DiscoverNatural Law Moment
Natural Law Moment
Claim Ownership

Natural Law Moment

Author: James Wilson Institute

Subscribed: 2Played: 4
Share

Description

The legal world is a tumultuous one, and to comprehend it, we must get to the heart of the matter. We must endeavor to understand the principles of judgment upon which the decisions that shape our personal and public lives are based.

Before we can ask "what ought to be?" we must ask "what is?"

To do this, we need the Natural Law.

Profs. Hadley Arkes & Gerry Bradley are the preeminent Natural Law scholars of our day. And with over 80 years of experience between them, not only will the Natural Law Moment podcast place you in the room with them, but it will also teach you to think like them.
12 Episodes
Reverse
It was only a matter of time before we at Natural Law Moment were tempted to do a crossover episode of our podcast with another podcast, and indeed we gave into temptation. But it was with good reason. Our friends at the 3 Whisky Happy Hour Podcast, its co-hosts Steve Hayward and John Yoo in particular, made for just the perfect inaugural crossover episode of Natural Law Moment, in which we take up with Steve and John questions of legal positivism and the natural law challenge to it.This episode was recorded in front of a live audience that the Institute gathered during the Federalist Society's 2026 National Lawyers Convention in Washington, D.C. Plenty of laughs, but also a few unexpected twists and turns of substance as well.
In March of this year the Supreme Court handed down two decisions that should have been seismic for the American family. Yet while most of the conservative legal world is satisfied with them as victories, and that’s whatour two cohosts Hadley Arkes and Gerry Bradley will argue is problematic for mainstream legal conservatism. Before we hear from our cohosts, a brief primer on both cases. First, in Mirabelli v. Bonta, California required schools tohide a child’s social gender transition—new names, new pronouns, the whole identity project—from the child’s own parents unless the child consented. The Court stepped in on the emergency docket and said those policies likely violateparents’ free-exercise and substantive-due-process rights, triggering a fascinating set of dueling opinions from Justices Barrett and Kagan, the subject of our discussion. Weeks later came Chiles v. Salazar in which  Colorado banned licensed counselors from any talk therapy that tries to help a minor align with biological sex or reduce same-sex attraction, while allowing the opposite. An 8–1 Court, in an opinionby Justice Gorsuch, called that move of Colorado’s viewpoint discrimination and demanded strict scrutiny. Both cases are indeed victories. But notice what they carefully avoided: any serious, substantive account of why parental authorityexists, what its natural boundaries are, and how far the state may go before it becomes a usurper. That is the central failing of modern conservative jurisprudence. We keep winning cases on process, speech, or thin historical tradition while refusing to grapple with the natural-law substance of thefamily itself.
For this special America 250 edition of the Natural Law Moment Podcast, we turn to the Declaration of Independence and its crucial importance as the statement that founding our country as a regime rooted in the Natural Law — a foundationthat remains urgently relevant in this, our natural law moment. We mildly dip into the Supreme Court's recent decision in Trump v. Barbara in a discussion over citizenship and consent for a teaser of future discussions over the recent Supreme Cour term as well.Since we are without Prof. Gerry Bradley for this episode, I am his understudy along with our regular co-host Prof. Hadley Arkes, the Founder and Co-Director of the James Wilson Institute. Don't forget to like, rate, and subscribe to Natural Law Moment!
Join Natural Law Moment for the next installment of a look back into the lives of our co-hosts Profs. Arkes and Bradley before they became the storied teachers they would become.This latest episode focuses on Hadley Arkes's intellectual formation at the University of Chicago in the early 1960s as a graduate student of the legendary philosopher and political scientiest Leo Strauss. Our co-hosts explore the ingredients that made the University of Chicago of that era such a vibrant place, a place where Arkes would never have wanted to leave "to study abroad." Arkes recounts classroom interactions between Strauss and his students as well as the philosophic developments that would come to be associated with a revival of conservative thought on the American Founders and Lincoln. And don't miss what Arkes says that Strauss might say to our leaders of today.
Join co-hosts Hadley Arkes and Gerry Bradley for the first of something we expect to become a regular feature on Natural Law Moment, a look back into the lives of Profs. Arkes and Bradley before became the storied teachers they would become. This latest episode focuses on how young Gerry Bradley was thrust into the rough and tumble world of the law as a young prosecutor in the Manhattan District Attorney’s office in the early 1980s. The conversation explores how the practice of law as a young prosecutor in the New York of that era was an education like none other, with the sordid business of prostitution, drugs, and homicide providing regular fodder for the work of young Bradley well before be entered academia to become a professor of criminal procedure. Arkes and Bradley delve into how moral decisions infuse the work of a prosecutor along with all those entrusted to maintain law and order in the city. Subscribe to Natural Law Moment on Apple PodcastsSubscribe to Natural Law Moment on SpotifyFollow Natural Law Moment on YouTubeLearn more about the James Wilson Institute
loading
Comments