This episode kicks off the PM Debate Podcast with a polarizing motion:

👉 “Project managers do not need to have industry knowledge to be successful on projects.”

Mary Elizabeth argues for the motion, championing the idea that core PM skills are universal and that overemphasizing domain knowledge can limit growth and flexibility.

Philip argues against, making the case that without industry insight, PMs risk becoming coordinators instead of leaders, relying too heavily on SMEs and losing credibility with stakeholders.

It’s a sharp, respectful debate covering:

* The role of context in project delivery

* Risks of under-qualification vs. overspecialization

* Whether PM is a portable profession—or one that demands depth

No easy answers. Just two perspectives exploring what it really takes to lead projects that deliver.

This is part of our revived PM Debate Archive. This is all about real conversations that still challenge how we think and lead in project environments.

Where do you stand?

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit philipdiab.substack.com