Discover
Wealth Actually
217 Episodes
Reverse
California Taxes the Cloud: The New Sales Tax on Software, with Neil Bass
Starting January 1, 2027, California will apply sales and use tax to prewritten software, including software as a service, no matter how it is delivered. In this episode of Wealth Actually, I talk with Neil Bass, CPA and managing member of Bass Tax Group, about what changes, who pays, and what buyers and sellers should do before the deadline.
https://youtu.be/8KWaeLoDm50
For decades, California taxed software sold on a disk but not the same software downloaded or used in the cloud. Senate Bill 122, signed June 29, 2026, closes that gap. Neil saw it coming and wrote about it on LinkedIn, which is how this conversation started.
https://open.spotify.com/episode/5K3bxwmvv5bUxzlA8HVrUY?si=HQVUsC05RdyDSfMVCH9oTg
We cover why the physical-versus-digital line existed, which products are taxable and which are excluded, how bundling can pull exempt items into the tax, and how invoices that straddle January 1 get split. We also get into the $5 million rule that shifts the tax to large buyers, economic nexus for out-of-state vendors, sourcing based on where the user sits, the stakes for AI companies, Colorado’s parallel change, and whether this pushes more businesses out of California.
Key takeaways
Delivery method no longer matters. Beginning January 1, 2027, prewritten (“canned”) software is taxable in California whether it arrives on a disk, by download, or through the cloud. Custom software remains exempt.
Bundling can make everything taxable. Certain digital items are excluded, but Neil warns that bundling different types of software together can expose the whole package. Sellers should separate what they sell on the invoice.
Taxability follows the period of use. Use on December 31 is not taxable; use on January 1 is, regardless of the invoice date. An invoice covering December 15 to January 15 may be half taxable.
The $5 million rule shifts the tax to big buyers. When a seller’s sales of these products to one customer exceed $5 million in a year, the seller stops collecting and the buyer remits use tax directly.
Out-of-state vendors are not off the hook. A vendor with no physical presence in California still has economic nexus once its California sales exceed $500,000.
Follow the user, not headquarters. The key question is where the software is actually used, which can be hard to track for distributed teams.
Model the cost now. At 9.5%, a $1 million software purchase carries roughly $95,000 of tax. Customization claims will matter, and they will be tested on audit.
AI revenue is a likely target. Neil does not see how AI companies avoid charging the tax to their California customers.
The end user pays. Whether or not it is itemized, the tax ultimately shows up in the price of software.
Episode timestamps
00:00 Preview: why delivery method no longer matters00:20 Introduction and disclaimer00:46 What California changes on January 1, 202701:41 Why physical and digital software were taxed differently03:20 What Senate Bill 122 changes04:16 Which products are taxable, and why bundling matters05:18 Timing: use dates, invoices, and the transition period05:58 The $5 million rule: when the buyer pays use tax07:25 Out-of-state software providers and economic nexus08:26 Sourcing: follow the user, not headquarters09:14 Modernization or a headwind to innovation?10:19 Before the deadline: model the impact11:46 Customization, unbundling, and audit risk13:32 AI companies and the new tax base14:59 Will other states follow California?16:13 Will this push businesses out of California?17:16 Could a federal standard simplify sales tax?18:28 Can offshore IP avoid the tax?19:23 Out-of-state buyers of California software20:32 Who ultimately pays, and avoiding double tax21:40 How to reach Neil Bass and Bass Tax Group
Notable quotes
“California doesn’t fool around when it comes to their sales tax.” — Neil Bass
“As soon as you start bundling different types of software together, all of it is potentially subject to tax.” — Neil Bass
“When you use the product on January 1, it’s taxable. If you use it on December 31, it’s not taxable, regardless of when you may be invoiced for the product.” — Neil Bass
“At the end of the day, the end user is going to be paying this additional tax.” — Neil Bass
About Neil Bass
Neil D. Bass, CPA, founded Bass Tax Group (formerly SmarTax) in 2006 and serves as its managing member. The firm advises companies on ASC 740 income-tax accounting, corporate tax strategy, international tax, mergers and acquisitions, and tax examinations, working with U.S. multinationals, inbound groups, and middle-market companies. Before founding the firm, Neil worked at a Big Four accounting firm, in banking, and at a regional accounting firm. He holds a B.S. in Accounting and a Master’s in Taxation from Rutgers University. (Bass Tax Group) He is regularly quoted on corporate tax matters, most recently by CFO Dive on FASB’s income-tax disclosure rules.
Editor’s notes
These notes add context to points made in the recording. The conversation itself is unchanged.
The agency. The conversation refers to the Franchise Tax Board. California sales and use tax, including the new tax on digital products, is administered by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA). The Franchise Tax Board handles income tax. (CDTFA)
The rate range. Neil’s 9.5% example is illustrative. As of October 1, 2026, combined California rates run from the 7.25% statewide rate up to 11.75% in Palmdale and Lancaster, which would mean about $117,500 on a $1 million purchase. (CDTFA rates; CDTFA notice L-1037)
The $5 million rule. As enacted, the rule applies when a seller’s receipts from one buyer exceed $5 million in the current calendar year, and beginning January 1, 2028, in the current or preceding year. The buyer must obtain a use tax direct payment permit, and CDTFA can grant a waiver that returns collection to the seller. Neil’s caution reflects regulations that were still in draft when we recorded. (PwC; CDTFA notice L-1036)
Subscriptions that cross January 1. CDTFA’s proposed regulations apply tax to subscription periods on or after January 1, 2027, regardless of when the contract was signed or invoiced, which matches Neil’s description. (Legal 500)
Which states already tax SaaS. Neil says most major state economies already tax this software, with Florida a possible exception. New York, Texas, Pennsylvania, Washington, and Ohio tax SaaS in some form, but Florida, Georgia, Virginia, and Illinois at the state level generally do not; Chicago taxes it locally. (TaxCloud survey)
Colorado. Neil’s point about Colorado checks out: House Bill 26-1223 makes most software, including SaaS, subject to Colorado sales tax beginning January 1, 2027. (Colorado Department of Revenue)
Frequently asked questions
What does California SB 122 do?It expands California’s definition of tangible personal property to include prewritten computer software, whether it is delivered on physical media, downloaded, or accessed remotely as SaaS. Sales and use tax applies beginning January 1, 2027.
What is excluded from California’s new software tax?Custom software is exempt. The law also excludes digital assets such as cryptocurrency, digital audio, audiovisual and visual works, digital books, digital video games, and digital infrastructure such as IaaS and PaaS.
Does the tax apply to an out-of-state software company?It can. A seller without a physical presence in California has economic nexus once its California sales exceed $500,000, and the sale is sourced to the customer’s California location.
How are subscriptions that span January 1, 2027, handled?Tax follows the period of use. Charges for periods before January 1, 2027, are not taxable; charges for periods on or after that date are, even under a contract signed earlier.
What is the $5 million rule?When a seller’s sales of electronically delivered or remotely accessed software to one buyer exceed $5 million in a calendar year, the seller is relieved of collecting the tax and the buyer reports and pays use tax directly under a direct payment permit.
Who ultimately pays California’s SaaS tax?Neil’s view is that the end user pays, either as a line item on the invoice or built into a higher price.
Interesting links
Bass Tax Group — Neil’s firm
Neil Bass on LinkedIn
California’s Next Tax Frontier: The Cloud — Neil’s article that prompted this episode
CDTFA Tax Guide for Retailers and Purchasers of Digital Products — the state’s official guidance
CDTFA Special Notice L-1036 — two-page summary of the new rules
PwC: California imposes sales and use tax on digital products and SaaS
Colorado Department of Revenue: Computer Software — Colorado’s parallel 2027 change
This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes. It is neither investment, legal, nor tax advice.
Transcript
[00:00] Neil Bass (preview): A lot of software, if not most software, is delivered electronically. And so if you’re a software company and you have a client in California and you deliver that software to them electronically today, you could avoid having to collect sales tax on that transaction. And so beginning in January, that all changes.
[00:20] Intro: Welcome back to the Wealth Actually podcast, the show that features experts, entrepreneurs and commentators that will give you the right knowledge, planning and guidance so you can preserve your assets and enjoy your wealth. Learn more and subscribe today at WealthActually.com. This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes. It is neither investment, legal, nor tax advice. It does not represent the opinions of the employers or the host or guests.
[00:46] Frazer Rice: Welcome aboard, Neil.
[00:47] Neil Bass: Thank you. Good to be here.
[00:48] Frazer Rice: Well, you’re here because one of the posts you put out on LinkedIn around tax policy really raised my eyebrows. It’s something I hadn’t really heard
Investors in private markets pay the fees, yet they often get the worst experience. They are demanding the streamlining of alternative investments. In this episode of Wealth Actually, I talk with Ryan Eisenman, co-founder and CEO of Arch, about why it can take thousands of clicks to manage a single fund position and what better data means for advisors, family offices and the families they serve.
Alternative investments are moving well beyond the institutional world. Private equity, private credit, hedge funds and venture capital now show up in high-net-worth and even retail portfolios. The paperwork has not kept up. K-1s, capital calls, investor letters and valuations still sit in dozens of portals and PDFs.
https://open.spotify.com/episode/12KzPkI0FjAybRk5nbsL5L?si=jhn6grB_RJ2Q8olge-pv2w
Ryan explains how Arch gathers those documents, turns them into structured data and gives investors a single view of commitments, cash flows, performance and exposure. We also cover the rules he sees good allocators follow, the gap in after-tax analysis, PPLI, valuation lag, estate-planning valuations and the next friction point Arch wants to remove: the subscription document.
https://youtu.be/WzNWc7Cz5KI
Key takeaways
The LP pays, so the LP should come first. Ryan’s starting point is simple: the limited partner pays the fees across private markets, so the invesotr”s needs should dictate the infrastructure..
Three allocation rules. Don’t lose money, avoid adverse selection, and diversify. Ask why an opportunity reached you and source deals actively rather than waiting for whoever knocks on the door.
Commitment-based assets break traditional reporting. Most performance systems were designed for stocks and bonds. Unfunded commitments, call pacing, redemption windows and wire instructions need their own data layer.
Holistic advice depends on seeing held-away assets. Advisors cannot give complete advice or plan well if they cannot see the private investments a client made elsewhere.
AI is already doing practical work. Arch summarizes long investor letters, captures manager-reported IRR and lets clients query their own portfolio data.
After-tax thinking is still underdeveloped in alts. Investors rarely know whether a fund will generate QSBS-eligible gains or how a manager’s trading style affects their after-tax return.
PPLI and trusts are a reporting gap. Policies holding insurance-dedicated funds create similar tracking burdens for trustees, trust companies and advisors.
Permissioned access helps the whole advisory team. Clients can share all or part of their data with auditors, tax accountants, valuation firms and estate planners.
The next frontier is the subscription document. Arch is testing a tool to automate subscription paperwork as it pushes toward a one-click experience in private markets.
Episode timestamps
00:00 Preview: why advisors need to see held-away assets00:17 Introduction and disclaimer01:26 Who pays the fees? The problem Arch set out to solve02:37 Lessons from large allocators for newer alternative investors04:02 What Arch does: documents, data and dashboards05:13 Cash management: commitments, capital calls and distributions06:50 How RIAs, multifamily offices and banks use Arch08:00 Working across custodians, fund administrators and portals09:03 AI insights, IRR and investor-letter summaries10:18 Who sees the data, and adding third-party context11:31 Power users versus weekly digest readers13:24 Educating the new wave of alternative investors14:53 After-tax returns, tax-aware funds and QSBS16:01 PPLI, insurance-dedicated funds and trustee reporting18:12 Helping advisory firms scale as alts grow19:36 Manager selection, partnerships and data protection21:06 Scale: $620 billion on the platform and new data partners22:43 Valuation lag and secondary-market marks23:34 Estate-planning valuations and permissioned access24:32 What’s next: automating the subscription document25:41 Where to find Arch and closing
Notable quotes
“Usually when you pay for something, you get a good experience. Private markets is such where people pay for investments and pay all the fees and get an awful experience.” — Ryan Eisenman
“There should be a one-click way to manage alternative investments and not the 5,500 clicks that it takes today to manage a single fund position over its 10-year life.” — Ryan Eisenman
“It’s hard to avoid the bad and prioritize the good if you don’t know which is good and which is bad.” — Ryan Eisenman
“Yes, the GP often hires the fund admin, but the LP pays the GP.” — Ryan Eisenman
About Ryan Eisenman
Ryan Eisenman is the co-founder and CEO of Arch, a technology platform for managing private market investments. He co-founded Arch in 2018 to address the fragmented, manual work of private investing, and the platform now centralizes K-1 collection, capital calls, distributions, documents and performance reporting. Before Arch, he worked at Deloitte and Techstars, among other firms. He earned his bachelor’s degree in Human and Organizational Development from Vanderbilt University. (Orion’s Standard Deviations guest profile)
About Arch: Arch announced a $52 million Series B led by Oak HC/FT in September 2025. In July 2026, it reported $539 billion in private market assets on its platform, and by late September 2026 it said it served more than 650 allocators with more than $600 billion in assets. (Business Wire, September 2025; Business Wire, July 2026; InvestmentNews, September 2026)
Interesting links
Arch — Ryan’s company and the place to schedule a demo.
Ryan Eisenman on LinkedIn
Ryan Eisenman on X
Arch Raises $52M Series B (Business Wire) — The 2025 funding announcement led by Oak HC/FT.
Arch Surpasses $500B in Assets on Platform (Business Wire) — July 2026 update naming MUFG Innovation Partners and Franklin Templeton as Series B investors.
Arch Pushes AI Portfolio Monitoring into Pre-Investment Due Diligence (InvestmentNews) — Coverage of Arch Investment Research, launched in September 2026.
‘Charles Schwab for Private Markets’ Arch Raises $52 Million (Fortune) — Background on Arch’s positioning and growth.
IRS: Exclusion of Gain on Qualified Small Business Stock — The Section 1202 (QSBS) rules Ryan mentions at 15:34, in the Schedule D instructions.
Private Placement Life Insurance with Jay Judas — Our related Wealth Actually episode on PPLI and insurance-dedicated funds.
Frequently asked questions
What does Arch do?
Arch collects documents from fund portals and managers on a client’s behalf, structures the data and presents it in a dashboard. Investors and advisors can see commitments, funded and unfunded amounts, performance, K-1s, capital-call alerts and underlying exposures in one place.
Who uses Arch?
Ryan says the largest client segment is investment advisors, including RIAs, multifamily offices and private banks. Arch also serves individual LPs, accountants and other allocators.
Why is reporting on private investments so difficult?
Private investments are commitment-based rather than share-based. Capital is called over time, distributions arrive irregularly, valuations lag and every fund reports a little differently. Most traditional reporting systems were built for stocks and bonds.
What rules should a newer alternative investor follow?
Ryan’s three rules: don’t lose money, avoid adverse selection by asking why the opportunity reached you, and diversify. He also recommends an intentional allocation plan and active deal sourcing.
How does Arch address valuation lag?
Arch adjusts the value shown on the platform for capital calls and distributions and is beginning to show underlying marks, including secondary-market pricing for some private companies, ahead of the next quarterly statement.
Can estate planners and valuation firms use Arch data?
Yes. Clients can permission all or part of their Arch data to third parties such as auditors, tax accountants, advisors and estate planners working on valuations.
Full transcript
This transcript is lightly edited for readability from the episode audio (26:17). Filler words and repeated starts have been removed without changing substance. It is not a certified verbatim record; please check the audio before quoting.
[00:00] Ryan Eisenman: We think that fundamentally, if you can’t see your clients’ other assets that they might have made away from you with another advisor or before they worked with you, then it’s really hard to give them true holistic advice and to help them understand which products to select or how to do planning.
[00:17] Frazer Rice: Welcome back to the Wealth Actually podcast, the show that features experts, entrepreneurs and commentators that will give you the right knowledge, planning and guidance so you can preserve your assets and enjoy your wealth. Learn more and subscribe today at WealthActually.com. This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes. It is neither investment, legal nor tax advice. It does not represent the opinions of the employers or the host or guest.
[00:42] Frazer Rice: Welcome back. Alternative investments are the rage these days. There’s an insatiable demand for hedge funds, private credit, private equity, infrastructure and the like. Ryan Eisenman is the co-founder and CEO of Arch, which is a tool to help investors understand what they own and the different decisions around allocation. We’re going to find out what the future looks like in this space. Ryan, welcome aboard.
[01:06] Ryan Eisenman: Thanks, Frazer. Great to be here.
[01:07] Frazer Rice: Thrilled to have you on. For those of us who work in the high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth space, the idea of reporting and aggregating assets and getting a real fix on what people have, where it is, how it should be spent, how performance is running and all that, it seems like a never-ending cycle. With Arch, what was the problem that you guys were trying to solve?
[01:31] Ryan Eisenman: Yeah. So who pays all the fees in private markets, or in
Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI) is a life insurance policy used as a tax-efficient wrapper for long-term investments. It works best for families who have money they will never spend, who can commit about $10 million in premium, who hold the policy in an irrevocable trust, and who are willing to give up control of investment decisions.
In this episode of Wealth Actually, JAY JUDAS, CEO of Life Insurance Strategies Group, explains how PPLI works, who it fits, where it gets missold, and how compounding inside a properly built policy can reach the third, fourth, and fifth generations.
https://youtu.be/fIknhINvP5I
https://open.spotify.com/episode/2RuIoiYqZw16xzGXNbY8nT?si=f6G_LpwHR9WiVbWCZbWsmA
Episode Overview
PPLI has moved from a niche product to one of the most discussed tools in ultra-high-net-worth planning. It now shows up in my own practice and in many conversations with trust and estate lawyers. I asked Jay Judas to help sort out the opportunities from the risks.
Jay runs a fee-based consultancy that does not sell insurance. Well over 60% of his firm’s work now involves PPLI. Yet he says more than half of the people who come to him believing they need PPLI should be in something else, or in nothing at all.
Our discussion covers why tax-inefficient alternatives such as private credit fit inside the policy, why the policy belongs in an irrevocable trust, and Jay’s “magic has a price” rule of thumb for minimum premium. We compare insurance-dedicated funds (IDFs) with separately managed accounts (SMAs), walk through the investor control and diversification rules, and look at why the “tax-free loans” pitch misses the point. We close with a case study: $50 million, three policies, and a 40-year runway.
Key Takeaways
PPLI is not for everybody. More than half of the prospects Jay’s firm evaluates are better served by another solution. Use money you will never touch. Jay says the right question is not what percentage of a portfolio to commit. It is which dollars are already set aside for children and grandchildren.Magic has a price. Jay’s practical minimum is about $10 million of premium, paid in as quickly as possible. Some low-cost carriers can make $5 million work.
Tax-inefficient assets benefit most. Private credit, private equity, real estate, litigation finance, life settlements, and infrastructure can face combined tax rates above 50% for New York and California residents.
Own the policy in an irrevocable trust. A policy held personally pulls the death benefit into the insured’s taxable estate.
IDFs and SMAs offer two routes. An IDF is an insurance-only version of a fund and usually covers a single strategy. An SMA lets a manager, often the family’s existing RIA, run a discretionary mandate under a broad investment policy statement.
Investor control is the real risk. You can choose an IDF or set broad goals with an SMA manager. You cannot direct trades, pick specific deals, or arrange a plan before the policy is issued. Emails can be subpoenaed.
Diversification is policed for you. Under Section 817(h), one investment cannot exceed 55% of the account, two cannot exceed 70%, three cannot exceed 80%, and four cannot exceed 90%. Carriers hire fund administrators to monitor compliance.
Policy loans are a weak selling point. In PPLI, the manager must sell assets to fund a loan, which can disrupt compounding and run into lockups. In 23 years, Jay has seen no more than 10 policies tapped for a distribution.
Trustees and trust protectors need periodic reviews. Jay’s firm found one 30-year-old policy whose fees were double current market levels and got them reduced.
Check who is selling. Most PPLI is now issued by established carriers and requires securities-licensed professionals. Be cautious of unlicensed producers who push offshore carriers.
The prize is G3 to G5. In Jay’s illustration, $50 million compounding at 9% inside a policy reaches about $1.6 billion over 40 years. The same money in a taxable California account, after federal estate tax, reaches about $159 million.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and disclaimer00:45 Why PPLI dominates UHNW planning conversations01:26 Life Insurance Strategies Group and why most PPLI inquiries are not a fit02:32 Asset location: tax-inefficient alternatives and the life insurance chassis04:45 Why the policy belongs in an irrevocable trust05:23 The ideal client and the “magic has a price” minimum07:07 How much to commit: money you will never touch08:06 Retail life insurance versus PPLI10:28 Insurance-dedicated funds (IDFs) versus separately managed accounts (SMAs)12:02 Why RIAs are embracing the SMA route12:52 Investor control: what you can and cannot do14:42 Diversification rules under Section 817(h)16:17 Single assets, Webber v. Commissioner, and prearranged plans17:53 It takes a village: the parties and their fees19:31 The liquidity myth and the problem with policy loans21:37 The trustee’s role and reviewing older policies23:34 Borrowing from the policy and the last-bucket principle26:23 Questions to ask before you buy27:44 Case study: planning for G3, G4, and G530:10 Where to find Jay Judas
Notable Quotes
“More than half of the people who come to us thinking they should be in PPLI, it’s not appropriate for them.” (Jay Judas)
“The price of PPLI magic, to make it work, is in my opinion a minimum commitment of $10 million, paid as quickly as you can into the policy.” (Jay Judas)
“Pick the fund, but not what that fund is doing.” (Jay Judas)
“In my 23 years of being involved in PPLI, I’ve seen no more than 10 policies ever touched for a distribution.” (Jay Judas)
“The real attraction of PPLI is that I can now plan for G3, G4, and G5.” (Jay Judas)
About the Guest
Jay C. Judas is CEO of Life Insurance Strategies Group (LISG), a Boston-based independent life insurance advisory firm that does not sell products. LISG advises individuals, families, advisors, and carriers on private placement life insurance, advanced estate planning, executive benefits, and cross-border planning. Jay is a former senior executive with Old Mutual, where he served as Senior Vice President and Chief Distribution Officer of Global High-Net-Worth Distribution. He also held senior roles with Sun Life Financial, Crown Global Insurance Company, and BF&M Insurance Group (Philadelphia Estate Planning Council). He co-authors the annual U.S. PPLI Market Report with Lion Street. Jay holds a JD from Rutgers University School of Law, an M.Sc. in Leadership from Northeastern University, and a BA from the University of Northern Iowa.
Resources Mentioned
Life Insurance Strategies Group
U.S. PPLI Market Report (Lion Street and LISG)
Jay Judas on LinkedIn
Diversification requirements, Treas. Reg. § 1.817-5 (Cornell LII)
Rev. Rul. 2003-91, IRS guidance on investor control (IRS)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is private placement life insurance (PPLI)?
PPLI is a variable life insurance policy offered privately to accredited investors and qualified purchasers. The premium is invested through insurance-dedicated funds or a separately managed account. Investment growth inside the policy is not currently taxed, and the death benefit generally passes income-tax-free, provided the policy meets the tax definition of life insurance and the owner does not control the investments.
How much money do you need for PPLI?
Jay Judas recommends a minimum commitment of about $10 million in premium, paid in as quickly as possible. At that level, carrier, manager, and broker fees are small enough to avoid a meaningful drag. Some lower-cost carriers can make about $5 million work.
Who is PPLI a good fit for?
PPLI fits families who hold long-term, tax-inefficient investments and have wealth they will not spend during their lifetimes. The best candidates plan to pass that money to children and grandchildren through an irrevocable trust. Jay estimates that more than half of the people who explore PPLI are better served by something else.
What is the difference between an IDF and an SMA in PPLI?
An insurance-dedicated fund (IDF) is an insurance-only version of a fund, usually a single strategy such as private credit. A separately managed account (SMA) is a discretionary mandate run by an investment manager, often the family’s existing RIA, under a broad investment policy statement. Both must comply with investor control and diversification rules.
What is the investor control doctrine?
The investor control doctrine holds that if the policyholder controls the investments inside the policy, the IRS can treat the policyholder as the owner and tax the investment income currently. Policyholders may choose among available funds or set broad goals. They may not direct specific trades, select specific deals, or set up a prearranged investment plan.
What are the PPLI diversification rules?
Under Section 817(h) and Treasury Regulation § 1.817-5, one investment cannot exceed 55% of the separate account’s value, two cannot exceed 70%, three cannot exceed 80%, and four cannot exceed 90%. In practice, this requires at least five investments. Carriers typically hire fund administrators to monitor compliance.
Can you borrow from a PPLI policy?
Yes, but it is rarely a good idea. In PPLI, the carrier does not advance cash. The investment manager must sell assets to fund a loan, which can interrupt compounding and run into lockups on private investments. Jay says he has seen no more than 10 policies tapped for distributions in 23 years.
Why should a PPLI policy be held in an irrevocable trust?
If the insured owns the policy personally, the death benefit is included in the insured’s taxable estate. An irrevocable trust, such as an ILIT, can keep the growing policy value and death benefit outside the estate for future generations.
Who are the parties in a PPLI transaction?
A typical transaction involves the insurance carrier, a securities-licensed insurance broker, the investment manager, a custodian, and often a fund administrator. Trustees, estate at
DAVID PAKMAN — political commentator, YouTube host, and author of the new book Pay Attention — joins me to talk about Algorithms, AI, and the Attention Economy. We break down how attention became the core commodity of the modern economy, why algorithms reward outrage over nuance, and what happens when AI starts cloning creators without their consent.
