscribe button. I mean, this gift isn't even affected by the supply chain — it's a Christmas miracle!And now, on with the show.This month I offered up some unsatisfying solutions for a big fat problem: Facebook. On Twitter, Harvard Law Professor Jonathan Zittrain called it "a brisk and thoughtful piece weighing different futures for social media." Who ever said Twitter wasn’t the absolute best? And Rose Jackson, Director of the Democracy & Tech Initiative at the Atlantic Council referenced it in her thoughtful testimony to the Senate Commerce Committee. Untangled made it to Congress, y'all.While writing the piece, I knew I wanted to speak with Daphne Keller. Daphne directs the Program on Platform Regulation at Stanford's Cyber Policy Center, lectures at Stanford Law School, and before all of that, she was an Associate General Counsel at Google. That's deep academic, legal, and private sector expertise all in a single human!Daphne has thought deeply about the problem of amplification and the practical challenges to implementing the solution of "middleware services.” In this conversation, we dive into both. Along the way, we also discuss:* How the private sector and civil society misunderstand one another when it comes to platform governance.* Why everyone seems to hate Section 230 and why regulating speech is so hard.* Why regulating reach is ... just as hard.Listen all the way to the end to learn the one thing Daphne would tell her teenage self about life.If you like the podcast, please do all the things to make it go viral - share it, review it, and rate it.I hope you’ve enjoyed the second monthly series of Untangled. For next month, I’ve decided to write about something we’re all not at all tired of reading about: the metaverse! 😬More soon,Charley Credits:* Track: The Perpetual Ticking of Time — Artificial.Music [Audio Library Release]* Music provided by Audio Library Plus* Watch: Here* Free Download / Stream: http://alplus.io/PerpetualTickingOfTime This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe

You came back! That warms my writerly heart. If someone forwarded you this email, definitely thank them - they just get your wonky sensibility. Then, if you’re so inclined, become a subscriber. 👉 One more thing before we get into it - if Untangled arrives in your Promotions tab, consider moving it to your Primary tab. If you do it once, our algorithmic overlords will take it from there. And now, on with the show. This issue of Untangled is a little different - I made a podcast, y’all 🙌. You can listen to it on Substack or wherever you get your podcasts. As you might recall, this month I wrote about decentralization and how power operates in crypto. Then I spoke with law professor Angela Walch about one interesting albeit imperfect solution: treating software developers as fiduciaries. To round out this series, I wanted to dive deep into crypto governance. Is it adding to the concentration of power or helping to democratize and diffuse it? Are there models that actually lead to more equitable outcomes? How do the economic incentives of any crypto project constrain or shape its governance?I'm thrilled that Nathan Schneider joined me on today's episode to discuss these questions. Nathan is an Assistant Professor of Media Studies at the University of Colorado Boulder. He is the author of many books and papers, including, most recently a paper called "Cryptoeconomics as a limitation on governance." I highly recommend it.In our conversation, Nathan:* Defines cryptoeconomic governance and outlines its possibilities and limitations.* Discusses what co-ops and crypto projects have to learn from one another.* Shares his perspective on how crypto governance can invigorate democracy.If you like the episode, please do all the things to make it go viral - share it, review it, and rate it. I hope you’ve enjoyed the first monthly series of Untangled. Next month, I've decided to give you a series of unsatisfying solutions for a big fat problem: Facebook. Yes, yes... I can hear you laugh-crying already. Until then 👋Credits:* Track: The Perpetual Ticking of Time — Artificial.Music [Audio Library Release] * Music provided by Audio Library Plus* Watch: Here* Free Download / Stream: http://alplus.io/PerpetualTickingOfTime This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe