Discover
The Wrong Cat Died
The Wrong Cat Died
Author: Broadway Podcast Network
Subscribed: 14Played: 1,083Subscribe
Share
© Broadway Podcast Network
Description
Grizabella was the wrong cat to die. After seeing CATS the Musical for the first time in July of 2016, podcast host Mike Abrams was filled with a whirlwind of emotions. He was amused, confused, and a little angry. Almost exactly three years later when the 2019 CATS movie trailer came out, Mike had enough. It was time to speak his truth – Grizabella was the wrong Cat to Die at the Jellicle Ball. In this podcast, Mike interviews CATS cast members, CATS superfans, CATS haters, and explores the backstories of the Jellicle characters all to make a case for why they were more worthy to ascend to the Heaviside Layer than Grizabella.Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.
312 Episodes
Reverse
“Every cat is rehearsing a way to make themself shine.” This episode features Korie Lee Blossey who played Old Deuteronomy in Casa Mañana’s 2025 “Cowboy Cats” in Fort Worth Texas. Korie recounts early fandom through the soundtrack, clips, and the 1998 filmed version, plus repeated auditions where he was told he sounded too young. He discusses Cowboy Cats’ country-style ideas with Stockyards-inspired design, props, and Grizabella’s Mule Alley. Plus, Korie shares his experience in a John Oliver Cats spoof where he was credited as Old Deuteronomy.
01:44 Chasing Old Deuteronomy
04:17 Cowboy Cats
17:59 Wild West Stage Magic
21:56 Honesty Over Camp
27:27 John Oliver Cats Spoof
28:06 Ken Page Tribute Moment
33:11 Rapid Fire
Check out Korey on Instagram: @itsmekorielee
Produced by:
Alan Seales & Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media: @TheWrongCatDied
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
“I was just so along for the ride.” This episode features Shelby Griswold who was an understudy in Cats: The Jellicle Ball at the PAC and is heading on the US National Tour of Six as Anne of Cleves. Shelby describes learning ballroom fundamentals, navigating improv versus set staging for a commercial musical, and creating her own movement material when covering tracks like Victoria. She shares how performing in revealing costumes and receiving an audience email about representation shifted her confidence and approach to work. Plus, Shelby and Mike cast the Six queens as Cats.
09:01 Casting Chaos
12:22 Learning Ballroom
20:42 Walking the Categories
32:36 Joining Six Tour
48:11 Rapid Fire
Check out Shelby on Social Media: @shelby__griswold
Check out Shelby's website: www.shelbygriswold.com
Check out Six on Social Media: @sixustour
Check out Six's website: sixonbroadway.com/ustour
Produced by:
Alan Seales & Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media: @TheWrongCatDied
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
“ I have the characters who have a named song be their characters the entire show. And every time Munkustrap announces ‘the cat who will now be reborn and go back to a different Jellicle life’ I have those eight players stand up.” This episode features Anne Beck, director and choreographer of 2026 Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre’s CATS in Indianapolis and a former Bombalurina. Anne recounts first seeing CATS at the Winter Garden, joining a 2012 Gateway Playhouse production with Ken Page, and learning extensive character backstories from Jacob Brent through rehearsal “tea time.” She explains how she stages CATS by starting day one with feline movement and story, emphasizing clarity, forgiveness, chosen family, and Grizabella’s throughline. She contrasts directing in large venues like Ball State with the intimate Beef & Boards space, notes the show’s fast rehearsal demands, and shares favorite roles, songs, and performance details for first-time audience members.
01:15 First Encounter with CATS
03:15 Playing Bombalurina
16:25 Beef And Boards Immersion
21:05 Prepping First Timers
29:48 Relationships And Family Tree
35:45 Fast Rehearsal Process
37:01 Dinner Theater Audience
45:13 Rapid Fire
Check out Beef & Boards on Instagram: @beefandboards
Check out Beef & Boards' website: www.beefandboards.com
Produced by:
Alan Seales & Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media: @TheWrongCatDied
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
“I felt like I owed it to the performers in The Jellicle Ball. Just because they changed the way I look at the world so I wanted people to have that experience.” This episode features Brett Evans, known online as Kermit MAFrog, to discuss becoming a CATS fan after initially viewing it as a “punishment,” discovering how different each production can be, and falling in love with the Jellicle Ball’s cast, intimacy, and audience interaction. Brett explains how he shifted from pursuing theatre to writing a poem a day for 10 years, then created his Jellicle Ball tribute videos to spotlight performers. He shares how his content began with viral Patrick Mahomes-as-Kermit sports videos before evolving into Muppets-meets-musical-theatre parodies.
05:33 Why The Jellicle Ball Hit Different
06:41 Poem a Day Origins
14:57 A Poem for The Wrong Cat Died
25:12 Kermit MaFrog Begins
28:12 Muppets Meet Musicals
36:51 Muppets Cats Dream Cast
43:51 Guilty Pleasure Showtunes
46:13 Rapid Fire
Check out Brett & Kermit on Social Media: @brettevansmafrog
Produced by:
Alan Seales & Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media: @TheWrongCatDied
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
“Chrissie Cartwright asked me to do a pirouette and I didn’t know what it was.” This episode features Dominik Hees who played the Rum Tum Tugger on the German Tent Tour and later in the Vienna revival of CATS. Dominik shares how he was cast despite no formal training and initially not knowing basic dance terms, receiving private dance lessons, and learning to sustain eight or nine shows a week in extreme tent temperatures. He shares how choreography and staging were adapted to his strengths, why the role evolved for him from a boy-band energy to a sexier, stiller, more mature performance, and how working with Chrissie Cartwright, Gillian Lynne, and Trevor Nunn shaped different interpretations. He describes changing onstage relationships with Mistoffelees, Grizabella, Munkustrap, and Bombalurina over time, shares favorite characters and songs, and weighs who should be the Jellicle choice. Be sure to see him in his upcoming Beauty and the Beast production.
04:28 From Rock to Musicals
07:07 Learning the Jellicle Ball
12:47 Finding Tugger’s Story
26:59 Parenthood Changes Tugger
28:08 Tugger Relationship Map
36:31 Rapid Fire
Check out Dominik on Instagram: @dominik.hees
Produced by:
Alan Seales & Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media: @TheWrongCatDied
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices








