DiscoverTech Deciphered
Tech Deciphered

Tech Deciphered

Author: Bertrand Schmitt & Nuno G. Pedro

Subscribed: 30Played: 947
Share

Description

Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news. To understand what’s really happening behind the surface, join our hosts, Nuno Goncalves Pedro, investor, co-founder and managing partner at Strive Capital, and Bertrand Schmitt, entrepreneur, co-Founder & Chairman at App Annie. They have been each in tech for almost 25 years, are now based in Silicon Valley, having both previously worked and lived in Europe and Asia. With Tech DECIPHERED, discover how the best entrepreneurs pitch, how investors think, and what are the deep trends underlying the tech industry. To learn more about Tech DECIPHERED, head over to www.decipheredshow.com for more info about the podcast, show notes, resources and complete transcripts.
86 Episodes
Reverse
The mythology in Silicon Valley is well known: stories that don’t quite match reality. Zero to Hero and Hero to Zero narratives, and everything in-between. This episode will focus on the communications machines of large and small Technology companies and its Investors, which have taken over the narrative, sometimes with disastrous consequences. Navigation: Intro The Factory The Performance The Megaphone Our Take & Conclusion Our co-hosts: Bertrand Schmitt, Entrepreneur in Residence at Red River West, co-founder of App Annie / Data.ai, business angel, advisor to startups and VC funds, @bschmitt Nuno Goncalves Pedro, Investor, Managing Partner, Founder at Chamaeleon, @ngpedro Our show: Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news Subscribe To Our Podcast Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Introduction Welcome to Episode 83 of Tech Deciphered. This episode will be about communications. We’ve called it “Smoke and Mirrors: How the Communications Machine Took Over Tech.” We will go through several examples on how the mythology of Silicon Valley has been built over the last few decades—from basic accelerators and how those companies have been able to create the notion of controlled access, to all the way through the tech companies, the big tech companies, and their communication machines, which are not always the most truthful. As always, no BS, straight to the point. Bertrand? Bertrand Schmitt The Factory It’s been around for a long time, so in a way there is nothing new. What might be new is the scale, the experience in all this marketing that different actors have, how this has been structured for a while. You could argue one of the most talented communicators was Steve Jobs, who started Apple, managed its comeback. He was considered to have one of the most potent weapons: the “reality distortion field”—his ability to make you believe in nearly anything. Usually it was, for sure, very surprising, impressive, but not always. But one of the most talented, gifted practitioners in that space. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Yeah, even Bill Gates, right? The whole word “vaporware” in some ways, I think, was—I’m not sure historically this is totally true, but it was, in my opinion, seemingly attached to Microsoft on how it announced certain things that really didn’t quite work out the way it was supposed to. That was back in the good old days of Bill Gates running the company. Bertrand Schmitt You’re right. At some point, it was called “slideware” from Microsoft. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Which is appropriate, given Microsoft’s ownership of PowerPoint, yes. Bertrand Schmitt Exactly. Yes, nothing new under the sun, but I guess it’s a good time to talk about this and explain a bit some of the recipes. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Maybe let’s start with the beginning of the problem, so to speak. If we go through stages of funding in some ways, and the beginning is the factories—the accelerators, what we would call the “demo day theater.” There is, in some ways, an industrialization of startup creation happening, and the accelerators—or certainly certain accelerators, Y Combinator being probably one of the strongest examples of that—have become a signaling machine, so to speak. Not really true to me that all of these accelerators are schools. In some ways it feels like the education they’re providing is on how to make yourself a hot company out there, and how to really propel yourself into fundraising—those two key things: communications plus fundraising as part of that offering. Y Combinator has grown quite a lot. We were just checking how many batches they have. They have four batches a year: they have spring, summer, fall, and winter. The spring, I think, is called “X,” just not to be confused with summer, which is “S.” Summer ’26 would be S26—that’s the batch—but then spring ’26 would, I guess, be X26, not to be confused. They have a ton of companies. The current cohorts are each roughly half the size of the old mega batches, but to be honest, when Y Combinator started, they didn’t have mega batches; the mega batches came later as well. But summer 2026, if we have the numbers absolutely right, had 235 companies in that batch alone. It feels like a batch machine. For YC, it’s great. Because they can cherry-pick. They’ll get into all the companies, but then at some point they can cherry-pick which ones are really great and not. They seemingly still have a little bit this index way of attacking the industry and really creating some of the biggest successes at the same time as the others that fail through the wayside. Bertrand Schmitt They still have a pretty high acceptance rate—even when you hold the size of the batches comparable, it’s a 1% acceptance rate. They are still pretty careful. It’s pretty impressive, I would say, to see that. After that, there is always this hype machine in terms of: do you manage to get in before the demo day, or just on the demo day itself. It’s always quite impressive. I would say some will say that the really big successes have been a bit more few and far between recently. I mean, compared to the origins of Y Combinator—the first few years—you might argue there might have been less, much bigger successes than before. But obviously they have a capacity to still attract quite a lot of pretty successful startups, or startups that are going to be pretty successful. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro I think YC is probably the most extreme example. It’s based in Silicon Valley. It feels like the Silicon Valley accelerator. Obviously there are others; 500 Startups is one of them. Bertrand Schmitt They do still exist, 500 Startups? Nuno Gonçalves Pedro They do. I’m not sure—let me put this in another way. I feel they’ve gone very geographical. They’ve decentralized for sure, and I’m not really sure how much of it is batch playing all the way through fund management. At the end of the day, they seem to have different interests. In some ways it’s a little bit like a franchiser-franchisee relationship, which Y Combinator is not. We have others—Techstars, Dreamit, et cetera. But they’re all working on the same thing: on distilling everything to a three-minute demo, on trying to get the companies and startups that are in the batches the highest chance of fundraising out of it as possible. Again, a lot of it is around communications—around a specific kind of communication. I was having a meeting the other day with a founder. He was very pissed off at me, I think. I wasn’t being facetious or aggressive, but he was pitching to me as a VC, and he came out of Y Combinator, I think, a couple of months before. I was like, “Hey dude, you’re giving me the demo day pitch. Not interested.” I’m not interested in the three-to-five-minute high-level thing. I’m like, “You were kind to share your deck. I’ve looked at your deck. I have specific questions. Can we go into that?” He kept going back to his message house. That’s how powerful the embedding—it’s like someone at Y Combinator or something, I don’t know, told him, “You need to stick to your message.” I’m like, “Well, I’m a VC, and the first thing I’m going to do is destroy your message house, because I want to get to the risks that your company has right now, and how are those risks measurable in terms of our analysis of your company, whether this makes your company interesting or not.” In the end, obviously—as you can imagine—we passed not so much because of the grand posturing of the thing, but because we didn’t believe the company was really at the right stage for us to come into. But that was very visible. He kept going back to his message house. I’m like, “Dude, I understand what you’re doing. I’ve been to a lot of demo days—Y Combinator and otherwise. I understand, but I have questions and we have 30 minutes. Can I go through my questions?” “No.” He wanted to go to his message house. In the end, I ended up putting some questions at the end after 15 minutes of him grandstanding with several layers of his message house. I was like, “Dude, not for us, I think. Not for us.” sometimes over-communicating—sticking too much to what you were told—doesn’t work. There’s something that you learn in communications and in negotiation very early on, which is the notion of releasing agenda. If the other person pushes you, probably the best option is to release your agenda, not stick to it. If you stick to it, then I’m like, “I’m not paying attention anymore.” Bertrand Schmitt My guess would be most of the learnings of Y Combinator have definitely some value, but at the end of the day, you need to adjust to your audience. You need to adjust to the needs of your audience. If you work like this with investors, then you will work like this with customers. At some point, that’s not going to work. Maybe there was not a lot of substance in that specific situation. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro There’s a couple of other accelerators we haven’t really mentioned. Speedrun from A16Z. Big batches now—they’ve moved as well from what used to be mostly gaming at the beginning and consumer to something that’s a little bit more broad. A little bit—no, a lot more broad. We’ll see how that works out. Early on, I remember going to demo days, and they were very well organized, very well done. They seemed to be going for the kind of company that already has some traction, which is, by the way, what 500 Startups used to do. That was one of the key distinctiveness versus YC, which seems to be more like earlier startups. Then there’s more specialized accelerators out there that have done very well. HF0 is one of them. Relatively hot serial entrepreneurs and all the solutions around it. There’s a few others that I’m probably not remembering exactly the name right now. This is on top of all the global, regionalized, domestic incubato
With age comes wisdom. Or does it? In this episode, we discuss what we would we say and share with our 25-year-old selves. What would we keep, what would we change and what nobody told us that we wish they had Navigation: Intro Where we actually were at 25 The conversation: six themes, professional then personal What we would NOT change The 25-year-old of 2026 Conclusion Our co-hosts: Bertrand Schmitt, Entrepreneur in Residence at Red River West, co-founder of App Annie / Data.ai, business angel, advisor to startups and VC funds, @bschmitt Nuno Goncalves Pedro, Investor, Managing Partner, Founder at Chamaeleon, @ngpedro Our show: Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news Subscribe To Our Podcast Bertrand Schmitt Welcome to Tech Deciphered Episode 82. This will be quite a special episode. We are going to talk about what we would say to our 25-year-old selves. With age comes wisdom, or does it? We are going to talk about what we would say to our old self when we were maybe around 25 years old, so quite some time ago, and try to share some wisdom about what we have learned over the years, maybe things to do, mistakes not to do. Maybe we start with where we were at 25. Nuno, you want to start? Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Yeah, and we have similar ages. At 25, we were around the same year, more or less. I was in, I think, the second of my third grueling years at Deloitte Consulting, about to make probably the biggest shift of my life, which was my move to London, which would happen a year later when I was 26. I think that was my platform to where I am today, having worked outside Portugal for many years now and having lived all over the world. But at 25, I was in my second year at Deloitte, working probably around that time, 90-100-hour weeks, like investment banking style. I would say Deloitte was probably the place where I learned a lot of my discipline around business, around structuring problems, where I first read Barbara Minto’s famous pyramid principle that helped me become a much more structured person in terms of my communication, et cetera, and also where I started having a little bit of a bullshit meter for what people around me were doing and how they were doing it along the way. I’m a computer engineer by background, as many of you know. I’d come out of that. I started studying when I was very young. When I was 17, I got in college, young by Portuguese standards. I’d also started a company in parallel, which many people don’t know about, which was DreamLink, of which I was a Co-Founder and the CEO. We were in the IT services business process outsourcing space. The company did become profitable, but we closed it out anyway. This was around the time that I effectively moved to Deloitte. One of my partners ended up moving to McKinsey at the same time. I was a little bit pissed off about that, that he got to go to McKinsey, and I only got to get into Deloitte. But basically, my life was going well. I didn’t have much time to enjoy the money I was making. I was making good money back then. I was very young, but I wasn’t enjoying it very much because I was working like hell. I feel at 25, that’s where I was at. Deloitte Consulting, working 90, 100 hours. I don’t think I had a girlfriend back then. Talk about personal maybe later. I was figuring out what I wanted to do next. This was the beginning of my realization that I needed to leave Portugal, that I was a bit too Germanic for Portugal, that an Anglo-Saxon environment, a place like London, would probably be more for me, and I did get that absolutely right. So this was the beginning of that part of the story, the beginning where I was getting just super frustrated with working. As I said, I learned everything I know about business or almost everything I knew about classic business and structuring at Deloitte Consulting, but at the same time, I was realizing it wasn’t for me. The environment of work in Portugal wasn’t for me. Bertrand Schmitt Interesting. Thanks for the sharing. I think we shared effectively a lot of things, very similar life experiences. Me, I’m French, obviously. My early life was in Paris. Been a fan of doing computer stuff. When I was a teenager, doing development on my own, publishing some early software, actually HP calculators, giving me an early love for mobile computing. I started my first company, my first business, Arkadia NetSystems, when I was around 21, 22, last year of engineering school in France. When I was 25 is actually when I closed my first business in 2001. That was one year after the crash of the dot-com, after the crash of the telco space. As a business, we lost suddenly a lot of customers or prospects. It happened very quickly in one or two quarters. It was pretty shocking to experience that early on after building a startup, to see your customers disappear, and not just any customers, but some big names in telco space suddenly closing down their mobile internet division, their web initiatives. I was at 25 just closing down the business, I don’t know, May, June 2001. Then September 11th happened. For me, I started to think about what’s next. Two things really came to my mind. One is I want to learn more about business, not just the technical side, but the business side, the marketing side. Two was I just cannot stay in France. I need to have a bigger international perspective from the get-go. Therefore, I started to prepare for MBA. Ultimately, in 2002, I was accepted at Wharton and started my MBA at Wharton in summer of 2002. So that’s where I was, having made the decision to have a bigger international perspective, US perspective. You have to know that in France, it’s very easy to get used to France. France is not that small, so you might wrongly assume that it’s big enough for a business when it’s not. I guess when you come from Israel, from Portugal, it might be easier to realize the world is bigger. But if you’re French, you think that France is big enough, which I think is a mistake made by a lot of French entrepreneurs. I made this decision to move to the US, do an MBA. It’s a pretty big decision around 25. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Yeah, and funnily enough, I actually did a Wharton executive program, not the MBA, around the same year, so maybe one year before you went into your MBA or something like that, which is interesting. Funnily enough, there’s a little bit of a commonality around Wharton, which we don’t normally talk about, Bertrand and I, but there was a little bit of that. Obviously, he did the real thing. I just did a 2-week executive program. He did the proper MBA. Bertrand Schmitt I did the expensive thing. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Anyway, there’s that in common as well. I don’t know if I told you this, Bertrand, but it’s one of the reasons why I got my job at GSM Association, that I moved to London, was because of Wharton, because the guy who was last minute told his assistant was the same person as the other officer that was supposed to re-interview me, the other officer didn’t show up. The guy who had become my mentor had the same assistant. His assistant was like, “Hey, can you take this call instead? Because the other guy is not around.” So he took it and he looked at the CV very quickly. He’s like, “Did you do an MBA at Wharton? Because I’m an MBA from Wharton.” I was like, “No, I did an executive program in M&A at Wharton.” That’s how the conversation started. That guy became my mentor for many years. Again, the Wharton connectivity. Wharton was definitely very important in my life. What conversation would we have with our 25-year-old self, Bertrand? Where would you start? Bertrand Schmitt Maybe we can start on the professional side. Maybe we can start with money, risk, capital, literacy, if you want. I think that on that side, I’m not sure I would change so much because at 25, I already had taken the risk to launch my own business, my own startup. Then I have taken the risk to change continent and to start a very expensive MBA. I certainly had, I don’t know if it’s an appetence for risk, but I felt that if there is enough value in the risk, it’s worth taking. I think I had that perspective early on. I think that if you don’t risk something, that also comes with its own risk in terms of your opportunities, your career, what you will end up doing and the like. Personally, I’m not sure I would change much in terms of risk, but in terms of capital literacy, understanding more how business work, I think doing an MBA, at least for me, at least at that time… I think we’ll talk more later about what changed in 2026. Because the environment has changed for a 25-year-old. But I think at that time, for me, it was very helpful. I think if you have an engineering background, I think if you are, on top of it, a student from a country like France with less strong culture about MBA, there is a lot of value to study abroad, do an MBA to learn more about business. I’m not sure there is the same value if you don’t have that part of the international experience you get with an MBA abroad. I don’t know if there is the same value if you have an undergrad in business already. It was pretty clear to me around me that people with business as undergrad were not getting as much from an MBA. They were getting the relationship, the networking. But you could see they knew a lot about what we were taught. As the engineer, the scientist like me definitely got some real value out of our MBA. In my own situation, that’s also how I met my wife. I will certainly not change anything about that. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Good to hear. I’m sure Andrea, if she’s listening to this, will appreciate that. My two cents on the capital piece and risk and money is I probably would tell my 25-year-old to actually pursue the start
“You’re too early for us”. “We have doubts on your market”. These are some of the things VCs say, but what do they really mean? If there was a VC-to-English Dictionary, what would it look like? In this episode of Tech Deciphered, we will offer you explanations on some of the most used expressions VCs use, but we will also go further and discuss their actions. What are the meanings behind them? Are these all machiavellian or could there be valid reasons for these? Navigation: Intro The Dictionary The Machinery Interlude – “Things Founders Say” The Courtship When Translation Fails: The War Stories The Decoder Ring + Confession Booth Conclusion Our co-hosts: Bertrand Schmitt, Entrepreneur in Residence at Red River West, co-founder of App Annie / Data.ai, business angel, advisor to startups and VC funds, @bschmitt Nuno Goncalves Pedro, Investor, Managing Partner, Founder at Chamaeleon, @ngpedro Our show: Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news Subscribe To Our Podcast Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Introduction Welcome to episode 81 of Tech DECIPHERED. In this episode, we’re going to provide you with the VC to English Dictionary, the things that VCs do and say, and what they actually mean to you if you’re a founder when you’re talking to these different venture capitalists. You may hear, “You’re too early for us.” “We have doubts on your market.” What does that actually mean? What is real, what is bullshit, and everything in between. Today, we’ll go through not only the dictionary, but also the machinery of how VCs process these deals. We will take a little bit of a stab on what actual founders say as well, because it’s good to be equitable in this sense. Then we’ll talk about the courtship. We’ll talk about war stories when actual translation fails miserably post-investment, the narrative economy. Finally, we’ll provide you with a little bit of a decoder ring or a confession booth, so to speak, that we can actually share, myself and Bertrand, on what we see in the market or things that we’ve done, things that we’ve seen being done, and all of the above. Bertrand, oh my God. If you got $5 for every pass you ever got, you’d be rich. Actually, you maybe not because you didn’t probably have as many passes as most entrepreneurs in general. Bertrand Schmitt I will argue on top of it, it’s not just that it’s always difficult to understand how VCs speak and to translate that into normal English. But on top of it, if you are a European or Asian entrepreneur, it may be even more difficult because you have truly a language barrier. On top of it, you will have to get a sense from euphemisms used in the US. As you said, definitely a lot of rejections. It happens to all of us. I think personally, I don’t mind the rejections. What I probably like less is when you get ghosted. As an entrepreneur, you have no news. Some have the belief maybe that it’s better to ghost us than to reject. I would probably say I don’t think so as an entrepreneur. I prefer a rejection, even if it feels a bit bullshit. I prefer clearly a why. One thing I’ve learned is that actually sometimes it can be real in the sense that if you correct, if you come back at a later stage, some investors are actually changing their mind. As they say they might do. I’m coming from a relatively positive perspective on some of this. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro The Dictionary Maybe this is a good time to start the dictionary section and start with ghosting. Ghosting is probably the most used non-word in venture capital, which is VCs stop answering your emails. You thought you were talking to them. You’ve gone maybe even to a partner meeting at some point, and they don’t say anything back. We don’t do that. If we do, you guys should call us out, whoever ghosts Chamaeleon, and then you don’t actually get an answer, be it to pass or something else. That’s one of the things we’re proud of trying to sustain over time, and we process a lot of deals, so it has a bit of a cost for us. But the way to understand a ghosting piece is basically saying, “Hey, we’re not really sure,” or, “We’re actually sure we don’t want to invest, but we don’t want to create a bad relationship with you.” Normally, it falls into one of those two sides. It’s either, “We’re not sure right now, we want to wait and see how your round goes, and maybe we’re not a lead investor, so we don’t want to necessarily build high conviction until we see other players coming on board,” or, “We are negative about it, and we just don’t want to tell you because we want to make friends.” This is one thing that we will get through the entire episode is this notion that VCs are in a sales business as well. Obviously, definitely in a sales business with their investors, with their limited partners that give them capital to manage funds on their behalf. But more importantly, they’re also a little bit in the sales business with entrepreneurs, in the sense that it’s a repeat business. An entrepreneur might do a stupid company today, but might be doing a great company tomorrow. I don’t want to have pissed off that entrepreneur that did the stupid company in the past. I want to actually invest in this great company today. There’s a little bit of this notion of optional value that will go throughout this whole episode. That’s, I think, what leads to this language that creates this necessity for translation, which is almost like a sales process in general. It’s like the entrepreneur trying to sell the VC on something, and then the VC at some point may be trying to sell the entrepreneur on something. Bertrand Schmitt I would say it’s not just repeat entrepreneurs. What I’ve seen also in the past, and I guess what many VCs have seen, is that once in a while, they make a pretty grave mistake on the business, on their evaluation, and suddenly something they could have said no becomes a rocket ship, and you would look like an idiot. The rocket ship might be simply because the business was much stronger than they thought, because there is a change in the market environment. Let’s not forget COVID or the rise of AI. Then suddenly you’re in that situation where you give some strong deep explanation about why, and everything falls flat on its face, and the business is suddenly a rocket. I guess you also want to be careful in that situation as an investor, not to have been too strong in your opinion. I guess this is also a situation where the entrepreneur is really strong. Nuno Gonçalves Pedro We’ll talk in the second section about the machinery of venture capital, the funnel management of venture capital, and we’ll talk a little bit more about false positives, false negatives. The industry, that’s the key thing that the industry lives on, false positives and false negatives. We’ll go into a little bit more detail. Maybe going into the next category. Ghosting is one. The second category is more around what people would consider stage or price passing, which is to say the classic ones are, “You’re too early for us,” or, “You’re too late for us.” I think the too early for us is generally one, for example, a lot of people come to us, we’re a Series Seed, Series A investor, and they come to us when they have an idea, and they’re starting to develop some stuff, but they have nothing. We’re not a pre-seed investor, so too early for us actually is something we use quite a bit, which is warranted. Stage mandates are real. Our focus showing that we don’t have style drift as an investor, that we are really always investing in seed and A is meaningful to us. We can’t just say, “Hey, we’re just going to write pre-seed checks left and right.” We can write pre-seed checks, but it’s the exception, not the rule. When we say it’s too early for us, it’s normally too early for us. It might be too early for us for that opportunity, for that market, for that kind of team. It might be BS. It might be basically the VC firm saying, “Hey, we’re not convinced, but we’d like the free option to see how you progress on your fundraising, or how you progress as a company. Come and talk to us later.” If you fail miserably, and you don’t do very well, great. We were right. This would have been a false positive for you, if you decided to invest. Otherwise, if you become a rocket ship, we’d still have the right to talk to you because we haven’t really aggressively passed. These stage passes, that too early or too late, are never super aggressive. They’re never perceived very personally by the founders. It’s never about their baby or themselves. It’s more about the stage and the thesis of the VC firm. It’s a little bit of a cop-out for certain VCs on saying, “Hey, we’re just not stage aligned with this.” “Too late,” it’s a little bit like, or, “Your price is too high.” “It’s too late for us,” meaning you’re raising too much capital, therefore your valuation is too high. Again, it could be very true. It could be that, again, from a stage perspective, if you’re a Series Seed, Series A-focused VC, which the classic VCs are in many cases focused on seed and A, and this looks a bit like a Series B or a Series C, you’re raising 50 million or something like that at 250, 300 million valuation. It just doesn’t make sense. Again, the cop-out, the translation element of this when it’s a bit of BS is, “At this price, you would have needed to attain more product-market fit,” is the other way to translate. “It’s too late for us,” if you are meeting a firm that you think could actually invest at that valuation. They’re probably telling you, “We don’t think you’ve achieved enough to justify your valuation at this moment in time.” Bertrand Schmitt I would say as an entrepreneur, something I’ve been always careful reaching out to investors is making sure these investors are doing the
In June, the most capable American AI models stopped shipping as public launches and started shipping through a government gate. Six weeks later the gate is open again — and the real fight has moved to the layer no gate can touch. A Chinese open-weight model rattled trillions out of chip stocks, Washington pivoted from gating American closed models to threatening bans on Chinese open ones, the industry mounted its largest-ever policy counter-mobilization, and an American frontier model literally broke out of its lab and hacked another company. Knee-jerk reactions, or the beginning of real AI governance? Navigation: Intro The Gate Opens The Kimi Shock The Escape The Counterstrike and the Petition Interlude — The Low-Background Books The Investor Reckoning Conclusion Our co-hosts: Bertrand Schmitt, Entrepreneur in Residence at Red River West, co-founder of App Annie / Data.ai, business angel, advisor to startups and VC funds, @bschmitt Nuno Goncalves Pedro, Investor, Managing Partner, Founder at Chamaeleon, @ngpedro Our show: Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news Subscribe To Our Podcast Bertrand Introduction Welcome to Tech Deciphered Episode 80. This one, once again, will be all about AI, government, frontier models, and open weight counterstrike. A lot has been happening in the regulation space, in cybersecurity, in the launch of new models in the past, maybe just 6–8 weeks. It’s actually pretty insane how much happened. We believe it was time to do an episode to talk about where we are and maybe where all of this is going. Maybe let’s start with a summary of where we stand, all that June and July saga, so you, our listeners, can get up to speed if you are not already there. You want to start with some points? Nuno The Gate Opens Yeah. Again, to your point, the gate swings. The gate had closed. We had to prepare an episode for the gate closing, and then the gate reopened. Now we have a different episode. This will probably change again as we’re seeing there’s news every day. Let’s start maybe with the first 19 days of the gate closing. There was an executive order on June 2nd from President Trump that asked frontier labs to share models with the government, 30 days pre-release. It inferred the protected frontier model designation into that. Basically, it was effectively a de facto licensing agreement defined by an executive order of the President as of June 2nd. On June 9th, Anthropic launched Fable 5 and the famous Mythos 5 or Mythos. I’m not sure how you actually say it in English. Then on June 12th, there was an export control directive banning access by any foreign national. Since there’s no way to verify nationality in real-time, Anthropic had to switch the models off for everyone worldwide. Bertrand On this point, you could argue that there are possibilities to check IDs. Many services let you check IDs online. You can pre-check a flight by showing your ID. There are ways, it’s just that if you don’t want to follow what’s already available, because guess what? Maybe it slowed down your revenue growth, maybe it looks bad on you or whatever. My point is that there was actually an option. I think it’s already a decision from Anthropic to say it’s either on or off, but nothing in between. Nuno I think the point is they had no way implemented of doing it. If they implemented it, to your point, it would have hampered use in general. A lot of people wouldn’t have gone through that trouble of doing it. Anyway, long story short, in June 26th, the White House apparently asked OpenAI to limit GPT-5.6, so Sol, Terra, Luna, to only 20 vetted partners. Now, apparently, the trigger for a lot of these things that have been going on was that there was a jailbreak that was found by Amazon researchers. All of that led to this jumping around of, let’s close the gates. You have foreign nationals, and therefore, Anthropic got it out and said, “Hey, then we’re going to switch the models off until we can sort this out.” OpenAI was asked also to only allow it for certain vetted partners, et cetera. The government came in, closed the gates effectively, and said, “From now on, we need to be involved in this thing.” De facto regulation, there’s no doubt that this has imposed de facto regulation, certainly on the top players in the market. But then came the reversal. Bertrand, do you want to talk about the reversal, the gate swinging the other side? Bertrand Maybe I just wanted to say that as a user of Anthropic products, ChatGPT products, for the brief moments, a few days where Fable 5 was made available to the public before it was closed the first time, I immediately started using it. I must say it was a real issue to use it because the guardrails were pretty crazy. It would keep saying that my code was not okay, there was cybersecurity risk and stuff when I was doing absolutely reasonable development with absolutely no connection whatsoever to any cybersecurity risk, attack, detection, anything. Still, it would keep blocking me, degrading me to Opus 4.8 at the time. I just want to say this was already very hardcore what they were implementing, and not just hardcore, but in some ways, plain stupid for something that’s supposed to be super smart. It was totally unable to classify properly some of my work. I must say I was already disappointed. On top of it, the costs were insane. Half a day, I would reach my limits when I had the best plan you can get from Anthropic. My point is that there were some real serious issues when they launched Fable 5, even at that point. Nuno I had a similar issue. I used Fable 5 as well before they had to take it offline or take it off. I think the issue was really not that the guardrails failed. As you said, maybe the guardrails were actually too aggressive, but it was this jailbreak that caused the recall, apparently caused this knee-jerk reaction. Bertrand But my point is that it seems that it was not working either way. It would either overclassify something that’s absolutely not doing anything wrong, and it might fail to classify something that is actively trying to do some cybersecurity work. It’s a real issue of quality for a company that’s supposed to be at the forefront of quality of AI and everything. I think for me, there are already signs that something is deeply wrong. Nuno Then it’s reversed, right? We went the other way around. The government came out on June 26th and approved redeploying Mythos 5 to US organizations defending critical infrastructure, and then the export controls were effectively lifted on June 30th. July 1st, Fable 5 came back online for all of us to use. Shocking enough, with strings attached, that were different. They had some time to revise their commercial deployment of it along the way because it came back with some, “Now you have usage credits, but you have some limits on plan use, et cetera.” I’m like, “You guys, this was blocked. But meanwhile, you did have some time to do some commercial stuff around it.” Bertrand It was crazy. I’ve never witnessed any such crappy launch of any service whatsoever in 30 years in tech, it was so bad. Every day, they would change the terms of service. They would tell you it’s part of the plan. It’s not part of the plan. It’s part of the plan for three more days, and then it’s excluded. You have a special discount now, but then it goes back to full price. It was a total nightmare. I’ve never felt myself being so much mistreated by a company. I guess you saw the same, but when I started using the newest version of Fable 5, it was even worse, actually, I think. I couldn’t do any work with this crap. I let it go and work on the work I wanted it to do. It was simply not working. On top of it, you never know how long you are supposed to lose your credit, how fast. It was burning credit like crazy. Me, personally, I can say, very quickly, I actually stopped using it. I was like, “No, I cannot deal with this shit. My main model is back to Opus 4.8. I’m going to use Fable 5 for code review, but not anymore to control anything because I cannot trust it would do the job without stopping or changing models and stuff. I just cannot trust it.” Back to Opus 4.8 as my main model, I can say that my life was much easier. I use Fable 5 as a review mechanism, as a support mechanism, but not as the main mechanism. Suddenly, the guardrails were not so horrible anymore because it was used in a much lighter way, I guess. As a pain as a user, I think it was really bad. I don’t know your experience, but me, for me, it was unacceptable. Nuno I wouldn’t say it was as bad as yours in terms of just end-user experience. I think the terms of service switching back and forth, which went one further step, because then when they then launched Opus 5, they started making comparisons between Opus 5 and Fable so that people would migrate more and more to Opus 5 themselves, which is interesting. It’s like they’re saying “This is much cheaper. This is whatever. You’re not going to run of credits. You should use Opus 5,” kind of thing effectively. To your point, I don’t think they managed well the launch. They didn’t really manage it well. We’re moving people around. A lot of people are using this for stuff that’s like daily tasks, hourly tasks, anything that relates to code and co-work. It’s like, we need to have visibility on what your terms of service are going to be. Should I be using this new model or not? What’s happening to the other model? I don’t see it as negatively as you, Bertrand, but I see your point. It was clearly mishandled in terms of how they deployed it, how they were redesigning effectively their pricing scheme and their terms of service almost on a daily basis, at a certain point in time. We’re like, “Dude, there’s mi
79 – The Cognitive Age

79 – The Cognitive Age

2026-07-3101:12:49

Competing in a Future World of Infinite Intelligence Navigation: Intro From Knowledge Workers to Judgment Workers The AI-Native Company: Org, Hiring, Culture The Human Element: Are We Underestimating It? Scenarios Our Take Conclusion Our co-hosts: Bertrand Schmitt, Entrepreneur in Residence at Red River West, co-founder of App Annie / Data.ai, business angel, advisor to startups and VC funds, @bschmitt Nuno Goncalves Pedro, Investor, Managing Partner, Founder at Chamaeleon, @ngpedro Our show:   Tech DECIPHERED brings you the Entrepreneur and Investor views on Big Tech, VC and Start-up news, opinion pieces and research. We decipher their meaning, and add inside knowledge and context. Being nerds, we also discuss the latest gadgets and pop culture news Subscribe To Our Podcast Nuno Gonçalves Pedro Introduction Welcome to episode 79 of Tech DECIPHERED. Today, we take a leap into the big unknown. This is a thesis episode, not your classic analysis, in-depth sharing episode. The big idea for this episode is that we may be approaching the cognitive age, and how would one, or how would a company compete in a world of infinite intelligence? The big idea, again, is that intelligence, which has been mostly scarce and expensive for all of human history, might become abundant and cheap. If that happens, what happens to work, what happens to companies, what happens to society? This episode will be really framing a lot of these discussions. From knowledge workers to judgment workers, addressing the AI native company and how does that change, going into the human element and whether or not we’re underestimating it, and finally, ending up going into scenarios, feasible scenarios of a future where, well, intelligence is abundant. Intelligence is quasi-infinite or infinite itself.Bertrand Schmitt Yes. Big questions for this episode 79. From Knowledge Workers to Judgment Workers We can start with from knowledge workers to judgment workers. Let’s go back first to how came the knowledge worker. It’s a 20th-century invention from Peter Drucker in 1959. The idea here is that that category might be splitting. The production of knowledge itself is on its way to being commoditized by AI. However, our perspective is that judgment around production of knowledge is not disappearing and is staying for a bit control managed by humans. What’s your take on this, Nuno? Do you agree with this split?Nuno Gonçalves Pedro I think it’s a little bit more profound than that. It’s not just judgment. Definitely, human judgment will be needed. We’ve seen agents perform all sorts of funny things in the wrong way when left alone to their own devices. Even some very well-known AI researchers coming forward and saying, “Hey, I tried to use this myself, and actually I messed up some of my systems,” or “I messed some of my code. I messed up some of my flows for a period of time.” I think just having human-in-the-loop from a judgment standpoint will be needed for a significant amount of time. That is something you can’t just delegate into machines, into algorithms, et cetera. The second part is, ultimately, there needs to be contextualization, and that contextualization, I think, comes from two forms. One from actual data, where the machine, I think, at some point will catch up, or the machines will catch up. The algorithms, at some point, on the data analysis will get better and better and have probably the closest to the truth that you can get, minus all the biases that are in the data, just to be clear, because data has a ton of biases. We’ve looked at this in the past and discussed it at prior episodes. But maybe on that, I think the machine has a chance to catch up, or the machines have a chance to catch up, so there’s less of distinctiveness from the human standpoint. But then, on just the attributes, the ability when you’re judging some situation, you’re in the middle of the situation. You’re judging the person and how it’s acting, in some ways, a lot of the things that end up happening, end up happening because there’s human interaction. There’s someone on the other side. I see how they’re delivering the message, how they’re implicating. We’ll talk about it later in the context of the organization and what changes in companies. I don’t think it’s just judgment. I think there’s a little bit more than that. One of the reasons I went to the dark side of management early on in my career from being an engineer was Peter Drucker and this notion of the knowledge worker, which he later on reemphasized with the publishing of his book, which for me was seminal and defined a lot of my career in life, the post-capitalist society, which is this notion that information rich and information poor is going to be the key distinctiveness that will happen in the world. The two big camps, information rich, information poor, which links back to this invention of the term knowledge worker, that knowledge is going to be key in some ways. I think that’s what we’ve seen for the last decades. Again, I think judgment is not going anywhere, but I think it’s beyond judgment. There’s elements of humanity and involvement that won’t go away anytime soon, where human-in-the-loop are particularly critical. We’ll discuss later some scenarios, but for me, that’s my stick in the ground. I think human-in-the-loop is going to be critical for many decades to come.Bertrand Schmitt While we are talking about all of this, and we share some possible scenarios, there is always that question. This is moving so fast right now. If you think about AI 10 years ago, AI 5 years ago, AI with the launch of ChatGPT 3, and then AI the past 2 years, now we have agents that are running at scale. Things are moving very fast. I can tell you, me in 6 months, the change has been pretty dramatic in terms of what I can use AI for. There is always that question that whatever we are thinking about cannot just be connected to what we were able to do 6 months ago or even today, we have to think and project ourselves at least in the next 6–12 months. Of course, we can go beyond that, and we will do that with some future scenarios, but it’s a very fast-moving, and it’s not clear yet where are the limits.Nuno Gonçalves Pedro I think that’s a very fair point. Let me try to analyze things that I don’t think will change anytime soon for the next few years. Agreed with you that many things will change, and we’ll have a lot better tools, platforms out there. That will be difficult to predict what exactly won’t change. I think there’s elements of humanity, and some of them do relate to judgment, like having good or bad taste, having a view on it, on whether something looks good or bad. Obviously, all of this sometimes is subjective, but some of it may not be as subjective as people think it is. The elements of contextualization. I think a little bit going back to what we did at Chamaeleon ourselves, where we built this platform, Mantis, and the objective of building Mantis was not really to replace us, was that it was a core augmentation layer in some ways that we would use investment or investor judgment as humans in the loop to systematize pattern recognition and a variety of other things, but that Mantis would really elevate all that judgment, not just in terms of timing, us being more productive, but also in terms of the quality of the decisions we’re making. Think of it as a little bit like having our human judgment in the context of operating Chamaeleon at a higher altitude, where we are more aware of the things that are happening and how they actually happen. The ability to really get to the data pieces and then make decisions on top of that that generate the needed alpha in our case for investors. What I mean by this is I think there’s always going to be core elements of humanity that I do think are going to be difficult for the machines to replace. For example, the taste piece people are like, “I can figure out what’s the taste in the market.” Yeah, but that’s mainstream. That doesn’t identify what’s the next big thing, which normally doesn’t start from mainstream. It starts from something else. It could start from opinion leaders and influencers. It could start by someone having a different way of addressing a problem and having a solution that hasn’t been thought through. For example, elements of creativity, I think, in human judgment and in human operations is something that I feel the machine will still have difficulty to replace.Bertrand Schmitt Let’s not forget how today current algorithms are working by feeding them enormous quantity of data, actually as much data as we can find. Finding more data is becoming a limitation these days. What it means is that it’s very hard for AI to think beyond its training data. There is some level of logic that’s being added, but at the same time, take the launch of the iPhone. What was the opinion before launch? Is that no, it doesn’t make sense. Not enough battery life, no keyboard, no this, no that. If you just base your analysis on what’s written out there, what’s being sold out there, you would just say, “It’s going to fail.” AI might really follow that more generic advice and perspective because that’s what in the training data and that’s what they’re in volume. It’s, of course, raising a lot of questions of, how do you improve the quality of the training data? How do you separate the weed from the chaff? There are a lot of questions there, and obviously, it will get better over time. But it’s still a critical part of how it’s working today. It won’t be that easy to change. I really like your point regarding Mantis, and I will say in general, platforms that you build with AI or leveraging AI capacity. Because when we say knowledge production is going to disappear, but we’ll keep judgment, it will be a different type of judgment because the quantity and quality of knowledge we will have in front of us to build our judgment will be very different. If suddenly we hav
loading
Comments