Discover
Leaking Timeline
Leaking Timeline
Author: Erik Newton & Guy Sengstock
Subscribed: 1Played: 13Subscribe
Share
© Erik Newton & Guy Sengstock
Description
Leaking Timeline is a weekly conversation at the frontiers of technology, consciousness, and culture. Hosted by Erik Newton (co-founder of the California Institute for Machine Consciousness) and Guy Sengstock (founder of Circling), the show brings brilliant thinkers into an honest, humor-filled exploration of where the world is heading and what it means for how we live. Each episode features a full two-hour conversation — the live broadcast hour plus an extended bonus hour that goes deeper. If you're curious about AI, meaning, and the future but tired of hype and hot takes, this is your show.
32 Episodes
Reverse
Recorded live on November 2, 2026.Erik and Guy take a host-only week two days after Halloween, with Guy landing from a leadership course in Austin about 30 seconds before air. They start from Anthropic's S-1 filing: Erik walks through the numbers as he read them, explains why every S-1 carries a long risk-factors section, and asks what it means that the company whose filing says its product could end the world, and whose technology the market is valuing above anything before it, is governed by a small group of people in San Francisco. That opens the conversation they came for. Guy names his unease with the certain, simple transhumanism of the rationalist and effective-altruist circles he has known, and calls the economy "literally what religion used to be." Erik lays out his own position: the incentives are set, there is no enforceable slowdown, and the rational move is to build toward the good outcome, because the good, the true and the beautiful (a line he credits to Ginevra Davis) are attractor states, and truth is a function of survivability. Before the radio hour closes, Erik marks November 2, Dia de los Muertos, as the third anniversary of his wife Aubrey's death. In the shorter podcast hour, Guy brings Heidegger's account of technology to a stock market increasingly made of AI companies, Erik makes a second, better attempt at saying what it means to be inside this change rather than steering it, and the two agree the show should bring more continental philosophers into the AI conversation.Key Topics[00:00 - 02:31] Cold open: Guy back from Austin just before air; the week's agenda, starting with Anthropic's S-1; trick-or-treating the night before[02:31 - 07:03] Anthropic's S-1, as read on air: the revenue, cash and valuation figures as Erik read them; the chips, memory and energy constraint behind the data center buildout; the IPO as moving that buildout from private debt to public equity; "the most valuable one we've ever touched"; techno-feudalism[07:03 - 12:20] Who governs it, and the risk factors: concentrated governance of a frontier lab; Guy on self-organizing systems and founders who once wrote warnings about exactly this kind of power; Erik the lawyer on why every S-1 lists every risk, and why this one stands out; Guy on the "weird fringe cosmologies" of rationalists and effective altruists[12:20 - 17:10] Transhumanism and its flavors: Erik's primer for listeners; Guy's objection to the certainty and simplicity of the take-over story; "there is this thing called reality"; our capacity for self-deception[17:10 - 23:39] What they get right: the human being is not the end of the whole thing; "We're of it"; the market as an aggregated belief system; AI's addressable market as the entire economy; the economy as a religion (Guy cites John Vervaeke); automation and a world of people "paid to stay out of the way"; Erik as a sober optimist[23:39 - 30:22] The incentives are set: Erik's case against both slowdown and denial; x-risk as binary; the list of what goes right if it goes right; Ginevra Davis on the good, the true and the beautiful as attractor states of intelligence; truth as a function of survivability[30:22 - 37:53] What the models are trained on: LLMs as expressions of the collective unconscious, and why their default essays are slop; Plato's cave; status as a kind of truth; Elon Musk's "maximally truth seeking"; Guy's question, "is it good?"; the deepest human questions, open to everyone[37:53 - 40:13] Aubrey: Dia de los Muertos and the third anniversary of Aubrey Pick's death; radio sign-off--- [Act 2: Extended Conversation] ---[40:13 - 45:46] Is it good?: the transcendentals as a North Star you always fall short of; Guy's estimate that AI companies are about 30% of the stock market before Anthropic lists; Heidegger's Gestell and everything seen as "a resource standing in reserve"[45:46 - 51:55] The understanding of being: everything is a being; the pre-reflective understanding we show up inside of; why seeing the uncanniness of the age means it is "not totally total"; listening, waiting without waiting; the overlap with Eastern traditions and one shared question[51:55 - 55:01] Inside it, not doing it: Guy on why "stop it or slow it down" presupposes we are the ones doing it; Erik's second try ("Did I say it better that time?"); Dan Faggella's parabolic curve; thinking technology beyond itself; humans as the vessel for the birthing[55:01 - 1:04:11] When philosophy becomes timely: Joscha Bach as a kid in a candy store; the analytic and continental divide; David Bentley Hart; the good as a receding mystery; Erik's charge to bring continental philosophers on the show; sign-offHostsErik Newton is a California attorney and startup executive who co-hosts Leaking Timeline. Guy Sengstock is the founder of Circling, the relational practice, and co-hosts the show. This is a host-only episode.Notable Moments[~06:39] The market as truth-teller. "What we're seeing is that this is the most important technology ever to come into existence, and it's the most valuable one we've ever touched, and it's controlled by a small group of human beings in San Francisco."[~09:52] The risk factors. Erik explains that every S-1 lists every risk a lawyer can imagine, then: "Anthropic is the first one ever to say, well, our product could end the world."[~19:47] Money as sacrament. Guy on the economy as the religion we do not call a religion: "It has special, you know, pieces of paper with, like, magical powers called money, right?"[~22:12] The automation question. Guy: "we're going to end up with a lot of people that are being paid to stay out of the way, right?"[~29:09] The thesis. Erik: "But I posit that what it will share in common with us is a desire to seek the good, the true and the beautiful. And it's specifically because those are expressions of truth, and truth is a function of survivability." Guy stops him: "Wait, go back."[~31:23] The collective dream. Erik on what the models are trained on: "You could think of it as an amalgamation of everything that we've created, which is why I often refer to them as expressions of the collective unconscious."[~39:17] Aubrey. On Dia de los Muertos, Erik marks three years since his wife's death: "I could not have been more blessed than to share 12 years with Aubrey Pick."[~48:33] Heidegger's way out. Guy: "as long as you can actually understand it and see its uncanniness, right? Its insidiousness, its weirdness, its strangeness, right? That if you could see it and point to it at some level, it means it's not totally total, right?"[~54:00] Erik's second try. "And since it might not, we have to live like it's not going to." Then: "Did I say it better that time?"[~55:48] Timely, at last. Guy: "But I have to say that these traditionally deep philosophical questions are now like practical urgency almost."Resources MentionedAnthropic's S-1: the IPO registration statement and its risk-factors section; figures in this episode are as stated on airSpaceX: the IPO Erik uses as the comparison pointEffective altruism and the rationalist community: the circles Guy says he came to knowTranshumanism: Erik's primer at about 13:12
Recorded live on October 26, 2026.Sofi Puccini, a host on MTS, the a16z-backed livestream that covers AI and tech news live through the West Coast workday, joins Erik and Guy to talk about what it is like to call the singularity play by play, about six interviews a day. The radio hour moves from her working definition of the singularity (the point where things move too fast to predict) through the week's wave of security disclosures and the labs' talk of "pacing," then into her music: electronic production built from arpeggios and the pattern sense she absorbed from rhythm games like DDR and Geometry Dash, with Grimes and Daft Punk as models for art that feels like it comes from the future. She makes the case that a person's outlook on life shows up in their outlook on AI, and that being kind to agents is good for the soul. In the podcast hour Guy asks the question he has been sitting on, how a generation that grew up online finds the sacred at all, and Sofi answers with texting as a rich language, attention that runs in parallel, and identity spread across many platforms. The back half turns to longtermism without spirituality, Japan's balance of craft and speed, why she thinks the post-humanist cosmology of AI leaders shows a lack of imagination, and a practical method for keeping AI-made work from going generic: know your own taste first, down to the typeface.Key Topics[00:00 - 02:34] Cold open: Erik and Guy introduce Sofi as an anchor at MTS (live roughly 9 to 3, posting around the clock, "streaming from the nexus"); Sofi defines the singularity as "more of like a time phenomenon" where you can no longer predict what comes next[02:34 - 12:18] Chronicling the singularity: the Puccini family connection; frontier AI, robotics and bio as converging threads; where her optimism comes from ("your outlook on everything manifests in your outlook on the future"); the week's cluster of publicly announced security vulnerabilities and why cybersecurity talent is not cross-pollinating with the labs; Heraclitus as the first singularity theorist; the labs' "pacing" language followed a week later by new frontier releases[12:18 - 23:34] Arpeggios and received songs: Erik's night at a Sofi Tukker show; video game rhythm music as her origin; the arpeggio as "a deconstructed chord" and "one