David walks through the real story of “The Daniel Carter Show,” a YouTube channel that used AI voice-cloning to impersonate him and was algorithmically recommended to his own audience. From there, the conversation covers why right-wing messaging has a structural advantage on algorithmic platforms, what “behavioral surplus” means and how platforms monetize it, and the media-literacy habits families should be teaching the next generation before handing over unrestricted social media access.
https://youtu.be/RTy2vuw7oe8
We also discuss anonymity and accountability online, why the “calm middle” is checking out of social media, and a simple “media diet” framework for staying informed without getting consumed.
https://www.amazon.com/Pay-Attention-Algorithms-Suppressing-Rewiring/dp/0063569809/
https://open.spotify.com/episode/3ti3d6FvXAmgwqX1h4pMQQ?si=x8cwV2-DQNewJJX9yM6Vpw
Themes
Why attention is the defining commodity of the digital economy
How “rented ground” platforms (YouTube, TikTok, podcasts) shape what creators can say
The real story behind an AI deepfake impersonating David Pakman
“Behavioral surplus”: how platforms monetize what you don’t even realize about yourself
A practical media-diet framework — and how to talk to kids and aging parents about safe media use
AI’s Impact on Video
Timestamped Show Notes / Chapters
00:00 — Cold open: “You just have to learn how to play the game” — David on the political right’s platform advantage
00:15 — Wealth Actually intro & disclaimer
00:40 — Introducing David Pakman and today’s topic: algorithms, attention, and responsible media consumption
00:59 — David’s new book Pay Attention: why he wrote it and the “confessional” behind-the-curtain angle
02:38 — Attention as the “lingua franca” of the modern economy
03:25 — Creating content on “rented ground”: YouTube, TikTok, and podcasting platforms as landlords with no clear lease
04:44 — How Facebook’s shift from chronological feeds to algorithmic “For You” feeds rewired the entire incentive system
06:36 — Why boring-but-important topics (like housing policy) need an emotional hook to break through
07:37 — What the political right does better on these platforms — and why it’s about style, not substance
08:01 — The COVID vaccine messaging case study: fear and scapegoating vs. accurate-but-boring nuance
10:10 — From the traditional GOP to the “Trump party”: the John McCain/POW moment as an inflection point
11:05 — The pre-Trump roots of modern right-wing messaging (AM/low-power FM religious radio, Rush Limbaugh) — and the recent press-corps ban of CNN, Politico, and MSNBC from the White House briefing room
12:08 — Why the “calm middle” checks out of social media, and how outrage drives engagement
12:40 — The trap of over-weighting vocal-minority feedback: “98% of my Twitter replies are anti-social screeds”
14:29 — Online anonymity, accountability, and Jonathan Haidt’s real-identity proposal
14:55 — David’s own experiment: requiring a real email address cut toxic messages by 95–99%
16:10 — AI and deepfakes: the danger of synthetic content built on real people’s data and personalities
16:44 — The “Daniel Carter Show”: how an AI voice clone of David was algorithmically pushed to his own audience
18:59 — “Behavioral surplus” — how platforms monetize the gap between what you say and how you actually behave
21:31 — David’s media-diet “food pyramid”: proactive, vetted sources as the staple; algorithmic scrolling as junk food
24:09 — Advising families and next generations on safer, smarter media habits
25:17 — David’s own household rules on kids, screens, and delaying unrestricted social media access
27:12 — The financial-literacy parallel: media literacy as a life skill that should be taught early
27:58 — The media-literacy pyramid — and the Pew Research finding that most Americans (across party lines) struggle to tell fact from opinion
29:10 — The AI risk multiplier: outsourcing critical thinking to algorithms
29:32 — Where to find Pay Attention and follow David Pakman
30:19 — Closing thanks
Transcript
[00:00] “So I actually think that from a political standpoint, if what people are trying to do is use these platforms to get the ideas they believe in out, you just have to learn how to play the game. I don’t think there really is any other solution on the political side.” — David Pakman
[00:15] [Show Intro] Welcome back to the Wealth Actually podcast, the show that features experts, entrepreneurs, and commentators that will give you the right knowledge, planning, and guidance so you can preserve your assets and enjoy your wealth. Learn more and subscribe today at WealthActually.com. This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes. It is not investment, legal, or tax advice. It does not represent the opinions of the employers of the host or guests. David Pakman has a multimillion person following and an outsized presence with his online political talk show. He knows a lot about how the algorithms work across platforms like YouTube. We’re gonna talk a lot about that and also how to responsibly consume media in this day and age
[00:56] Frazer Rice: David Pakman, thanks for coming on.
[00:58] David Pakman: Thank you.
[00:59] Frazer Rice: You’ve got a new book out. Pay Attention. By the time this podcast launches, it will be fully out and about on Amazon and wherever else everybody gets books. Tell us a little bit, just briefly, from the book writing process, your major voice in media, and what got you writing on this topic?
[01:18] David Pakman: Well, there’s a confessional aspect to the book — just kind of explaining the compromises as a content creator that I have to make. And I say “have to” in the context of, if I want this to be my full-time job, if I wanna succeed at it, there are compromises that have to be made, as is the case in most jobs. So one aspect of the book is kind of pulling back the curtain a little bit. The other aspect is about best practices at the individual level, when so much of what we come to believe is true — and sometimes isn’t — is mediated by these digital platforms that are algorithmically delivering content in a way that is not impartial. It’s so important to understand why we are fed the things we are fed rather than other things, as a starting point for having conversations about what we want the world to look like. And then I also have a political interest in this — as someone on the political left, I think the political right naturally benefits from the way these algorithms work, not because of anything special they’ve done, but from their communication style. So if the political left wants to succeed — which I think it does, at least it claims to — it has to better learn how to conduct itself on these platforms. We’ll dive into that in a second.
[02:38] Frazer Rice: One thing in your book — and I think generally that you talk about — is the commodity of attention, and how that has become really the lingua franca of the modern economy. Maybe dive into that a little bit about why that has become the case.
[02:55] David Pakman: Tell me from which perspective do you want me to talk about it? ‘Cause that could go in a bunch of directions.
[03:00] Frazer Rice: Well, I think the main thing is to say: if people are sort of used to oil or plastics or gold being a commodity, the idea of attention really driving, in many ways, economic decisions or allocation decisions around productivity — that seems to be something that’s a little bit more nuanced in the last, certainly five years, but maybe even back the last 10 or 15.
[03:25] David Pakman: Well, I think that conversation kind of starts with understanding incentives. I create content on what I describe as “rented ground” — YouTube, TikTok, podcasting platforms — all of these platforms are basically lending me space, for as long as it’s at their pleasure to do so, to publish my content. And they’re landlords that don’t really give me a clear lease that tells me what I’m allowed to do and expected to do. I kind of have to figure it out by doing it. Their incentive is to keep users on the platform as long as possible — the longer users are there, the more money the platform makes. So when we look at the content we get from these platforms, it’s not because the content is true that we’re shown it. It’s not because the content makes society better or makes us better citizens. We’re shown the content that the algorithm determines is most likely to keep us on the platform. That’s really the starting point. One of the critical changes: I don’t know how early you were on Facebook, but at the start, when I was in college, if you were friends with 20 people, your home feed was a chronological feed of what your friends posted. Very simple — if you looked on Saturday, went back Sunday and scrolled, at some point you’d hit the last thing you saw Saturday, and you were kind of done. There was a clear break point — “okay, I’m caught up, I’m getting off Facebook.” That’s a real problem for a platform that wants to keep you on there as long as possible. So eventually Facebook and Twitter switched to an algorithmically recommended feed. TikTok calls it the “For You” page, and it’s just the default. What that does is show you content not in chronological order, but based on what keeps you watching.
[05:52] Frazer Rice: At a much, much smaller scale than you do, I get frustrated oftentimes saying, I’m putting out things that I think are interesting and good that get a good response from a narrow set of people. But if I were Sydney Sweeney or a dancing bear and able to proliferate content in those terms, I’m
What happens to your voice, image and online accounts after you die? In this episode of Wealth Actually, I welcome back NATALIA PARKER and TATYANA THURSTON of DEXIT to discuss digital identity and estate planning in the age of AI.
https://youtu.be/MdnUcekE-08
The issue is bigger than recovering a password. An executor may have to decide whether to keep a book on sale, preserve a podcast, close a social media account or respond to an AI-generated version of the person who died. Those decisions can put income, reputation and family wishes in conflict.
We discuss how to build a digital-asset inventory, document instructions for online accounts, protect against deepfake scams and think through the use of your name, image, likeness and voice. The practical question: does your estate plan give the next person enough information to make these decisions?
What we cover
Digital estate planning: Why books, podcasts, photographs, recordings and online accounts belong in the planning conversation.
Instructions, not just an inventory: What an executor needs to know about the assets, the platforms and what you want done with each account.
Deepfake fraud: Why a familiar face or voice should not replace verification when money or sensitive information is involved.
AI after death: The questions raised by avatars, simulated social media activity and the reuse of a person’s creative work.
Fiduciary judgment: How executors and trustees may have to weigh commercial value against reputation and the emotional impact on a family.
A technology component: Why Natalia and Tatyana argue that technology planning belongs alongside wealth, tax and estate planning.
Episode timestamps
Timestamps refer to the supplied episode audio, including the opening preview and introduction.
00:00 Preview and introduction00:52 Why AI belongs in the estate-planning conversation03:36 Name, image and likeness beyond celebrities04:56 Platform access, ownership and closing accounts06:54 Deepfake fraud and verifying money transfers08:48 Building a digital defense strategy10:22 Digital-asset inventories and consent to AI recreation13:15 Facebook, posthumous posting and the ethics of AI15:46 Avatar businesses and the digital afterlife18:50 Robin Williams and restrictions on likeness21:02 Executors, trustees and the emotional cost to families23:10 Adding a technology component to the estate plan23:53 Where to find DEXIT and closing thoughts
About the guests
Natalia Parker and Tatyana Thurston are the co-founders of DEXIT, a digital succession-planning business. DEXIT works with clients, wealth advisors and estate planners on plans for online assets and accounts. (DEXIT founder profile; DEXIT)
Resources and related episodes
DEXIT: Learn about the guests’ work at dexitplan.com.
Our earlier conversation: Digital Assets Estate Planning with Natalia Parker and Tatyana Thurston covers digital inheritance, account access and planning for executors.
Related Wealth Actually episode: Technology and Estate Planning explores digital tools for estate-planning work.
Questions from the episode
What should a digital-asset inventory include?
In this conversation, we discuss online accounts, publishing platforms, books, podcasts, images, recordings and intellectual property. The emphasis is on pairing the inventory with instructions about what should be preserved, closed or considered for continued use.
What should I decide about an AI version of myself?
The guests suggest documenting whether you want your voice, image or recordings used to recreate you digitally after death. They also discuss the tension between those wishes, an executor’s decisions and the family’s reaction to the result.
Why is this an issue for people who are not celebrities?
Our discussion includes family photographs, personal accounts, recordings and unpublished creative work. Their importance may be emotional rather than commercial, which is why the conversation extends beyond celebrity estates.
What is the first planning conversation to have?
Start with what exists, what matters to you and what you want done with it. The next question is who will have to carry out those instructions and whether they have a usable roadmap.
Clarification on the Meta discussion
The opening preview and the discussion around 13:15 refer to Meta’s patent for simulating a user’s social media activity, including after death. In February 2026, a Meta spokesperson told Business Insider, “We have no plans to move forward with this example”; the report distinguishes the patent from a decision to implement the technology. (Business Insider)
The transcript below preserves the conversation as recorded. This clarification is separate from the speakers’ remarks.
Transcript
This transcript has been lightly edited for readability, removing filler words and repeated starts while preserving the substance of the conversation. Speaker timestamps are approximate navigation aids; examples and legal or technical statements reflect the discussion, not independently verified advice.
[00:00] Tatyana Thurston: Facebook in 2060, they’ll have way more deceased user accounts than live user accounts. And Facebook needs to monetize that. It takes up space in their servers, and they’ve actually recently patented the right to use the content that has been posted by deceased users. And they will be reposting as if they were still around.
[00:26] Announcer: Welcome back to the Wealth Actually podcast, the show that features experts, entrepreneurs, and commentators that will give you the right knowledge, planning, and guidance so you can preserve your assets and enjoy your wealth. Learn more and subscribe today at wealthactually.com. This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes. It is not investment, legal, nor tax advice. It does not represent the opinions of the employers of the host or the guests.
[00:52] Frazer Rice: Natalia, Tatyana, welcome back.
[00:54] Natalia Parker: Thank you for having us.
[00:55] Tatyana Thurston: Thanks for having us.
[00:56] Frazer Rice: Well, our last discussion actually engendered a lot of feedback from people who, if they were stuck in the executor role or in the trustee role, I thought it was very helpful in terms of laying out the roles and responsibilities and what you have to do to keep yourself and the estates safe. I thought we’d talk a little bit today about the intersection of technology, which hits close to home to me. I’m a big user of AI and really helped move things along for clients that way. But for me, I have a lot of IP as well.
[01:29] Frazer Rice: I’ve got podcasts, I’ve got books, I’ve got all sorts of images, et cetera. And there’s an AI component to some of that as well. Maybe take us through a little bit about how you think about preparing someone who has to preside over somebody else’s IP, their name, image, likeness, and that type of thing as a broader scope of issues as they get prepared going on this journey.
[01:57] Natalia Parker: Yes. First of all, yes, you do have a lot. And right now, your executors will have to know which platforms you’re using. And they have to know what you would like to do with those accounts. Do you want to keep your book open for readers and keep collecting money? Do you want your podcast to stop podcasting? Everything has to be written down somewhere. And then you have to have a plan for each one of them. We had a case where we had to close their Amazon book account. That was difficult because there were several authors.
[02:37] Frazer Rice: Oh, yikes. So a lot of cooks in the kitchen, and all of them have an opinion on what they want to do with it.
[02:45] Natalia Parker: Yes. So that’s where the DEXIT plan comes in.
[02:52] Frazer Rice: In terms of getting your arms around what it means to have digital assets nowadays, a lot of people, we talked before about social media accounts, images, maybe even voice recordings, et cetera, that may not be commercial, but they’re personal and important to them. And as we all know, AI is using every bit of data to train their LLMs and all the other things that they have at play to make their AI agents more effective. What is the state of the art as far as either using or protecting your own digital presence if you don’t want to be a part of AI, or how do you responsibly be engaged with it?
[03:36] Tatyana Thurston: I think it depends on where the name, image, and likeness is being used and in what capacity. For example, we have kids today as young as in high school, and they have a social media presence. They’re gaining followers in their teens, and maybe their goal is to be a professional football player. All those platforms hold their data and their videos and their name. And maybe they’re making money from it even at a young age.
[04:07] Tatyana Thurston: So even estate planning isn’t just for folks who are older. It could even start as early as young kids because they’re on platforms. Those are platforms which are public. The public platforms is a ripe source for scammers to take your name, image, and likeness and capitalize it in another way. So there’s a source of truth that some people are trying to do, especially celebrities. A lot of celebrities now are actually creating avatars of themselves so that the true representation of themselves is on record. It’s actually really interesting, but that’s part of preserving their digital presence online.
[04:56] Frazer Rice: And to circle back a little bit to what we were talking about in the previous episode, when you’re intersecting with these platforms, usually the social media platforms, the Facebooks, the Twitters, the Instagrams, et cetera. Step one, obviously, is to catalog exactly where you are, which is its own full-time job in many ways. But then what exactly do you have on there? It’s images, it’s quotes, it’s things like that. How do you intersect with these companies to not only get the terms of service figured out and get things pointed in the right dir



