DiscoverSoundproof Your Studio
Soundproof Your Studio
Claim Ownership

Soundproof Your Studio

Author: Wilson Harwood

Subscribed: 2Played: 21
Share

Description


I teach you how to build a soundproof studio. Even if you know nothing about soundproofing or construction I go in depth to turn you from a total beginner into a soundproofing master.
246 Episodes
Reverse
SOUND ISOLATION DESIGN · SPYS DESIGNS The Client Should Not Be the Go-Between: Lessons From a Drum Room Built Without Plans Jeremy is a composer, producer, and drummer in Washington state. Last year he built a single room for mixing, tracking live drums, and rehearsing with his band as part of a new custom home. He was a consulting client of mine from the period when I offered consulting without plan sets, which means he built this room without one. He was generous enough to sit down and walk me through everything on camera, including what went wrong. This article pulls out what I think matters most for anyone planning a high-performance room. Why he needed the room in the first place Before this room, Jeremy lived in a townhouse with thin walls. He worked in headphones because he could not be loud, he could hear his neighbors, and his acoustic drums sat in storage for four years. When he and his wife built a new home, the studio was a priority from the start. What he wanted is what most of my clients want. He wanted the freedom to turn up when the work calls for it and to stop thinking about who might be listening. What we built, and what it actually delivers The room sits on the slab, with a living room directly above it. The walls are a double wall construction with an air gap between two independent leaves. The ceiling is hung on resilient clips with hat channel and heavy layers of drywall. The entry is a pair of doors, one high-performance isolation door and one budget door with glass, which gives a few extra decibels of reduction for a small amount of money. Fresh air comes through baffle boxes connected to an energy recovery ventilator in an adjacent utility room. Here is how he describes the result. With the kit at full volume, it sounds like a miniature drum kit being played somewhere in the house, and his wife can watch television while it happens. When he mixes loud or plays a guitar amp, you basically cannot hear it outside the door. At the property line he says you would have to stand a foot or two from the siding to hear anything. What we do on most residential builds is turn the volume knob down. That is a real result, and it is hard to achieve. I want to be honest about that framing, because it is the most important expectation to set. Sound isolation on a project like this is not silence. Drums are the loudest thing in most homes, and the wall without a door was never going to be quieter than the wall with one at the same level of treatment. Jeremy said it was louder on the drum side, and that is physics. What he got is a room where the volume comes down enough that the people in his house and his neighbors are not bothered, and that is the outcome we designed for. The floor question One detail worth pausing on. Jeremy did not float his concrete slab, and the room performs very well. I know that surprises people, and AI tools in particular love to insist a studio floor must be floated. In his case the room sits on a slab on grade and the real work was done by the isolation of the walls and ceiling. That does not mean a floating floor is never needed. A room over a framed floor, or a project with heavy low frequency content next to living space, is a different problem. Every project has to be evaluated on its own conditions, which is the whole point of design. Where it got hard: the client became the translator The build was not the hard part. The hard part was communication. Jeremy's builder was excellent, but he had never built a room like this, and he came in with good intentions and a few assumptions picked up online. Jeremy was caught in the middle. He was learning from me, then going to the builder, and trying to carry the language of two different worlds back and forth without being fluent in either. I'm the go between. Over a build that ran about fourteen months, the budget grew, as it does. Lumber and material prices moved, and the studio had no contingency the way the house did, because nobody could say in advance what a specialty room like his would cost. Jeremy ended up doing much of the finishing himself, including tile and electrical trim, because the money was gone and the room was his workspace. He told me he has never learned so much in a year, and I believe him. But no client should have to learn a trade to get the room they hired a designer for. Two moments show why this matters. The electricians connected the studio circuit back into the rest of the house even though the plan called for it to be separate, so Jeremy rewired part of it after the fact. And the first layout had the plumbing stack for the house running through a studio wall. Both are the kind of conflict that a coordinated set of drawings catches before anyone picks up a tool.   The one thing he would change When I asked what he would redo, Jeremy did not name the budget or the builder. He said he would move the door about eight inches. Because of where his desk sits, the door location left him without an absorption panel at one of his first reflection points, and he notices it every day. It is a small issue in a good room. It is also a clean example of why we work out reflection points, door swings, and ceiling cloud locations on paper before anything is framed. When he moved the door late in the process, the acoustic layout did not move with it. What this means for your project Jeremy's room works, and he is very happy with it. The lesson I take from his build is about process more than product. The wall and ceiling details were sound. What cost him time, money, and sleep was the gap between the designer and the people holding the tools. That is the reason we moved from consulting only to full construction plan sets with a checklist that a site manager can verify and photograph for us. The plans carry the language so the client does not have to. The biggest lesson: the homeowner shouldn't have to be the communication system holding a specialized construction project together. Learn more about Jeremy:https://jeremykdavid.com Listen to Summer Eyes:https://summereyesband.com Planning a sound-isolated room? If you are planning a room that has to perform at this level, the details are not optional considerations. They are the difference between a room that works and one that does not. That is the standard we hold at SPYS Designs. NEXT STEP: Start with a Sound Isolation Site Assessment. Tell us about your room, your structure, and your goals so we can tell you what it will take to reach them.   
SOUND ISOLATION DESIGN · SPYS DESIGNS Depth Follows Fascination: Why Sound Isolation Is Rarely a Specialist's Specialty If you are building a home theater, a listening room, or a recording space, you will almost certainly end up with more than one expert on your project. An architect. An acoustic designer. An AV integrator. Structural and mechanical engineers when the building calls for them. And, if the room has to keep sound in or keep it out, a sound isolation designer. It is natural to wonder who should lead, and whether one person could cover all of it. After years of working alongside these specialists, my honest answer is a kind one. The strongest teams I see are made of people who each do less. Several experts, all starting at once One thing that surprises homeowners is that these specialists do not work in a neat line. The architect is drawing, the acoustic designer is thinking about how the room will sound, the integrator is planning cable paths, and the engineers are checking loads and ventilation, all in the same few weeks. That overlap is normal. It is also the reason no single person can be excellent at every part of it. That is not a flaw in anyone. It is simply how expertise works. My goal here is to make the hiring conversation feel lighter. Who does what Architect: layout, structure, ceiling heights, code, and the space the mechanical systems need. Acoustic designer: how the room sounds inside, including reflections, absorption, diffusion, and bass behavior. AV integrator: equipment selection, cabling, wiring sequences, and control, across hi-fi, theater, and studio rooms. Structural and mechanical engineers: the loads the building carries and the ventilation and air systems the room needs. Sound isolation designer: keeping sound from leaving or entering the room, through walls, ceilings, doors, and every penetration. Ensuring the mechanical/HVAC design is quiet. Depth follows fascination Here is the idea I keep coming back to. People go deep on what fascinates them, and nobody has unlimited hours. Sound isolation is not a topic most people find exciting. I say that with love, because I find it endlessly interesting. But if you are building a business around room acoustics, your evenings go to room acoustics. If your passion is AV, you spend your spare time on AV. So most specialists learn sound isolation well enough to do their own job well, and then put their remaining attention where their curiosity lives. That is a sensible use of a limited life. People go deep on what fascinates them, and nobody has unlimited hours. I should be clear that this is an observation, not a rule. It is the pattern I have noticed, and there are always exceptions. It also explains something about the best firms. As a design firm gets better, its experts tend to do less and less. They know they can only reach a very high level by focusing on one thing, maybe two, and certainly not five to ten. It runs in both directions I am the same way. I know enough about room acoustics to know when to bring in a specialist, and not enough to do that person's job at their level. The same is true for AV. My focus is sound isolation, and that is where my hours and my curiosity go. It is the reason I coordinate with the specialists on your team instead of trying to become them. A ceiling as one small example Here is a small, general example of how focus shows up in practice. Imagine someone wants to hang acoustic treatment from a ceiling. That treatment has weight, it needs hanger locations, and it often needs backing built into the framing. The isolation design needs to know all of that early, because it shapes how the ceiling is framed. A specialist whose attention is on how the room sounds will not always think about ceiling framing, because it is not where their attention lives. Nobody did anything wrong. The information simply has to travel between specialists, and everyone is working at the same time, so the answer is early conversation more than any perfect order of operations.   When the gap matters, and when it does not For many rooms, a generalist's working knowledge of sound isolation is plenty. The gap shows up when the stakes are high: a drum room, a theater beside a bedroom, a recording space with close neighbors, or a hi-fi room where silence is part of the performance. If your room has to perform at that level, it is worth bringing in someone who has gone deep, and bringing them in early. What we do At SPYS Designs we design sound isolation, and nothing else. We coordinate with the specialists you already have, and when a project needs a structural or mechanical engineer, we help you find one. That focus is the whole point. Planning a room that has to perform at this level? Start with a Sound Isolation Site Assessment. It is the clearest first step for a theater, listening room, or recording space. soundproofyourstudio.com/plan Wilson Harwood Sound Isolation Designer and Principal, SPYS Designs  
SOUND ISOLATION DESIGN · SPYS DESIGNS The Lab Rating Is a Ceiling, and Four Details Decide Whether You Reach It Every sound isolated wall starts with a number. Somewhere, an assembly was built in a lab, measured, and given a rating, and that rating is real. It is also the best that assembly will ever do. The wall that gets built on your property, with several trades working around it, does not get lab conditions. It gets whatever its details allow. In the video behind this article, I walk through four details from one of our projects, drawn in Revit and followed through with a gated inspection checklist. This is one of our anonymous projects, so the drawings appear without any identifying information. The wall is the example here, but the same logic applies to ceilings, floors, and every penetration in the room. What the Lab Number Actually Tells You A lab rating describes an assembly that was built perfectly, with nothing connecting it to the structure around it and no air paths through it. That is useful, because it tells you what the design is capable of. It does not tell you what a crew will build. A single rigid connection across a decoupled assembly, or one unsealed path for air, can pull the result far below the tested number, and nobody will see it once the drywall is up. That is why we treat the rating as a ceiling, not a promise. Reaching it is a job of details, and details only work when they are drawn, explained to the builder, and checked before they are covered. Detail One: A Quarter Inch at the Ductwork A sound isolated room still needs fresh air, so ducts have to pass through the isolated ceiling. On this project, four ducts carry the ventilation and dehumidifier air through the assembly (we call these ducts chimneys), and each one is framed independently from the ceiling it passes through. The drawing leaves a quarter inch between the chimney and the ceiling drywall, filled with backer rod and acoustical sealant. That quarter inch is the whole point. If the chimney touches the ceiling drywall, the decoupled ceiling is connected to the rest of the building and the isolation is gone. The chimneys are built from 3/4 inch plywood and 5/8 inch drywall and sealed airtight on the inside. In most builds the ducts are simply left open to the building, which is where breakout noise gets into the cavities and lowers the rating of the ceiling or wall around it. Here the duct is enclosed and sealed, so that noise has nowhere to go.   Detail Two: Where One Wall Meets Another Most walls get built the same way. A second wall runs into the first, the two are tied together for strength, and the drywall goes on afterward. The drywall that breaks at the intersection is the mass layer, and a break in the mass layer weakens the wall at exactly the point where it meets another. We draw it differently. The partition wall stays separate from the isolation wall, with a gap between the framing so no stud ties the two together, and the two layers of drywall on the isolation wall run continuous past the intersection. The mass layer never stops, so the wall keeps the performance it was designed for.     Detail Three: Where the Wall Meets the Ceiling The ceiling on this project is independently framed with I-joists, separate from the roof above. Where it meets the isolation wall, the drawing leaves a quarter inch perimeter gap, filled with backer rod and acoustical sealant, so the ceiling drywall is never fastened to the wall framing. The drywall wraps around instead of tying in. The wall still has to stay upright, so the top of it is held by sway bracing, a clip called GenieClip LB. It is the only intended connection between the isolation wall and the structure beside it, and anything else that touches across that gap is a bridge. It is also visible only before insulation goes in, which is why it gets its own priority checkpoint.   Detail Four: The Roof Eave The eave is a place where an air barrier is easy to lose. Here the wall sheathing meets the roof sheathing, and the joint is taped and sealed with the weather resistive barrier, which gives the assembly mass and an air barrier at the same time. The attic floor is two layers of 23/32 inch OSB with its perimeter sealed with acoustical sealant, and closed cell spray foam goes at the roof deck. This is not a common detail, and it has to be designed carefully, so it was run past an engineer before it reached the builder. The sheet is covered in callouts for a reason. Each one tells the builder what goes where and what has to be sealed, because once the assembly is built, the chance to fix it is gone.   The lab rating is a ceiling. The details decide whether you ever reach it. Why Acoustical Sealant Shows Up Everywhere Look at the four drawings and you will see the same callout again and again: seal with acoustical sealant. The gaps are left on purpose, backer rod goes in first, and sealant goes over it.  Fireblocks are another example where details matter. Code requires them, and the design has to accommodate them, but a fireblock that is fastened, foamed, or caulked rigidly between two assemblies turns two independent walls into one. The fireblock is a fire barrier, not a tie. We specify approved acoustical sealants at these joints, never standard latex caulk or spray foam. Design It, Draw It, Inspect It A correct drawing and a buildable drawing are two different things, and neither protects a wall by itself. We design it, we show it on paper, and then we follow through with an inspection checklist. On this project the checklist has five gates. Work stops at each one until we have reviewed and approved the listed items, and the inspections happen by live video, with the contractor capturing the photos and video we ask for. Gate one comes after framing and before any insulation. That is where we verify the chimney clearance, the gap at the partition walls, the independent ceiling, and the sway bracing. Gate three comes after drywall and before taping, and that is where the sealant and perimeter gaps are checked on video, because everything verified at that gate becomes permanent. Why This Creates Coordination Problems None of these details live in a single trade. The framer builds the walls and ceiling, the insulator covers the clips, the drywall crew hangs the layers that make the mass, the HVAC contractor runs the ducts, and the electrician cuts the penetrations. A detail that is obvious to us can be invisible to a trade that has never built a decoupled assembly. The checklist resolves those conflicts before anything is covered. It also forces open questions into the open. On this project, the rooms next to the studio still needed an HVAC decision, and the checklist requires that decision in writing while the walls are open, because every duct and wire for those rooms has to be located before it can cross the isolated envelope. If you are planning a room that has to perform at this level, the details we covered today are not optional considerations. They are the difference between a room that works and one that does not. That is the standard we hold at SPYS Designs. READY TO PLAN A ROOM THAT PERFORMS? Start with a Sound Isolation Site Assessment, and we will look at what your project actually needs before you build anything. soundproofyourstudio.com/plan  
SOUND ISOLATION DESIGN · SPYS DESIGNS Two Rooms, Same Size, Very Different Price Tags Almost every conversation about the cost of a sound isolated room starts with the same question: how much per square foot? It is a reasonable place to start, and it is also the reason so many early budgets miss. Square footage tells you how much room you are building. It does not tell you how hard that room has to work, where it lives, or how much of the building has to change to support it. In the video behind this article, I ran three rooms through our budget calculator, one at a time, so you can see exactly which choices move the number and which ones barely do. You can follow along with your own room at soundproofyourstudio.com/calculator. What the Calculator Actually Uses The calculator is built around the two inputs that matter most at the budgeting stage: how big the room is, and whether it sits inside an existing building or stands on its own outside. Those two answers get you a realistic range quickly, which is what you need before you hire anyone or draw anything. It is a budgeting tool, not a design. It cannot see your joists, your mechanical system, or your neighbors. What it can do is keep you from planning around a number that was never real. Room One: A Small Vocal or Podcast Room Inside the House A small room inside an existing building is the simplest case. The structure, the roof, and the utilities already exist, so the budget goes into the room itself. That makes it the cleanest baseline. Enter the dimensions, read the total, and then change one input at a time to see what moves it.   Room Two: A Drum Room A drum room is a larger footprint, and larger rooms cost more in ways that are easy to underestimate, because there are more walls, more ceiling, and more air to condition. It is also a far louder source than a voice, which is one more reason to treat the calculator result for a room like this as a starting point rather than a finish line. Compare the two results, and then ask what the larger room is asking of its walls, its ceiling, and its air handling. The difference in size is only part of the story. Room Three: The Same Studio in the Backyard Now move the same studio outside. A room inside a house borrows the building around it. A backyard studio has to bring its own: foundation, structure, roof, weather barrier, power, and a way to keep the air comfortable. Flip that one input in the calculator and the new total tells the story. The room did not change, but what it takes to build it did.   This is where many backyard plans go sideways. People price the interior they imagine and forget that they are really pricing a small building. Square footage tells you how much room you are building. It does not tell you how hard the room has to work. A Word About Multi-Room Studios The calculator can accept a larger square footage for a multi-room studio, but it was not built to give you an accurate result for two or three rooms. Dividing the space adds walls, and every added wall adds materials. The HVAC system also becomes far more complex, because rooms that need to stay isolated from each other cannot simply share ductwork. If you are planning a multi-room studio, add a serious buffer to whatever number the calculator gives you. When the Budget Is Too Low for the Goal Sometimes the honest answer is that a budget and a goal do not match. If your number comes in under what the room requires, the worst move is to build a lesser version of the same plan and hope. Sound isolation behaves more like a switch than a dial, and a room that is almost there is often still audible. The better moves are to lower the goal, change where the room lives, phase the build in a sensible order, or wait until the budget can carry the plan. Any of those is a better outcome than spending real money on a room that cannot do its job. What Guessing Costs A guessed budget feels cheaper right up until it meets reality. The expensive surprises are rework after the walls are closed, HVAC retrofits for a room that was never designed to breathe, and a finished room that misses the isolation goal. Each of those costs more than the planning that would have prevented it. A $10,000 design fee that surfaces a $75,000 scope gap before construction starts is not an expense. It is the best money spent on the entire project. That is the thinking behind the calculator, and behind how we approach every room at SPYS Designs: get an honest number first, then decide with clear eyes. READY TO SEE YOUR NUMBER? Run your room through the budget calculator and see where your number lands before you spend anything. soundproofyourstudio.com/calculator    
SOUND ISOLATION DESIGN · SPYS DESIGNS The Most Realistic Sound Isolated Room Beats the Best Possible One I came to sound isolation as a working musician who taught himself acoustics. I had no background in construction besides some hands-on experience for a year building my own studio with my contractor. I really didn't understand how the whole design and construction industry worked as a system. I also didn't realize that I was entering a system that had been around for decades and had a lot of embedded dynamics. It took me a while to realize that I needed to adapt my textbook soundproofing designs to work more seamlessly with the systems that were built around safety, code compliance, energy efficiency, and the contractor's workflow for their own efficiency on the job site.    What follows is that specific realization through the lens of specifying an exterior window on a soundproof room and how a simple exterior window can become a massive design problem when it comes to sound isolation.   Construction already runs on a system A contractor wants to buy a window online, have it delivered, and install it the way the manufacturer says to install it. A code office wants a label on that window, an NFRC rated U-factor, so it can check the thermal performance of the building envelope. Anything that does not fit that path adds questions, risk, and labor. A custom window asks the contractor to become a fabricator, and asks the code office to accept something it has no way to verify.   Labor is the real cost of construction Buying a standard item saves money and saves labor. Most people do not realize that labor is the real cost of construction, and it is the number that moves a budget more than any single material. There is a second issue that has nothing to do with money. Even with a great set of plans, many clients worry that their contractor will not want to build a custom window, or will not be able to. That worry is reasonable. A design that depends on someone choosing to fabricate something unusual is a fragile design. The best possible sound isolated room and the most realistic one are not always the same room. What an exterior window actually has to do An exterior window is part of the building envelope, and code evaluates it that way. Soundproof Windows Inc. builds its windows for interior use, and the manufacturer is clear that they are not intended for exterior applications. In lab testing, a two leaf configuration with 5/8 inch glass and 8 inches between the leaves tested at STC 64 and OITC 53. That performance comes from the mass and the air space working together inside the building. Standard exterior windows are a different product with a different job. Marvin publishes STC and OITC ratings for its Ultimate Direct Glaze units in its Architectural Detail Manual, and the laminated glass entries list STC in the mid 30s and OITC around 30. One caution applies to any manufacturer: confirm that the exact glass makeup you want also carries the NFRC rating, because a performance table and a label do not always describe the same configuration.   Patching into the system This is why the design uses two windows in one wall. The exterior leaf is a standard, code compliant window that the contractor can order online and install per the manufacturer manual. The interior leaf is where the sound isolation lives, with a deliberate air space between the two. On one recent project that cavity measured about 11 inches. The exterior leaf satisfies the thermal value needed to pass codes and is designed to be used on the exterior of a building. The interior leaf delivers the sound isolation performance. To be clear, both windows are needed to create optimum sound isolation, but the interior leaf is the specialty sound isolation product. On the plans, the window schedule carries a basis of design note, and the manufacturer, glazing, and rough openings are verified by the contractor and dealer before anything is ordered.   Design for the room that gets built None of this lowers the standard. It moves the standard to where it can be met. A room that performs on paper and cannot be built performs at nothing. A room designed to fit the way construction already works gets built the way it was drawn. That is the discipline behind everything we do at SPYS Designs: start with the best possible room, then do the work of making it the most realistic one. Planning a room that has to perform at this level? Book a Sound Isolation Site Assessment and we will walk through your project, your constraints, and what it will take to build the room you are picturing. soundproofyourstudio.com/plan    
loading
Comments