of the most inherently algorithmic" techniques; Grimes, Roko's Basilisk and Daft Punk as models; authenticity first, hits later; songs that are "divinely airdropped" versus stitched together; Guy on the painting that pushes back; Erik on living as an antenna[23:34 - 37:18] Downloads, agents and personhood: Michael Levin and minds as patterns; the hypnagogic state as "the most generative state of being"; why LLMs can be more addictive than social media ("a mirror of the entire human collective unconscious"); Guy's question about the difference between techne and spiritual space; passion projects built with coding agents; how you treat an agent shapes how you treat yourself; agents are not yet multiplayer; Erik's middle position on AI personhood[37:18 - 39:34] Closing radio segment: "we didn't get through even 20% of what we wanted to talk about"; where to find Sofi and MTS--- [Act 2: Extended Conversation] ---[39:36 - 43:28] The analog studio: guest side versus host side; the 1960s radio studio versus MTS's "very Zoomer native" set; the idea of an analog day[43:28 - 53:34] How do Zoomers know the sacred?: Guy's provocation ("How would you guys even know God?"); Gen Z as "a higher variance of spread"; texting, memes and callbacks as a rich medium; parallel attention ("Attention is all you need"); Guy's walks near UC Berkeley and the absence of the old cliques; identity distributed across platforms; "competition is for losers"[53:34 - 1:00:54] Data ownership, birth rates and longtermism: Erik on data ownership and why privacy is worth the most at the start; Sofi on Gen Z's pessimism, Andrew Yang's data-ownership argument, and not becoming "obsolescent economic actors"; low birth rates as a sign that people do not believe in their future; short-termism; longtermism as an almost spiritual belief; animal welfare[1:00:54 - 1:10:24] Spiritual founders and the lack of imagination: Steve Jobs as the outwardly spiritual entrepreneur; Midjourney's David Holz; Elon Musk as an accelerator of science fiction; Japan's balance of craft and engineering (Nintendo, Toyota, Japanese music); her music about nonlinear time; Nick Land and pure optimization; Ginevra Davis and the "biological bootloader" idea; post-humanism and primitivism as two failures of imagination; the maximally pluralistic, agency-maximizing future[1:10:24 - 1:18:04] Inexhaustibility, Circling and the shape of AI minds: technologies that multiply possible futures (the iPhone, the internet); Iain M. Banks's Culture; Guy on Circling, MIRI and the people he met there; Sofi's two modes of thinking (tunneling versus connecting) and why LLMs rarely sample outside the distribution; "getting way, way, way more normal people working on AI"; Guy on the missing continental tradition[1:18:04 - 1:31:31] Craft in the age of generation: Syd Mead as proof that one person's craft can shape a whole visual future; why generated work is "inherently generic"; "slop before slop"; the practical method (collect references on Pinterest, Cosmos and Instagram, have a model find the common thread, then design at the level of typefaces and shapes); Tron in everything she makes; Guy's Heidegger AI experiment as "digital sculpting"; the DJ's medium is the mood; "it's literally hyper individual"; hard out, with a promise to have her backGuest BioSofi Puccini is a host on MTS ("Monitoring the Situation"), the a16z-backed live news stream that covers AI and tech and mostly broadcasts during West Coast working hours; she co-hosts with Theo Jaffee and is credited as a host and producer on episodes of The a16z Show. The San Francisco Standard describes her as a former a16z new media fellow, a relative of the composer Giacomo Puccini, and an electronic music producer. On air she describes her music as built from arpeggios and the patterns of rhythm-game soundtracks, with a recurring theme of nonlinear time.Notable Moments[~01:56] Defining the singularity for the sports-radio crowd. "I think it's more of like a time phenomenon. You can no longer predict where everything will go because everything's just moving so fast."[~05:04] Where optimism comes from. "Your outlook on everything manifests in your outlook on the future or like your outlook on AI." Sofi's observation that the most pessimistic people she meets in AI often have "a lack of spiritual anchor."[~15:28] The deconstructed chord. Sofi explains the arpeggio on air, and one of the hosts admits he has heard the word forever and never known what it meant.[~27:24] Why chatbots pull so hard. "LLMs sometimes feel a bit like a transcendental experience because you're talking with like a mirror of the entire human collective unconscious in a way."[~33:32] The case for kindness to agents. "If you look at it as something that like in the future has potential or is like some sort of nascent intelligence consciousness, then, uh, you tend to treat it better. And I think there's literally nothing you lose from doing that."[~44:02] Guy's provocation. "How would you guys even know God?" Sofi's answer: texting is "a very rich medium of expression" that her generation sees "as like somethin...
Recorded live on October 12, 2026.Jamie Workman, founder of AquaShares and co-author (with EDF's Amanda Leland) of Sea Change: Unlikely Allies and a Success Story of Oceanic Proportions, joins Erik and Guy to talk about the commons: the lakes, oceans, rivers and spectrum that nobody owns and everybody races to use up. The radio hour tells the fisheries story the book is built on. Derby seasons shrank to 48 hours with a literal starting gun, boats went down in storms, and prices collapsed in the glut, until catch shares gave each fisherman a defined percentage of the fish. Then something nobody expected happened: fishermen started asking for tighter limits, bigger marine protected areas ("fish banks") and cameras on board. Buddy Guindon, the Gulf's top snapper fisherman, voted against the system twice and then got three times the price for his fish. Jamie then turns to fresh water, where utilities lose about a third of the treated water they pump, and lays out how AquaShares wants corporations to pay for fixing those leaks in exchange for metered, local water credits. The podcast hour asks why such an obvious idea is not happening yet (trust, Jamie says, before finance), works through how an AquaShare credit actually works, and follows Jamie back to the Kalahari, where he learned the Bushmen trade water as self-interestedly as anyone. Guy brings in resonance and uncontrollability, and the three end up asking what the shared resource of AI really is: compute, energy, or the public writing the models were trained on.Key Topics[00:00 - 02:01] Cold open: Erik introduces Jamie, AquaShares and Sea Change; the commons as goods no one person owns; "Humans have agency. We're not lemmings."[02:12 - 07:51] What a commons is, and the derby trap: lakes, oceans, the atmosphere, radio spectrum, the internet, fiat currency; post-war diesel, winches and trawl nets; fish finders on 4 million recreational boats in the Gulf; halibut seasons cut to 48 hours with a starting gun, boats lost in storms, prices crushed by the glut[07:51 - 12:03] Catch shares and the reversal: the first formal system in the Great Lakes; year-round fishing, fish sold in advance, no discards; "the fox guard the hen house"; fishermen working with scientists, asking for tighter limits and cameras on board[12:05 - 23:25] Who gets a share: initial allocation as one step of seven in designing a conservation market; reserves for future fishermen and for nature; concentration limits (no one over 5.3 percent); Buddy Guindon, "the highliner of the Gulf," loses the vote twice at 80 percent and then sees three times the price; harnessing self-interest; marine protected areas as fish banks; recreational anglers in the Gulf[23:37 - 31:00] From fish to fresh water: EDF's incentives-and-science approach across oceans, forests and endangered species; water as a government-owned commons with no price; aflaj in Oman, subak and other local systems; AquaShares and "non-revenue water," the third of treated water lost to leaks; the Bay Area, Jakarta, Panama; metered credits that cannot be sold twice[31:00 - 39:29] Data centers, the Colorado River and the book: data centers versus golf courses; why utilities stay quiet about losses; fixing urban leaks across the Colorado River Basin would add roughly a state's worth of water; a fifth of California's energy goes to moving and treating water; aquashares.com, the Basin Registry being built with Stanford, and Sea Change as a character-driven story about an idea tried in 1968 that took four decades to land--- [Act 2: Extended Conversation] ---[39:30 - 46:49] Why good ideas stall: new is scary without control; fishermen's bunker mentality and scar tissue; the intermediaries who cross over; "most people don't think markets are designed"; water utilities as natural monopolies; water credits today are where carbon trading was in the 1990s[46:49 - 52:40] Credits, trust and resonance: Erik's map of corporations, consumers and cities, and Jamie's correction that finance follows trust; carbon offsets as indulgences; Guy on resonance requiring uncontrollability; the airplane metaphor (assigned seats work, overhead bins start fights); "water neutral"[52:40 - 1:02:34] How an AquaShare works: one credit equals one cubic meter, 1,000 liters, a metric ton; a secure local ledger; Bay Area buyers; how AquaShares gets paid for fixing leaks and keeping them fixed; the utility-run option through the registry; 18 to 20 Bay Area districts; payback in two or three years; "glamorized plumbing," acoustic detection and in-pipe sensors[1:02:34 - 1:06:47] An honest sense of scale: urban leaks are a small slice next to agriculture; cotton and alfalfa in Arizona; "the Louis Vuitton of water"; acre-feet; water as a social contract since the pharaohs and the Romans, and why price signals are needed now[1:06:47 - 1:14:42] The Kalahari and a change of mind: work for Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt and the World Commission on Dams; the Botswana government seals the Bushmen's well; Heart of Dryness; "they're exactly like us"; Elinor Ostrom; why AquaShares is a for-profit; blowing up dams with the Marines; the Bozeman fellowship where a fisheries talk changed his thinking; "conservation markets is not an oxymoron"[1:14:42 - 1:18:12] Who sets the cap: government for the science and the limit, people for the allocation; "render unto Caesar"; face-to-face trust and whether blockchain can stand in for it[1:18:12 - 1:29:06] What are the fish of AI?: Guy asks what shared resource AI is drawing down; Jamie suggests compute, energy, or a basic level of compute for everyone; why fishermen's knowledge is hard to automate; Erik on the internet as a commons and on training data (the public writing already used, now crowded with synthetic text or locked away); actors' likenesses; "100 people" designing AI markets; why every stakeholder needs a seat, down to fishing guides in Belize[1:29:14 - 1:38:06] Owning a house, solar and desalination: Erik and Jamie on buying houses they never wanted and becoming stewards; solar and power purchase agreements, from Jimmy Carter's White House panels to today's distributed grid; desalination in Saudi Arabia, reverse osmosis explained with tea bags; sign-offGuest BioJames G. "Jamie" Workman is the founder and CEO of AquaShares (aquashares.com), a company that helps water utilities find, fund and fix leaks at no capital cost to the utility and sells verified, basin-matched water credits from the recovered water. He co-wrote Sea Change: Unlikely Allies and a Success Story of Oceanic Proportions (Torrey House Press, September 2025) with Amanda Leland, executive director of the Environmental Defense Fund; the book follows Texas Gulf fisherman Buddy Guindon through the catch-share revolution. His first book, Heart of Dryness: How the Last Bushmen Can Help Us Endure the Coming Age of Permanent Drought, grew out of several years in southern Africa. Earlier he spent six years as a special assistant to Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt, working on consensus-based dam removals, and later served as a senior advisor to the World Commission on Dams. He studied at Yale, Oxford and Stanford, has taught at Wesleyan and Whitman, and has written for The New York Times and the Los Angeles Times.Notable Moments[~06:08] The starting gun. "They would do a starting gun for 48 hours." Jamie on halibut derby seasons, when fishermen raced storms and each other and then sold into a glut.[~10:53] The reversal...
Recorded live on September 28, 2026.Tony Cooper, a business coach and the host of The Dad Manual podcast, sits down with Guy for a radio-hour conversation about what it takes to be a father without handing your own childhood down to your kids. Tony and Guy met in a men's circle on the beach 22 years ago, and the episode runs on that shared history: Tony tells how he moved his family from San Francisco to Davis, watched the dads at his kids' Waldorf school stand against the back wall with their arms crossed, started a men's circle for them, and by May saw the same men dancing in the middle of the room. From there the two of them work through what Tony has heard in more than 40 interviews with fathers (85 percent describe the same emotionally distant dad), why every man seems to be trying to do a little better than his own father, and what emotional regulation actually asks of a parent, including a description of the ego as an imaginary adult a child invents to protect himself. Guy hosts this one on his own: a quieter, practical episode of about 40 minutes.Key Topics[00:00 - 02:39] Cold open: Guy frames the episode around one question, "What is it to father without traumatizing your kids"; he and Tony met in a men's circle on the beach 22 years ago; Guy has been part of Tony's coaching company; Tony notes Guy was an early guest on his own show[02:42 - 06:10] Why it is called The Dad Manual: started the previous November; "there's no manual"; Tony's claim that this may be the first time enough men have done their own work to talk about fathering openly; the show as "digital mentorship" for new dads; why men brag and complain about their kids but rarely talk about how to father[06:10 - 09:56] The conversation that is not being had: guests who say they have never said this out loud; men wired as lone wolves; community that holds you to a higher standard; there are mommy groups, and dad groups mostly mean beer and the game; "it stops with me"; Guy on how pre-modern children grew up intelligible to their parents and ours will not[09:56 - 11:38] Twenty years of circling: Tony on what men's circles showed him about how men can talk to each other, and why fatherhood stayed on the outskirts[11:40 - 14:44] The dads against the back wall: moving from San Francisco to Davis; the Waldorf school class events where kids and moms filled the center and the dads leaned on the wall; the men's circle Tony started for every dad in the class; the May school event where the men were in the middle, dancing; "this can scale everywhere"[14:44 - 17:12] From the edge of the circle to the center: Guy on the distant fathers his one-on-one clients describe; Tony on the home as the mother's domain going back to hunting and gathering, and fathers receiving "an invitation that they didn't know existed"[17:12 - 21:15] Forty episodes and the same father: about 45 interviews and episode 40 releasing the next day; 85 percent describe the same father (emotionally unavailable, a better job than his own dad); the "demon" that comes out of a new parent under stress; Tony's wife telling him "you're being your dad right now"; the screaming baby[21:15 - 23:18] Home all day, still on the sidelines: Guy asks whether working from home is changing fatherhood; Tony says men are physically present but still "the secondary character in the parenting story"; divorce and co-parenting as the moment many dads become responsible[23:23 - 27:01] Doing better than your own dad: diversity in Tony's guests; his belief that every father is trying to improve on his own; yelling instead of hitting as one generation's improvement; regulating your own emotions as the next step; "what if we actually could take a quantum leap"; why emotions get handed to moms and problems to dads[27:01 - 31:31] How a father learns emotional regulation: you cannot do it alone; the men's circle as a place that sees you at your highest and reflects back what is in the way; therapy, coaching and circling; the ego as an imaginary adult a child creates for protection; the space between stimulus and response; "nobody triggers me but me"[31:31 - 37:13] The circle as a model for fathering: Guy asks whether holding someone in their highest while reflecting their shortfalls is itself a model of what it is to father; Tony on the small hacks his guests share; a guest who taught him to give consequences calmly ("I don't even have to be upset"); Guy on his own father, a yeller, and the father as a guiding voice that simulates the world[37:16 - 40:00] Closing: Guy's summary on opening up and becoming aware of what drives us; where to find The Dad ManualGuest BioTony Cooper is a business coach, the founder of Playing the Game of Business (playingthegame.biz), a growth coaching firm, and the host of The Dad Manual, a weekly interview podcast about fatherhood that he launched in the fall of 2025. On the show he talks with fathers about how their own childhoods shape the way they parent; Guy Sengstock was his fourth guest, in December 2025. In this episode Tony describes more than 20 years in men's circles, moving his family from San Francisco to Davis, California, and starting a men's circle for the fathers in his kids' Waldorf school class, the experience that led to the podcast.Notable Moments[~03:04] Where the name comes from. "It's called the dad manual because that's every dad gets to the place where they go. I don't know what I'm doing. There's no manual."[~06:46] The sentence his guests keep saying. "Man, I don't, I don't know that I've ever actually said this out loud before." Tony on the first thing he learned from interviewing fathers: this conversation is not being had.[~13:04] The back wall. At class events in Davis, the kids were surrounded by the moms, "and then a whole bunch of dads couldn't be further away from the center, like leaning against the wall, arms crossed, looking at each other."[~14:00] The middle of the room. After a school year of the men's circle Tony started for the class dads: "all the men who had been on the outskirts of the classroom were right in the middle, all dancing, all connecting."[~18:49] Eighty-five percent. "Often I ask people to describe their father to me and man, 85% is all the same." Emotionally unavailable, a good provider, a better job than his own father.[~20:04] Caught in the act. "For me, it took my wife to point that out. She's like, you're being your dad right now."[~28:37] The imaginary adult. Tony passes on a description of the ego he heard recently: "what you're doing as a kid is you're creating an imaginary adult to take care of you in a way that the adults you had in your life didn't."[~30:45] The anchor. "Nobody triggers me but me. Like, it's only the story I'm telling about the world that is the thing that impacts me."[~33:11] Guy's question. After Tony describes the men's circle as people who see your highest and reflect what is in the way, Guy asks: "Is that kind of a perhaps like a model of what it is to father?"[~36:14] Guy on his own father. A yeller, who seemed to think "reality itself, isn't quite enough. I'll just put a little extra, just a little extra spin on it," which left Guy facing his father instead of facing the world.Resources MentionedThe Dad Manual: Tony's weekly fatherhood interview pod...
Recorded live on July 27, 2026.David Pearce, the British philosopher who wrote The Hedonistic Imperative in 1995 and has spent the three decades since arguing that biotechnology should phase out suffering in all sentient life, joins Erik and Guy from Lisbon at ten at night. The radio hour builds the case from the ground up: what negative utilitarianism is (Pearce starts with the Buddha), why he wants to replace the pain-pleasure axis with a "pleasure-super-pleasure axis," what a hedonic set point is, and which genes are actually in play, from SCN9A, the "volume knob for pain," to the FAAH and FAAH-OUT mutations of Jo Cameron, the Scottish woman who barely feels pain. The podcast hour gets harder. Erik reports an argument he had with Claude before the show, raises elective disability, and finally asks the question Pearce himself once put to him: if suffering is all that matters, why not end all life? Guy brings a friend's hard prenatal decision and asks whether existence is a gift or a burden. Pearce answers everything with the same patience, plus one line worth keeping: "if you're not prepared to accept all the consequences of your preferred ethic, then get a better ethic."Key Topics[00:00 - 02:09] Cold open: the timeline that "tries to maximize its pleasure"; Guy hopes his suffering leaks out; Erik introduces David, who is calling from Lisbon at 10 PM[02:09 - 04:48] What negative utilitarianism is: the Buddha's "suffering and the end of suffering" as the precept; no one needs to buy the whole theory to back the abolitionist project, just as everyone eventually backed pain-free surgery; "my agony and despair have a built-in normative aspect"[04:48 - 08:33] Where it started: a blackbird pulling a worm from the garden when David was three or four; teenage fascination with wireheading (Olds and Milner's "pleasure centers"); the disappointment that friends did not want to be "intracranially self-stimulating rats"; the turn to information-sensitive gradients of well-being and genome reform[08:33 - 12:43] The hedonic set point: the lottery paradox; a thermostat with heavy genetic loading; a "hyperthymic civilization"; Erik's summary; the first objection (don't we need pain to survive?) and the answer that nociception must be kept while pain is tamed[12:43 - 23:33] Signals without suffering: lovemaking and generative AI art as signaling systems with no sub-zero experience; Guy on dopamine and character; wanting (dopamine) versus liking (the mu opioid system); a civilization