What Did We Just Watch?

"Hi, babies, it's time to slam down and get even. It's time to spin out and boil your hair, you know? I want you to brace yourself for a night of high solid podcasting." Happy New Year everyone! We are starting 2026 off right with an early Cannon classic. Our panelist answer questions about "New Wave" hits, complex murder plots, time zones, telethons, and the First Lady of Rock and dysfunctional family. Call in now!Host: Mark Nessel Contestants: Steve Goff, Bob Killion, Mo McGee

No one can be mad at a podcast on Christmas! This week we complete our magical snowman trilogy with the 2024 Christmas romance, Hot Frosty, a movie that has us question snowman sentience, whether Born Sexy Yesterday is actually sexy, and the correlation between Hot Frosty and Jesus Christ. Tis the season to kick back and relax with some hot chocolate while Craig Robinson serenade you in our cozy town of Hope Springs.Host: Mo McGeeContestants: Brendan Nessel, Sebastian Szőllős, Marlaina Stuve

“Well, isn't that a pretty picture, Santa rolling down the block in a PODCAST!” You better watch out and you better not cry, because this year What Did We Just Watch is putting the 1994 classic The Santa Clause down your chimney and under your tree. Pour yourself a cup of cocoa, put on your best vintage sweater and have yourself a merry little Christmas with the WDWJW crew.Host: Steve GoffContestants: , Bob Killion, Mark Nessel, Sebastian Szőllős

"Legend has it, in the mystic land of Prydain, there was a podcast so cruel and so evil that even the gods feared it." Welcome to the depths of the Disney vault for a screening of the black sheep of their classic animated library, 1985's "The Black Cauldron." On a quest for podcast glory, two contestants go head-to-head, answering questions about Disney history, the naming of cats, Jeffery Katzenberg's taste in editing, the difference between dwarves and fairies, and how not to confuse this fantasy film with a certain genre classic. Grab a slice of bread, an apple, and your favorite oracular pig...we're going down to Prydain!Tim Burton's original designs vs Milt Kahl'sCheck out Mission: Rejected Here⁠⁠⁠⁠Host: J. Michael DeAngelis Contestants:  John Guest, Chris Klaniecki 

"I'm Castor Troy!" Or is he Castor Troy? Is this podcast Castor Troy? Hold on to your faces. This week we watched the 1997 face-swap classic that can only truly be described by the title itself: Face/Off. Join our contestants as we discuss Nicholas Cage at his absolute craziest, John Woo's first crack at a Hollywood film and the legacy he created, and who would be cast in a reprisal of this movie today (and whether this movie could even be made today...)Check out Justin's Podcast Cows in the Field Here⁠Host: Mo McGeeContestants: John Guest, Justin Khoo, Mark Nessel

That's a sweaty podcast. That's two sweaty podcasts. Let me feel you. Ah, that's another sweaty podcast.” Hope you're hungry! This week we are serving up a heaping helping of 1985's horror comedy classic The Stuff! Put on your bib and make room for dessert because enough is never enough! Will you be listening to it? Or will it be listening to you?Check out Cinema Smorgasbord's website Cinema Smorgasbord on Facebook, Twitter, and BlueSky13 Strange Things You Wouldn't Believe are in GeorgiaHost: Steve GoffContestants: John Guest, Mark Nessel, Doug Tilly

"Pease podcast hot, pease podcast cold, pease podcast in the pot nine days old." Welcome to all our fays, elves and trolls out there in podcast land. We are taking a trip to San Francisco via Italy for a look at this 1986 cult-horror film. Our contestants answer questions about the surprisingly recognizable cast, fun practical effects, confusing lore, references to other Empire Picture films, and of course Ratburgers. There ain't no better cure for the summertime blues!Check out Stage to Screen here Check out Talk Film Society on Patreon ⁠⁠⁠Check out "Coco The Barbarian Needs A Friend" on Mission: Rejected feed here⁠Host: Mark NesselContestants: Bob Killion, Mo McGee, Marcelo Pico

"To crush your questions; see their points tallied before you, and to hear the lamentations of the other contestants." That's what's best for our guests this week as they embark on an epic podcast journey through 1982's Conan the Barbarian. Hear them grapple with made up fantasy words, attempt to explain the un-narrated parts of the film, and guess why James Earl Jones was so comfortable with snakes. Do you want to live forever? You will when you're done this episode! ⁠Check out "Coco The Barbarian Needs A Friend" on Mission: Rejected feed hereHost: Bob KillionContestants: Matt Candio, Lydia Grajauskas, Mark Nessel

"Whoever said 'Tomorrow is another day' didn't check the weather... Or listen to this podcast!" Sorry to rain on your parade, but this week we warm up to a movie about global warming and... ice storms? The year is 2004 and the North Atlantic currents somehow make frozen hurricanes, floods, and tornadoes in L.A. in The Day After Tomorrow. Our panel talks about Roland Emmerich's many strange choices as a director, wolves, Russian boats in Manhattan, how easy it is to survive -150-degree weather, and Bilbo's bromance with Dennis Quade. We also very importantly discuss how attractive Jake Gyllenhaal is in this movie. You won't want to miss this chilling disaster of an episode!Host: Sebastian SzőllősContestants: Steve Goff, Mo McGee, Brendan McMahon

"Fiddle-de-dee! I don't much like the way you podcast!" We are covering a big-budget comedy classic this week. This 1965 picture has stars, stunts, and set pieces galore. Push the play button, Max!⁠Check out Mission: Rejected Here⁠⁠⁠Host: Chris Klaniecki Contestants:  J. Michael DeAngelis, Bob Killion, Paige KlanieckiP.S. Easter egg for our audience, mentioned at the very end of this episode!  

"Heroes in a Halfshell. Podcast Power!" Cowabunga everyone! We are highlighting the most adolescent terrapins this week by revising this 90's blockbuster. Our contestants share their history with the turtles, delve into some of the lore of the Turtles and answer questions about antique stores, revenge plots, the logistics of the ooze. Just remember: never pay full price for a late pizza.⁠Check out "Coco The Barbarian Needs A Friend" on Mission: Rejected feed hereHost: Mo McGeeContestants: Steve Goff, Bob Killion, Mark Nessel

"You ever hear the term 'podcaster'...used outside of its normal meaning?" We've got another Bronson caper for you all this week. Our contestants answer questions about elaborate assassinations, weird parties, sleepy time tea, big cats, motorcycles, and as usual, we take a trip to the zoo. Come listen, it won't even cost you a lot of bread!⁠Check out "Coco The Barbarian Needs A Friend" on Mission: Rejected feed here⁠ Get your tickets for Mission: Rejected live on Saturday, August 2nd⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Host: Mark NesselContestants: Steve Goff, Bob Killion, Mo McGee

"Oh my Podcast, my pants are toast" It is summer, and we got ourselves a summer blockbuster this week. Our contestants answer questions about what's true and what's not about how this film came to be, discuss the differences between the theatrical and directors cuts, and decide where this film fits in the Ghostbusters cannon. When there are movies to discuss we always Answer the Call!⁠Check out Chilling Scenarios here⁠Check out "Coco The Barbarian Needs A Friend" on Mission: Rejected feed here⁠Get your tickets for Mission: Rejected live on Saturday, August 2nd⁠Host: Vince NigitoContestants: Kenny Destefano, Bob Killion, Mo McGee

"To bee or not to bee? Isn't that the bloody question? I think I'll take to podcast." What's the buzz everyone? This week we are making a beeline to this 2024 action extravaganza. Our panel talks about where this sits among Statham films, accents, car product placement, the different evil weirdos the Beekeeper dispatches as well as the disappointing lack of bee puns in this film. Swarm, don't walk because this is a show you will not want to miss. Host: Steve GoffContestants: Mo McGee, Brendan Nessel, Sebastian Szőllős

"Madam Secretary, I don't represent any one particular podcast, but I'd like to address the delegates." We are talking Superman this week...no not that movie...The infamous 80's Cannon "Disasterpiece" that put the whole franchise to sleep. Our constants discuss kids writing to their local superhero, the journey Lex Luthor's hair takes throughout the series, scenes that were deleted for the original cut, as well as some of the strangest powers Superman has ever demonstrated. You don't have to be the greatest criminal mind the world has ever known to know you can't miss this one.Get your tickets for Mission: Rejected live on Saturday, August 2ndCheck out Mission: Rejected Here⁠⁠⁠⁠Host: J. Michael DeAngelisContestants: John Dowgin, Chris Klaniecki, Mo McGee

Happy Birthday! On this day 2 years ago we published our first show. This year has been great, and to celebrate we are revisiting those shows in the only way we know how: a quiz show. We've got questions about the movies, questions about our guest and questions about...our questions. Thanks to everyone who has supported us. Excited for new films, new contestants and new head-scratching questions in the weeks to come.Host: Mark NesselContestants: Steve Goff, Bob Killion, Mo McGee

"When I want your podcast, I'll beat it out of you." Another year, another Norris film. This time we are traveling to the mean streets of Chicago for a hard-boiled police drama. Our contestants answer questions about local landmarks and actors, as well as baseball, get-rich-quick schemes, and killer robots. Put on your Cubs hat and Action Jeans and celebrate the start of our new year with us!Get your tickets for Mission: Rejected live on Saturday, August 2nd⁠⁠Host: Mark NesselContestants: Steve Goff, Bob Killion, Mo McGee

"Another one of them new worlds. No beer, no women, no podcasts, nothin'." Greetings Earthlings. For this week we are sending back dispatches from a planet that you're not allowed to go to...unless you ask nicely. Our contestants answer questions about the sci-fi jargon, the antiquated sexual politics and everyone's favorite robot. Just strap on your Plastic Educator and enjoy the show.Check out Mary's Tiktok hereHost : Bob KillionContestants: Chris Brockway, Mary Brownlee, Steve Goff

"Oh, I just wanted to say good-bye and remind you that the podcasters always win, even in the eighties." We have a famous flop to discuss this week. Our panel dives into...a lot of things: Grease (1978), rattlesnakes, Mattel, the musicals of Stephen Sondheim, Xanadu (1980)...as well as answer questions about Megaforce. We take a look at what doesn't work as well as what almost works; the weird, the off-kilter and the technically groundbreaking. You might say this film is a bit of an Egg...And that's no "yolk."Check out Mission: Rejected Here⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Check out Oz 9 HereHost: John DowginContestants: J. Michael DeAngelis, Paige Klaniecki, Shannon Perry

"They may be podcasters, Robin, but they're also human beings - and may be salvaged." Salutations, chums! Today we are dawning the cowl for this 1960's comic camp classic. Our contestants answer questions about bat-vehicles, the villainous schemes, riddles, exclamations, POWS, THAWAPS and KABOOMS. This episode is perfect to listen to in your batmobile, batcopter or batspeedboat.Check out CultPOP on YouTube, Apple and SpotifyCheck out Inside the Morgue on YouTube, Spotify and InstagramHost: Steve GoffContestants: Alice, Noel Bartocci, Mark Nessel