Discover
Workers Comp Matters
Workers Comp Matters
Author: Legal Talk Network
Subscribed: 183Played: 641Subscribe
Share
© Legal Talk Network
Description
Workers’ compensation is about more than laws and benefits. It's about people. Attorneys Alan S. Pierce and Judson L. Pierce draw on decades of experience advocating for injured workers to explore the issues that matter most. Through insightful and engaging conversations with lawyers, doctors, industry leaders, and other experts, they examine everything from workplace injuries and recovery to important legal developments, national trends, and the occasional unusual case.
172 Episodes
Reverse
What happens when a student athlete – in today’s world of lucrative financial contracts – gets hurt? When a student playing under revenue sharing provisions and Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) contracts is injured, is that still a “student playing a game” or is that a paid performer entitled to Workers’ Compensation?
Guest Frank McKay is an appellate judge and a director of the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation. He recently co-authored an article titled “Student Athletes: Are They or Should They Be Employees?”
The argument over student athletes goes back decades, but changes in the past few years – along with massive broadcasting, sponsorship, and merchandise contracts -- are challenging long-standing questions over when a college is proving a fun activity for students and when it’s engaged in sports as a business.
McKay delves into the murky waters of student athletes, payments, and injury compensation. NIL payments, transfer portals, and years of player eligibility are changing the world of college sports. The question in Workers’ Comp law remains to be at what point are student athletes, working hard and paid well, employees? Today’s models don’t seem to fit. Enjoy this fascinating conversation.
If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].
Mentioned in This Episode:
Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation
Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation SBWC AI Standing Order
College of Workers’ Comp Lawyers
The National Association of Workers' Compensation Judiciary
“The Stormy Petrel Strikes Back: College Athletes and Employee Status,” Alabama Workers’ Comp Blog
“University of Denver v. Nemeth (Colo. 1953),” Justia
“State Compensation Ins. Fund v. Industrial Com'n (Colo. 1957),” (the “Dennison decision”), Justia
“National Collegiate Athletic Assn. v. Alston,” Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
“Judge OK's $2.8B Settlement, Paving Way For Colleges To Pay Athletes,” House v. NCAA settlement, ESPN
“Johnson v. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (3d Cir. 2024),” Justia
“Senate Passes Major Bill to Overhaul College Sports,” (Protect College Sports Act), CNN
“29 CFR § 795.110 - Economic Reality Test to Determine Economic Dependence,” Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
“Explainer: What Does NLRB Ruling on Dartmouth Men's Basketball Actually Mean?” Yahoo Sports
“Top (Paid) NIL Athletes 2026,” The Sideline
Artificial intelligence is all around us, in courtrooms, law offices, insurance claims processing, medical practices, and just about everywhere else. But what happens when AI makes its way into an actual Workers’ Compensation case. Today’s guest, Judge Frank McKay, is an appellate judge and a director of the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation. This is a fascinating conversation on the cutting edge of Workers’ Comp management.
The Georgia board this summer issued a standing order regarding the use of AI, but what does it mean? McKay says AI is “an amazing thing” but notes while it may be a useful tool, there have been examples of cases where a lawyer – and even pro se litigants – have submitted materials where AI “hallucinated,” or “made up,” case law that didn’t exist. That’s a problem.
Case citations, imagined participants, or real cases that don’t match the argument presented are problems. If someone is going to file a document, McKay says the Georgia Board is directing that the cases cited both exist and apply, verified by real, human review. AI is supposed to make things more efficient, not clog up the system with nonsense.
The new Georgia rules on evidence and case law don’t ban the use of AI, but they do require the parties document AI use and accept responsibility to use human verification of AI generated findings or even AI medical record reviews. When it comes to AI, perhaps we can expect more, similar verification requirements.
If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].
Mentioned in This Episode:
Thomson Reuters CoCounsel
LexisNexis Lexis+
Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation
Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation SBWC AI Standing Order
“AI 'Hallucinations' in Court Papers Spell Trouble for Lawyers,” Reuters
It’s been 25 years since 9/11. In this special episode, we revisit our conversation with Kenneth Feinberg, the architect of the federal compensation plan for victims and their families. As he asks in his book on the subject, “what’s life worth?”
Feinberg is an internationally known attorney who was appointed by President George W. Bush to administer the federal fund established to aid those injured in the terrorist attacks and to support the families of those who lost their lives.
We reflect on Feinberg’s Herculean efforts and how his team grappled with a national open wound and struggled to put a monetary value on thousands of lives.
In today’s often divisive political climate, a brutal period 25 years ago reminds us of a time when our nation came together as one. If any episode of Workers’ Comp Matters bears a second listen, this is the one. Everyone working with injured workers and their families can take a lesson from Feinberg’s extraordinary challenge.
If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].
Mentioned in This Episode:
“Worth,” a Netflix film on Ken Feinberg’s work, trailer
“What Is Life Worth? The Unprecedented Effort to Compensate the Victims of 9/11,” by Kenneth R. Feinberg
Let’s go way down south to Alabama. As we know, Workers’ Compensation systems can vary from state to state. In this episode, we’ll explore the Alabama system with Birmingham-based Workers’ Comp attorney David Nomberg, a partner in the Nomberg Law Firm.
In Alabama, the system operates uniquely as the only state without an administrative Workers’ Comp system to settle differences. If there is a dispute or denied claim, the case goes directly to the Circuit Court, the same judges that would hear other civil cases. This means attorneys may have the extra duty of explaining the issue to judges who may not be familiar with Workers’ Comp.
Nomberg shares insights into the importance of communication. Not only with judges, but also with clients who may be surfing the internet and finding information from law offices in other states, where different laws apply.
But as Americans, we all share some similarities, too. We all want to help workers injured on the job become whole and live their best lives. Nomberg sees some nationwide areas where we can all do better, including caring for an aging workforce, mental health and PTSD, heat-related claims, and changes in technology. Jump in for this fascinating dive into the complicated web of Workers’ Compensation in an ever-changing environment.
If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].
Mentioned in This Episode:
Workers’ Injury Law and Advocacy Group
Previously on Workers’ Comp Matters, “’A Patriotic Obligation’: Kenneth Feinberg and the 9/11 Fund,” with guest Kenneth Feinberg
“Worth,” trailer YouTube
“The Looming Tower,” trailer YouTube
Workers’ Compensation Research Institute (WCRI)
Let’s talk about work-related joint injuries and replacements. Sebastian Negrusa, Ph.D., joins Judson and Alan to share the Workers’ Compensation Research Institute’s (WCRI) new report, “Recent Trends in Joint Replacement Among Workers’ Compensation Claims.”
While back injuries usually come to mind for workplace injuries, joint injuries, and subsequent replacements, are becoming more common. Are you up to speed on this trend? Shoulder, hip, and knee replacements are important parts of making workers whole and getting them back to their jobs and their lives.
How do you prove a workplace-related joint injury when someone has worked at the same job for decades? What’s work-related, what’s just a function of natural aging? What if the workplace only aggravated a naturally occurring degeneration? It’s complicated, but all workers deserve to be treated fairly, and all workplaces should be safe.
If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].
Mentioned in This Episode:
“Recent Trends in Joint Replacement Among Workers’ Compensation Claims,” WCRI, By Dongchun Wang, Vennela Thumula, Randall Lea, M.D.
“CJR-X (Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement Expanded) Model,” CMS.gov



