Discover
Oklahoma at The Voice of College Football
Oklahoma at The Voice of College Football
Author: The Voice of College Football Network
Subscribed: 4Played: 65Subscribe
Share
© The Voice of College Football Network
Description
Welcome to Oklahoma at The Voice of College Football Network, your home for In-depth discussion, debate, & analysis on all things Oklahoma. We have you covered from offseason all the way to game day. Join us as we embark on another season!Boomer Sooner!For business inquiries please contact: [email protected] Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
210 Episodes
Reverse
Oklahoma Sooners LIVE #225
Hosts: Rob Fontenot & Roger Schilling
OklahomaVOCFB | Sponsored by FanDuel
Episode focuses on the recent win over Mississippi State (first true road victory of the season), the upcoming home game vs. South Carolina, Top 25 reactions, FanDuel odds, QB comparisons, the team’s alternating win/loss pattern, and the Touchdown/Turnover segment. Heavy chat interaction and light personal banter.
Episode Overview
Runtime: ~1 hour 24 minutes
Tone: Casual, conversational, optimistic but realistic about offensive inconsistency.
Core themes: Mateer’s every-other-game pattern, need for cleaner turnovers, home-field advantage, and South Carolina’s recent momentum.
Key takeaway: Hosts believe a win is realistic if Oklahoma stays positive in the turnover battle and gets a functional run game; they are not expecting a blowout.
Timestamped Key Segments
00:00 – 00:04 | Intro & Personal Check-In
Welcome to episode 225. Light banter about being tired, mowing grass, watching NFL, and wearing the “victory shirt.” Viewer shout-outs (Tyler working on Sunday, Grandmaster).
00:04 – 00:09 | Top 25 Reactions
Discussion of the new rankings: Miami #1 (deserved), Ohio State #2 (lost to Texas), Georgia #3 (lost to Auburn), Indiana #4, Notre Dame #5 (lost to BYU). Hosts note that some teams with losses are still ranked high and express skepticism about voter consistency. Mention of Utah’s late win over Houston and UCLA remaining undefeated. Oklahoma is outside the Top 25 and hosts do not expect a single win this week to change that significantly.
00:09 – 00:12 | Mississippi State Recap & Pattern Talk
Big win yesterday. First true road victory of the season (Texas game was in Dallas). Mateer had no turnovers. Run game eventually broke through after early struggles. Alternating pattern highlighted: win-loss-win-loss-win (UTEP, Michigan, New Mexico, Georgia, Texas, Kentucky, Mississippi State). Hosts note they have won two in a row only once so far and joke about a potential “hangover” this week.
00:12 – 00:16 | Turnovers & South Carolina Context
Mateer has 10 interceptions in the three losses to Michigan, Georgia, and Kentucky. South Carolina has a very poor turnover margin (hosts initially say –6 with only two takeaways all year, later correcting that they forced turnovers vs. Florida and Tennessee). Discussion of Shane Beamer’s career pattern of “just enough” results.
00:16 – 00:20 | FanDuel Odds
Oklahoma is a 3.5-point favorite.
Win probability: 61.2%.
Over/under: 44.5.
Hosts view the total as reasonable given both offenses’ scoring profiles. They want a louder home crowd than the Kentucky game and hope Mateer’s confidence carries over.
00:20 – 00:25 | Schedule Look-Ahead & Scoring Trends
Upcoming games: South Carolina, Florida, Ole Miss, Texas A&M, Missouri. Hosts still project 7 wins and a bowl game. Offense has been low-scoring against real competition (most points vs. UTEP). Need ~24 points to feel comfortable.
00:25 – 00:33 | QB Comparison & South Carolina Threats
John Mateer: ~1,591 passing yards, 11 TDs, 7 INTs, 60.7 rating.
Lenorius Sellers: ~1,548 yards, 13 TDs, 5 INTs, 65.1 rating. Both 4-3.
Hosts call it a fairly even statistical matchup. Note South Carolina’s back-to-back wins over Florida and Tennessee and highlight DE Dylan Stewart as a potential disruptor. Running back Matt Fuller has 485 yards and 5 TDs.
00:33 – 00:45 | Hangover Trends & Offensive Identity
Discussion of the national “upset then lose” pattern from the previous week (Oklahoma beat Texas then lost to Kentucky; Florida beat Ole Miss then lost to Missouri, etc.). Hosts hope South Carolina experiences that hangover. More talk about Mateer’s decision-making on the run and occasional underthrows. Brief mention of Witt Neubauer and whether he will see meaningful snaps.
00:45 – 00:58 | Personal Stories & Chat Interaction
Long stretch of personal anecdotes (driving through the Florida Panhandle, Oklahoma geography, Hooker/Turpin, Lincoln Boulevard memories). Multiple viewer shout-outs (Bishop, Pink Floyd, Donut Man, SoCal Sooner, Ryan Lemon, Grandmaster). Victory shirt and “55+ club” jokes continue.
00:58 – 01:10 | Touchdown/Turnover Segment
Hosts and chat submit TDTO questions:
Will fans boo Mateer in Norman no matter how he plays? Mixed responses; some say they will, others note they didn’t boo much after the Texas win.
Dylan Stewart has zero sacks. Split (hosts lean toward him getting at least one).
Lanorris Sellers throws two interceptions. Mostly “touchdown” (unlikely).
Hold South Carolina under 17 points. Generally “touchdown.”
Mateer has back-to-back good games. Most say “turnover” based on the season pattern.
Additional chat submissions include questions about the run game helping Mateer and whether the offense can stay consistent.
01:10 – 01:15 | Broader Turnover & Kicking Discussion
Oklahoma has a poor turnover margin (hosts cite high total turnovers lost). Sandell kicking accuracy and uniform (longer pants vs. rugby shorts) briefly discussed. Chat asks whether Venables has ever blown out a Power conference team; hosts note the biggest wins have mostly come against non-Power or weaker Power opponents.
01:15 – 01:24 | Closing
Light wrap-up, thanks to regulars (Tyler, Rhyming Lemon, Donut Man, etc.), reminder to like/subscribe/comment, and a dad-joke closer about skinny jeans (“cheap hotel… no ballroom”). Next show timing may shift slightly due to Halloween weekend.
Key Insights & Analysis
Mateer pattern is the central storyline: Hosts repeatedly return to the idea that he (and the team) plays well every other game. Breaking the streak is the clearest path to a win.
Turnovers remain the biggest self-inflicted issue: 10 picks in the three losses; overall team margin is poor. A clean or positive turnover day is viewed as nearly decisive.
Home field matters more than usual: The Kentucky game was quiet. Hosts want noise and energy to help Mateer and the offensive line.
South Carolina is not a walkover: Back-to-back SEC wins and a disruptive pass rusher (Dylan Stewart) give them confidence. Oklahoma cannot assume the hangover narrative will play out.
Realistic expectations: 3.5-point favorite feels right to the hosts. A 24-17 type result would be viewed as a successful day. Bowl eligibility (7 wins) still feels achievable.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Oklahoma VOCFB Postgame: Sooners Win 23-15 at Mississippi State
Hosts: Rob Fontenot, Roger Schilling, Chad & Tierani Smith (Sooner Smiths)
Air date: October 25, 2026 (postgame show)
Key Takeaways
Oklahoma improved to a win with a gritty 23-15 road victory over Mississippi State. The Sooners led 10-0 at halftime and controlled the game despite self-inflicted issues.
John Mateer delivered one of his most complete performances of the season: efficient, turnover-free (2 TDs, 0 INTs), and complementary to an improved run game. Hosts noted this as likely his best overall game as a Sooner (not necessarily the best win), with better decision-making and no reckless plays.
Defense was the foundation: Mississippi State managed just 1-of-11 on third down, was shut out in the first half, and never established a consistent run game. OU forced the issue and limited big plays.
Offense showed encouraging balance with the return of Fasusi and more commitment to the run early (Blaylock had a strong day; nearly doubled recent rushing output). 467 total yards marked a high-water mark.
Persistent concerns: Tate Sandell’s kicking slump (missed field goals + alignment penalties), Rocky Beers’ fumble (though he also scored), and occasional self-inflicted issues that kept the game closer than it needed to be.
Broader context: SEC parity is high with many two-loss teams; hosts discussed tiebreakers, Texas, and the need for consistency heading into the next stretch.
Timestamped Notes
0:00–5:00 | Opening & Immediate Reaction
Hosts open live after the 23-15 win. Rob notes the Sooners were “blessed” by Mississippi State’s starting quarterback getting hurt (backup played okay but not at a high level). Final score and 10-0 halftime lead highlighted. Early praise for the defense shutting out the first half and overall resilience. Roger joins after technical issues.
5:00–12:00 | Offensive & Defensive Stats Breakdown
467 total yards; Mateer ~283 passing yards, 2 TDs, 0 INTs (compared favorably to his Texas performance—held the ball, didn’t give the game away).
Third downs: OU 7-for-16; Mississippi State 1-for-11.
Penalties roughly even (OU 9 for 75, MSU 8 for 90).
Discussion of the defense having to “shut everybody down and then try to score 20-something points.” Rocky Beers scored a touchdown but also had the game’s only turnover (fumble). Hosts note one-turnover games are a positive.
Fun observations: Mississippi State’s connected “MSU” logo and cowbell noise.
12:00–20:00 | Sooner Smiths Join; Deeper Game Flow
Chad and Tierani Smith join. Conversation covers SEC standings chaos (many two-loss teams, upcoming tiebreakers with Texas, Ole Miss, etc.).
Mateer’s clean game praised again; hosts texted during the game that “that’s my quarterback.”
Second-half sequence: Touchdown before half, then a strong opening drive out of the half (47-yard play, another score).
Peyton Bowen’s strong play noted, but injury on an interception return (quad) is a concern; he may miss time. Hosts debate whether he should have taken a knee instead of running it out.
Rushing context: Fifth game without a rushing touchdown in seven games (only against UTEP and Texas). Blaylock’s production highlighted (strong single-game output relative to season totals).
20:00–35:00 | Mateer Evaluation, Run Game, and Kicking
Strong consensus that this was Mateer’s most intelligent and controlled game. He operated within the offense, took what was there, and made plays when available without forcing throws. Early commitment to the run (first several plays) paid off and helped the passing game.
Hosts push back on outside commentary that “you don’t need a run game.” They cite the importance of keeping the defense fresh and reducing Mateer’s interception risk.
Tate Sandell’s struggles: Missed kicks, possible alignment/illegal formation penalties (called inconsistently), and the emotional/mental side of a kicker’s slump. Hosts express sympathy but frustration—knowing what he is capable of makes it hard to move on.
Discussion of whether certain missed kicks or the Beers fumble cost points unnecessarily.
35:00–50:00 | Broader Context, Injuries & Next Week
Continued talk on SEC parity, Texas, and what a clean Mateer performance means going forward.
Peyton Bowen’s injury and recognition (playing at a high level but the team’s record limits national attention).
Drive success rates, average starting field position, and points off turnovers noted as positive.
Hosts emphasize the run game’s role in wearing down the defense over the course of the game (echoing former Sooner running back perspective shared on air).
50:00–1:05:00 | National Landscape & Other Games
Shift to the wider college football picture: no clear dominant team (Georgia, BYU, Indiana, Ohio State backup QB situation, Notre Dame’s schedule, etc.). Discussion of Texas-Ole Miss and other results. Lighthearted moments about weather, family, and the show’s production issues.
1:05:00–End | Closing, Upcoming Show & Wrap
Hosts tease the next show (6:30 the following day) for more opinions. Victory shirt mention, final thoughts on the win being encouraging despite imperfections, and sign-off.
Clip Suggestions (Short-Form)
0:32–1:05 — Opening reaction to the 23-15 win and 10-0 halftime lead.
2:30–4:00 — Mateer’s clean game + 467 yards discussion.
5:30–7:00 — Third-down disparity (7-16 vs. 1-11) and defensive dominance.
12:30–14:30 — Rocky Beers fumble and “hard to be mad at him” segment.
23:00–25:30 — “This is John’s best overall game” evaluation.
25:30–28:00 — Importance of the run game and pushback on “just throw it” takes.
13:00–14:00 — Tate Sandell kicking frustration.
Notable Quotes
On Mateer: “When John didn’t turn the ball over… that’s one of the first things we said.” / “That’s my quarterback. I haven’t said that all year.”
On the defense: “This is a game we do not win without our defense. There’s no way.”
On the run game: Hosts stressed sticking with early runs even when they weren’t explosive, because it wears down the defense and opens things later.
On Sandell: Frustration over missed kicks and alignment issues, tempered by acknowledgment of his past clutch performances.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Sooner Smiths Live #58 – Oklahoma’s Horrific Offense | 24-Team Playoff
Hosts: Tierani Smith & Chad Smith
Aired on: OklahomaVOCFB
Core focus: Post-Kentucky loss reaction, elite defense vs. broken offense, John Mateer/turnovers, O-line injuries, Venables/Arbuckle future, and the 24-team CFP.
Opening & Setup
~1:02–2:30 — Intro. “Not fun weekend.” Reacting to Kentucky loss, Jake Kroll SEC Freshman of the Week + Defensive Player of the Week. Offense venting is the main topic. Live Mondays ~7 p.m. CT. Merch mention (Tierani in logo shirt; Chad not). Presented by Fandle. Baby meltdown delay.
Kentucky Game Reaction & Offense Critique
~2:34–4:00 — Opportunity wasted: Georgia lost earlier, chance to be tied for first in SEC after Texas momentum. Defense gave up only 13–14 points and still lost by 8. Pick returned to midfield essentially gave Kentucky a free 7. Defense did its job.
~4:40–5:20 — First drive: Will Stein (ex-Oregon OC) scripted them down the field. Offense responded with nothing, then a late FG. Defense mostly shut them down afterward.
~5:20–6:10 — Offense is “horrific.” Dead last in nearly everything. Worst turnover margin in college football. Nothing exciting except running the ball on Texas, then abandoning the run vs. Kentucky.
~6:10–7:15 — O-line issues. Captains not playing. Fasusi looks great but out (AC joint). Fojay injury major. Parents would be livid. Stats: only 5 red-zone appearances since UTEP (10 total). Defense creates more 3-and-outs than it allows scoring drives — elite unit.
~7:15–8:00 — With a competent offense and no 4 turnovers/game, this could be the #1 team in the country. Reality is far from that.
Game Flow, Red Zone & Mateer Issues
~8:00–9:00 — At the game: Driving the ball but “magnetic resistance” near the end zone. Fake FG same play had a false start (3rd-and-2 became 3rd-and-7). Same play without penalty was likely a TD. Frustration with decision-making.
~9:00–10:00 — Mateer not benched? Room that bad? First half looked like old John (6-for-6 at one point) then collapsed. “Other teams just wait until Mateer messes up.” Fojay exit hurt the line. Human-level empathy for the struggle, but results are brutal.
~10:00–12:00 — Film watchers see open receivers constantly; Mateer doesn’t. Waiting too long, no anticipation (contrast to the late Texas Satania throw). O-line not perfect even pre-injury. Right tackle giving ~2 seconds on the tip INT. Two things true: better timing needed and more protection.
~12:00–13:00 — Bored/tired at the game. Long drive to Ardmore for niece’s birthday. $20 corn dog energy. Caring less like the Cowboys now — check box score and assume embarrassment.
~13:00–14:30 — Elite defense (arguably best in country) wasted. Hard to score 2 offensive TDs against them, yet teams put up 21–27 because of OU’s own turnovers (scoreboard-changing ones). Tip pass to Satania — could have been earlier; tackle protection was poor. Mateer used to rebound (Michigan 2024 example); not this year.
Talent, Play-Calling & QB Room
~14:30–15:30 — Talent is there: Manny Choice, Satania, Rocky Beers (NFL caliber). O-line beat up/injured is the biggest limiter. Bench Mateer for Witt Neubauer or Bo Bentley? “Show us.” At this point, fewer turnovers might be better even if they struggle to move the ball.
~15:30–16:30 — Arbuckle too close to Mateer? He’s gone after this year anyway. Writing on the wall for Arbuckle even if they somehow finish 9-3. Venables retention logic: elite defense is locked in; replacing him risks losing that side while still needing an offensive overhaul.
Coaching Future, Spending & Program Direction
~16:30–20:00 — Hard to replace a coach who guarantees championship-level defense. Plan: spend heavily on offense (potentially double defense), target a proven high-level OC (maybe Kevin Wilson). Need a “certified ball-knower” who can win in the SEC. Buyout not full $51M if Venables gets another job quickly. Must overpay OC (6.5–8M range) + fire/hire staff + buy proven portal players (not developmental). Fasusi, Fojay, Noah Best retention assumed as foundation; still need center and guard.
~20:00–23:00 — Balance required. Losing some defensive recruits to load up on offense is acceptable. Expectation was never world-beater offense — just average/top-25 or even last year’s level would have been enough with this defense. Currently dead last / near-bottom in scoring and total offense. Jacob Jordan note: only multi-year offensive player with snaps; small but productive when used.
~23:00–28:00 — Development gap vs. defense. Coach identities matter; Saban/Kirby self-scouted and adapted (Lane Kiffin example). Last time OU scored 4+ offensive TDs in a conference game: 2023 vs. TCU (Dylan Gabriel + Billy Bowman pick-6). PTSD from Lincoln-era “just get a defense” now flipped to offense.
24-Team Playoff Discussion (Major Segment)
~49:00–52:00 — Opinions mixed. Inevitable because bowls are devalued, NIL makes investment harder without title access, and more schools want a path. 19 at-large + 4 power conference champs + highest G5. 1–8 seeds get byes.
~52:00–55:00 — Championship consequences matter more than pure win totals. Extra SEC conference game + tougher schedule hurts vs. softer Big Ten/ACC/Big 12 paths. 3-loss SEC team can be better than 1-loss weaker-conference team. Indiana/Miami/Notre Dame schedules cited as soft. SEC floor and talent level higher.
~55:00–1:00:00 — Hot teams at the end of the year (South Carolina/Texas 2024 examples) get more runway. 24-team format can “save” big rivalry games. Views still follow stakes (Alabama-Oklahoma numbers vs. lower-seed playoff games). Momentum doesn’t carry the same way with portal.
~1:00:00–1:09:00 — Miami remaining schedule mostly non-ranked; one loss should eliminate them. Big 12 teams look better because they face weaker fronts. OU would likely be undefeated or 1-loss in the Big 12 with this roster. 24-team helps power-conference teams that play real schedules.
Closing
~1:10:00–1:16:00 — Zeno (dog) picks segment: OU–Mississippi State, Ole Miss–Texas, Houston–Utah, Indiana–Michigan, Tennessee–Auburn. Record tracking. Calls to action: like/subscribe on YouTube, comment, share on X. Views up this season. Sign-off: hope for OU win vs. Mississippi State, then South Carolina on Halloween. “Boomer.”
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Oklahoma Sooners LIVE Episode 224
Hosts: Rob Fontenot & Roger Schilling
Aired on: OklahomaVOCFB
Focus: Kentucky loss recap, Mississippi State preview, keys to victory, Touchdown or Turnover, and team outlook
Intro & Opening Banter (00:00:11–~00:02:00)
Episode 224. Roger is on the road (unusual travel for him these two weekends).
Pre-show chat comment: “Wasted defense, poor play calling, and poor quarterback.” Both hosts agree.
Arch Manning and John Mateer described as having turned out overrated.
Light banter about the show schedule feeling quick and the full crew expected for the upcoming away game.
Kentucky Loss Recap (21-13) (~00:02:08–~00:08:00)
OU lost 21-13. Mateer threw 3 interceptions; OU had 4 turnovers total vs. Kentucky’s 0.
Hosts criticize the trick plays (including a flea-flicker-style and a fake field goal/jump pass by the holder). None worked. Rob notes OU outgained Kentucky and questions why they were so desperate to run them.
Kentucky did little after their first drive until Mateer’s interceptions flipped the game. Hosts say “we beat ourselves.”
Field-position and decision points discussed (e.g., Kentucky going for it on 4th-and-goal instead of taking a field goal; OU’s own missed field-goal opportunities).
Opportunistic plays noted from other games (interceptions, blocked punt) as a contrast to the offensive struggles.
Red-zone offense called “awful”; Mississippi State’s red-zone numbers viewed as better.
Mississippi State Preview (~00:02:52–~00:07:00 and ongoing)
Next up: Mississippi State on SEC Network at 2:30. Postgame show expected around 7.
Records: Oklahoma 3-3 (favored by 2.5), Mississippi State 4-2.
Statistical comparison:
OU scoring offense: 113th; MSU: 48th.
OU scoring defense: 30th; MSU: 111th.
OU total offense: ~311 yards/game; MSU: ~454 yards/game (22nd nationally).
Mateer: 9 turnovers in 6 games — must be fixed.
MSU quarterback (referred to as Jeff Levy / Mario Taylor in discussion; injury status uncertain). MSU scored big in earlier wins (e.g., 62, 38, 41) and beat Missouri 31-24, but lost 31-0 to LSU without the QB. Hosts see a potential advantage for OU if the QB is out.
Hosts note MSU hasn’t faced a defense like Oklahoma’s and that turnovers must be eliminated for any chance.
Keys to Victory & Offensive Issues (~00:08:00–~00:16:00 and ~00:11:23–~00:15:00)
Hosts’ stated keys:
No turnovers.
No trick plays — just run the ball.
Take the points (don’t get cute in scoring position; fake FG criticized).
Run the ball and use the tight ends.
Defense must create turnovers and possibly a score (as in the Texas game), because the offense has been unreliable.
Additional discussion:
Offense has “no identity.” Defense has done its job repeatedly only for the offense to stall or turn it over, which is described as disheartening.
Mateer viewed as no longer a dual-threat; he “doesn’t think fast enough” and is “easily rattled.” Hosts and chat discuss whether he should be sat down.
Punting/field position: OU often starts with long fields; need better pinning.
Portal concerns raised — hard to recruit to this offensive situation.
Comparison of Lincoln Riley years (offense) vs. Brent Venables years (defense). Hosts prefer having a functional offense.
Venables and the team described as looking subdued/not hungry after the Texas win. Fans have lost trust; “no one will drink his Kool-Aid again.”
Touchdown or Turnover Segment (~00:29:00–~00:38:00)
Viewer-driven segment (with hosts and chat picks). Examples discussed:
OU can bounce back and win vs. Mississippi State (especially if MSU QB is out) — mixed.
Mateer throws 3 more picks and is done — strong lean toward eventual benching.
Offense can handle cowbells on the road — mixed (some say no, given home struggles).
Hosts/viewers won’t get mad if OU loses — mostly “turnover” (they will still be mad).
Force 3+ turnovers and run for 100+ yards — mixed faith.
Mateer gets benched sometime this season — near-unanimous “touchdown” (it will happen).
Consensus themes: season is effectively over for the playoff; bowl games matter less; still want wins for momentum and to avoid total collapse.
Fun Facts on Mississippi State (~00:38:40–~00:43:00)
Davis Wade Stadium (built 1914) is the second-oldest FBS stadium (clue given: SEC team; answer Georgia’s Sanford Stadium).
First live mascot (Bully One) is buried under the 50-yard line.
Cowbell tradition traced to a Jersey cow wandering onto the field during a 1930s win over Ole Miss.
First meeting as SEC opponents.
MSU historical win percentage: .488.
Dak Prescott and related MSU offensive history briefly noted.
Closing Thoughts (~00:43:00–end)
Season viewed as over for playoff purposes. Realistic goal is simply winning enough to reach 6 wins.
Hosts still get angry at losses but are adjusting expectations.
Roger traveling/working; hopes to be home for the Saturday postgame. Sooner Smiths expected on the postgame show.
Light banter about a backup QB sparking the offense and fans saying “we told you so.”
Outro and thanks to viewers. Sponsored by FanDuel (odds discussion earlier: OU -2.5).
Overall Tone: Frustrated but still engaged. Heavy focus on self-inflicted losses, Mateer’s turnovers, lack of offensive identity, and the need for basic execution (protect the ball, run the ball, take points, stop trick plays) against Mississippi State. Playoff hopes are gone; the conversation has shifted to salvaging the rest of the season and longer-term program questions under Venables. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
OklahomaVOCFB Sooners LIVE Postgame Notes: Oklahoma 13, No. 15 Kentucky 21
Hosts: Rob Fontenot & Roger Schilling
Aired: Saturday night postgame (~10:30 p.m. CT), ~44 minutes
Context: Sooners fall to 3-3 (1-2 SEC) at home after leading most of the game. Kentucky (6-1, 4-1 SEC) moves into a tie for the SEC lead. John Mateer: 24/40, 270 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs (plus a fake-field-goal INT by the holder). OU outgained Kentucky ~346-230 but had four turnovers to zero and scored zero points in the fourth quarter.
Episode Overview
Frustrated but analytical postgame after a game the hosts felt Oklahoma dominated for long stretches (especially on defense after Kentucky’s opening drive) only to collapse late due to turnovers, poor play-calling, an inconsistent offense, and offensive-line depth issues. Strong defense is praised; offense, Mateer, Arbuckle (OC), and Venables’ ability to fix the offense are heavily criticized. Other results (Texas loss, Georgia loss to Auburn, Alabama loss to Tennessee, BYU over Notre Dame, etc.) are noted. Outlook is bleak: possible 6-6 or worse.
Timestamped Key Segments & Discussion Points
00:00–02:00 | Opening reaction & “we should have won”
Hosts express the dominant feeling: OU controlled the game for long stretches, then the offense “disappeared/melted” from late third quarter through the fourth. Announcers’ OL excuses sound familiar after three years of the same issues. Lack of depth forces constant shuffling when injuries hit.
02:00–04:00 | Play-calling & abandoning what worked
Criticism of razzle-dazzle (flea flicker, unnecessary tricks) and the failed fake field goal (should have taken the points). Run game looked decent early and then was abandoned. When they ran it, it worked; they went away from it.
04:00–07:00 | Game flow & early dominance that faded
Kentucky’s easy opening 67-yard TD drive created early worry. OU answered with a FG (7-3). Defense then largely shut Kentucky down; hosts felt there was “no way” they would lose. At halftime they felt good despite the close score (roughly 10-7 or 13-7 entering the late stages). Offense had some good drives. Turning point: interception near the end of the third, Kentucky TD to take the lead, more punts, Kentucky failed on 4th-and-goal inside the 10, then the pick-six sealed it.
07:00–09:30 | Turnovers, fourth-quarter collapse & stats
Four turnovers for OU (zero for Kentucky) are the killer. Pick-six is the backbreaker. Fourth quarter: essentially four total yards for the offense. Stats discussed: OU ~346 total yards (strong passing volume), Kentucky ~230 total / ~70 rushing. “You can’t throw three picks.” Hosts note they dominated the eye test and time of possession feeling but not the scoreboard.
09:30–12:00 | Mateer, QB situation & confidence issues
Mateer looked better when winning/confident; when trailing he “lost it” and couldn’t throw accurately. Discussion of putting in Whit Neubauer — “no reason not to.” Comparison to last year’s running threat that kept defenses honest. Now he appears more hesitant (injury/fumble fear, less explosive). O-line problems compound everything. Package deal with Arbuckle noted.
12:00–16:00 | Other results, rankings & missed opportunity
BYU over Notre Dame (hosts happy), Houston over Oklahoma State, Texas loss, Ohio State beat Indiana, Georgia lost to Auburn, Alabama lost to Tennessee, Miami survived Florida State in OT. Broncos win with former Sooners (Mims, Benito, Powers). Frustration that other big teams lost and OU couldn’t capitalize to climb back into the rankings. Chance to get back toward the top 20 is gone.
16:00–20:00 | Venables, Arbuckle, coaching & hot seat
Venables credited fully for the defense (looked really good after the first series; pressures/sacks). But he is viewed as a defensive coordinator more than a head coach who can fix the offense. Needs an elite OC. Arbuckle (brought in as package with Mateer) is on the hot seat — “no way he should still have his job.” Play-calling called dumb. Hosts note if the fake FG had worked, feelings would be different, but it was still a bad call. Comments about not hearing Venables’ postgame yet.
20:00–25:00 | Remaining schedule & season outlook
Ole Miss next (forced rivalry). Winnable games: Mississippi State, South Carolina, possibly Texas A&M. Harder: Florida, Ole Miss, Missouri. Hosts project maybe three more wins at most, or 6-6 if lucky; some say they wouldn’t be shocked by a continued slide. “Who are they going to beat with this offense?” Defense gives them upset potential, but the offense is “pathetic.”
25:00–30:00 | Broader frustration, anger & lower expectations
Hosts were mad (one took a shower to cool off). Lowered the bar after earlier games (Georgia loss, ugly New Mexico win that knocked them out of the top 25). “We suck” is said bluntly. Comparison to past Big 12 dominance and high expectations vs. current reality. Harder to get as angry when the offense has been this bad for a while.
30:00–36:00 | Talent on offense, specific criticisms & solutions
Skill-position talent exists (RBs, WRs, especially TEs — “don’t fire Witten”). OL can’t block, so nothing works. Abandoning the run on first downs creates 2nd-and-10. Suggestions: change QB, fire Arbuckle, consider Chip Kelly if available. “What do you have to lose?” Play-calling and OL are both problems.
36:00–43:55 | Wrap, more hot-seat talk & close
More on 3-3, needing changes, AD/GM pressure. Facebook page growth noted in passing. Hosts sign off tired and disappointed; Rob dealing with being sick. “We suck” as the bottom line. Peace out; back tomorrow.
Clip-Worthy Moments (Short-Form Friendly)
~00:00–00:45: “We were dominating… then the OU offense just disappeared/melted… you’re not going to win any games with an offense like this.”
~02:30–03:15: Fake FG / razzle-dazzle criticism — “They should have just kicked it.”
~06:40–07:15: The sequence that turned the game (INT end of third → Kentucky TD → pick-six).
~09:20–09:45: “You can’t throw three picks… and one of them’s a pick-six. That was the backbreaker.”
~10:15–10:45: QB change discussion — “What do they have a reason to not put Whit Neubauer in there?”
~13:00–13:45: Abandoning the run when it was working (4-5 yards) for first-down passes.
~17:30–18:15: Venables as DC vs. head coach; needs an awesome OC. Arbuckle/Mateer package deal.
~21:20–21:50: “They’re going to be lucky to win six or seven games… this offense is so pathetic.”
~29:00–29:40: “They scored thirteen points on a team that was allowing 34-35 every game.”
~36:00–36:40: “No way Arbuckle should still have his job. And no way Mateer should still be starting.”
~38:40–39:10: “OU’s a football school that is good at everything but football.”
Key Quotes
“It feels like we were dominating the whole time and then… the OU offense just disappeared, melted, lost the game for us.”
“You’re not going to win any games with an offense like this.”
“You can’t throw three picks. And one of them’s a pick-six. That was the backbreaker.”
“We do have the defense to upset somebody… but they didn’t do anything tonight” in terms of the offense supporting them.
“No way Arbuckle should still have his job. And no way Mateer should still be starting.”
“OU’s a football school that is good at everything but football.”
Bottom-Line Takeaways
Defense was the bright spot and kept it close after Kentucky’s first drive. The offense (play-calling, OL depth/injuries, Mateer’s late turnovers and confidence issues) collapsed when it mattered. Hosts see this as a continuation of multi-year problems and expect pressure for changes (OC and/or QB). Season is trending toward mediocrity or worse unless the offense improves dramatically. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.



