Discover
One Great Case
One Great Case
Author: Areta Lloyd
Subscribed: 1Played: 2Subscribe
Share
© Copyright 2026 Areta Lloyd
Description
A podcast about law to learn more about people.
Every episode goes behind the scenes of a case with the lawyer who argued it, and sometimes the judge who decided it.
You may ask, what makes for a great case?
It might be novel, it might move the needle on a point of law, it might be shocking, or frivolous, or high profile.
Maybe you’ve heard of it, maybe you haven’t.
But behind each case are the people who drive it.
And that’s who we find continually fascinating, because at the end of the day, what are lawyers except well paid managers of human relations.
Join us for each episode, as we do a deep dive into one great case.
Hosted by Areta Lloyd, a litigation lawyer in Toronto, Canada.
Every episode goes behind the scenes of a case with the lawyer who argued it, and sometimes the judge who decided it.
You may ask, what makes for a great case?
It might be novel, it might move the needle on a point of law, it might be shocking, or frivolous, or high profile.
Maybe you’ve heard of it, maybe you haven’t.
But behind each case are the people who drive it.
And that’s who we find continually fascinating, because at the end of the day, what are lawyers except well paid managers of human relations.
Join us for each episode, as we do a deep dive into one great case.
Hosted by Areta Lloyd, a litigation lawyer in Toronto, Canada.
15 Episodes
Reverse
We can all agree that shelter is a basic human need. The key issue is when the state can prohibit or interfere with people’s shelter, especially when they are unhoused.Justice Gibson’s May 2026 decision recognizing homelessness as an analogous ground of discrimination has been seen by some as supporting ‘squatter rights.’ But the case revolved around a vacant, municipally-owned property. When the Mental Health Legal Committee got involved, Mercedes Perez suggested an amicus appointment and built a team to represent unhoused persons who relied on the property for shelter. In this episode, Mercedes shares her perspective from inside the case.What You’ll Discover In This Episode Who the unhoused residents really wereHow intersectionality played a big role in the caseThe earlier by-law that in combination would have effectively made homeless shelters in Waterloo illegalHow Mercedes formed her strategyThe key insight that may have won over Justice GibsonWhere lawyers get distracted & how to refocus on what’s importantWhere the case is going & what’s at stake bout the GuestMercedes Perez is a lawyer and founding partner of PBP Lawyers, with extensive litigation experience before administrative tribunals and at all levels of court in Ontario, the Federal Court and the Supreme Court of Canada. She has argued precedent-setting Charter cases, including Regional Municipality of Waterloo v. Persons Unknown and to be Ascertained and Corporation of the City of Kingston v. Doe. Both were successful challenges that limited municipal powers to evict homeless individuals from outdoor encampments. Her practice also covers mental health and capacity law and constitutional litigation, including P.S. v. Ontario, a successful challenge to the Mental Health Act. She co-instructs the Law and Psychiatry course at Osgoode Hall Law School and has been called to the Ontario Bar since 2003.About Your HostAreta Lloyd practices estate and trusts litigation, with a particular focus on capacity litigation. She participates in public speaking, mentoring junior lawyers, and presenting courses on the topics of estates law, health law, and law practice management. Areta has written for several publications and wrote a column for the Alzheimer caregiver website ALZlive.com.ResourcesHave a suggestion for a great case to feature on the show? Email me at [email protected] for support in your legal career? The Toronto Lawyers Association offers resources, networking, and legal research at no cost. Visit https://www.tlaonline.ca/
Short term rentals (STRs) have put residents and investors at odds all over Canada, but Tiny Township in Ontario recently took center stage. The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal from an application judge’s decision regarding the validity of a By-Law that regulated STRs. The dismissal upheld municipalities’ broad authority to regulate STRs through licensing, without crossing the line into zoning or outright prohibition. So I brought in Matt Hodgson, Senior Associate at Barriston Law, who represented Tiny Township, to give his perspective from inside the issue.What You’ll Discover In This Episode Why the STR owners’ “disguised zoning” argument failedHow the by-law research & consultation process shaped the court’s view The missing evidence that undercut STR owner claimsHow one key factor supported the 300-licence capWhy proving bad faith against a municipal by-law is so difficultMatt’s advice for municipalities passing a contentious by-lawAbout the GuestMatt Hodgson is a Senior Associate at Barriston Law, where he practices municipal law and public sector litigation. He represents and advises local governments, First Nations, and other public entities on civil and regulatory matters, including applications for judicial review, and regularly appears before the Ontario Land Tribunal. Called to the Bar in 2019, he has appeared before the Ontario Court of Appeal, the Superior Court of Justice, and various tribunals. He advises on municipal liability and risk management, and previously articled with the Crown Law Office – Civil, where he focused on administrative law and regulatory negligence. He holds a Juris Doctor from Osgoode Hall Law School. About Your HostAreta Lloyd practices estate and trusts litigation, with a particular focus on capacity litigation. She participates in public speaking, mentoring junior lawyers, and presenting courses on the topics of estates law, health law, and law practice management. Areta has written for several publications and wrote a column for the Alzheimer caregiver website ALZlive.com.ResourcesHave a suggestion for a great case to feature on the show? Email me at [email protected] for support in your legal career? The Toronto Lawyers Association offers resources, networking, and legal research at no cost. Visit https://www.tlaonline.ca/
How much privacy is too much? The Court of Appeal recently granted a motion, in part, that will be the standard for sexual assault cases, using the Sherman Estate framework. The implications are especially critical in sexual violence cases, where litigation itself can be re-traumatizing for the victim. The case is B.E. v. O.R., 2026 ONCA 501 and to dive into this decision, I reached out to Anna Matas, the lawyer who brought the motion on behalf of her client, B.E.The issue is, what factors go to the core of ‘individual dignity’, and how the result affects the litigation process for victims. As Anna pointed out, “ I don't think we ever actually succeed in making litigation easy for survivors of sexual assault.”What You’ll Discover In This Episode The information breach that triggered the first motion for anonymizationThe sequence of pretrial orders that sealed B.E.'s medical recordsHow the Court’s experience with criminal appeals informed Justice Dawe's decision The appeal that may make it safer to report sexual violence and abuseWhy Anna moved away from big ‘crusader’ type casesA disturbing new trend of abusers using litigation to re-traumatize victimsHow Anna prevents burnout in sexual violence casesFor more case details, visit CanLIIOther cases mentioned:Sherman Estate v Donovan Law Society of Ontario v AAAbout the GuestAnna Matas is the founder and principal lawyer of Matas Legal, and a passionate advocate for survivors of sexual violence. She is a Director of the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) and previously served as Chair of the Board of Directors of the Barbra Schlifer Commemorative Clinic, which supports survivors of gender-based violence. In 2024, she received the Women's Law Association of Ontario President's Award. Matas holds an LL.B./B.C.L. (2006) and was an editor of the McGill Law Journal.About Your HostAreta Lloyd practices estate and trusts litigation, with a particular focus on capacity litigation. She participates in public speaking, mentoring junior lawyers, and presenting courses on the topics of estates law, health law, and law practice management. Areta has written for several publications and wrote a column for the Alzheimer caregiver website ALZlive.com.ResourcesHave a suggestion for a great case to feature on the show? Email me at [email protected] for support in your legal career? The Toronto Lawyers Association offers resources, networking, and legal research at no cost. Visit https://www.tlaonline.ca/Follow One Great Case on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or your preferred app to stay up to date with the latest cases and conversations. If you’ve found the show valuable, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts or share it with a colleague. Each time you do, you help another professional discover insights that can shape their practice.
Can historic family law obligations continue to have consequences after death through Part V of the Succession Law Reform Act?A recent case touched on that question, causing a stir in the estates litigation community. The lawyer at the center of the issue is fielding calls from fellow lawyers, who themselves are fielding calls from people seeking to use this decision.But did this decision create new law?To find out more, I reached out to Jenny Bogod, who shared the unique circumstances of the case, as well as her perspective on losing a motion for summary dismissal under Rule 2.1.01.What You’ll Discover In This Episode The strategy behind filing the motionWhy a summary dismissal in this case was ‘ deceptively difficult’How a previously-unknown child support order came to lightThe related threshold motion still awaiting decisionHow Jenny recovers from lossesThe implications of an influx of similar cases in the next few yearsAbout the GuestJenny Bogod is a partner at Rosen Sack LLP, and a passionate litigator whose practice focuses on estate, trusts and capacity litigation as well as professional negligence. Jenny represents dependants, estates, beneficiaries and persons whose capacity is being questioned by others in matters related to will challenges, will interpretation applications, power of attorney disputes, dependant support claims and guardianship applications. For more information or to connect directly with Jenny, visit https://www.rosensack.com/jenny-bogodAbout Your HostAreta Lloyd practices estate and trusts litigation, with a particular focus on capacity litigation. She participates in public speaking, mentoring junior lawyers, and presenting courses on the topics of estates law, health law, and law practice management. Areta has written for several publications and wrote a column for the Alzheimer caregiver website ALZlive.com.ResourcesHave a suggestion for a great case to feature on the show? Email me at [email protected] for support in your legal career? The Toronto Lawyers Association offers resources, networking, and legal research at no cost. Visit https://www.tlaonline.ca/
What happens when the law defines a dog owner more broadly than most people realize?Under Ontario’s Dog Owners’ Liability Act, a person may be treated as a dog’s owner simply because they have temporary possession or control of the animal. That can include a professional dog walker, a friend taking someone else’s dog for a walk, or a neighbour asked to care for it while the actual owner is away.But the surprising definition is only part of the legal problem.In this episode, I’m joined by Toronto personal injury lawyer Shane Katz, who represented a dog walker severely injured while following the owners’ instructions inside their home.The result? A law intended to hold dog owners accountable may now prevent injured caregivers from recovering against the people who actually own the animal, while also exposing those caregivers to liability themselves.Things You’ll Learn in This Episode;Why Ontario’s Dog Owners’ Liability Act ordinarily allows an injured person to establish liability without proving that the owner knew the dog was dangerous.How temporary possession and control of a dog can cause a dog walker or caregiver to be treated as an “owner” under the current interpretation of the law.Why being classified as an owner may prevent an injured person from suing the dog’s actual owner under the statute.How the precedent discussed in the episode shaped both the summary judgment decision and the unsuccessful appeal.Why Shane believes legislative reform may now be the only practical way to restore accountability and protect people temporarily caring for someone else’s dog.About the GuestShane Katz is a personal injury lawyer at Singer Kwinter, where he has been a member of the legal team since 2001. His practice is dedicated exclusively to representing plaintiffs in personal injury, insurance claims, and medical malpractice matters.Shane has advocated for clients before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Divisional Court, and Court of Appeal. He has been involved in several significant cases, including Bonaiuto v. Pilot Insurance Company and Hazan v. ING Insurance Company. He has successfully resolved many matters in which defendants had previously been unwilling to compensate his clients.Known for his honest, approachable, and compassionate manner, Shane is committed to achieving the strongest possible outcomes while treating every client with dignity and respect.He is a member of the Ontario Trial Lawyers Association, the Ontario Bar Association, and The Advocates’ Society. His peers have recognized Shane as a leading personal injury litigation lawyer in Best Lawyers in Canada. He also regularly contributes to the profession through continuing legal education, mentorship of articling students and junior lawyers, and involvement with organizations supporting injured and disabled people. Connect with Shane on LinkedIn. About Your HostAreta Lloyd practices estate and trusts litigation, with a particular focus on capacity litigation. She participates in public speaking, mentoring junior lawyers, and presenting courses on the topics of estates law, health law, and law practice management. Areta has written for several publications and wrote a column for the Alzheimer caregiver website ALZlive.com.ResourcesHave a suggestion for a great case to feature on the show? Email me at [email protected] for support in your legal career? The Toronto Lawyers Association offers resources, networking, and legal research at no cost. Visit https://www.tlaonline.ca/