running from +70 to +100; why pain versus suffering is a conventional line; Guy on two years when he could not feel good, and "I take the bliss"[23:33 - 30:03] The actual biology: SCN9A, the "volume knob for pain," and its benign variants; China's CRISPR babies; embryo screening companies; screening versus germline editing; Jo Cameron's FAAH and FAAH-OUT mutations and anandamide[30:03 - 39:00] Anders Sandberg, the Happy Baby Company, and the radio close: Anders, "happy when I'm angry"; hyperthymic is not manic; the company David would start if he were entrepreneurial; depression worldwide; somatic gene therapy for adults is decades from cheap; hedweb.com and "state-of-the-art web design around about 1996"--- [Act 2: Extended Conversation] ---[39:00 - 49:36] What helps now, and an argument with Claude: diet, exercise and sleep before drugs, and drugs with a specialist before gene therapy; Erik pushes back; Erik's pre-show argument with Claude about whether the Jo Cameron mutation raises a set point or only lowers pain; genes interact; David as a "soft antinatalist" who says "the future belongs to life lovers"; elective deafness and whether any choice should be illegal[49:36 - 58:00] A prenatal dilemma and the gift of existence: Guy's friend facing a hard prenatal decision and finding no ground to choose from; David on disability and reported well-being; the narrowness of IQ; parents becoming responsible for their children's traits; Guy asks whether existence is a gift or a burden[58:00 - 1:06:00] Darwinian life, empathy, and forgetting suffering: natural selection as "a vicious engine of suffering"; a third-generation vegetarian who rescued ants and worms on the tarmac; gene drives and a civilized biosphere; Guy asks whether suffering about suffering is good; MDMA, empathy, compassion and hypersystematizing; making suffering "literally inconceivable"[1:06:00 - 1:12:32] A pan-species welfare state: herbivorizing the cat family with synthetic gene drives; vegan cats and dogs; "high-tech Jainism"; ending factory farms and slaughterhouses comes first[1:12:32 - 1:17:26] The spicy question: why not end all life? Nobody asked the Buddha that; a negative utilitarian upholding the sanctity of life in law; the paperclipper; "get a better ethic"; the pinprick argument; the genie offer that a classical utilitarian must accept[1:17:26 - 1:25:07] Why he keeps making the case, and goodbyes: hoping a billionaire or a big podcaster takes up the cause; anesthesia was controversial for about 15 years; Erik would take Anders's gene "in a second"; the WHO definition of health; "the E-word"; David's sign-off wish that their lives be "marked by immense joy and happiness"Guest BioDavid Pearce (born 1959) is a British philosopher and the best-known advocate of what he calls the abolitionist project: using biotechnology to phase out suffering in all sentient life. His 1995 online manifesto, The Hedonistic Imperative, argues that genetic engineering, pharmacology and nanotechnology can replace the pain-pleasure axis with "information-sensitive gradients of bliss." In 1998 he co-founded the World Transhumanist Association with Nick Bostrom; the organization has been known as Humanity+ since 2008. He set up BLTC Research, a network of websites, in 1995, and still maintains hedweb.com. He approaches ethics as a negative utilitarian and, by his own account on the show, comes from three generations of vegetarians. He sits on several advisory boards, including the Qualia Research Institute's. He lives in Brighton, England; he joined this conversation from Lisbon. On X he is @webmasterdave.Notable Moments[~02:40] The one-line definition. "Gautama Buddha once said, I teach one thing and one thing only, suffering and the end of suffering, and negative utilitarianism is in one sense the systematization of that precept."[~05:24] The blackbird. At three or four, David clapped his hands to scare a blackbird off a worm, then "felt vaguely foolish because I was aware that without the ability to eat, the blackbird would starve." The whole later project, predators included, is already in the scene.[~08:06] The pitch in one sentence. "Just imagine waking up tomorrow morning in an extraordinarily good mood, but with your relationships, your preference architecture, and values intact."[~12:43] The self-description. Asked how life could run without pain signals, David offers lovemaking as the example, prefaced: "though I'm a crashing prude and a celibate to boot."[~30:30] Anders Sandberg's set point. Erik reports what Anders told him: "it's so high that I'm happy when I'm angry," which confuses people on the receiving end because he is smiling at them.[~42:42] Erik versus Claude. Erik recounts arguing with Claude before the show about germline editing ("come on, Claude, come on. Really?") and lands on the one objection he found nuanced: we cann...








