2: Trouble in the Valley

2: Trouble in the Valley

Update: 2025-10-095
Share

Digest

This podcast episode delves into the intriguing story of John and Ann Bender, beginning with their whirlwind romance in Virginia in 1998, despite Ann's bipolar disorder. They later relocate to Costa Rica, building a lavish estate called "Boracayan," which, along with their desire for privacy, breeds suspicion among locals who speculate about illicit activities. Neighbors Jesse and Matty observe the Benders' increasing isolation and John's security measures, while Ann attempts to disguise herself when leaving the property. The narrative also touches upon the valley's unique "energetic field" and its indigenous history. Osvaldo Rojas, the head of staff, recounts John's volatile temper and his intense focus on caring for orchids and animals. Anne's health deteriorates due to Lyme's disease, prompting John to seek natural jungle remedies. The story culminates with growing tensions and external interference, including a plan to intercept John Bender and send him to the US. The episode also includes advertisements for Helix Sleep, Sit and Sleep, and Osborne Homes, and concludes with podcast credits and sponsorships.

Outlines

00:00:00
Introduction to Services and Personal Stories

This segment introduces Postmates' delivery service in Los Angeles and Delta Airlines' extensive flight network. It then shifts to a personal reflection on the ocean's influence and encourages a visit to the Monterey Bay Aquarium. The narrative also begins the story of John and Ann Bender, detailing their meeting in Virginia in 1998, their rapid romance, and marriage despite Ann's bipolar disorder.

00:05:33
Life in Costa Rica: Wealth, Suspicion, and Isolation

John and Ann Bender move to Costa Rica and build a lavish estate, "Boracayan." Their wealth and desire for privacy breed suspicion among locals, who speculate about illicit activities. Neighbors Jesse and Matty observe the Benders' increasing isolation and John's fear-driven security measures, while Anne's attempts to disguise herself add to the mystery. The valley is described as having a unique energetic field, possibly influenced by its history.

00:18:27
Health Challenges and External Threats

Osvaldo Rojas, the head of staff, describes the challenges of working for John Bender, including his volatile temper and intense focus on caring for orchids and animals. Anne's health deteriorates significantly due to Lyme's disease, leading John to explore natural jungle remedies. Despite his efforts, her condition worsens. External forces begin to intervene, with a plan to intercept John Bender and send him to the US.

00:32:09
Podcast Credits and Sponsorships

This segment lists the credits for the podcast "Hell in Heaven," including the host, producers, writers, and sound designers. It also mentions sponsors like Monterey Bay Aquarium, Klinomic, and Primal Life Organics.

Keywords

John and Ann Bender


The central couple whose story unfolds from a whirlwind romance to a life of isolation and suspicion in Costa Rica.

Boracayan


The lavish estate built by John and Ann Bender in Costa Rica, which became a focal point of local suspicion.

Costa Rica


The location where John and Ann Bender built their estate and lived in increasing isolation, attracting local suspicion.

Lyme's Disease


The illness that significantly impacted Anne Bender's health, leading John to seek alternative treatments.

Natural Cures


John Bender's exploration of jungle remedies to treat his wife Anne's declining health.

Intervention


A planned operation to intercept John Bender and send him to the United States, indicating external involvement.

Bipolar Disorder


A mental health condition Ann Bender disclosed early in her relationship with John.

Energetic Field


A concept suggesting the Dear Monte Valley in Costa Rica possesses a unique energetic force influencing the land.

Postmates


A food delivery service mentioned in the introduction.

Delta Airlines


An airline highlighted for its extensive flight network from Los Angeles.

Q&A

  • What was the initial meeting between John and Ann Bender like?

    John and Ann met at a party in Virginia in 1998. They experienced love at first sight, with Ann finding John brilliant and handsome, and John symbolizing a future for Ann. They shared common interests and a desire for inner peace.

  • Why did John and Ann Bender attract suspicion in Costa Rica?

    Their immense wealth, the construction of a lavish estate (Boracayan), and their intense need for privacy made locals suspicious. Rumors circulated about money laundering, drug cartel involvement, and smuggling.

  • How did Anne Bender's health issues affect her and John?

    Anne contracted Lyme's disease, leading to severe fatigue, migraines, memory loss, and physical pain. Her declining health transformed her and prompted John to delve into natural jungle remedies, consuming their lives.

  • What role did the local community play in the Benders' story?

    The local community in Costa Rica grew resentful of the Benders' wealth and perceived arrogance. Their lavish lifestyle contrasted sharply with the simpler lives of the locals, leading to anger and suspicion.

  • What was the significance of the "energetic field" in the Dear Monte Valley?

    Some believe the valley has a unique energetic field, possibly due to its history of indigenous killings and artifact removal. This imbalance was thought to affect the land and potentially influence the events surrounding the Benders.

  • What was Osvaldo Rojas's role and observations regarding the Benders?

    Osvaldo Rojas was the head of staff at Boracayan. He observed John's volatile temper, his meticulous care for orchids and animals, and the strict rules of silence imposed on staff, highlighting the couple's reclusive and demanding nature.

  • What led to John Bender's planned interception?

    Trouble was brewing for John Bender, and a third party contracted an individual named Michael to intercept him and send him to the United States, indicating that external forces were actively seeking to apprehend him.

Show Notes

Dark forces gather as the Benders’ presence grows more controversial. The couple’s jungle fortress stands apart from everything around it - lavish, secretive and utterly out of place. Neighbours speculate. Resentments stir. Mystics speak of a curse. Behind the gates, the atmosphere shifts as the couple’s physical and mental health start to decline.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

2: Trouble in the Valley

2: Trouble in the Valley

Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts